I am ultra picky. We ordered salads and the Mediterranean plate. The salad was outstanding. However when someone's is sharing a salad I should not have to ask for an extra plate. The appetizer plate was not great. The pita was undercooked. It looked more like a tortilla than pita. The hummus was good and the falafel was delicious. The tzatziki was over seasoned. Way too much garlic and the cucumber was huge in it. The orzo was under seasoned as well as the tahini. The spanakopita was outstanding. The restaurant is beautifully decorated and the food was very good. I could eat that salad every day. I would definitely go back! read more

Love the ambiance at the Black Pig, cool place! Four of us sat at the bar & had drinks & lunch. Everything was great, burgers, charcuterie board, etc...The bartender was excellent. Great personality & very attentive. Would highly recommend!! We will be back read more

Love this place try to make excuses to get back and with 3 sheep's brewing nearby it's an A+ read more

Black Pig - Perfect burger - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Food: 2.5 stars (Porchetta is 2 stars, other food is better, but nothing special) Service: 3 stars Price: Too high for what it is This review is really about the Porchetta, because its a surprisingly rare dish (given the simplicity), that I usually order it when I see it. I really didn't feel like spending $30 on dinner, but I could quiz the waitress on this porchetta's fitness and that would maybe make me feel better about it.... I asked the waitress if the porchetta had a crispy crackling ring on the outside, and it was pretty clear she had no idea what I was talking about, so against my better judgement I got it anyway. To make the story short, it was extremely disappointing - rubbery outer fat ring / skin from not being cooked at a high enough temp / hot enough oil to crisp up the other ring and puff it out, and somehow overcooked and dry on the inside / belly section. I wouldn't be happy with that dish for $8, let alone the $28 or so it cost. That being said, the mac and cheese and fries are decent there, but who cares, you can get that literally anywhere. read more

Black Pig - Porchetta - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

The service was fast, but our server did not have a lot of suggestions or information about the menu. We felt rushed to leave even though we had an early-ish reservation and there were open tables. I had the pulled pork mac, half portion-definitely big enough as an entree. The Mac and cheese was not flavorful and just felt like a kid's Mac and cheese with pork on top. My husband had the pork ragout. The pasta was al dente and tasty, but didn't have anything really special about it. In my opinion, the people who wrote the menu did a really great job of making the food sound really delicious, but there wasn't really anything special about it. I don't think it is worth the money. read more

We sat at the bar for dinner and from start to finish our bartender was amazing! The drinks were delicious and the food was great. Pretty busy for a Wednesday and they were short staffed, but you would never know it. Well definitely try again when in the area. read more

Great ambiance, lots of people but not crowded, perfect for connecting with friends. I highly recommend!!!

My few experiences are the Black Pig have been underwhelming and overpriced. For example, today we got the eggroll app which was 2 pieces of eggroll (like 2/3 the size of a normal one) for $8.95. It was good but very small. Then we had the 2 different macs. The bbq pork was over salted but the Mac was bland. I like the vibe of the restaurant but would not return for a meal. read more

Black Pig - Full Mac - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Nice place witH very convenient location down town Sheboygan. We had reservations for 5:30 PM for a party of six. We were greeted quickly and properly and seated right away. The waiter greeted us quickly and explained the menu and was very polite and well gestured. We had appetizers which consisted of different flavors of fries and the bacon tray. Very tasty. Dinners for us consisted of the steak sandwich, mac & cheese along with burgers. All of the food was excellent. The only real gripe we had was the fact that as the restaurant began to fill, the service began to fall. The waiter seemed overwhelmed and his once friendly demeanor turned into apology after apology for the mistakes he continued to make. I think we'd give the place another chance and hopefully the owners of the restaurant Read this review to know that when the place gets busy you really do need to help your waitstaff, they need it. Probably the only reason why I gave it a four-star was because the service was not five star. That's my story and I'm sticking to it. read more

Black Pig - Upper loft area - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Best breakfast/brunch spot in Sheboygan! From the outside, its an unassuming spot on the main stretch of downtown sheboygan. Once inside, there is a sprawling space (which includes an upstairs which Im sure would be nice for more intimate events!), with funky pig-oriented decor, and a full bar with a few TVs. Food-wise I've tried a chorizo hash special, the chorizo eggs benny, omelets, and at the most recent visit, lemon blueberry french toast. All the meals have been delicious and made with quality ingredients, and we have always received prompt, friendly service. read more

Black Pig - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Wonderful atmosphere. Attentive wait staff. We were there a bit early before the snow starting and was delighted with the salad, crunchy and spicy and wonderful visual with the microgreens amaranth! Entrees we picked were the rabbit and the pork and pasta. Both great and way too much food! Fantastic in the little burg of Sheybogan. read more

Black Pig - Salad with soba noodles and micro greens, chili and peanut dressing with cucumber - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

I was so excited to try this place based on the yelp reviews and I mean, how can you go wrong with a bacon appetizer?! Or bacon in general! Well, apparently you can! The chipotle bacon tasted like bad jerky, the brown sugar bacon was mostly fat and grizzle and the salt and pepper was fine but nothing my dad couldn't cook up at home. Their truffle oil Mac and cheese is literally truffle oil... with Mac and cheese SUBMERGED in it! It was so gross I had to pass on eating it or anything else because I lost my appetite as a whole. My husband almost vomited at the table from his meal - just awful and gross. Will never ever ever return. read more

Interesting menu items. You will find a great unique item (or many) that you'll love! Service was phenomenal. We'll be back!

