The pizza here is AMAZING! My go to is the steak and cheese sandwich Burke Street style. The cashier is always kind and it is a comfortable dining environment. They also have great deals for different days of the week. If you are in the Winston Salem area and are in need of a good pizza spot then search no further read more

Burke Street Pizza is good, but I don't think it's the best pizza in the area. The pizza is consistently fresh, the portions are fair, and the prices are reasonable. I've eaten here several times and have never had a bad meal. The crust has a nice texture, and they offer a good variety of toppings. That said, with so many great pizza spots around, nothing here really stands out enough to make me choose it over some of the competition. The flavor is solid, but it doesn't quite have that "I can't wait to come back" factor. Overall, it's a dependable place if you're craving pizza and happen to be nearby. Good food, friendly service, and worth trying--just don't expect it to be the best pizza you'll ever have. read more

I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Burke Street Pizza - Robinhood. They are, hands down, the best pizza in town! However, our last 3 orders have been wrong. We order delivery because will live close. 1. One order had an unidentifiable 'appetizer' that we had not ordered and our garlic knots were missing. They went in the trash. 2. The last TWO orders I have specified SQUARE CUT (cuz it's an option they offer) and instead have received DOUBLE CUT, which is not the same thing. If you offer the option, then provide the service. So, we haven't ordered the last 2 weekends because the attention to detail has been missing. I KNOW it's just pizza, but the details DO matter. read more

Well, I wish this visit to Burke Street Pizza on Robinhood was better but they were really off their game tonight. Friday is a pretty common night for pizza and Burke street on Robinhood was definitely busy but the dining room was not too full and they had at least 12 people that I could count working so it looked like they were not short staffed. We ordered a few slices and an order of garlic knots. After about 20 min we got our slices but not the garlic knots. My husband reminded them we ordered garlic knots at the counter and they assured us they would be right up. If you don't know, they have a big container of plain garlic knots right behind the front counter they just add the garlic flavored butter/oil to when someone orders them. It's super quick and we usually get them within 5 min. We finished our sliced and still had not gotten our garlic knots. That was when my husband went back up and as soon as he did one of the workers remembered out them. By this time we had been there almost an hour. A couple min later they called us up to get the garlic knots but after eating my slice and waiting so long I didn't really want them. I took a bite of one and it was barely warm. They rushed it so much they didn't even give them time to warm up all the way. As someone who's been part of the restaurant industry for over 30 years, my husband and I could tell the kitchen was not communicating at all with each other. The silence in there was obvious. Communication is the most important part of a kitchen running well and when no one is talking to each other that is when it fails. We still love the pizza at Burke Street and the one on Robinhood is closer to home than the Burke Street location so that's the one we frequent. Hopefully the next time we go in, they will be better. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Menu 1/16/26 - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

Burke Street Pizza is a classic neighborhood pizza joint, nothing more and nothing less. The interior is dark and dated, which, while not terribly appealing, adds to its bona fides. In addition to pizza, the menu includes fried apps, wings, salads, and hot and cold sandwiches. The availability of grandma pies - a Long Island delicacy - was a pleasant surprise. I ordered an Italian sandwich and a veggie slice to go. Both were prepared quickly, and while I wouldn't call service here friendly, it is efficient. The food proved to be fairly satisfying albeit with room for improvement. The sandwich came stuffed with meats (Genoa salami/pepperoni/ham) and veggies though the oil and vinegar was barely discernible. The pizza slice was appreciably huge. Burke Street uses good-quality cheese and a nice sauce as well although the crust isn't as remarkable. As with other places, for specialty slices, they toss on toppings and re-heat, which means that said toppings don't get as cooked as long as they ideally should be. Presumably, a whole pie would offer a better texture. Ultimately, Burke Street pizza proved more serviceable than sensational. You could do a lot worse if a pizza craving hits, but don't expect to be blown away. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Italian sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

See all

Great NY style (or close to it) pizza. Definitely recommend. Also have wings and salads but I mostly stick to take out pizza.

