You want the real thing handmade and delicious? Then you need to stop here. Homemade everything. The Italian owner is in the kitchen whipping up some goodness. They don't have or use a microwave so it is all fresh. Meatballs are fabulous. It isn't new, flashy or make ahead of time and froze. FRESH! read more

Cafe Italia - Angel Hair Pasta and Meatballs! Delicious, fresh and yummy. - Italian Near Me - Marshall, Texas

Excellent service and food. So relaxing and we know we will get wonderful food! I highly recommend! We will always return!

Disappointing Our order was stuffed mushrooms the baked pasta combo dish and spaghetti We also had a side salad. Salad was from a bag with a lone cherry tomato added Server couldn't tell me what the stuffing was in the mushrooms and I couldn't tell either had a faint fish taste. Didn't eat Combo dish came drowning in a cheesy gooey sauce and had to hunt for the pasta dishes. Impossible to tell where the two items were. Also did not eat Spaghetti was ok Did not see our server again after our food was served. We had finished for over 10 minutes before he showed again. Brought our bill which wasn't totaled and promptly left to go sit with friends in another booth. Left hungry Oh and the dinner rolls are hot dog buns read more

Really good Italian by authentic Italians! Stopped in never mind the construction, disregard it being in front of a motel and was rewarded by a great lunch served by exceptional people. read more

Cafe Italia - Italian Near Me - Marshall, Texas

See all

Just a great experience. The pasta combo is yummy and the cook and waitresses can't be beats

I've been here a few times now and every time it's been a great dining experience. Menu has a wide selection and prices are very good. Likewise, the food has been flavorful with good size portions. The service was very good, and our waitress checked on us frequently. The restaurant is very pleasant and comfortable to be in. Everything was clean and well-cared for. The lunch menu prices go until 3:00 pm, even on the weekends. For talking to one of the owners in the past, I was told that they have been here for 30 years and everything on the menu is made to order in their kitchen. Cafe Italia is one of the best places to dine in Marshall. If you have never been, I recommend it most highly. read more

This is true Italian food. Made fresh. Service is exceptional and everybody is very welcoming.

A friend and I visited Cafe Italia for the first time tonight. We won't be back. To start we were escorted to a booth with a broken seat. When we pointed it out to the waitress she shrugged, admitted it had been broken awhile and walked off. We laughed thinking, "strange but whatever." We ordered drinks (a soda pop and an iced tea), the stuffed mushrooms with bread as an appetizer and we decided to share an order of the chicken picatta and a large pizza Florentine, thinking we could take the leftovers with us. The bread we received was stale and inedible. When the main courses arrived we were sorely disappointed. The picatta sauce was thin, runny and completely lacking flavor, the chicken was so tough that even trying to cut it with a knife and fork was difficult. We gave up on the chicken and tried the pizza, which again was completely flavorless and tasted bland, the spinach seemed as though it had been frozen and then thawed before it was added to the pizza. We were so disappointed that we told the waiter who offered to send the owner to our table. He arrived openly hostile and told us that this was the first complaint he had ever received in more than 20 years. I told him that maybe it was because people were afraid of his anger. We paid the bill in full ($65.00 including tip), left the food largely untouched, and left very disappointed. Zero stars, I do not recommend. read more

Love the food and service! It is also BYOB! very very good Italian food. I got the chicken Murphy and my daughter got the chicken parmigiana and they are both so good. We get them every time we go! read more

Nice little quaint restaurant, service was okay. Server was not in a very good mood, after expressing how tired she was after a long day, had sweet tea but she refilled as unsweet. Menu said the chicken Murphy comes with rolls, I had to ask several times for the rolls. When she finally brought me 1 out, it was cold and hard. Menu says served with rolls, not roll! Other than our service, food was great! read more

So, while visiting the lovely town of Marshall, Texas, I decided to grab some Italian at this place Café Italia. Let me say that it's far from authentic. The sauce was terrible way too much oregano and quite over seasoned. When I cut into the veal I was surprised, no breading whatsoever. Now let me say that I am aware that authentic veal parmigiana is made with breaded veal and then sautéed in a pan with oil so it comes out Friday as if it was put into a deep fryer. As you can see here, no breading whatsoever. I did ask the waitress and she went to the kitchen and came back to. Yes it's breaded, but it's a light dusting on Friday. Well let me see I didn't see anything and I'm sure it was probably absorbed by the oil. I will tell you there is a finished piece of processed veal I ever had. Didn't taste too bad, but it was definitely process and you can tell him and frozen. Not out of the ordinary, though. That was far as the spaghetti with standard dry pasta. It was not fresh as they say on their menu. No possible way was that fresh pasta. Definitely dry. I also see the sauce too again over seasoned way too much seasoning especially oregano. And I'll tell you it reminds me of going to a Greek own diner, and getting pasta. It seems like a Greek tomato sauce more than an Italian. And it's definitely not find dining as they say. read more

Cafe Italia - Veal Parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Marshall, Texas

See all

Very friendly. Great food. Fast service. Just what I needed after a long taxing drive!

