Caffe Italia

4.4 (130 reviews)

InexpensiveCoffee & Tea, Gelato, Bakeries

Open • 8:00 am - 11:00 pm

Updated 3 months ago

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Order Caffe Italia Takeout or Delivery

Order Takeout or Delivery

Caffe Italia Photos

Caffe Italia - When you're here, you're in Italy! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Caffe Italia - Strawberry and cookies and cream gelato with a wafer on top - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Deer Park, New York

+129

Caffe Italia - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Caffe Italia Popular Desserts

3 Photos4 Reviews

3 Photos3 Reviews

1 Photo1 Review

Caffe Italia menu photos

See all

CAFFE ITALIA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

Inside

15 Photos

Outside

6 Photos

Good for working

Outdoor seating

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Caffe Italia

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Vito D.

This place was worth the drive. We've been looking for an authentic gelato spot on the island and after much experimentation, we've found it. A good selection of all the important flavors, a great blend of traditional favorites and some of the new stuff. Authentic, family owned spot with top notch gelato and espresso. Will definitely be back to try more flavors soon! Blows away any ice or ice cream spot in the area.

Hands down best place in town!! Don't hesitate just go! A hidden gem! If you know you know... No more dirty Dunkin coffee machines, old sitting 711 coffee or even over priced Starbucks ! This is now my go to for it all! 10/10 best coffee, best cappuccinos & best shots of espresso around ! Not to mention the Gelato... Omg 25+ flavors and swapped out regularly -always something different. Not feeling coffee or gelato? Try a lobster tail you can't go wrong! Once you go I promise you will be back!

I've had this place bookmarked for awhile. It's kind of like a convenience store that sells Gelato. I originally ordered a waffle with Nutella. The online ordering offered banana nutella but it wasn't available in person. Instead they had me pick a Gelato flavor for an upcharge, instead of just giving me the waffle with plain nutella. Tiramisu Gelato was tasty, the waffle was possibly cornmeal? It was thick but not too heavy. Also bought 2 different chocolates on the counter. Cute spot. But probably will not return.

If you get chocolate or cinnamon powder they always make a pretty design

Jennifer K.

Delicious espresso beverages and gelato! Friendly staff. The iced cappuccino is unique and the best coffee you'll have!

Vivian P.

This little hidden gem of a gelato spot! Nothing fancy... Just good old homemade authentic gelato! Good Italian coffee!! Affogato Thank you!!

Minah S.

We had a belly full of some salty seafood and was in need of some coffee and sweets. I was able to find this jewel of a place on Yelp and we went there immediately after looking at the scrumptious photos of their offerings. Interior is relatively long and narrow, they have plenty of unique Italian sweets ranging from cookies, crackers, chocolates and even Italian antique coffee tin makers. Gelatos are all housemade and the small size begins at $6.50 but all are served with these adorable wafer crackers with their store signage which is such a wonderful, unique, personal touch. I tried the limoncello gelato and it was citrusy, bright and sweet. My son tried the strawberry gelato and there were tons of fresh strawberry bits and it really had the essence of sweet strawberries. We also grabbed coffee and their eclairs and they were light, creamy and delicious. Will definitely be back as the owners were hospitable and the workers were quick and friendly.

Paul P.

Love this place! Sure prices increased from covid but they are still reasonable and they are all perfect flavors! So much variety and the owner is such a nice and cute guy! He gave my girlfriend and I testings of all the flavors and talked to us about them! Always a great place for some cones, pints, cups or even coffee and small bakery items!

Giovanni L.

Late night gelato cravings were happening this past Sunday and luckily Caffe Itália was there to fulfill. Since it was around 9pm on a Sunday night, I was mentally accepting the lost and going to go grab ice cream. One quick Yelp search and I was so happy to find caffe Italia. It was ver traditional gelato and I got an espresso to go with it. The staff was extremely nice and super patient, especially with us getting there right before closing. Even though this spot isn't super close to where I live, I will be coming back tenfo

Iced Cappuccino--the best that I have had outside of Italy. They use imported Italian espresso

Gail B.

