Great pizza, especially the brothers veggie. I like the big slices and thin crust. Fresh veggies and flavorful sauce. I get it close to pay day because it's not cheap, but it's delicious! Best pizza in Crystal River hands down read more

Trying all local places since my regular place went down hill.This so far is in top 3 of 25-30 places Nice crust Real good cheese and plenty of it. Large pizza feed 3 adults an 1 child with ease .Service was good and fast Thanks read more

Pizza was quite good, but do not order their "jumbo" chicken wings. The only thing jumbo about them is the amount of breading. The menu does not indicate they are breaded. We ordered the garlic parmesan cheese wings. They are battered and fried wings that are then saturated in minced garlic and sprinkled with parnesan. I bit into those bits of minced garlic. Disgusting. And I love garlic. Do it right or don't do it at all. If we had only ordered the pizza, I would have given 4 stars. They did offer an in store credit though. read more

First time here. Excellent pizza and sausage bread bowl. Full menu with a lot to choose from. Prices are average. Will definitely be back!

Pizza was delicious! Crispy with a thin crust! Service was great - quick and accurate!

Very rude and unfrendly. Would not deliver to me because I drive a truck. How do they think they get there food to serve....

The best white spinach and mushroom pizza i have ever had![and Im from ny!!!] AND THE OWNER IS VERYYYYYY NICE! Rachel Sherman read more

I'm from NJ and have been looking for a Pizza to remind me of home. THIS IS IT !!. Also try the fried DUCK tenders. I have been to all the Pizza resturants in Crystal River-Homosassa and this beats them all. Fast service, excellent product quality, and some great specialty pizza. read more

A while back this location held a quite nice Italian/Pizza restaurant (don't remember the name) which I enjoyed very much, but it disappeared for some reason. I was again in the neighborhood and saw that the spot was now Brother's Pizza, so hoping that the previous place's Karma was still present I dropped in for lunch. The interior is small but comfortable and clean. My server was friendly and efficient (and also very pretty, but that doesn't impact the review). I had two slices; one pepperoni and one veggie combo, which was spinach, tomato, peppers and 'shrooms with a white sauce, as well as a soda. First - Both these slices had ABSOLUTELY THE BEST CRUST I HAVE EVER HAD. Nominally "thin crust" pizza but not New York thin, it was a perfect combination of light, tender, firm and crispy but not crunchy. Even the outer crust without cheese or toppings was heavenly - I did not leave a crumb. The sauce and toppings, especially on the white pie were also first rate and plentiful. One slice of pizza would have been enough for a lunch with a side salad, but I wanted to try two different types. I will be sure to come back and try some of their other Italian food, as the orders of pasta etc. that I saw being served looked mighty tasty (but it will be hard to beat the pizza)! read more

Not my favorite pizza. To high in salt and use cheddar cheese in their cheese mix not very traditional.

My husband and I eat here at least weekly. It's a very popular place because the pizza and entrees are exceptional. (Try the Brothers veggie pizza - the cheese is like butter!). While it's not big on ambience, it's clean, attractive, and the wait staff are friendly. I've noticed that it's a favorite for groups and families. Their delivery is timely and delivered hot. Give it a try - it's the best pizza in Citrus County! read more

I am super picky about pizza. This place is good and decent prices. The pesto pizza is amazing!!!

Picked this place based on positive Yelp reviews. Got a medium cheese, pepperoni, sausage and bacon for pick-up and took it back to our hotel. It was delicious! Crust was excellent. Would definitely order again if we were local! read more

Amazing Place to eat. The food was awesome. Great Pizza, great bread knots and the bread bowls were good also. The staff was friendly and attentive. We come to Crystal River once a year and we will def make this a repeat restaurant. read more

Great food, and fast delivery. I have not been in the restaurant yet, but it's a definite to do. Fried mushrooms were flavorful, pizza was hot and delicious, and the small salad portions are huge. read more

We ordered a buffalo chicken salad, a small house special pizza, and two bread sticks. They delivered really fast which was nice but they forgot my sauce. The salad was big and had the perfect amount of buffalo chicken on it! I did find a soggy french fry in my salad which was unfortunate. The ranch is the fake stuff which is also disappointing. The pizza was good and very well priced for the size! I tipped the delivery guy but was unaware that they had already charged me $1 for delivery and $1 for gratuity. I obviously tip more than a $1 but it would have been nice to know that was already added on. Overall it was good. read more

Not exactly New York style pizza but pretty close. When I want good pizza this is one of the places I order from.

I just moved here about a month ago. I found my new pizza place! Very good! The crust was excellent and they were very generous with the cheese. They have a full menu with many options. read more

My wife & I have always been chain store pizza people until about six months ago. Now it's Brother's exclusively. Best locally made pizza around, bar none. Everything on the menu is made fresh to order and fantastic. read more

Great pizza, great service. Burbon St. Pizza is the best! Fast delivery too. My favorite pizza place in town.

The best pizza in town, was totally surprised with the quality of the pizza and the expertise in the waitresses! Will definitely go back again! read more

Placed an order for delivery. The guy on the phone wasn't very nice, but the pizza was awesome. Got the chicken & broccoli, huge pieces of pie that had me wanting to eat more! read more

This place is amazing, the only bad thing is I moved away and I haven't found anyone to compare to them. Best Pizza hands down.