A little gem tucked away that you would never know existed. Great food and great service.

Super nice staff & atmosphere. The starter bread is excellent (make sure to get some marinara for the dipping). I had one of, if not the best arrabbiatas of my entire life. It's one of my go-to's so I'm pretty picky. I was honestly very surprised at how amazing the food was considering the small town location and the fact that it was next to a Waffle House, but don't let that fool you. Delicious food - stop by if you're hungry for some Italian! read more

Awesome pizza and veal piccata. The bread and pizza and pasta are all made in house.

1/9/20 Came here for dinner after being on the road for a while. Yelp shows me this restaurant and how great it was, so here I came. I ordered the seafood Alfredo and shared mussels as appetizer, my coworker ordered the lasagna. Our food came out pipping hot but it was so delicious. I sincerely appreciated the establishment staying open for us to be their last order. Every bite was yummy and the service was great. Will always return here if in the area. Also this place is BYOB, so bring in whatever you'd like to drink. read more

See all

This is one of our favorite places in Marshall. The food is always good, the bread is incredible, and the service is smooth. They do not sell alcohol so diners are invited to bring their own. They will provide glasses and uncorking. Prices are reasonable. We've never had a bad experience there. read more

Ordering the chicken piccata: Me: "Can you please add artichokes to that?" Them: "No, 'she' won't do that." Me: "But you have like 5 other things on your menu with artichokes. I'm happy to pay extra." Them: "We can't do that." Me: "Can I get a side of artichokes on a separate plate?" Them: "No." Me: "I'm confused. You have artichokes in one of your salads." Them: "If you want something with artichokes, might I suggest..." Me: "No thank you... I'll take the chicken piccata." Tip: if you aren't willing to accommodate simple customer requests, that's totally your prerogative. Probably best not to expect positive reviews though. You also might consider relocating off the main highway where people from out of town, and who may have out of town service level expectations will be less likely to stop in to try your establishment. The food was ok. Service was awful. If you are from out of town, just keep driving. This place has a very strong "locals only" vibe. And by the way, artichoke hearts are more common than not in chicken piccata. See pictures. Cheers. read more

See all

A hometown favorite for good reason! I've never had a meal or experience from here that wasn't great. The staff always provides wonderful customer service. On my recent visit, I ordered a meat lovers pizza that was delicious. So much better than main stream pizza joints. I will continue to go back to Cafe Italia! read more

Cafe Italia - Meatlovers Pizza (Medium) - Italian Near Me - Marshall, Texas

Great Italian food, pizza and desserts. Complimentary bread with meals is delicious. I enjoy their lasagna and chicken parmigiana. Meeting room available. Friendly staff. BYOB. read more

What a great place to eat at! Wonderful prices, delicious food, and pleasant atmosphere! read more

Cafe Italia - Activa Products dinner photo - Italian Near Me - Marshall, Texas

Great food Great Service Ambiance could use some updating! The pizza is amazing lived in Marshall 20 years and just found this gem a few years back. The location is a bit tucked away read more

Quick rant: Tonight my boyfriend & I went to Cafe Italia in Marshall. Usually, I love the food & go back a lot, but have never been a huge fan of the owners. I ordered ravioli & he ordered shrimp fettuccine. We got the pastas & he tried it. You could tell by his face that something wasn't right. The shrimp tasted bad, as if the meat had come from a bad batch. It ruined the whole bowl of pasta. He got up to go to the restroom because he felt nauseous & I set the plate to the edge of the table. The owner walked by & said, "What's wrong with this?" I told her the meat wasn't fresh & it tasted really bad, as if the meat was spoiled. I also told her that he went to the restroom because the food made him nauseous. She told me that her food didn't make him sick & that he was sick before he came & that her shrimp is fresh. I repeated my statement as to how it had to have been a bad batch of meat & that it was okay and that I understood because I work in the service industry & it happens. She could either take it and give a new batch or take it off the bill, as any restaurant would do. She ignored me & asked if I wanted a togo box. I said no. I was brought my ticket with the alfredo on it. I went up to the front where the other owner was located to pay for my ravioli & garlic bread because one bite was taken since the shrimp was spoiled. She told me that it was his problem. We proceeded to go back & forth for about 5 minutes about the situation. I paid & left. Won't being going back because of how unkind they were to me, especially having supporting them for so long. read more

We go for lunch weekly. Always a nice break to the busy work day. The food is always good!