Buon Giorno a tutti, This is my favorite coffee shop on the Island. All coffee beans are imported from Italy. The espresso is unusually smooth yet potent. I usually order a cup of iced cappuccino or latte to perk me up on my down days. The gelato is also authentically Italian. It is the same as you would get in Italy. This is the real deal, folks! It is the only gelato on the Island that I eat. My favorites: Wildberries Mascarpone Blueberrry Lemon Basil ( has whole blueberries and basil leaves) Tiramisu (has chunks of ladyfingers) Salted Butter Caramel Runners up: Cassata Siciliana (available all year, not just Easter) Ferrero Rocher (Italian chocolate and hazelnut confectionery) There are lots of other sweet treats, like the crescent-shaped dark chocolate croissants that are baked fresh every morning. The customer service is fantastic. They certainly "know thy customer". For example, they know that I like any gelato that is flavored with berries; and that I only take my coffee iced, without sugar or any flavorings. Si parlo Italiano qui. The owner and most employees are native speakers. Free copies of the Italian/Italian-American newspaper GIA (Giornale Italiano Americano) are stacked by the window for your reading pleasure. Relaxing European atmosphere. Plenty of parking spaces are available on an average-sized retail strip. Buon Appetito, Gail B.

Julia A.

Amazing, authentic Italian shop. Found them on Google and will definitely be returning

See all

Anna B.

5 years ago

Coffee was really good, and you can tell that the workers work hard, but I didn't expect it to be so expensive. I paid $18 for two ice coffees. It was delicious, but I wouldn't pay that price again. Place was cute, and they have outside seating. I didn't get the ice cream, but the kids next to us seemed to enjoy it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

N M.

4 years ago

BEST GELATO EVER!!! So fresh and delicious! If you love coffee and gelato you MUST come here!!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gail S.

5 years ago

I've been wanting to try this place for quite some time and I finally did! It's local and I was looking forward to it, especially after reading all of the reviews. What a disappointment! I bought 4 different flavours. I didn't like any of them, they didn't even get simple chocolate right. All four flavours tasted like ice milk and not at all like gelato. Tasteless, at best. I honestly don't understand the high ratings and recommendations for this place. I really wanted this to become my new go to place. It isn't cheap either but I have no problem paying for a quality product. I actually threw 2/3 of the cups in the garbage, that's how bad I found it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Jay O.

Elite 21

580

254

1449

8 years ago

Nice little spot that I must have missed a million and one times as I drive on by. We just got back from Boston and had a craving more chowder and gelato. We stop off and had our chowder and then headed over here. The place is small is is easy miss on Deer Park Ave. Lots of neon lights for different places in the strip mall. The place is small and has a few tables, but it's also crowded with an assortments if candies and sodas from Italia. Anyway, they offer samples as you like. I had a small, which is two scoops and had one Pistachio and one Nutella. Both creamy and delicious, tab bit on the sweet side. Either way, when I'm in the mood for some gelato, I now have a local place. read more

See all

Helpful 15

Thanks 0

Love this 11

Oh no 0

MaryAnn B.

3 years ago

Bought a box cake for Easter. Not even close to what photo showed. No cream, dry as cardboard. Call the owner and he would do nothing ! Told me he doesn't make the cakes he only buys them . It was $18 of junk. Very nasty man probably the owner read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kathleen V.

2 years ago

If you can't travel to Italy, this place can give you the taste of Italy in their amazing Gelato! Don't dream just go and visit right here on LI!! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Leyda J.

Elite 21

513

8 years ago

To be honest the only thing I have ordered here are the gelatos. So my review might not be the most accurate. If you like gelatos then you won't be disappointed. However, is a hit and miss on the flavors. Silly me, I always forget to ask for a sample and just order whatever I am in the mood for. Not very accurate on the flavors. For instance, I ordered the apple pie one and the only apple pie thing about it was the small pieces of cooked apples and graham crackers. Didn't really taste like apple pie at all. Now the cherry one I had...yass!!! I will definitely go back and try the drinks, etc and of course to make sure to get a gelato sample beforehand! I read great reviews on their customer service. However, I have yet to experience that. Mine has been bland and to the point! Hopefully, I'll experience the welcoming service some day. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Handy Andy Y.

599

4 years ago

Great ice cream place great place to sit down get down some good old boys always have some great entertainment a real Stop in Italian world

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Desiree S.

2 years ago

Nice little place in shopping center. Wonderful staff, warm and personable. Amazing cappuccino fairly priced, great quality. From hot to iced, flavored to not, lovely tasting no matter what. American coffee as well. Cute European finds.The gelato is so delicious my family and I have tried a few flavors now and everything seems exactlyyyy what it says. It's creamy and flavorful! You get tiny plastic spoons with wafer. Yummy, delizioso =) read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dante B.

