Great taste... quick service and nice staff . Will come back! Fresh tasting and frozen drinks were good

Food- 5/5 Service- 5/5 Ambiance- 4/5 Classic for pizza and icees! A neighborhood gem that's been in the community for as long as I can remember. 2 thumbs up and would def recommend and return! Fav slices include classic buffalo and white slices! read more

I had a horrible experience. I told the guy I was going to the store and I'll be right he caught an attitude then I address him about it he says nothing. Then they take my food out and just leave it there to the point I have to say hey that's my food can I get that and then i pay while walking out a employee comes out of nowhere and ask me while I'm walking out did I pay. if you was doing your job and paying attention of course paid. I'm not gonna walk and just pick up and walk out and steal . The pizza isn't all that and if I had to rate the pizza as New York I'll give it like five. Maybe people think this pizza is good because of the location but I'm general I would never go back to the establishment again and the pizza mid. read more

Neighborhood staple, always satisfied with the taste and quality of the pizza. The garlic knots and wings are tasty too.

Now that's a pizza...!!! It's one of the few pizza spots left in the hood that taste like pizza made by italians still. read more

Not gonna lie for a neighborhood pizzeria it's good and has good pizza I've been coming here for awhile and it always hits and never had any bad experiences here definitely recommend!!! read more

- regular pizza is too cheesy - they were out of a lot of products like megharita pizza and chicken - sausage and peppers were good - pasta needed more salt - buffalo wings were well made, well seasoned, well salted - yelp delivery time told me an hour+, but delivery was under forty five min - not much special about this place that separates it from other pizza shops read more

This pizza shop has the BEST pizza by far i have been going here for years and it has never changed it's like reliving my childhood all over with every bite it's definitely a must try and the slushies are sooo good i only with they allow you to mix the flavors on door dash read more

Wow!!! I had 1 plain slice yesterday and it was so delicious. Even the crust was so soft and full of flavor. My son had a pepperoni slice and he said it was the best he ever had. I dont live anywhere close to this pizza shop but I would go out my way to get here. Its on a busy road so if youre driving good luck with parking. We also had the hotwings. Once again it was a winner. You've won my child and I over read more

Pizza is really good. First time trying it and I'm sold . The staff is very friendly.

First time I older from this place online I was not impressed, with the delivery which I though they over priced me for what I order, but actually when I checked back I made the mistake and order the wrong thing. The manager of the place contacted me and the next day I gave him a call back and he wanted to credit me back for what I order that came out to $31. That was very professional and I was not expecting that. He sent me a large cheezy pie which was delicious. The crust was so crunchy love it. I will continue to order from this place since I'm a pizza head and it good to know that I have a great pizzeria on my neighborhood. There is also a domino's pizza near by which I do not recommend buying from. I try them before and you can tell the difference with the taste, and the delivery which took over 2 hours. Also the delivery guy from this place is nice and makes his deliveries on time. Just gain a new customer :) read more

See all

Fantastic food delivered hot fresh and made to order Have to reorder again just to get thru the menu at least Assorted options and toppings Yummy and cheesy Perfect prepared and cooked read more

Where do I begin about this place while still keeping it short and sweet? In simple terms this is the BEST pizza you will find in the area. I have dibbled and dabbled with other pizza shops but this place is unmatched. Whether you are looking to have a slice, order a pie, or even picking up dinner for you or your family Sal & Paul's will not disappoint. Flavor and satisfaction in every single bite! *Major Key: The Chicken Parm fresh out the kitchen slaps harder than Mike Tyson! Would have posted pics but I ate the food as it showed up lol read more

