It can be a little chaotic in here but I sure do love their vodka slice. Other stuff is fine but that is one of my lesser known city favorites. read more

On 7/1/ 26, I ordered 4 slices, one with Spinach. Please, Google Spinach Pizza to see what it looks like cause mine arrived with a just a bunch of what looked like a frozen quality, tasteless spinach stacked up on top of the Pizza! Just sitting on top, no cheese melted on at all! Not like anything I've ever seen in my life! I called, and the owner, who was sarcastic, condescending, mean and preceded to tell me that his Pizza is made like how HE likes it, NOT made with whole leaf spinach that's melted into the cheese! I hung on him, as his entire attitude was terrible for a business person and he was of no help! He actually texted me to tell me that i'm BANNED from getting delivery . I will no longer set foot in that place! The food quality has gotten poor over the years anyway, while prices are high. I paid $30.00 for FOUR slices of pizza that was very thin with very, very little cheese! I scraped off the PILE of spinach, added my own cheese and broiled, it was s little better. Never, ever again! Very nasty person and the food is no longer as good as it use to be. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - The plane slice was thin as heck with hardly any cheese. Wish I took a photo of the spinach slice! - Italian Near Me - Rockaway, New York

I went twice. Both times had dirty, empty tables throughout. The pizza was not as good as some of the frozen pizza you can buy at the nearby Stop & Shop for a lot less money. The meatball hero was good, but overpriced compared to places in Bklyn and Manhattan. The thing is, in this Arverne neighborhood, there are very limited options. So some people know they can serve whatever, and if it's not the greatest, and if the price is higher than it should be, it's okay because customers don't have the choices they have in more populated areas. read more

The food quality is decent, but way overpriced, come on ! $6 for a pepperoni slice? And other menu items are through the roof, like the tourist trap of the 70s & 80s. I can get much better quality in Brooklyn or Manhattan for less $. The owner, isn't pleasant at all, always has a straight forward sourpuss face, like he can't be bothered or thinks he's better than everyone else. I can tell who he voted for. Next time I'll just walk over to papa John's, its closer, more reasonably priced & they don't act like their $#it don't stink & I'm positive they're not trump lovers. read more

For years, I have ordered 1 or 2 times a week from Boardwalk. The food I order is not anything extraordinary but I know what they make that I like and have been ordering those items for years. This evening, I made a mistake on an online order and called the store to make the correction. The customer service was abysmal. After I realized the person on the phone was rude and condescending, I asked to speak with the manager (just in case this was a language issue.) The man identified himself as "The business owner." My ordering error was easily resolved but his conduct was very off-putting. While waiting for my delicious grandma pie and chicken roll, I did a quick google search of reviews and found many people have been treated poorly by this man. I spend thousands of dollars here each year on their delicious grandma pies, fried calamari, and chicken rolls. Sadly, this will be my last order from Boardwalk. (Also, their delivery drivers have always been awesome!) read more

Amazing pizza slices with plenty of seating inside and outside the restaurant. Offers a great variety of pizzas, along with drinks and ice cream, so there's something for everyone. The prices are reasonable for the quality and portion size, and the slices are exceptionally big, making it a great value. The service is also a plus! The staff is really friendly and helpful, which adds to the experience. Been coming here for years ! read more

Amazing service! Paulie made sure to take excellent care of us! Calamari alla vodka was delicious! And so were their slices (we tried the cbr and margherita). With love, Liz and Autumn! read more

Okay, so considering that this is the only Pizzeria in this area, it's not bad. Actually, I really do like the pizza. Pizza Breakdown: The Sauce tastes well-made; not too acidic and not too sweet. Has a nice savory flavor. The Cheese; it's not dumped on top of the pizza in copious amounts and the mozzarella is pretty tasty, chewy, and stringy. Just like we all love it. The Crust/Dough; I do tend to like my pizza dough more in the thinner side, for maximum crunchiness but overall the thickness of their pizza crust/sough is well balanced and affords you to grab several slices in one sitting. At this point, you're probably wondering why I'm only giving 3 stars Basically, it's the service and hygiene of the workers here. If I'm not mistaken I believe they were robbed a couple of months ago, and it seemed like a personal vendetta because, really, who robs a pizza shop lol? When you walk in you have a lot of options of where you can sit down, which is great. But the flies will find you and follow you everywhere. They used to have napkins on every table now you have to ask for them. Ask for extra too so you can wipe down the crumby table and chairs you're about to sit at. It can also get crowded really fast and when it gets busy they seem to forget who came in first and what's going on, so be mindful of when you ordered so your not left sitting or standing around like an idiot. If you're going to order a pie and extras; CALL AHEAD OF TIME. Thank me later, lol. read more