4 years ago

Great place to get some Caffe and some gelato. If you go to ask him to make you an Affogato. Delicious.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Angelo A.

Elite 25

265

4 years ago

Great coffee, excellent gelato, and a lot of choices. I had the salted caramel latte and it was delicious. Definitely will go back when in town again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sasha S.

Elite 18

104

8 years ago

Cute place! Glad I stopped by there instead of heading to Starbucks. I went in for a cappuccino but I noticed they have panini sandwiches, a nice selection of pastries and some good gelato that they kindly offered me to taste once they saw my eyes light up. They have tables to sit for a few minutes to enjoy your coffee and snack. Reminded me of the small cafes in Queens that I often pop in to for a good cappuccino or just a little break. I'll make this my usual place for a coffee when in Deer Park. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Arineh N.

5 years ago

We tried this spot for the first time last night and got gelatos and biscotti to go. The gelato was good and the girl behind the counter was very sweet and helpful. We wanted to try their sandwich so we went back today and ordered the chicken/broccoli rabe panini. Brought it home to eat during my lunch break and 3rd bite in, it tasted like there was a fragrance mixed in within the sandwich. Not sure if it was soap or lotion. But it was awful! I called the place and nicely explained to the woman how the sandwich started having a fragrant taste and I even had my boyfriend try it to verify. This woman's immediate response was so rude & defensive. She said "I don't know what to tell ya. We make everything fresh." And in so many words implied she didn't care. Her tone was unacceptable especially since I was telling her in a nice manner. This was the complete opposite experience of what we had last night. I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS PLACE! I am all about supporting family businesses but the nasty attitude (& let's not forget gross sandwich) is completely uncalled for! What a shame. **update, I did receive a message from the owner so I went back and spoke to someone named Tony who was really nice and apologized for what had happened. I will give them another try. read more

Business owner information

MICHAEL C.

Sorry for your experience was handle the wrong way… we offer you…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Jessica S.

Elite 24

192

7 years ago

Deff my go-to spot for fresh homemade gelato. The flavors always vary but they never seems to disappoint! Love it here! read more

Caffe Italia - Creamy homemade chocolate gelato - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Jennifer C.

5 years ago

So sad to write this but they have no care for Covid protocols, went recently. Girl making coffee,gelato etc not wearing a mask, no gloves while serving. Her answer was that she had been vaccinated. Uhhhh that's not how it works. Had to walk out, will never be back. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Florencia G.

163

5 years ago

Great coffee and great people! Thier Gelato is incredible and the customer service is unbeatable.Love it here

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Diana N.

Elite 21

5 years ago

The service was great. The lady was Italian, I believe, and made the BEST latte for us. Prices were great compared to those in the area.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

D A.

3 years ago

So unprofessional! I ordered via Grubhub. The driver called me to say that he was at the restaurant to pickup my order. Then he puts the owner or whoever on the phone to tell me he cannot fill the order because Grubhub isn't working and he never got the order. So he has no way of getting paid, even though my card was charged and they sent a driver to pick it up. He said you gotta call Grubhub. He was very rude and he hung up on me. Pretty sure I'll never order from here again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Natália C.

9 years ago

The coffee did not impress me, but it was good. i The gelato is amazinnnng, try it! The service was not great. The lady that was there was very dry. They have to work on that! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jennifer R.

246

3 years ago

Stopped in for iced coffee and it wasn't the best. Coffee was weak and watered down, too much milk and the ice cubes are way too large. they only had one size forcing you to buy a large which I did not want. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Didem A.

5 years ago

This tiny show is so cute and the coffee is great. Their ice cream is so good too!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

K P.

3 years ago

Best Gelato, and I have tried plenty! This taste like you are in Italy having it. This gelato is made with love and you can definitely taste it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Loretta W.

6 years ago

Delicious itialian gelato! Cute little shop with the best gelato on long island! I come here almost everyday just to get my gelato fix! Try the wildberry cheesecake and the lemon sorbetto these are my faves! So good! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Linda J.

6 years ago

I have gone here everyday since the day it opened. Best Cappaccino! staff is wonderful.. As far as someone complaining about masks. I go everyday and never have felt unsafe.. Never have been in a shop that is Constantly cleaned during this this pandemic and even before the pandemic! best coffee and Gelato in town!!!!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Fouzia H.

