What a Reuben !!!!!!! Have had quite a few from here and where excellent with pastrami or corned beef. Pleasant and efficient staff too. They tell me the bagels are good. read more

My coworkers and I ordered bagels from here for a late breakfast. The bagels were HUGE. They were super fresh and soft on the inside and firm on the outside. We devoured the bagels so I could only take a picture of the one that wasn't eaten yet. The everything bagel was so good. The top and bottom halves of the bagel is seasoned and it has salt on it as well. I would love to get more bagels from here again. read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Takeout bag - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Stopped in for a quick lunch pickup. Place is packed, lots of people in and out. I got the Rueben sandwich it came with Cole slaw. Was pretty good, the Cole slaw was excellent. Daughter got the meatball parm sub, said it was quite good and very filling. Other daughter had the turkey club, she enjoyed it very much. All the kids enjoyed the fries, was more than enough for a few people to share. Nice spot to stop in and have lunch, will be back to try more stuff. read more

See all

Stopped in around 2 o'clock on a weekday to grab a bagel sandwich. One other person in front of us. Ended up waiting about 20 minutes after ordering because there was only one person behind the counter. The sandwiches were huge and delicious, though! They should hire more help especially around lunchtime. read more

I come here for the breakfast sandwiches, they are great. Eat in or take out. Friendly staff. Reasonable prices. I usually call ahead to order and it's usually done by the time I get there. read more

I've been coming here for years, and they have never failed to make me feel like I'm getting my money's worth. $11 for a Turkey Ham and Cheese with 2x the amount of meat Jersey Mikes would give you for $4 less. + Chips are included. It is the one of the BEST sandwiches I've had for the price. I do independent food reviews on specifically bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches all around North Jersey, and Brooklyn Bagel is hands down top 3 if not top 2. The ratio between cheese and bread is the best among North Jersey bagel shops. They load it up with crispy bacon every time. The atmosphere is so welcoming, they have a massive drink selection and very good specialty coffee. They also make fresh Mediterranean desserts which taste incredible and makes it a nice Lunch spot for a sweet treat. The service is lightning quick and even when the line is long, you get your food in less than 15 minutes. I've been swearing by the place for years and all of my friends which I've put on since then, will tell you the exact same thing. Brooklyn Bagels is legit. read more

See all

These bagels are massive. Doughy on the inside and crispy on the outside, perfect IMHO! I'm lucky enough to have a co worker who lives in Randolph bring them to gatherings at work but I'm going to have to go for myself one time to see the place and try more items! read more

I LOVE this bagel place. I've never had a better tasting bagel. I drive 45 mins for these bagels every few weeks. They freeze beautifully. Service is fine. Ambiance kind of reminds me of a snack counter at a movie theatre but it's a bagel shop not a restaurant, so it's really not an issue. read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Everything and sesame seed bagels - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Another bagel adventure with my Daughter led us to Randolph to try Brooklyn Bagel & Deli. On a snowy day with hunger building we headed out. The place is in a strip Mall off RT 10. It was hopping when we entered. We wanted to try the French toast bagel but they were out. So we ordered a pumpernickel a d a. Everything bagel with Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese. Bagels came out very hot as in just off grill with grill Marks. Bagels were big and very filling. Everything was cooked nicely and the structural integrity held up. This is key because I do t like my bagel sandwich falling apart. There was seating inside and a lot of parking available. I'd come back here. Nice people. Also large selection of Greek goodies to bring home. Check it out if you are in the area. read more

See all

There's a lot of competition in the Randolph area with Bagel shops. For me, I just moved Brooklyn Bagel to the top of the list. I've been coming here more and more often over the past year and rest like it. The bagels here are excellent. Today, I had a sausage, egg, and cheese on an egg bagel and it was delicious. Other favorites are the Asiago, marble rye, and everything. My wife always gets the French Toast bagel warmed with a little butter. Other advantages....plenty of parking here, the prices are less than some of the other places, and the staff is much friendlier. There's also plenty of room to sit inside in a nice atmosphere. My Best Bagel in Randolph award now goes to Brooklyn Bagel! read more

See all

Food was not good and service wasn't helpful at all. Unfortunately will not be coming back

I tried their bagel for the first time this weekend. The girl at the register was very nice. Everything was made fresh. There bagels were still hot when they serve me it. This is my new favorite spot read more

Look at the food scale how dirty that is. They actually put peoples food it, there opened at 6 o'clock in the morning an is the busiest hour. They have one person at the counter takes forever to get a sandwich. Will not be back there. read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Food scale, this place is extremely dirty. Look at that scale that was like that at 6 AM this morning. It looks like it hasn't been cleaned - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Awesome spot! In addition to all of the great bagels, they have some pretty awesome sandwhich offerings. I had the chicken cutlet sandwich after it was recommended to me by a friend and it was delicious. They also have a nice sitting area if you choose to eat in. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area! read more

Love the tuna on a bagel. We love the bagels and the lox spread is delicious. Quick service. Favorite bagel place.