This is my mom's favorite pizza spot close to her home. Growing up in ENY, Brooklyn we were always going to Pitkin Avenue to shop for school clothes, sneakers or household items. After shopping we would get something to eat. Over the years, Pitkin Avenue has developed and more chain stores are popping up. However, this pizza joint is one of the old skool spots from back in the day and its still thriving. I remember ordering slices as a kid for me and my brother with the small fountain juice. We would eat in the back of the pizza shop with our shopping bags in between our legs. Lol. To date, the set up is still the same. They have advanced to a variety of flavored slushies that's a hit with people young and old. You have the option to mix the sugary drinks. All that's missing is a bit of alcohol in them bad boys. Lol. They used to sell the Italian ices in front of the store. The pizza is good to me but great to my mom. I can be coming from Queens and pass tons of pizza spots but my mom specifies she wants pizza from the one on Pitkin Ave. read more

Almost as good as John's on Bleeker, and that's the highest compliment. I wish these guys were near me in the east Village instead of east NY. The pies are cheesy, delicious, and you almost always get a fresh slice. Forget the clowns who make 20 pies in the morning and reheat slices all day (and the next day if they don't sell.) They make pies the old fashion way, one at a time. It brings tears to my eyes to come to a place like this! read more

Great experience. Prob as good as Italy. Great versitile staff and quick. I actually came I. To use the restroom and my friend and I ordered food. Very nice little quiet spot. Soda and 3 slices came to just under 14 dollars. 5 stars read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - Great food and fresh - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This pizza is definitely underrated. From the crust to the sauce to the cheese i was amazed. Was in the area shopping and ran in for a slice and some garlic knots which were to die for. Don't skip it! read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - The best garlic knot i ever had. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I really do believe this is the best pizza in Brooklyn I don't know if something about the crust that is absolutely out of this world I literally come from the other side of Brooklyn to get a slice or pie read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Food is definitely good, I love the thick crust it's like that old school pizza from the 90's. Service is always pleasant even over the phone. My staff, and I always enjoy they're great pizza. read more

Good pizza like always I'm not sure what's in the dough if it's cornmeal or what but the pizza is consistently good always decent cheese and sauce. If I'm in the area I have to get a slice. read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Let me start off first by saying that Sal and Paul's Pizzeria is definitely a not a hidden gem in Brownsville Brooklyn but rather to the rest of Brooklyn. For as long as I could remember they have had the best slices in the neighborhood. Years ago the slices were only a dollar twenty five. I decided to grab a plan slice well done while waiting for my laundry to get done and as usual it hits the spot. Generous slices with crispy potato crust with herbs baked in the bread simple and perfect. read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - Plain crispy slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is by far one of the best pizza shops in the area. Anytime I visit Pitkin Avenue, I make sure to stop by and grab a slice. You can tell by the quality that they make the pizzas fresh daily. You won't find any cold rock-hard slices here. My favorite is their Pepperoni slice. I have tried other toppings such as; Pineapple, Broccoli, and Extra Cheese (my hunger took over hence why there are no pictures, sorry...not sorry). Another favorite of mine is their flavored slushies. You cannot call yourself a pizza shop without a slushie machine. I love how their slushies are made just right (not too sweet.... just the right amount of flavor and ice ratio). What's even better is the customer service. Of all the times I have visited, I've never received the usual Brownsville attitude. The staff is friendly and greets their customers with a smile. The shop is a little small. They do have seating available in the back and outdoors (during warmer weather). I would recommend if you're ever looking for a quick bite to eat if ever in the area. read more

See all

Ordered from here twice on Doordash. They're personal deep-dish pizza is sooo delicious! read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - Personal pan pizza topped with spinach, garlic, and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Very good pizza. Ordered on Uber Eats. Got a large pie with plenty of cheese and sauce. Nice thick crust and very tasty. I will order again. read more

Pizza is the best I've actually had. Expensive for a slice especially when's crowns has it for a dollar but so worth it. The crust is garlicky. The pizza is always cheesy n never doughy. read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - a dirty counter - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Didn't expect it but, Sal & Paul's Pizzeria was simply brilliant. Sal & Paul's Pizzeria is a hidden treasure. Only quality. Every single thing I've tried until now has been awesome. The workers were extremely good, smiled a lot, felt genuine. We felt really welcomed at Sal & Paul's Pizzeria. read more