8 years ago

YOU GUYS!!!! How have I missed this place?! I don't live in the area but visit my in laws often enough and let's be real- Deer Park doesn't have much going on in the food space. But this place? Legit the best vegetarian panini I've had in my life. And I've had so many. It's my thing. But this was amazing. Latte was a bit strong for me but still good! Nutella Belgian waffle omg amazing. Gelato? AMAZING. Great customer service. They work fast. Seating but space is small. Great for parties of 2-3 otherwise you can't sit together but who cares. You'll be too busy being planning your own 5 Star yelp review in your head. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Ryan T.

301

6 years ago

It is amazing! Best paninis and gelato on the island! They never disappoint. I started coming here in the beginning of quarantine and I have come to get lunch here all the time! Tony is the man! Great owner and staff and management! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Fatoma R.

Elite 25

111

333

1157

8 years ago

Came back for a gelato pick me up with a friend and I'm happy to report that yes, this place is still amazing. Great stuff, new gelato flavors and perfect spot for after a long day of work. I had their strawberry this time and it was perfect! Their gelato is so creamy and has the right amount of sweetness. read more

Caffe Italia - Strawberry gelato - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Deer Park, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tiffany M.

6 years ago

How they give you the ice cream is soooo cute !! The colorful small spoons and the little waffle cone on it & just the design of the cup ! So clean & workers are so friendly ! I called and he gave me just what I was looking for- just better ! Defiantly will come back for more gelato now that I discovered this place ! read more

Caffe Italia - Gelato - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Anthony G.

Elite 19

469

1533

7010

9 years ago

For a taste of the sweeter side of Italy, come to this Deer Park cafe. The gelato is quite close to how they make it in Italy with nearly perfect chocolate. They also have coffee, pastries and some Italian breakfast items as well. Cute little place, space is tight so don't count on getting a table. Counter service is welcoming and though not cheap, the quality is high. Definitely going to come back and recommended. read more

See all

Helpful 15

Thanks 0

Love this 17

Oh no 0

DJ B.

8 years ago

Best Ice cream in LI. really feels like you are getting Ice cream in Italy! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dan B.

103

8 years ago

This place is awesome. The best gelato I've ever had. Anywhere. They have about 14 flavors. There are also other Italian pastries, breads and things like that. I would highly recommend this place. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Peter L.

4 years ago

Ok this is a hidden gem in a shopping center. I had gelato in Italy and this place was as close as it gets!! I loved the chocolate and my daughter had the Espresso flavor. Excellent! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Aileen C.

Elite 21

209

8 years ago

Small and cute atmosphere. Not a lot of seating, but a nice selection of snacks and coffee. The coffee is really good too. I drank mine with no sugar or flavors and it was amazing. Definitely recommend stopping by. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ruby A.

5 years ago

Bit pricey compared to other places around, but worth the quality...pistachio ice cream stands out.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maria C.

6 years ago

Great cappuccino.....awesome gelato.....service with a smile! What else do you want?

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Natalia D.

109

189

9 years ago

Wow! what an amazing surprice! THANKS FELLOW YELPERS FOR POINTING ME IN THE WAY OF THIS PLACE Really nice caffe in Deer Park, I went here after a long day at the beach and had a panini and some gelato everything was amazing ! Will return when I am around the area definitely The only complain is that they don't have water for customers ! and they serve ice cream! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Danielle I.

5 years ago

Came here on a Friday night ... not a single soul in the place. I came in with my dog at night who is a certified service dog and emotional support dog might I add, and was told my dog couldn't come in? ... my dog has eaten at 5 star restaurants and your going to tell me she can't come into a gelato spot?.... seems bizarre I won't be back. Also skeptical at the fact it's empty on a Friday night. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Ta B.

8 years ago

My sister and I randomly stepped into this shop while stocking up on some groceries from the neighboring bazaar, and fell in love! We enjoy the clean and friendly service but keep coming back for the delicious coffee and gelato! I love the pistachio almond gelato and their cappuccino! I love the variety too! I would definitely recommend this shop to anyone! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ashley K.

522

7 years ago

My rainbow cookie gelato was AMAZING. Highly recommend. Don't forget to get a yummy special cone too! read more

Caffe Italia - Rainbow cookie - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Rebecca A.