Terrible people. Terrible management. Lost customer due to them not fixing THEIR mistake. Totally unwilling to make a problem right. DO NOT GOT THERE read more

Our go to, they always stack the bagels with whatever meat we get and they never disappoint! While we were waiting for our bagels we were watching the guy making fresh bagels by hand! read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Pork egg and cheese bagel with tomato - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Delicious delicious BECb the bagels are so delicious and so big! I couldn't finish the entire thing but it was soooo tasty. I love the seating area and all the varieties they offer. read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Bacon, Egg and Cheese Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

I love this place. I'm a student at the nearby college so it's a perfect place to grab a quick lunch. It's super clean, they have a broad menu of subs and sandwiches, along with a great selection of bagels. They have a nice seating area inside and all sorts of foreign cookies, crackers, and other good there. Their service is quick and very friendly, they also have one kiosk for self-ordering. Their prices are also very reasonable. I was able to get an italian sub w/ mayo & extra vinegar (comes with coleslaw and a pickle), a monster, and a snapple for $13, also came with a reusable bag and napkins. I've paid that much for just a sub and a water at other delis. read more

See all

This location in Randolph Nj is clean, and the food is hot and tasty. Large menu boards surround the bagel store, so you always know what you want . If you want a fresh hot bagel or a deli sandwich, there is always something for everyone on. This place is always packed so wait times for food may vary. But over all this is a good establishment. read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Sign board - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

2 stars because once they get it right its not bad. However I have been to this place a number of times. Today will finally be the last time. I have never had a hot breakfast sandwich. I attribute this to them cooking a large number of eggs and storing them off to the side of the griddle on the warm side and keeping them there for a while. You would think by doing this you would get your order quickly, but no. The place could be empty inside with no other orders, and you will wait 5-10 minutes for a sandwich that comes out with a Luke warm egg, deep fried charred bacon and about 4-5 slices of cheese (some may like eggs with their cheese sandwiches). Advice If you make your sandwiches to order like EVERYWHERE else you will serve a quality hot product. tell your cooks to stop being lazy, you're not that busy that you need to cook 20 eggs and store them for an hour, they come out cold, hard and rubbery. Nobody likes cold unmeted cheese on their sandwiches. The kicker to all this. after complaining and having them re make the order i made a comment that its constantly cold, and the women said "i know i know" read more

I've been going to this place for a while, and I'm always happy after I leave. They have a great assortment of big, fluffy bagels and sandwiches for some of the most reasonable prices around. I personally always go for the sesame toasted with butter on the side which never fails to impress. They give it to you fresh out the toaster within a minute or two with enough butter on the side for a family of 5 (not a bad thing considering the price). The only thing I would say is get the butter on the side because they tend to put a bit too much on if you don't ask for it on the side. Review 4.3/5 read more

Updating my review. This location maintains a 5 star rating. Food quality and choice of fresh bagels remains excellent. Staff is friendly and are able to actually deliver what has been ordered time and again. I dont mind adding a tip for takeout orders when service is friendly and consistent as is the case here. Bagel and scallion cc - excellent. Bagel and egg w taylor ham - great. And their coffee is strong and hot. I will continue to recommend and support this business. They make an effort to get things right and its appreciated! read more

For the #kindnesschallenge @BigDudesBigFoods decided to buy #RainbowBagel #BreakfastSamiches from @Brooklyn.Bagel for all of the guys we work with. They were really good samiches! If you are in Randolph and want a good one, this is the place! Spread kindness anyway you can. It doesn't have to be with samiches but it works for us. #actofkindness #BigDudesBigFoods #CelebrateEveryDay #foodies #foodiesofinstagram #globaleats #shenanigans #BDBFCertified #cheatday #cheatdayeats #cheatmeal #ThePhoneEatsFirst #WOYP #Forkyeahfoodies @forkyeahfoodies #ClearEyesFullBelliesCantLose read more

See all

Place is descent . They pack the sandwiches just the flavor isn't good taste blah. But you will get your moneys worth as long as you don't like seasoning . read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Taylor ham bacon egg cheese - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Best bagels and sandwiches in New Jersey! My boyfriend and I come here all of the time and I don't think any other bagels around compare.

