We were there around 8:30 on a Saturday night. Sat at the bar to have a drink and a couple of appetizers. We had stuffed mushrooms, stuffed clams and rice balls. The mushrooms were like rubber and the baked clams were just cheese in a clam shell and not very good. The rice balls ok. I felt like these were left over from a party and microwaved and brought out to us. How this place is still there with all the great italian food on LI is beyond me. Will not be going back. read more

"Borrelli's Italian Restaurant" is not a Pizzeria, they are a Italian Restaurant. Just wanted to make that clear. It is a great dining experience for the entire family. I pulled up to the large parking lot and couldn't believe how colorful the outside of the building looked. It was nice to see such brave choices used to bring a positive vibe. Heading in I was equally impressed. The place was immaculate and big. It was really spacious. I had went to the counter to place my order when I met with the most wonderful woman there. She was friendly and extremely professional. She talked to me as if I was her best friend and it made me feel great. The atmosphere in the place also made me feel comfortable, that and the classic music playing in the background. I saw a gentleman walk in to the place not to order food, but to have a conversation with the owner. Can you believe that. The lady I was talking to told me the rich history of the restaurant. It's been around for 63 years, that longer then I've been alive! She also told me they cater for parties up to one hundred people. Nice for a graduation or surprise party. They also offer karaoke and live music on Thursday's so they offer a excellent time for groups. Only negative was they had a ten dollar spending limit, but I was over the limit so I didn't need cash. They don't do slices. So I got a personal pie and waited patiently for it. But once I smelled what they had cooking I became a little impatient. I wanted to know what this place was about. I soon found out when my boxed pizza came out. It was hot and fresh. I sat down and just took a minute to admire such beauty. It was like looking at a woman for the first time, or the first time you learned how to ride a bike. I mean it was special. When I grabbed the first slice I knew I was in trouble because I understood that this wasn't going to end well for the pie. The relationship ended quickly, but the memory of the taste would last forever. I was sold on that crunchy crust, the juicy chicken and the side of blue cheese they gave me. It was more then I could handle. I even thought about getting ice cream, which they do offer as well. Everything about this place was amazing. The food, atmosphere and staff were excellent. The pain of missing the food was so extreme that I would soon have to take a shot at love again. I'm a sucker for true loves first bite. read more

See all

Borrelli's Restaurant has been a pillar of great food and customer service for many years. It is a family run business, and their priority is clearly making customers happy, satisfied, while making them feel at home. The food and service is always consistent and delicious! In addition, they go above and beyond for large group parties to make sure everything flows smoothly for the special occasion! read more

Borrelli's - Italian Near Me - East Meadow, New York

See all

Did take out tonight , couldn't have been better. We ordered the family meal for 4. It was ready when we got there, the chicken parm and rigatoni vodka was delicious. Even the salad was good. Great value , much appreciated in this stressful time. The staff served me with a smile, that helps too! read more

The place is old school Italian. The bread was very good, the appetizer and dinner were decent. Nothing really stood out. Except the lack of service unfortunately. Saw my waitress for my order and giving me my food. Needed another drink but never saw her. I always heard good things about this place. Hopefully it was just an off day. Place was pretty empty minus a party in the back room. read more

My family took me here for dinner when I was visiting last weekend. I currently live in Florida, so when I'm back up on Long Island visiting bagels and Italian food are a must. My uncle described Borrelli's as "sloppy Italian food" which I loved. It wasn't messy, but this isn't the type of place where you'll get gourmet food, small plates, and expensive prices. This was good, old fashioned, Italian food. I had the stuffed shells and boy we were they stuffed! So much cheese-it was wonderful. The bread they bring out ahead of time is warm as well, which is a great touch! read more

Great food. The kitchen even agreed to cook us up some extra francaise sauce for what we could not finish to take home. Value was very good too, and they do promote with generous 20% off weekday coupons. I will more than likely go back because the food really was standout but I will request from hostess that we do NOT get same waitress/server who was inattentive and lacking. Service was unacceptably slow despite being one of just three parties at the place for dinner it took the waitress way too long to find us and she was scarce even though we were the only table she had. 4 star rating because I was there once before, the food was great then too and I know service can be respectable-- just guess it depends on server. Went back-Kristen and crew are top notch! Food great again-I had lasagna. Music entertainment on Saturday night is possibly a great idea, but the guy was playing way too loud, which resulted in very loud restaurant conversation. I think he was awful to be honest so maybe they should just shut it down or find someone else. read more

I usually don't go out of my way to leave reviews. But what an excellent place. I've lived here for 20 years and never came in. Today was my first time and I regret not coming before! Excellent food, flavor, and ambiance. My server was also a very kind young gentlemen. Theres a reason this place has been around so long. Give it a try! read more

Borrelli's - Four pasta for 2 - Italian Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Linguine clam, round Sicilian pie, gelato. Nothing else to say. Go here. Right off meadow brook parkway (and on my way to stew leanards). Dining room is really nice and take out is done perfectly. read more