I Today i went in and patiently waited on line. When it was my turn two guys at the back of the line who were friendly with the counter person yelled in their order and were given priority and those of us waiting were ignored. I walked out. read more

Great pizza spot! It's been a while since I've visited here but it'd definitely worth visiting. I always get a margherita and buffalo chicken pizza slices. It's also right next to the subway so it's not hard to find as well. It's the only pizza spot in this area that I go to. read more

Best pizza in Rockaways and a top contender in nyc. My favorite slices are their rare sweet chili chicken along with their vodka and buffalo chicken. Can't go wrong here with plain slice, grandma and cheese sticks as well. Always reliable and friendly service! read more

Always great pizza and full of toppings and close by and fast deliveries . Flavors always on point and a great vodka sandwich read more

For my first time this is one of the best pizzas i've had in the rockaway !!! definitely recommend

If you don't know someone behind the counter be prepared to be ignored and wait longer

Food quality sucks -- Going to Elegante from now on. Around 6:30 P.M. on Tuesday, 4/16th I was charged $10 in person cash for 2 orders of garlic knots, which I thought was insane. If I try placing the same order online now it's $7. I brought this up to the worker and he blamed it on "the prices change daily". Liars and crooks. See my screenshot below. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Italian Near Me - Rockaway, New York

The pizza is good it's just the customer service is terrible. Telling a customer they are wasting your time while the shop is empty and you aren't doing anything but standing around miserable is insane. If I hadn't place my order and paid already I would have left. read more

The pizza was way too greasy and also salty. I honestly think it's overpriced. I've had $1 slices of pizza that tasted better. I got two different slices to try, and I was super hungry so I ate everything but I wasn't impressed and probably would not come back unless it was the only option and I am too hungry to wait. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - two slices of pizza on a plate - Italian Near Me - Rockaway, New York

They have some of the best Cheese bread sticks you'll ever have. I recommend them if you go to this place.

Went in on a Sunday afternoon after a day at the beach...I'd say that it wasnt that busy. Upon walking up to the register I awkwardly stood there waiting to be greeted while one worker ate his pizza and the other stared at me...I broke the ice lol....and luckily they had a pepperoni pizza in the oven that would be ready in a few minutes. I ordered two slices and was stunned that it was over $10...so stunned I had to ask if it was the correct price...why on earth is 2 slices of pizza $10.....we sat outside where they have additional seating and I will say that the pizza was good....was it worth over $5 for a damn slice? NO but the flavors were there. I will never be back read more

Order Vegetables soup it was too salty to enjoy. The Penne Volka was ok. I don't know if they have a new chef, but I don't remember eating their food with so much salt. I will recommend their pizza and maybe their pasta dishes, but not the soup. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Penne Volka it is a nice meal. I recommend it. - Italian Near Me - Rockaway, New York

See all

I don't know exactly when they went under new management but I definitely tasted a difference in the food. Used to be my favorite slice in Rockaway and now I order because of the proximity. I recently ordered a Cesar salad from them and it was the WORST Cesar salad I've ever had. The "grilled" chicken wasn't grilled at all it was chicken marinated in balsamic and very sauce and the lettuce was terrible it was all the white/bottom part of the lettuce head, barely any green. Maybe next time I'll stick with the spinach or gorgonzola salad. I'll give it to them they do have quick service and a variety of pizza toppings/slices. I've also never encountered any issues with the service, never over the top friendly but never nasty either. read more

This is a place my coworkers LOVE to order from. I must say we are terrible customers as I always call right on the dot at 10:30am (when they open) with a multiple pizza order to be delivered at 12pm. The service is always Great, did I mention complimentary plates and condiments without me even having to ask?!? I highly recommend the Grandma Ala Vodka slice! read more

We get their Grandma pie practically every week. All the food is great and the menu has some different options than you normally find in a standard pizza joint. Excellent read more

I love the food and staff at this location and honestly if it wasn't for them, my money would all be going to Elegante. Which might start happening sooner rather than later. The owner is absolutely nasty and rude. His attitude and the way he treats people, even customers, is horrible. He has no idea how to run a business. It ran so smooth with the previous owners but ever since this new one took over the service has been bad. He just doesn't know how to talk to people and just shut up and listen. I gave it 3 stars because of the staff. If you take him out of the equation it would be 5. read more