Honestly not good. Got a roast beef sandwich. The meat wasn't super fresh and wasn't rare and the bread was awful. Their "roll" or "sub" bread is awful- dry and no flavor. We asked prior if there was any other options and they said no. Should have pushed the situation and got a bagel. Pickle was soggy and off. Go to the cash only bagel place on route 10- my all time favorite and always good. Good point. Price wasn't bad but taste was bad. read more

I love Brooklyn Bagels! Fresh and tasty bagels every time - $2.75 each. I especially love the blueberry bagel with walnut raisin cream cheese. I'd imagine it tastes good with cinnamon honey cream cheese too, but they're always out of it when I want to order it lol. read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Blueberry bagel (left) and rainbow bagel (right) with walnut raisin cream cheese! - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Great, and underrated bagel spot in Randolph, NJ. This is the place to come to for a great fresh bagel.

First I went to this place for breakfast the service was good and table was clean and the food was delicious the bagel was good and BIG it was great 9.5/10 would recommend! read more

My wife said to try this far-from-our-home bagel place. She loves French toast bagels and her research said they have the best. Her review says 5 stars. As Duke Philip the Good of Burgundy once said about his wins, none other will I have. Their basic bagels are good too. 5 stars for a new find for Sunday bagels. read more

Overall very pleased with our pit stop for lunch here. Nice eating area and everyone was happy with what they ordered. Pastrami Ruben hit the spot and bagels are big and fluffy. Missing a star because it's was 85 degrees by the register on a nice spring day but they finally opened the door and some windows. Service was a little slow with the place not being very busy. Still would stop back to try something different if I was in the area. read more

Inattentive rude staff ordered a t ham e+c. Dry flavorless lukewarm and stale bagel. I dont expect much in the way of customer service just a good hot bagel breakfast sandwich. Place was empty I ordered a few mins later 3 people came in ordered after me. I noticed a sandwich sitting on the line then another appeared and then a 3rd. All the while the 2 front staff were chatting while now surely my sandwich was sitting. All 3 people that ordered after me got their orders which clearly included hot bfast sandwiches like mine. Pretty shitty attitude as the woman finally got mine and said nothing about the mistake and my order getting skipped. The THEC sure enough was luke warm from sitting out. Cheese barely melted either. Bagel was dry and stale chew. Even with SPK sand was dry and pretty flavorless. Do better BB read more

This is one of the nicest looking bagel establishments I've seen in my travels in northern and central New Jersey. Many bagel restaurants have very limited seating areas. This place has a decent size outdoor and indoor seating area with a television, so you don't have to eat and run. I ordered a turkey bacon, Swiss cheese, and egg white sandwich on a blueberry bagel and it came out exactly as I requested. The size and taste of the bagel were both very good. Many of the reviews we're not so kind to the staff inside the restaurant, but I didn't have anything to complain about. If I was in the area, I would stop by again. read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Blueberry bagel with turkey bacon, egg white, and Swiss cheese. - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Still the best bagels and bagel sandwiches in NJ. ALWAY fresh, often still hot! Been coming for 6 years I think. Owner Bobby a great guy. read more

Brooklyn Bagel & Deli - Taylor Ham and Egg Whites on toasted marble rye bagel - Delis Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

great bagels and friendly staff always good and very good assortment clean and well run read more

Edit : lowering my star rating, due to repeated interactions with rude staff, and my food being made incorrectly My daughter really enjoyed the bagels here, as they have several colorful options. I had a Greek salad with grills chicken, which was quite tasty . So much so, that I didn't mind the tiny bug I found in it. I would definitely return to Brooklyn Bagel & Deli, even if the staff isn't friendly . read more

See all

Great place. Discovered by accident after Java Joe's people turned out to be deplorable goniffs the way they treated customers. Brooklyn has great bagels and fast service. read more

Average tasting bagels, Jumbo size , looks clean cost is reasonable in this Biden economy. Little disorganized or chaos because the cashiers are taking customers cash , plus call orders and jumping in with other staff . I guess just be prepared before entering . read more

I know it's a dick move to pull up like thirty minutes before closing time, but I'm from Texas and all I wanted was a jersey bagel. We came here at 3:30 and the doors were locked with the employees clearly inside. People quite literally just walked out with bagels but the front door is locked. All I'm saying is if you're gonna say you're closing at four, actually close at 4 pm read more