Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Brooklyn's Brooklyn's Olde Towne Arvada

    5.0 (1 review)

    Brooklyn's Brooklyn's Olde Towne Arvada Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Brooklyn's Brooklyn's Olde Towne Arvada

    Recommended Reviews - Brooklyn's Brooklyn's Olde Towne Arvada

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Naomi A.
    104
    59
    68

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Brooklyn's Finest Pizza

    Brooklyn's Finest Pizza

    4.4(588 reviews)
    2.6 miNorthwest
    $$
    Full bar
    Catering service

    Ordered delivery from Brooklyn's Finest Pizzas after a long workday and got the Little Italy pizza…read morewith the Italian chopped salad. Everything showed up still warm, and the order was packed carefully so nothing was messy when we opened it. The pizza had a really good crust and enough toppings without feeling overloaded. I also liked that the salad tasted fresh instead of something thrown together last minute. Delivery timing was close to what they quoted online, which I appreciated since a lot of places run late on weekends. Solid experience overall and definitely better than the usual chain pizza spots nearby.

    While in Northwest today, my assistant suggested stopping by Brooklyn's Finest Pizza for an…read moreauthentic New York style slice, and it proved to be a thoroughly delightful choice. Situated right on the corner, the location offers convenient street-side access and a cozy, well-maintained waiting area. While the interior is somewhat compact, it remains impeccably clean and remarkably convenient for a swift, comfortable bite. The entire aesthetic pays a charming homage to classic Manhattan charm, and I was pleased to note their seamless options for both takeout and delivery. The service was remarkably patient, courteous, and efficient. To begin, I ordered a classic Margarita cocktail, though I was equally impressed by their well-curated selection of fine craft beers. For my meal, I selected the Supreme pizza, customized with black olives, green peppers, red onions, and an extra portion of savory meats the customizability here is truly wonderful. When the pizza arrived with impressive speed, it was an absolute triumph crispy, hot, and rich with bold, nostalgic NYC flavor. Between the spotless environment, remarkably fast service, and authentic culinary execution, Brooklyn's Finest Pizza earns a very solid four stars. A wonderful, high-value spot I shall certainly be returning

    Photos
    Brooklyn's Finest Pizza
    Brooklyn's Finest Pizza
    Brooklyn's Finest Pizza

    See all

    Randi's Pizza & Italian Restaurant - 8" Pepperoni for Lunch! Delicious

    Randi's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

    3.8(191 reviews)
    3.0 mi
    $$

    FRI-YAY FIELD REPORT:…read more Alright you beautiful chaos goblins, it's Friday night and I found myself back at Randi's. You know the place, strip mall chic, nothing fancy, the kind of spot where you show up in whatever you wore to Target and nobody blinks. I've been here before, and honestly the experience has always been a bit of a roulette wheel: sometimes great, sometimes just ....meh. Tonight? Buckle up First, the service. I'm not asking for Broadway jazz hands and a standing ovation when I walk in, but a hint of pleasantness would be nice. My server looked like smiling might actually cause structural damage to her face. Honey, that scowl was so deep it came with its own zip code. Those cause wrinkles, sweetie. Just saying. While I waited (and waited... and waited...) I was treated to a lovely soundtrack of staff conversations about doom, gloom, and existential dread. Babe... I'm just trying to order carbs, not prepare for the apocalypse It was not exactly the light Friday night vibe I was going for while trying to order a drink. BTW It took a solid stretch of time just to get that drink and put in an order. I kept checking my watch like I was waiting for a delayed flight. Eventually, we got the drink and the order placed. The food shows up and let's give the kitchen the applause it deserves because the food crew clearly came to work tonight. Actually good. Not "call the Vatican we've witnessed a miracle" good, but solid. The antipasto salad was fresh and yes they included peppers, which I appreciate because some places act like peppers are a controlled substance. And the calzone? The bread was homemade. And listen... when you bite into bread that clearly came from a real human effort and not a Sysco freezer tomb, you notice. It was warm, chewy, and legitimately good. So now I'm emotionally conflicted. The kitchen is back there doing honest Italian-food work while the front of house is acting like they're being forced to serve pasta at emotional gunpoint. The Breakdown: Calzone bread: Homemade, heroic, deserves a medal Antipasto: Fresh, crunchy, pepper-inclusive (we love representation) Food overall: Solidly good Service: If enthusiasm were calories this would be a diet plate Randi's, my chaotic carb dealer, I will probably return because that bread had my attention. But next time maybe let the staff know it's okay to experience joy.

    Great sausage and cheese with peppers sandwich. I recommend this restaurant a 100 percent. Server…read morecommunication was good.

    Photos
    Randi's Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Pizza box

    Pizza box

    Randi's Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Our $20 dinner. Not bad portion size, quality taste for sure!

    Our $20 dinner. Not bad portion size, quality taste for sure!

    Randi's Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Meatball Calzone

    See all

    Meatball Calzone

    Pietra's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant - Hawaiian pizza and salad

    Pietra's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

    3.4(183 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    $$

    They were gracious to accommodate our party at the last minute when another restaurant double…read morebooked. We were placed in the private room and a buffet set up for us. Water and iced tea provided in the room and other drinks ordered at the bar. We had a bowl of salad and different flavors of pizza. Hawaiian, pepperoni, sausage... The place is worn and comfortable. Nothing flashy. Restroom located in the private room so it was awkward because we were making presentations and guests would come in to use the restroom. Local artwork is available for purchase and decorates the walls . Photos of the local youth football team the restaurant sponsors. The salad was meh. The pizza not bad. I had the pepperoni and the crust was crisp and the pizza not oily. My friend liked her Hawaiian pizza slice. The server was average. Sodas came in large cups. No red pepper flakes or Parmesan cheese provided. I guess you would have to request it but we were busy with the event and I didn't. Parking in shared lot. It's a cool place but not modern. The server wasn't that friendly. But solid pizza. And they accommodated our large party.

    I was starving, hadn't had hardly anything to eat all day and got seated right away even though…read morethey were busy with to dinner rush. The dining room has a homey throwback vibe. Didn't get off to a good start, our margherita pizza came to the table without basil; I'll give them the benefit of the doubt that they ran out... but still I ordered linguine with sausage and it came out with meatballs, but they gave me a side of sausage to make up for the mixup. Lastly, I wasn't offered a top off or refill on my drink.

    Photos
    Pietra's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant - Beverages

    Beverages

    Pietra's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant - Pizza buffet

    Pizza buffet

    Pietra's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    Brooklyn's Brooklyn's Olde Towne Arvada - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...