Absolutely terrible!!! Ordered stuffed shrimp that was not edible and sent it back. Stuffing was all bread with no taste and other part of dish too salty. Side of pasta with garlic and oil had no taste and was overpriced at $11 for a small side plate. (Would not have ordered if I was told price) Table next to us sent back all of their food and was complaining. Service was excellent, not her fault food is so bad. Would never go back. My companion's food also was not good. A waste of $85.00. read more

Went to a private party here last night. Salad was served family style, in two large bowls. Both salads contained cheese. A problem for some with dairy issues. When asked, was told there are no other options. Then pasta course. Ask if there are non- gluten options. Was told take pasta or not. No options. The entree is served with no sides. Just protein on the plate. Server said pasta was second course. I asked for veggies. "No". In 2017, most restaurants are more accommodating to patrons with food sensitivities. I would never hold a function here. read more

Great family Italian restaurant. Detroit style pizza (only Thursday) a must have, that crust is amazing. Delicious meatballs. Service is fast and friendly. Music some nights, call to confirm. Homemade gelato too! read more

We had our company holiday party here tonight for 70 people! Angela and Frankie Borrelli did an outstanding job organizing this event! Everything was perfect! The staff was super attentive and the food was delicious! We had plenty of room to accommodate all our guests! The bartender was a pro! She handled the crowd with ease and grace! This literally was the BEST party we have had in the 5 years that I have been planning them!!! Thank you Borrelli's for an epic event!! We will see you soon! read more

Very low quality food, waiter seemed way too occupied to even refill my water once. Sauce was basically red water, also got a hero which was a complete mess. Hero bread was a soggy mush with a very thin, rubbery piece of chicken. Thankfully I ordered off the lunch menu but other than that, you will be very disappointed if you get one of the $30 entrees. Don't go here. read more

I came here for a private event. The space was spacious and private. The service was attentive and courteous. The bar even has some beers on tap which I haven't seen at too many Italian restaurants. I had the rigatoni with meat sauce followed by the veal parmigiana. Both were delicious. The pasta and meat was perfectly seasoned and cooked. It had a great balance between savoriness and saltiness. The portions were handsomely generous. read more

Definitely delicious food played classic Music pizza was delicious salads were good the ice cream was good read more

See all

My boyfriend grew up right around the corner from borelli's. The calimar was great and linguine with red was even better. They accomadate to most requests. Great people. Great place. Great flavor. Guarantee to leave full and with a smile read more

See all

I tend to come here once every few years because I always forget about my past experience. I do enjoy the ambiance with the brick walls and showcase of the desserts in the front, but it seems that it needs a new face lift. The bar seems misplaced and when one of the members of the party ordered a special veal dish, the waiter asked if she wants salad (ok), pasta (ok) or, fries (WHAT!!!) In an authentic Restaurant, you are going to offer fries on a specialty veal dish? how does that match well? Anyway, the pizza was very good, a nice change to the ordinary NY pizza the chicken in my parm sandwich was good, but the sauce was chunky. My friend's Penne alla vodka was "kick ass" as she proclaims and the other member loved his chicken franchese. All in all, it was a nice quiet dinner that we all thoroughly enjoyed. The yelp deal helped a little as well read more

Borrelli's - Italian Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Food is sub par. For $300 (with tip) was hoping for a decent meal. The shrimp Francese was BORING and had no flavor. For $30, expected more. Expensive for boring food. Dessert was good. One and done!!!!!! read more

When we went, it may have just been an off day (this was a little while ago, just never got around to this) The mozzarella sticks tasted freezer burned and we're somewhat tough. Then the lasagnas came out and weren't edible... The meat was rubbery, the pasta was mushy, The ricotta was overpowering, and the sauce didn't have any flavor. On the upside, the staff was extremely friendly and there was a decent tribute band playing read more

Came here tonight for dinner. Had the baked clams..they were good. I had angel hair with arrabbiata sauce which was very spicy and tasty. I think you should definitely try this place..it's a hidden gem! read more

Borrelli's - Italian Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Hot spot for Isles games, great tap beer and heros. There's a bar at the front and a ton of seating in the back. LGI

Pasta for 2 was enough to feed 4 people. Baked clams were delicious. Mozzarella was mixed in with the stuffing and the extra sauce was perfect. Garlic bread was amazing. Chunks of garlic and light on the grease. Table Chianti was very good and definitely ready to drink. One of the best value Italian restaurants around. read more

I came here with a large group and they were able to set us and serve us promptly and with such poise. Borrelli's was very helpful with accommodating gluten allergies and other food preferences. The atmosphere was nice and the restaurant is set up with mirrors and beautiful art to make it look very elegant and grande. I would definitely come back! read more

Ordered take out from here tonight. The pasta was totally bland. I got penne Alla vodka which was ziti for some reason and my boyfriend's chicken was okay but came with a side of pasta with marinara which had no flavor. I was literally worried I was getting covid because of the lack of flavor from the pasta sauces and rice balls. The rice balls didn't have much flavor but the marinara on the side tasted like jarred sauce. I tried to add flavor to the vodka sauce by adding seasonings and cheese but nothing really helped. I ended up tossing the meal and ordering from somewhere else. read more