PIZZA REVIEW We ordered two 16" pizzas to go, a Pepperoni and the Ultimate Vegetarian, and they both were hot and hit the spot. The veggie was loaded so the "ultimate" box was checked. About four to five pieces of pepperoni were on each slice of the Pepperoni. The restaurant is located in the corner of the shopping center and not readily visible. Parking is not a problem. I was surprised by how dimly lit the place was upon entering. Although a few patrons sat at tables, most of the activity was take-out based. Other than the amount of veggies on the Ultimate, nothing stood out. Their dough is average, in my opinion, and neither the sauce nor the cheese supplied a pop of extra flavor. It's a solid pizza place, but I'd rather choose another pizzeria next time. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Ultimate Vegetarian Pizza 16" - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

See all

Following our summer vacation, it was time to pick our dog up from our in-laws. On our way, we decided to pick up pizzas, but sadly found that 2 of our favorite Winston spots and former Yelp events aren't open on Sundays. So had to find another spot, and were recommended Burke Street. We wish we'd checked the reviews before going through. We placed the order over the phone, with our first pizza option being rejected and told they don't make it at this location, despite it being on the menu for this location...so we quickly regrouped and placed our order with some other options. We got a large pepperoni pizza, a large bacon cheeseburger pizza and an order of garlic knots. And we were told it would be 15-20 minutes The order was ready by the time we arrived, looked, and smelled good, so we were definitely excited to give it a try. Unfortunately the looks were deceiving, and we found ourselves very disappointed by the quality. The pizza lacked any real flavor despite being incredibly greasy the garlic knots were especially disappointing having absolutely no garlic flavor and again or incredibly greasy. While just trying to tear one of the garlic knots in half I released an ungodly amount of oil on my plate unappetizing. Overall, it was a very disappointing experience, and I would not recommend this spot to anyone, I know I definitely won't be returning read more

See all

The best pizza I have had in Winston-Salem. Everyone there was friendly and nice and did not take long for my order to come up. I will definitely be going back for more. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Lunch special number two. One cheese and one pepperoni pizza, and a drink. - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

Terrible service. I called for delivery and they continuously lied to me about when it would be delivered. I was hung on multiple times with no apologies for the misleading. I live less than a mile from the restaurant. read more

Place is located inside shopping center. Good service. Place is small, so seating is limited to small groups. Food was descent, not impressed with the pizza. Overall just an ok place for a quick bite. read more

You must be doing a lot correctly in a very competitive marketplace when you've been around as long as this restaurant has. The original opened in 2003, and this spot has been open for about 12 years. They offer NY style thin crust with the dough made in house daily and hand tossed before being rolled out! In the pizza area they offer a number of specialty pies, cheese, pepperoni, and specialty pizza of the day by the slice, hot and cold subs, some salad choices, and most of the usual appetizers - and they have daily lunch specials! In this visit, my first, I ordered the #3 Lunch Special - 2 slices of Pepperoni pizza with a large soda for $9.25 - and an 8" Italian Sub for $10.30. The order was up in no more than 10 minutes, and I headed for some near by outside seating with umbrellas to protect from the sun - very pleasant on this sunny day! The pizza slices were huge, the biggest I've seen in the entire Triad! The taste was great, with the pepperoni delivering a real kick. The sub was outstanding - loaded with salami, pepperoni, ham & provolone and well topped with lettuce, tomato & banana peppers, with mayo - no red onion or oil & vinegar (with take out the sub usually gets soggy)! Ambiance - 3 Food - 4.5 Service - 4 Value 4.5 read more

See all

Ordered takeout. Got the 12 piece sweet chili wings fried well done. Order was just coming out when I arrived. I liked the sauce and size of the wings but the blue cheese dressing had zero flavor. Wish I had gotten ranch instead. read more

Top 2 pizza in Winston-Salem. 1 slice is a meal. Our pizza go to. Good wings & meatballs as well. Wife loves the Greek salad. Strong recommendation. read more

We ordered pizza from here and I did not feel like pizza. I got a Cheeseburger hero thinking it would be a burger patty but it was ground beef that was really salty and not very good. Ended up throwing it out. Waste of money! read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

I moved here from n.y. 6 years ago I looked for good pizza everywhere was just ok but I happened to find Burke Street 2 and finally found my go to place everything on menu is good but pizza hands down the Best customer service is great & very clean I don't see what the 3 stars people with negative minds are talking about read more

