food is great. but they cant figure out delivery. last order left off the naan. this orde forgot the rice how hard is it to get an order right. goid lord. a littke attention to detail. so they make us go pick up the rice and naan order at your own risk. read more

I ordered the butter chicken and rice. The order ended up taking over an hour to get to me.. This was last Friday around 7:00pm. I assumed I would be past the huge dinner rush. I ordered through postmates and it was estimated to take 35-50 minutes. I'm only like 6 blocks away from Cafe India too, so I thought this would be quick. I was wrong, the order sat in "preparing" for 60+ minutes. When I tried to call the restaurant to get the status of the order, I didn't get an answer. I didn't want to blame Cafe India as it could have been a postmates error, but they accepted my order and took over an hour to prepare. My postmate delivery driver did not even pick up the order until around 8:15pm. The butter chicken was decent, but I have had better. I probably wouldn't order it again.. The naan is very good though. I would be open to trying C.I. again but I would not order, I would have to go and sit or pick up the order myself. read more

THE BEST Indian food in Milwaukee. I'm not a lover of curry but you'll find plenty of options here even if you're not. The food is super flavorful and robust. Service is great as well. I recommend the bayview location for a more romantic feel but walkers point provides more of a casual feel. read more

Amazing food again just love this joint. Service great staff friendly and helpful. Portions enough for a small meal later.

Nice easy location with ample parking. Food is decent - we were not warned that spicy would be super-duper 'Indian' spicy. We ordered spicy based on 'American' spicy standards. There were a couple of other customers who also complained of the same, so we know it wasn't just us...maybe the chef was extra generous on that day. Portions are generous. It's Self-service and the counter Staff are quite courteous and friendly. Overall a decent quick-stop for a weekend afternoon. read more

This wasn't the best Indian food I've had in MKE, but it was quite good. It was fast and fresh. The portion sizes are huge. One entree is easily 2 meals. I highly recommend saving some as the flavors are stronger on the 2nd day. read more

The most authentic Indian food in town. Fast and affordable, a great place for lunch. Service is friendly and helpful. The owner and his wife are from India and these are family recipes, so you know you're getting the real deal! I got a mixed platter of chicken tikka, palak paneer, goat curry and chicken masala. Everything is spicy and flavorful without being over the top. Not too greasy, either. Some of the other Indian lunch stops are so greasy and salty...but not the case here. my new favorite lunch break!! read more

Ever since moving away from college I was in search of a new Indian restaurant. (I went to Iowa State, and in Ames Iowa, & I highly recommend India Palace.) I wasn't sure what to try and had high expectations because my last favorite Indian restaurant was my favorite restaurant ever. Cafe India is an amazing substitute. Every time I order to take out the food is hot and fresh and when I dined in the service was awesome. Everyone was so kind and attentive. We ordered butter chicken, Tikka Masala, regular and garlic naan with a side of rice. Highly recommend all of those dishes. They were all so savory and the chicken was so tender, not dry at all. I honestly crave it every day. However, the only thing I wish was that I could pick my spice rating for each dishes. A fair warning, Tikka Masala is spicier than butter chicken. Cafe India is my new go-to place! read more

Great food, made fresh daily with a real tandoor oven. I tried the Chicken Tikka Masala and Butter Chicken, both were very good. The Garlic Naan was also delicious. The meal was perfectly punctuated with some Rasmallai for dessert. Friendly staff, nice atmosphere, though it may get a bit crowded during the lunch rush. Decent size menu, including several vegetarian dishes. They even have a small selection of sodas from India. read more

wow ...what a great place to get some of the best Indian food in Milwaukee. I have been to many big city in US and to many fine Indian diner's. But this is a place where you can get authentic Indian cuisine with no pinch on your wallet. I tried there chicken tikka masalla with garlic nan...hhummmm..it was dam good.!!!. Also there kheer (rice pudding) was just awesome & i love indian sweets Samosas were fresh,flavorfull & crispy . I am sure looking forward to visit cafe India again & soon. It's my new eat out place ;-)))) read more

I usually go here for lunch and occasionally get a dinner to go. They are generous with rice portions but skimp on meat. I have to ask for more every time I eat there. The food is good but the portions size leaves me rankled. It's an OK lunch destination to mix up the food options. read more

The food is amazing! I would recommend the potato stuffed Nan (it reminds me of Trinidadian aloo pie).