They're ok can't really complain service can be a little better I just hate calling in for the order because they like to rush off the phone,but otherwise it's fine... read more

No flavor the inside tables dirty and outside table are dirty Good service bathroom out of service read more

Honestly lack of communication with the gentleman on the phone. Guy took 15 mins just to understand all I needed was one pie. One soda . An to understand the address he says hes not familiar with rockaway addresses we only 8mins away from location. so why even work there Or have someone answer phones... I ain't even the type of person to do this. But common sense and lack of not understanding coustumers over the phone is bad experience is a down fall. read more

Made an account just to write a review about my experience the other day. First things first I feel bad for the workers it is so hot in that place , my daughter wanted to eat there and I refused it felt better outside . He refuses to put AC on and his workers suffer. I had the pleasure of being helped by a young lady with the tattoos she is very sweet and friendly and does very well at her job but she was running around doing so many jobs at once I could see the heat and exhaustion getting to her but she still made my experience pleasurable. The boss just seems like he doesn't care about the workers or anything it's how he wants things and that's it . NOW THE PROS- the food there is very very delicious definitely one of the best pizzas I've had . - and he does have great workers there in the establishment and always have a good experience with them . He should be more grateful of the help he has. read more

The pizza is great, overpriced but overall taste decent but they are predjuiced. I go there in uniform all the time get good treatment , the second I go in regularly clothes I get harassed inside the store, asking if I can pay if I can afford to pay I say yeah and go get my water and they refuse to start my pizza until I paid. Which was never done before & they didn't do to anyone else who ordered. Never in my adult life have I ever been treated like that. Pizza is ok but not worth spending money where you aren't wanted. read more

Great pizza ,sandwich and excellent service love the marinara slice wish you had available for my immediate appetite more often! Cannoli is excellent als Had fantastic chicken broccoli rabe sandwich read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Really delicious - Italian Near Me - Rockaway, New York

Pizza is always fresh and it's always delicious. My kids are very picky about their sauce and this is hands down their favorite pizza spot.

The meatballs pomodoro is my all time favorite version of this dish anywhere, including homemade (sorry, mom!). The service here is friendly, even when its busy and crowded, though the vibe can be a bit hectic, especially in the summer or on a busy weekend. I don't want the chaotic ambience keep you from checking this place out, it's definitely worth it. read more

Wasn't able to cook today but thankfully they deliver to the whole peninsula since this is one of our favorite pizza shops to stop at. read more

See all

Not sure what happened. Use to order all the time. The waiting time for delivery is well over 2 hours. If it happened once or twice I could understand. People call in sick etc. Cars break down. But this is almost every time, And to add insult to injury, after 2 hours and 15 minutes it's the wrong kind of salad. This is my last order. read more

Great place for pizza-lovers! Big choice, reasonable price, big sizes, freshly-baked, pizza pies are also available. What about pasta, it is quite good, big portions, A LOT OF CHEESE, little meet though. It is also very hot inside, sitting outside could even be better due to seaside breeze. read more

See all

So I'm gonna preface this review AND my stars to my experience with their SINGLE slices. Boardwalk's SINGLE slices. Because quite frankly it was some of the best pizza I've put in my mouth in a long while. And that is saying A LOT cuz I'm fruuuum Brooklyn. However. I ordered a pie today. Cuz I just couldn't bear the thought of putting on clothes and moving my vehicle to get my cheese and dough fix today. Ugh. I promise you I wish I did not. The pizza was cold. Ok no prob. I've eaten Broadway pizza cold and stiff and it's been still amazing! But this. This was not even mediocre. I'm not gonna butcher them with my review. Cuz like I said- single slices are amazing. Squares are pillowy and delish. But this was not it. You live and you learn. Periodt. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Ate some slices and peeled da cheese offa some too - Italian Near Me - Rockaway, New York

Incredible!!! Not just, the pasta and calamari, brueschtta It's all great It's definitely a big upgrade from n previous owner which was okay read more

Solid slice shop. Located right below the Beach 67th Street stop and conveniently on the way to Rockaway Beach. Grabbed a regular slice which was priced at $3.75. They put a perfect crispy on the crust so it was crunchy yet the edge had a bit of airiness left. Sauce and cheese were good too. read more

Great Pizza When it's Hot. It took 1hr and 45 minutes to get my delivery. I called to complain about the cold pizza and was told to pop it in the oven. read more

Customer service is horrible. They sent my pizza out by mistake an had me waiting an didn't say a word. Didn't try to make it right . I give them 0 customer service slice of was a 6.5 read more