This place has been around forever. Surprised to see it as busy as it was on a weeknight since the Nassau Coliseum closed for renovations. Anyway let's get to the food. Basic Italian. Everything you would expect to see on their menu. No surprises. Salad starter was fresh, crisp and not drowning in dressing. The veal parm and lasagna are solid "3"s. Not a bad thing when that's what you expect. Service was good. Location was convenient for a business meeting and I knew it wouldn't be a 1 or 2 star. They are consistent. Full bar. Plenty of parking in their lot. I'm sure if I tried a few other items on the menu there would be a couple of "4" star dishes. Maybe next time. read more

Went tonight to have dinner with our daughter. College student came down for a bit to eat. GROSSSSSSSS. The food was awful. The stuffed mushrooms were disgusting. Not baked, soggy just yuck. Had the stuffed shells and the sauce was awful and salty and the pasta floury. Mr.Romances, lobster Ravioli was in penne sauce also yuck. NEVER AGAIN. I usually read my Yelp reviews before trying a new place, I didn't this time. Again I learn my lesson. Look at Yelp first and enjoy your meal second. Only reason for 1 Star have to put something. read more

Wife picked up a pie last night since we were in the area and we are big barstool fans. Prez should of gave it an 8! Great pizza and the staff were great. read more

I stopped in after seeing it on Barstool and the pizza lived up! I also take my Italian restaurants very seriously and this place had all the old school charm and lovely service. Looking forward to more takeout soon. read more

Yesterday I ordered the chicken parm dinner with penne and tomato sauce and a Caesar salad on the side. I also got a small personal pie. Everything came to my house within 15-20 minutes of my order. Everything was delicious! I unfortunately did not take pictures this time to share, but I was so happy to have that meal. I've ordered out a few times now and the quality is consistently great! I also ate at the restaurant one night back in September and I remember the dine in experience being great. This restaurant does not seem to need much advertising or Yelp to maintain its business. It's been around for decades and many former residents of East Meadow go out of their way to dine here when they come back to visit. I like this place. I really do. I look forward to eating from here again in the future! Thank you! read more

I've been here once and that's all I really needed. This place is very cozy and feels like a traditional Italian home. However, the food was not as good as I expected it to be, very average. I was really expecting some good traditional Italian grandma's cooking, but it was like eating pasta from a regular pizzeria. It's alright, glad I gave it a try. read more

Went here 2 weeks ago to see my mom's friend perform in their tent and it was GREAT! Atmosphere was awesome, Caesar salad and grappa sauce was GREAT- I'd have it every day if I could. Performer has ALS and performs there on Wednesdays- he is great and super inspirational. Highly recommend! read more

Very nice staff! Thanks to the young lady for bringing my food to the car, I'm stuck on crutches for a few more weeks. Food was great as usual. read more

The best part of my experience at Borrelli's was walking out the door. I will never return to this place. The food was horrid and the employees were disrespectful. I overheard one employee say to another "I bet that fat whale over there could eat six of our pizza pie even though they taste like packing peanuts". Completely unacceptable. Don't spend your money here! read more

A local legend, Borrellis is one of the best restaurants and definitely has the best pizza. They've been owned and run by the same family since the 50s and make you feel like family. The round Sicilian pie is a big fat mozzarella dream. Once in awhile they have live comedy with an included prix fixed menu. I loved the local comedians. read more

See all

Our first time at Borrelli's and will not be our last. The service and food were amazing. Our waiter went out of his way to make us feel like regular customers. The bread came out toasted and warm. The meal was delicious. I would highly recommend Borrelli's if you are looking for a great Italian meal. read more

I had my engagement party here super last minute IT WAS GREAT! I was really upset because the venue that I previously booked, Mio Posto Hicksville, literally decides to closed down a week before my party with no explanation so shady but Frank was extremely accommodating and I felt a relief when he said it wasn't going to be a problem to host our party. The food was delicious and there was sooooo much of it. The place is super cozy and you just feel very comfortable. Staff was amazing. Borrelli's does not disappoint! read more

This place is a joke! I came here to celebrate my friend Java baby. The food was salty, customer service was terrible. We were given tin pans to put our left overs in and the tins had roaches in them!! Baby roaches all over the tin pans. We told the waitress and they tried to justify it by saying " it wasn't in the food, they were just in the tin pan" HELLO roaches shouldn't be anywhere!! Poor response to a valid complaint. Do not come here. read more

I have been meaning to review this place for a while but I never knew where to start. This is a classic Italian place. I love the Chicken Parm and I'll occasionally split a pie. If you love Italian this is definitely the place to go. It's fantastic and it's been around before I was born. Great place, absolutely can't wait to return read more

ONE BITE EVERYONE KNOWS THE RULES. This place lived up to the 7.9 review on barstool. I liked how the place has been there since 1950 and that they do personal pies. The specialty pies are a little pricy, but worth it. read more