Cafe India has two of my favorite takes on two food items in the city: samosas and stuffed naan (onions AND potatoes). They're also home to the most bang for your buck with their lunch special. For 7 and 1/2 bucks you get a heaping container full of whatever you want, plus rice, bread, and a drink. All of their food is delicious. My only issue is that the menu appears limited, or at least limited to someone raised on a purely western palette. But everything I've eaten has been of quality, and I look forward to every time I choose to enjoy a meal a cafe india. It's also worth noting two things: 1.The seating is limited and uncomfortable. Cafe India is a place you go to to buy food to take home. 2. The service is GREAT. They're always very nice and want to make sure you leave smiling, which always happens when I go in =) read more

Is there a way to give negative stars ?? Forget the taste .. worst possible service. Placed an order for delivery .. Waited for about 20 mins and then got a call .. Apparently our apartment is very far which is 2.3 miles, to be specific Brady street. But their website shows an amazingly huge delivery range. Well explained him .. Waited for another 10 mins but they said no because they don't have a GPS !!!!! Really ????? read more

Order two dinners $34 and no rice. I can't believe that not even a small side of rice is offered! I'll make sure to take my money elsewhere that actually offers rice with their food! read more

Cafe India - Indian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I read about this place in the Milwaukee Journal/Sentinel. The longer I live, the more I enjoy sampling new cuisine from around the world. Now, I am well aware that unfortunately, often times some of these restaurants cook to their Clientele. (ie "The Locals") The one thing that I have learned over the years is that do not knock a restaurant just because it is in a strip mall. Oh that's not to say that I haven't had mediocre or bad meals at strip mall restaurants, because I have! To be totally honest with this review, this is only the second time that I have had Indian Food. The other was at an established Indian Restaurant here in Milwaukee. It was under new ownership and it was the tail-end of a buffet. It wasn't too bad, but I was hoping for more. So I went in with a limited knowledge of the food. I was informed that it was a Northern Indian cuisine but again, I'm still learning. I had the Chicken Curry with rice and a salad. I also ordered one order of Roti. (Wish I would have ordered two or three for it was tasty especially dipping it with the curry sauce.) Going back to cooking to "The Locals", the blurb in the paper stated that if you wanted to have it spicier to ask for it. The meal turned out well. I will go back. I will try something different. I will go back after that and have the Curry Chicken again. The only reason that I gave the place 4 stars was because of my limited knowledge of Indian cuisine. Honestly, if your adventurous give the place a shot. The place was reasonably priced. The woman that had taken my order stated that until the article most of the customers were those in the strip mall and nearby locals. I say, give this place a fair shake. It was clean, the staff was friendly and willing to answer questions, and gave good service. read more

Love Cafe India!!! Best Indian food in Milwaukee! Tikka masala with chicken is amazing, highly recommend!

The best Indian restaurant I have experienced in Milwaukee so far! Consistently good.

You guys, this place is really good! I love the lunch special, because it is cheap and you get a ton of food. I also like that I can try new foods I wouldn't normally order full plates of. Everything I've had tastes wonderful. read more

I had ordered the butter chicken and it was perfect with the Naan bread. Fast and friendly service. Nice quiet place to eat in the evening.

As others have said, the location is not amazing. It is in a gas station parking lot, it is definitely like a sad fast food place inside. The food, however, is amazing. I have to admit that I am not an expert on Indian cuisine, and I only get the butter chicken and naan - I know, I know. But the butter chicken is SO GOOD and the naan is SO GOOD and I won't try it at any other Indian place in Milwaukee for fear it won't be as good. If you are looking to dip your toe into Indian food, this beginner thinks it's a good place to start. And no matter what you order, get the naan. I have dreams about it. read more

I've gotten carry out and delivery from Cafe India many times. I've tried most items from the vegetarian section, and several vegetarian apps. A couple of dishes haven't been my favorite, but none have disappointed. I love trying new things. The biggest stand out items for me are the samosa chat appetizer and the kheer. Dishes aren't overly greasy like I've experienced some other places. Service has always been friendly and quick. read more

My boyfriend and I love coming here for the malai kofta, we prefer this location. We didn't care for the other gas station one - that didn't taste the same. read more

This is a great spot for all your Indian food craving. Also, they have delicious flavors of cake, cookies and Snacks.