The food was absolutely delicious and our waiter was great! Would definitely go back.

My tennis team was playing a tournament at Sports core and decided to eat here for lunch. We were intrigued by the "American food with a twist" description. That's exactly how I would describe the food. A few people got the tacos which they said were delicious and would highly recommend. Same with the lamb burger. I got the Spanish Pamplona Mac and I loved it. Just the right amount of cheesiness, and the corn, shrimp, and chorizo gave it the right amount of twist. read more

Black Pig - Spanish Pamplona Mac - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

The food was very good and had a variety of selections. The wine selection is very extensive and the bourbon selection includes very hard to find bottles . We ate at the bar and had a great time. read more

Our food was delicious! Give them a try! We can't wait to go back. They are a bit expensive but totally worth it! read more

They buy whole pigs and break them down themselves. Do you know how rare that is in the Midwest? Rare anywhere? A limited menu, which is good because what they do make is great. Perhaps the best pork chop I have ever had in n my life. No, the best. Great service, great food, good rye selection, but not cheap. Not NY expensive, but not Wisconsin cheap. Overall, a great place for dinner or lunch, but not a cheap night out read more

See all

Went here with a group of 13 people and not one of us walked away satisfied. The dishes were a mix of bland and overcooked. One of us had an eggplant dish that smelled and tasted like one of the ingredients, probably the feta, had spoiled. There was no effort to correct it and she was still charged for it even though it was basically inedible. The cocktails were good but, like the rest of the menu, overpriced. The atmosphere was decent. I don't see myself ever going back. read more

This place was PHENOMENAL. Best meal we had while visiting Sheboygan/Kohler for the weekend. We ordered the pork schnitzel and the NY strip. The schnitzel was light and crispy and the steak was... just wow. Old fashioned was balanced and delicious. We finished off with the flourless chocolate cake which was pure decadence. Loved every bite and sip! We will be back!! read more

Great Ragu and wine selection. Atmosphere is fun and staff is warm, kind, and very knowledgeable about the menu.

With open tables outside & indoors, we were immediately turned away "you need reservations, next one is at 7:30pm" While we stood there, the same lady repeated herself & now saying "next reservations is at 7:45pm" As first time customers that were visiting Sheboygan excited to explore the city. Don't go here, as they won't take you! read more

So, the food was good, but not worth it for price. I ordered the beef tenderloin special and asked for it medium rare and it came back well done (to the point where it was cooked like pot roast). The flavors were on point but for $45 bucks just a big disappointment. I'm not one to send food back because I've worked in food service and typically I can get away without causing a fuss. Black Pig tries to have an "upscale" menu type feel, but to overcook a $45 steak to the point I received it was no bueno. I'd give them another shot if I'm in the area, but likely will try to stay basic. read more

Went here because it was recommended by a friend but it wasn't very good. the portion sizes were very small for the prices and the truffle mac and cheese was terrible. the only good thing was the staff was very friendly but i would not come back here or recommend it to others. read more

Very good location and great menu with daily specials. They feature local beers and I highly recommend the "3 Sheep" beer as it went well with the meal. I've never seen bacon sliced so thick for a burger. Also, they make specialty french fries and macaroni and cheese plates. Sheboygan features great comfort food and they did not let us down here. The location is all very clean with a very friendly staff. Figure lunch/dinner will cost two people $35-50 (including tip) depending on whether or not you're drinking alcohol. read more

Black Pig - Specialty burger - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Wow. Amazing restaurant! Everyone was very friendly, they squeezed us in as they had a full list of reservations. Robbie was our server and was very pleasant. The food had so much flavor and was delicious! I am vegan and gluten free...they even had a menu item that I could have. The brussel sprout salad was AMAZING, as was the spicy cauliflower entree (pictured) and the curry french fries were light and crispy and just perfect! Cannot wait to go back!! read more

Black Pig - Spicy Sweet Chili Glazed Cauliflower - Comfort Food Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

