I've been on the hunt for the perfect bagel shop in this area... I think I have found it. Super friendly staff that seem to know a lot of the regulars by name... Which gives it a hometown feel...something I don't see at the others. Ordered the basic: Taylor, egg and cheddar on an everything. Bagel had a nice consistency and was nice and fluffy in the middle. They also have a good selection of bagels...nore than the average shop in this are.... This is my go-to, now. read more

Best deli in the area hands down ! No competition. Great service , nice environment and delicious food. What more could you ask for? The Begals must be handmade fresh every morning because they are good . Highly recommend read more

My bagel was amazing. I had a bacon egg and cheese and it was the best. I loved it and the staff was amazing, they made everything perfect. 11/10 would visit again. read more

I go here all the time for breakfast and I love it, but today I went for lunch and was so disappointed...:( I asked for the club sandwich on a bagel. They had it written as a lunch special. I got the completely wrong sandwich and it was on a hero. I kept trying to explain to the guy but he just kept saying its the same price. And there was no one else around:( I really don't want to ever go back, even though I've been going for 7 years...:(( read more

I was craving a bagel I found this place stopped and had a bagel and a coffee with strawberry cream cheese. It was awesome good. Highly recommend read more

I have been regular at this place for some time and hands down the best bagel in the neighborhood. Unlike some bagel stores, they make their own bagels at the store and if you are lucky, you can one just came out of the oven. The bagel size is huge so I usually ask them scoop out in the middle, which is perfect. Employees are nice and friendly too. Highly recommended. read more

Borderline Bagels - Cinnamon and sun dried tomato - Bagels Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

See all

My boyfriend and I live fairly close to Borderline Bagels and have visited it several times recently. Unfortunately, each time we leave with our order, it is not the exact order we placed. I always just chalk it up to human error, but this is now the second weekend in a row that something was wrong with our order. Today he requested an everything bagel, spicy mustard, ham, lettuce and onions. What I received instead was, the bagel, minus the spicy mustard and adding munster cheese. I realize they are kids behind the counter, but perhaps the owner should pay a little more attention to making sure the staff has an effective system in place considerint this is not the first time. read more

Super friendly environment. With some of the best bagels. I love the seasonal colorful bagels. The chicken salad is a must have, fresh, tasty and good. Would definitely recommend this place for anyone, kids, teens and adults. They make an above average coffee. This is the only place I ever had coffee. If your looking for a quick healthy and nice meal this is the place to go. The staff is very attentive and gave me exactly what I asked for. Definitely looking forward to go back there when I go to NJ again. read more

I like to come here. I tried our locations bagels store, but this is the place where I come. The workers are nice and fast, I like the bagels too. My favorite is Sesame and Everything with Cream cheese. read more

Today I go in there and get 3 bagels asking the guy for peanut butter and jelly on bagel and couple of other bagels with cream cheese he goes and puts cream cheese with jelly !!!! This place was better before now it's starting to fall apart , the register Mexican decent person does not know how to take orders or ring up the register . Other younger person that's always there is polite and fast , this place has to replace employees read more

I've been coming to this bagel shop for years! It's usually hit or miss. Their bagels are amazing. Always good however their cream cheese can sometimes taste old or not up to par. I get olive cream cheese. My advice would be to go in the morning everything is fresh. The customer service after 2 is horrible. I don't know his name but he is rude. I have known him to charge more in the afternoon than in the morning. read more

Terrible service. Bad bagels. Very overpriced. One day i go in and the bacon egg and cheese with a hasbrown comes with a coffee and the next day it doesnt? They do not know how to treat their customers. I tried calling in to pickup and was cut short and hung up on. I called back to ask what happened and there was no appologies. I will never go back to this place and you should not either. It is unfortunate because some of the employees are very nice and some do not give a damn. read more

This place makes their own bagels at the site so the bagels are soft and chewy. My favorite is everything bagel with veggie cream cheese. The bagel is huge and it keeps me full until later in the afternoon. Make sure to try with a freshly brewed cup of coffee. I really really like the taste of it as well. Highly recommended! read more

Unsanitary! Walked out after I saw an employee touch money WITH GLOVES ON and then continue to touch my bagel.

this place is the popular go-to bagel spot in town! the location is killer right on madison ave , the parking is great . its easy to pull in , leave the car running and grabbing a 2$ cup of coffee the customer service is great. nice polite , fixes mistakes without arguing ( bc thats the worst!) clean store its definitely the place for a Sunday morning hang over ! read more