One of the best Indian restaurants in Milwaukee! Their food is just so awesome..As an Indian, this is one goto Indian restaurant for me:) Rakesh, the owner of this place is an awesome person. He is always a huge supporter of fundraising events and he agreed to sponsor for Dance-a-thon, a fundraiser for animal rescues as soon as I mentioned about the event. read more

Fab food.But the only issue is everything is made fresh so u have to wait a little.Every item is worth it and owners are wonderful.

This place is better than the crap they serve at some of the Indian restaurants on N. Farwell. In fact, this is not bad, it's okay and it would get 3 stars if it wasn't so outrageously over priced. I ordered Chicken Korma which came with rice (was actually given Vegetable korma instead), 2 samosa's, an order of naan, and dessert. Someone please tell me how this works out to be $35.00??! What they charge is not represented on their menu. Even the two menu's in the 'restaurant' have two different prices for the same thing! It's a hole in the wall joint IN A GAS STATION charging restaurant prices. If the prices were lower I would consider going back if I had a craving and was driving by - but for their crazy prices, no freakin way. Drive the extra 10 minutes and go to Bombway sweets. They may not serve meat, but it's a million times better and at least half the price! read more

Excellent food. I've always ordered online and never seen any delays. The gravy for the dishes is creamy and full of flavor. This one missed 5 starts because the desserts weren't good at all. read more

Absolutely delicious food, can't wait to return here to sample another dish. I love the informal atmosphere and the variety of menu options. We were able to tailor our spice level, which was appreciated. read more

First time ordering after hearing so many good things. Super fast delivery and the food was WONDERFUL and warm. Looking forward to many future orders. Loved the samosa (still crispy and warm, delivered all the way up to Bayside!) and lamb curry. read more

Great service, great price, excellent portion size. Perfectly seasoned food was dank and its telling me to keep writing lol

I was in Milwaukee for the weekend and decided to order from this place. Ordered our food through a different app and waited almost 2hrs to receive our food (I understand they were busy or drive was far) but we I finally received the food. It was pure disappointment! I ordered 2 chicken tikka masala and naan bread. The chicken tikka masala was water-down with NO FLAVOR along with the naan bread. Food was overall awful to taste. Will NOT recommend! read more

Very yummy chicken Tikka masala and lamb biriyani. Alot of meat in the biriyani and juice chicken in the masala. Great price for value.

Food was hot and delicious when it arrived. It was not overly spicy so that was good for me. Chicken was so tender and was clearly well cooked. Great delivery time. Will be back! read more

Please don't miss an opportunity to taste this authentic delicious food! I am a customer for life very satisfying and filling. I am so happy to be served by a happy team of people. Don't let the fact it's by a Gas station discourage you. Go in ASAP! read more

Cafe India proves that there is heaven on earth! Check out their lunch special. Pile on the Chicken Tikka Masala, spinach, veggie specials and more! Awesome people and awesome food! read more

I ordered buttered chicken and chicken tikki masala for my husband and I and it was the worst Indian food we've had. We've eaten our way through most of the other Indian restaurants in Milwaukee and they are all amazing, way better than this but we decided to try something new. The sauces were both really runny and spices were severely lacking. The dishes just tasted like cream. The naan was great but I will never be ordering from Indian Cafe again. Luckily there are many other great Indian restaurants in town that I'll return to. read more

Excellent food and delicious sauces! Some of the best Indian food I've had in Milwaukee!

Ordered for it to be delivered and food was really good! Good per portion for everyone. I loved the somosas most of all BUT was disappointed to see that one of the six that I ordered was empty. (Cause they're stuffed) basically waisted money on that one. But other then that everything was delicious! Definitely recommend it! read more

Quality has declined steadily in last two years. Current Chicken Tikka Masala has basically devolved to tomato soup with four pieces of chicken. Palak Paneer (spinach base with cheese) equally disappointing also with 4-5 pieces of cheese. Cost is too high for this mediocrity. Drive on to another choice. read more