We've been to the black pig a total of 2 times. Our first time was absolutely amazing! Which incentives us to come back. The food is always amazing (despite them using truffle oil in a lot of things- I'm allergic) our second time... may 24th. Not so great... we were greeted at the front door and from that point on was just down hill. Our server was very attentive to a table on the opposite side of the room from us but seemed to have other staff member come and check up on us. So we were not even sure who was supposed to be our server. After we were done eating we sat there for an extended period of time until I was fed up and just asked for the check (which took a while to get.) we paid and just simply left disappointed but our overall experience. We were very hesitant to tip but we know servers do not make a lot with their hourly wage and would have felt bad for leaving nothing despite our overall experience. I think we would consider coming back eventually but not anytime soon. read more

Very much enjoyed the restaurant. Grabbed drinks and dinner at the bar. Bartender was on top of the recommendations. We went with a large mac with many small plates (No entree). Order in preference: 1) Cajun mac 2) Bacon! 3) Rangoon 4) duck fries Highly recommend this place. read more

See all

Visited a Friday for lunch, was very satisfied! Waitress was so friendly and the perfect amount of conversational and attentive. I had the beer cheese soup and a sandwich. My friend had a burger I think. Everything was super tasty and it wasn't too busy or noisy. Will be back. read more

Super fun interior and design however I was fairly disappointed with the actual meat served. Kind of dry and lacking on flavor. That being said the curry fries were BOMB and the drinks were excellent! read more

This place could be great, but the service and atmosphere are poor. Let's get one thing clear; the food is excellent here. All the dishes are high quality and properly prepared. The service is terrible. Why? Maybe if the wait staff was a little less "stoned," the service might be better. Our waitress looked like she bathed in leftover bong water and had the smell to match. They. even had"tweeking" bus boys to match; honestly the experience would be tik-tok worthy, but we were hungry and grew tired of the antics. Finally, lets talk about how loud the place was; this place is loud! I think it's due to the high open ceilings, but the restaurant is louder than some football stadiums. This was a far different place a few years ago. I'm not sure the food is worth the service experience; maybe try takeout. read more

Downtown location is a fun restaurant/bar atmosphere. Menu items have a bar feel but all upscale. I had the pork chops special and it was delicious. read more

Great service, good (fancy) food. Portions are small though and it's a bit pricey. Very nice place to take a date, great atmosphere, cool part of town across from the theater. read more

One of my favorite places for really good food and drinks. Friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere. Of course, Micheal makes me laugh and is just great overall. read more

The place was awesome and some of the best, fresh food I've had in a long time. Highly recommend it. Everything was delicious and a real treat. read more

Food was good! We had shrimp appetizer***** Hamburger ***** Halibut cheeks with fried ​fingerling potato slices. Halibut was good!! But potatoes need to change. Chef may consider smashed herb f​ingerling potato as it's side. read more

Traveling through and stopped here for an early lunch today, had the option of outside seating or inside. Was accommodated nicely at the table we wanted. The food... Wow. Candied bacon is a must. Between 2 adults and 2 kids we devoured the appetizer. I had the Wagyu/bacon burger and fries, there was nothing left on my plate when I got done with it. Fries are by far much better than McDonald's. Also, tried my daughters mac-n-cheese (I'm not a fan of mac-n-cheese) but soooo good! Highly recommend to anyone. Will be coming back! read more

We came on for cocktails and Mike was fabulous! He made the perfect cosmopolitan and gave us the recipe. We had a wonderful afternoon. We will be back! read more

The Black Pig is a hidden gem in Sheboygan, WI. From the appearance, it looks like a hipster run restaurant trying to be trendy but it's not. It's actually a fine dining restaurant that transformed itself while keeping its culinary techniques. I learned from the owner's son that The Black Pig used to be a fine dining restaurant that decided to go into a different direction. They got rid of the dress code and white tablecloths and replaced them with an urban décor serving comfort food with a twist along with a whiskey list. It was the right decision because this place is stellar. You still see the personality of the classically trained chef and owner throughout the menu from duck fat fries, Berkshire pork belly, and duck confit tacos. These are dishes and cooking techniques that stand out from the surrounding area. The Black Pig caters to a diverse crowd whether it's for large groups, casual dining, a quick lunch, or an intimate dinner - they really have it all. It's a bit pricey but where else can you get duck confit tacos in Wisconsin? read more

See all

We stopped by The Black Pig on our way to Door County over Valentines Day Weekend. It was a Friday afternoon towards the end of lunch time. I loved the building, the atmosphere and the decor. Our waitress was very friendly, answered our questions about the tap beers and the menu. I ordered tomato basil soup and a grilled cheese with apple smoked bacon. The soup was tasty and the grilled cheese was good, though it was missing the bacon. The beers were wonderful...it was a darker seasonal tap with winter spices. We left feeling like the food wasn't necessarily over the top, but feeling that if we ever make it Sheboygan again we needed to try other items from the menu. The cosiness of the venue makes it a nice place to relax with a beer. read more