Bomb pizza. Tastes really good. the sauce is sweet and nice. The pizza doesn't look like much but its fresh and cheesy and one of the best pizzas I've had in a while. Will definitely be going back! read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

By far and away the best pizza in Brownsville. This place is practically a landmark. I don't know what they do that yellowy crust, but yum, yum, yummy, yum, yum! read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

A great neighborhood pizza spot. Service is great. But that pizza is phenomenal. Ask them to make a mix of the slushy too. Got to have skills to make it. read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - Margarita pizza and slushy mix - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

There pizza is one of the best. There Italian ICE in the summer are natural juice and fruit made. The slushies are awesome as well. Nice little sit down area. Very friendly read more

I really wanted to like this place, especially after all the other positive reviews and the fact that they delivery to my apartment, but my experience was nothing but disappointing. My boyfriend and I ordered the vegetarian deep-dish special pizza for delivery on a Thursday night. The pizza didn't arrive for nearly 90 minutes and it was delivered by a friend of the family - all of their normal delivery drivers were busy. OK, so they were having a really busy night - I can understand that. Unfortunately, something I can't forgive it when my pizza arrives at barely room temperature and the crust has become so soggy that the box almost fell apart. The pizza itself was loaded high with vegetables, so that was good, but I had to reheat it in the oven first. I'm open to going to the restaurant in-person and trying their pizza again (when its actually fresh from the oven), but I absolutely won't order from here again. read more

My favorite place to get my mini pie for lunch. Usually there is a bit of a crowd but if you call ahead they usually have it ready. Really friendly guys working. Summer time treat with those awesome slushees. read more

I'm glad I picked this spot for my fiancé & I to grab some slices , the pizza is so good we both enjoyed it & will stop by again , loved the yellow pizza dough & the taste of the garlic on the crust was delicious read more

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria - Good Pizza , glad I picked this spot - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Wonderful classic NY pizza. Stopped in for a quick lunch during a layover at JFK. Well worth the Uber ride!!!

Went to buy some zepoles. I notice that the guy wasn't using gloves as he was serving and taking money. I actually was trying to observe how he opens the bag to put the zepoles in but I was blocking someone's path and when I turned around to move out of the persons way I didn't get to see how he actually open the bag I wanted to make sure that it wasn't with his bare hands. well after eating the zepoles and that was the only thing I ate all day at around 7pm I ate it went to bed around 10:00pm and now I'm up at 3:10 am with food poisoning so that means he used his hands to open the bag or they don't use safe practices when preparing the food. There is a very polite Mexican guy there very very nice he's the only on with gloves on but the person I went to had no gloves on and I noticed that he was frowning at everybody he was a young Caucasian kind of rude guy could have been Italian I don't know but it was his expression and his manner that told me he didn't like being there around he kind act dismissive. Anyway I am waiting for it to get a little later so I can make a food poisoning complaint with 311. I will never ever go back there even if I didn't get food poisoning I wouldn't go back because of the hate that I saw coming from that worker and that fact that we didn't wear gloves while serving food and taking money. read more

There pizza is delicious. The only pizza I eat I'm also pregnant so I send my baby father to get it.

Sal's & Paul's is the best pizza shop in Brownsville. The food is so delicious and the place is super clean. The staff and owner are super friendly. I love this place. read more

Pizza arrived on time and was fresh and delicious. The delivery person was friendly, as well. I would definitely order again and recommend if you love authentic NY slices. read more

Very authentic pizza shop in Brownsville the food is good and the prices are decent. The hot wings are crispy and with a lot of sauce they taste amazing and the chicken parmesan is one of my favorites read more

They did a custom order of 11 pizzas for me and went out their way to make sure the party went as planned -- they were on time and very professional. The pizza was AMAZING!!!! Thank you guys for everything!!! -Shayna read more