It's not the best pizza in town, in my opinion, but it can be tasty. It's the type of pizza that's kind of sloppy and doesn't hold itself up. That's a personal taste thing. If you happen to be around T.J. Maxx or Lowes Foods, it's convenient and tasty enough for a great lunch. Oh, and they sell pizza by the slice, which are huge! read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Chicken pesto pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

I've been on a pizza kick lately! Okay, so it's more like a 40 year habit, but I digress! First time trying BS, and they ain't no BS! Got the grandma slice with the cup char pepperoni, and it was scrumptious! Got a "control" slice too, just for quality control purposes, and the quality checks out! I've only gone to this location, and the inside is deceptively large and clean. The staff seemed friendly enough, though I didn't have much interaction. The price seems a tad steep, but good for a treat! I'm sure I'll stop in again for a specialty pie! Cowabunga!!! read more

You can't go wrong at this location. The New York style pizza is ALWAYS great, and the Hot Italian sub with mustard and a side of fries is a GREAT meal! read more

If you like TONS of toppings, eat here!!! And, they let you do a 1/2 & 1/2 pizza! That is all I have to say... :-) read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Five Meat & Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

See all

This is the second location for Burke Street Pizza and I highly recommend it. It always has consistent service and their pizza is really good. They also have some really great salads that are often overlooked but a really great side to balance out the pizza. read more

Burke St pizza is SO underrated. I must say-it is traditionally a late night stop, but is just one of the BEST options in town for NY style pizza. We stopped in for lunch today. The hubby got pepperoni pizza but I had to be a bit difficult, and they were SUPER accommodating. I ordered 2 slices of the lasagna pizza (if you haven't tried it-you're missing out) and added mushrooms and onions. Also-I needed a side salad with ranch. Their ranch is so yummy. I honestly had forgotten how huuuuuge the slices are, so I got to take one home for later. We ordered at the counter, and it was done pretty quickly. Minus one star for the restroom situation-they could use some TLC. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Lasagna Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

See all

I usually think of Burke St as my late night downtown snack option. It's a gem after a long night. Today we did lunch at the robinhood location. It was great! Crispy, a little greasy, tasty, NY pizza. Of course the slices are huge! I had a couple slices of traditional pepperoni. Two slices were more than enough. My wife picked up a salad and a couple slices of lasagna with mushrooms and onions added. Hers was great too...shout out to the sausage! And the homemade ranch is best in class...order plenty! The service was kind and quick. You order at the counter and seat yourself. They were very accommodating for my wife's picky order. read more

See all

We stop in here at least 3 times a month. We appreciate how late they open on Friday and Saturday nights. We usually just order a slice of pepperoni pizza, fried ravioli, 6 hot wings. The food I always so warm and delicious. The hot wings are crunchy on the outside. One time I got the Angry Honey Bee (I think it might be called something different inside the store, my angry honey or something. This is what the menu states it called) and it was delicious it had spicy soppressata, hot cherry peppers, mozzarella and honey drizzle on it. I've never been let down by Burke street and we can always get out pretty cheap. It's a great little pizza joint. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Half angry honey bee half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

See all

This Burke Street Pizza location seems to be really polarizing for many people, and I have to say that my visit was really nothing special either. As others have said, it's not a particularly inviting spot, isn't very well lit, and generally just feels kind of dingy on the inside. At lunch time you can get a couple of one topping slices and a drink for a decent price, but know that you'll likely be getting a reheated pizza. Not that that isn't common practice at many places, but many that do it only mostly cook the pizza beforehand, then when they put it back in the oven, it cooks to full and is warm for you. Here, the result is a very dry and crispy slice, with not much cheese to keep the top moist, and the sauce a bit insulated. The slices are nice and big though, so you'll be happy with that. I would wager that the way to go here is to order a pizza to share so you get a fresh one, or one of the other menu items for yourself at lunch as those seem to be more pleasing to people. Still... it is called Burke Street PIZZA, so you'd hope that would be a highlight. For me, it was just fine. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Lunch special pepperoni pizza. Fine. Nothing more. - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