I grew up in nyc and I live in Chicago and brothers pizza has really friendly Staff and great pizza! My sister ordered the Greek pizza and loved it, and I had a mushroom spinach and olive pizza which was really good as well! My mom was not a huge fan of their pasta because she thought it was too garlicky, so maybe stick to pizza (that being said my dad who loves garlic was a fan) We also had the garlic knots which were fantastic! Seriously not to sound like a snotty New Yorker but I didn't expect pizza of this quality! Our waitress was super friendly and helpful even though we came close to closing time! read more

Pizza was very good. My kids loved it too. The wings were good as well but i had asked for a few extras they repeated over the phone and then did not bring them. Over food was a five but attention to detail was a 3. I would order again. read more

I can't eat much pizza due to the fats and carbs. In 40 years of being in this area, I have only tried one place, a national chain and it's pretty good but this place is different. I have not had this before. Two pieces and I was full. You get your money's worth, no scrimping on quality ingredients and the sausage is the best I have ever had on pizza. I am no expoert but I would recommend this for some people - those who love a cheesy, tasty pizza. read more

I'm not a pizza fan, but out of the choices in Crystal River, this one's the best. I prefer take out over eating in. We've experienced some interesting service from the waitresses. They do have some decent specials and they do deliver. read more

Stayed the night in Chrystal River and needed something to eat. Saw Brothers Pizza on Yelp and decided to give it a try, and glad I did. My wife and I ordered a medium pizza and split a chef salad, both were excellent, and we had plenty to take with us when we left. The pizza, chef salad, beer and a glass of wine was very fairly priced, less than $35. The wait staff was nice also. I highly recommend giving it a try. read more

Not great...pizza made in a publix shopping center is a joke right...bland ingredients, pricey for not great pizza...won't be back

Best pizza we have ever had. We love the Brother's Veggie with all the garlic. You eat two slices of that and you can blow your breath on a rose and it will WILT! Awesome!................Expensive, but you get what you pay for...........You won't go back to Howie's unless you are serving pizza to your inlaws! read more

Started eating here this summer. Dine in or delivery, the pie is good. Lasagne is also tasty as well as their spaghetti. Staff is prompt and friendly, price is right. Check them out you won't regret it. read more

BAD SERVICE and charged TWICE. A group of us went and stayed at the Port Hole Marina hotel for a friends 30th birthday. We ordered pizza to be delivered. Over an hourlater the delivery driver called wanting to know where we were...HE was at the wrong hotel. When he finally arrived ALL the pizzas were COLD. He took them back to be remade. We waited about 2 1/2 hours for pizza. No discount, no nothing. Then they charged my friends card twice. When she called the manager to have him fix it, he refused to even look at the transaction and told her to file a claim with her bank. They obviously don't care about customer service. BEWARE!!!!! read more

Everything here is made fresh daily...and it shows. The fry their sausage and bacon everyday...veggies chopped fresh...great crust, great sauce! Very small seating area, so would recommend avoiding dining in during peak times. Delivery is a local option. read more

Great pizza and friendly takeout service!

The food is great we have been there many times. But sad to say I probably will never return. My husband and I brought our granddaughter there this evening we had Stromboli and sausage roll very good. My granddaughter just wanted spaghetti with some butter and parm cheese. The spaghetti arrived and about a quarter of it had a big glob of melted cheese, we removed it and she ate some of the spaghetti ( not very good). She also got a salad and bread stick she didn't order or want. When the bill arrived I was shocked to see her spaghetti cost $9.50!!!! Our meals cost $4.95 and $5.95 and well worth it. I asked the server about the price and she asked the boss about it and was told it's a meal and that's the price (I would say not worth more then $5.00). I was not happy but paid the bill. Then another server ( blond hair in ponytail) decided to add her two cents and was very rude I asked if she was the owner ( no ) I told her she was very rude and would not return. She walked away, no apology, I felt bad our server was upset. But rudeness is not acceptable. I will make sure to tell anyone who will listen not to go there. read more

Wanted lunch that had delivery and worst mistake that i could have made. Got the spaghetti because lets be honest its hard to screw spaghetti will I guess I was wrong. It tasted as though it was burnt and overcooked at the same time. I will never eat there again. Oh and called to tell them about it. They wanted to bring me another one well I didn't want another one. NOPE read more

Best pizza in town! There are several varieties to choose from. Spaghetti with meat sauce is very yummy, also.

This is the best pizza we have ever had. We got the meat lovers and the bacon was crispy as well as the sausage had a crispness. The crust was perfect and sauce delicious with just the right amount. Staying at The Hampton Inn and asked for a local pizza place. This is where they recommended and we are certainly happy they did. The pizza was piping hot when delivered. We will certainly be ordering from them more often. read more

I think this is the best pizza in Crystal River, Fl. I have lived and traveled all over the country so I know a good pizza. I had given up on getting a good one here in our little town. I found Brothers last summer and have been going there ever since. The only reason I did not give them 5 stars is because of the price of the salad . If you subtract items from the garden salad you don't like and ask them to put in items you do like they charge you ala carte for each item. So a 7.00 salad became a 12.00 salad. And I'm talking veggies here, not expensive ingredients like meat or seafood. So I just never order the salad anymore. So keep up the good work. read more

What an amazing find! We drove from Lithia to visit the Three Sisters Springs and decided after a long day of paddle boarding we would reward ourselves with some pizza. I Yelped pizza and Brothers Pizza had great reviews. The restaurant is super clean, the service was EXCELLENT and the garlic knots, cheeseburger soup, and pizza was DELISH! We finished with a piece of NY cheesecake that was out of this world! Brothers Pizza has got everything right! A must try! read more