We had my 60th birthday party there the food is always great, never a complaint. The wait staff are young but they know the menu and were attentive to our table of 13 people. They have a private area just off to the right when you first walk into the restaurant. It was quiet and cozy. I really had a good time with my family read more

Fabulous food and the pink sauce is to die for. There has not been anything that I didn't like there. Don't let the road construction keep you away, its worth it. read more

The restaurant is good, with nice environment. The only con I can think of is: for the price I'd think they'd allow you to have fresh basil as a topping, and homemade salad dressings. read more

Great restaurant. The lasagne is absolutely amazing. This is my go-to for great Italian home cooking.

This food is awesome! However, we can't eat lunch here much because it puts us down about 2:00 pm. We have eaten here for the past 7 years. This family is Macedonian and seriously good cooks! The Calzone is our all time favorite!!!!! One of the top 10 things we have ever tried! It is full of Ricotta Cheese and Sausage and heaven. Tortellini Bologneze with pink sauce is next in line for us. The White Pizza is awesome. Homemade bread and butter is first each meal and very good. We have had many other entrees but these are our favorites. read more

See all

Friendly and really good food. The appetizer of mushrooms stuffed with crab was delicious. The food was served hot. The restaurant dining was very clean. Recommend to friends and will return soon. read more

You can't add anything to your meal because "the chef doesn't like that" want pasta with shrimp? Nope. Wanna change the pasta in your dish? Nope. Wanna pay extra for adding something? Nope. Can't do it. read more

Horrible service and the owners are absolutely terrible people, food is not that great and the service from a blind German shepherd would be better read more

Small town Italian is either great or horrible and unfortunately for us this was the latter of the two. The staff wasn't very friendly at all and I get that peoples nerves are frayed from being short staffed and so forth but you should never take that out on your patrons. I travel all over the world so I've always been prepared for the worst. This place between the food, ambiance, and staff is mediocre at best. I always try to give a very fair review but this is by no means a go out of your way restaurant. The sauce tasted like it came in a jar and the pasta was beyond mushy. Refills rarely happened and the list goes on. For us this was a swing and a miss by far. read more

I just have four words. Chicken Murphy and bread. Seriously. One of the best meals I've had. I've been craving it since the first time I tried it and can't wait to go back to Cafe Italia. read more

I like this place, in spite of some problems. I had a basalmic chicken. It was a good dish. I was disappointed in their spaghetti which tasted like regular ol grocery store spaghetti, but the blackened sauce with mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes and chicken on top was good. The waiter forgot to get me a salad until I asked for it, and he kept saying bread was coming but didn't bring it until after the meal. When it came, it wasn't worth the wait - pretty plain. Salad was just a simple bagged salad mix and bread was something u could buy at the store for cheap as well. The bathroom was a little grungy and part of it was out of order. The whole restaurant smelled more of whatever artificial room fragrance they are using, and it far outweighed any natural Italian food smell that should accompany an Italian restaurant. Use a basil essential oil diffuser instead and that would be much more appetizing read more

They close at 10 pm I came in at 9:30 and the lady said they were closed because "they close in 30 minutes" , I get it, but I've worked in the restaurant industry and we were always told to take customers until it was the time we were supposed to close. Not to mention the lady was rude in the way she told me. Won't be back. read more

The food is good but the service is slow and it takes a while for the food to come. The place is nice and gives a nice small town vibe to it. read more

We were visiting Marshall Texas and stayed in the area for over 10 days. Cafe Italia is located within walking distance to our Fairfield by Marriott hotel. Cafe Italia became one of our favorite places for lunch. Soups were very good and hot, as well as the bread was heavenly. In addition ordered spaghetti with meatballs and eggplant lasagna - so good home cooked meals. The owner is working hard to provide fast service and the waitress was attentive and friendly. This was during COVID-19 pandemic when many businesses were struggling and finding it hard to find kitchen staff. I highly recommend this place - great home cooked meals, excellent service, and clean. Two thumbs up!!! read more

We arrived about 6:30 on a Friday night, we were seated immediately.The staff was prompt and courteous. I had the chicken cacciatore while the wife ordered the pasta combo, each of us liked our meal and would consider ordering it again on another visit. The restaurant was well populated but the noise level allowed a quiet conversation. We will add this restaurant to our list of places that we would take visitors to. read more

The food was great and service was good. We got the Stromboli and it was crisp on the outside and gooey and cheesy on the inside. Marinara with garlic cheese bread for app was good too. read more