Great pizza, friendly staff that remembers you when you come in for a meal or even phone in! The ambiance is a "pizza parlor" of my college years! Great all around! read more

Burke Street Pizza is one of those places I eat at frequently but forget to write a review. I've eaten here too many times to count. The slices are a great value for their size. Typically the crust is thinner and crispier than anywhere else in town. They rotate daily specials and have some great pies like their Voodoo Chicken, My Angry Honey, Spinach Artichoke and Lasagna Pizza. I also find their garlic knots to have more butter, garlic and parmesan than their competitors. While I'm not a fan of their sandwiches, I consider their pizza some of the best in town. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - The Angry Honey Bee! It packs a punch with hot Soppressata, Peppedew peppers and a honey drizzle. - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

See all

The pizza is tasty and the service is fast. Nothing fancy about my review, just like there is nothing fancy about Burke st.

Had craving for NY Pizza, being a little bad but rewarding self for a good hard long workout, after being inactive during the pandemic years. Walked in close to closing time and asked if can get slice and eat it there. Staff eagerly and welcomingly said yes. Very nice and polite. Took time to warm up a slice which has the qualities and flavor I wanted. Slice was good sized and plenty filling with glass of water. Good texture and ratio of dough to sauce to cheese. True to it's NYC origins. I should know from growing up there. Would have taken photos but got a call I needed to take. Plenty of booths. Good photographs of NYC in black and white. For me nostalgic. Plenty of available parking in the outdoor shopping center strip. Grab a bite to eat when grocery shopping, or getting hair cut or whatever services on Robinhood road. Definitely will return when get the urge for a slice. Food is the same quality of the original on Burke Street but with more dinning space. Specials offered daily and for lunch. Typical offerings for this niche of Pizzerias. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Specials per day and lunch. - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

Burkestreet is the best pizza in town for sure. My favs include the New York white, pepperoni, and cheese. They also have rockin garlic knots, and great salads. Also when you order pizza be sure to order ranch for dipping you wont be disappointed promise. This place is awesome and must try if you have never been there before. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Cheese Pizza 14'' and ranch - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

See all

I am not use to this customer service. The lady taking the order only cares about counting her money and treats the customer rude. Food ok but service is terrible. read more

We have been loyal customers for years. We called in to check on our order that was placed at 6:00p. At 7:30p we called to check on the order. We were told that "it's a busy night and we have a new driver. What do you want us to do?" read more

I've given up hope on them being anything worth spending money on. It's gone downhill over the years and no matter how specific I am with an order, it's still wrong. And now this is the "side of chicken" and you can clearly see, in person, where it was cut from the rest of the bread. Keep in mind I've ordered the same order for years. This was just comical. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - A side of chicken - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

See all

Good Pie. No thrills just good pizza. New York Style. We will be back. Affordable. Pizza by the slice. A good neighbor hood place.

I grew up coming here and have always loved it, so I was very excited to stop in while visiting town. The Philly cheesesteak is great and I enjoyed it this time however, towards the last few bites I found this hair in my sandwich. I hope this was the only one. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Philly Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

Very good pizza with quick service. I usually pick up from the Robinhood location because they do not deliver where I live.

Amazing place! Pizza tastes so good, mouth-watering-worthy! Just like a taste of authentic New York-style pizza. Service is the best! I have a best friend that works here and she is so sweet and kind ! 10/10 recommend this place for all nights! 10/10 pizza 10/10 service 10/10 taste 10/10 quality 10/10 cleanliness. read more

Pizza is terrible. I did not finish it. Have been here before and loved it but seems to have dropped their standards since. Very little sauce and hardly any cheese, yet the prices are up. It didn't even look appealing. Unfortunately I Don't think I will be coming back again. read more

Burke Street Pizza Robinhood - Huge delicious slices! - Pizza Near Me - Winston-salem, North Carolina

See all

Pretty good. I'm hard to impress with pizza but this was good. Service good. The toppings were even. The place is nice and clean.

The pizza is pretty good, but the garlic knots are the best!!! The sauce they use is very good. Toppings are good portions. All the staff are friendly. We usually go for Marios Pizza, but this is as good. read more