6 years ago

It really upsets me to have to write this review because this is a place my family and I had visited frequently. After visiting tonight I don't believe I will ever return. The carelessness in covid safety shocked me. I was one of 7 people in this tiny shop and the only people wearing a mask were the girl serving the gelato and myself. At least three people walked about of the back without a mask on and despite the sign on the door the other customers inside were not wearing a mask and it was clear no one was going to ask them to do so. I was so uncomfortable with the situation I walked out. In your own personal life I support you to make whatever choice is best for you but to see this business who serves the public be so blatantly irresponsible was disappointing. read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Back

Page 2 of 4

1745 Deer Park Ave
Deer Park, NY 11729
Directions
(631) 667-0201
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://caffeitaliany.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Caffe Italia open?

Caffe Italia opens at 8:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Caffe Italia close?

Caffe Italia closes at 11:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 8:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Caffe Italia take credit cards?

Yes, Caffe Italia takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Caffe Italia have catering options?

Yes, Caffe Italia does have catering options.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Caffe Italia have bike parking?

Yes, Caffe Italia has bike parking.

Does Caffe Italia have outdoor seating?

Yes, Caffe Italia has outdoor seating options.

Does Caffe Italia have parking?

Yes, Caffe Italia has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Caffe Italia wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Caffe Italia is wheelchair accessible.

Does Caffe Italia have free WiFi?

Yes, Caffe Italia has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Gelato espresso cappuccino..latte macchiato italia cookies fresh bread daily

Ask the Community - Caffe Italia

Are there indoor/outdoor seating options?

yes... limeted

View question details

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

A & G Bakery

This place is now called The Ultimate Bakery and located in one of those strip malls. Hubby was…read morecraving some sweets from here the other night so we stopped by and he specifically wanted to come to THIS place. He said he's been coming to this bakery for quite some time and his brother always buys a bunch of things when he visits. There was plenty of free parking on a Saturday night and the store itself was brightly lit. Very spacious inside and very clean. I was surprised at the variety and amount of items for sale! Everything was stocked pretty full, especially the cookies and individual pastries. I believe everything goes by weight when you're purchasing the cookies and pastries but if you have any questions, the staff were super sweet, patient and helpful! Hubby purchased an assortment of items like eclairs, cookies, rainbow cookies, cannolis and some sort of Napoleon looking pastry. Although some were a bit on the sweeter side (I have a sweet tooth too), everything was very delicious! I was very surprised that the butter cookies were really good because those are usually my least favorite anywhere I go. The rainbow cookies were also very good! There were no tables and chairs for customers so if you were planning on sitting down to enjoy something, sorry! I did see a small round table with two stools next to it but the table contained their cake binder so I'm assuming it's used for cake related orders.

Great neighborhood bakery. Quality cookies, cannolis, and fresh bread / rolls. Clean, friendly and…read moreinformative service.

Photos

Very clean, brightly lit and spacious interior.

Cake ordering binder area.

See all

Villa Bella Bakery

Family-owned & operated

Established in 1982

This was my first visit and it felt like stepping into a bakery in Italy. The aromas were amazing…read moreand hearing Italian spoken behind the counter confirmed this is the real deal. Most importantly, the pastry was delicious. Absolutely authentic. Can't wait to return.

This is nothing like the quality of product the old owners gave to customers - was unaware it was…read morebought about a year ago - stale cartucci such a tiny amount of cannoli filling in stale pastry - 5 bucks each - not worth 50 cents to be honest - cookies the large one 5 dollars everything grossly overpriced and underwhelming ! A woman came in for a small tray of cookies 1 lb she told her 36 dollars - come on !! The bread was small - better going to uncle Giuseppe's for at least bread - sad that this place was bought out ! We miss them ! Plus the new owners very cold and not embracing of customers !

Photos

See all

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis

4.1

(108 reviews)

1.4 mi

This was my first time trying The Dirty Cheesecake but my order was Uber Eats delivered as my…read morefamily and I are recovering from COVID! We are extremely lucky we did not lose any loss of taste because we would be missing out big time of these outrageously delicious treats we enjoyed immensely tonight!! The orders tonight were the S'mores Lava Cookie, Midnight Cookie and Cream Milkshake and the Strawberry Cheesecake Cup. The milkshake was devoured by my daughters BF. He said it was a perfect consistency, the Cookie and Cream were tasted in every sip but he said there was just a little too much chocolate syrup! He will absolutely order it again but with a little less syrup next time! The cookie was ordered by my daughter but she said it was gooey and a little too rich for her taste but still enjoyed some with a big glass of mik! My 5 stars goes to the Cheesecake that I ordered! It was literally perfection in every bite! The cheesecake was so creamy, decadent and layered with deliciousness! There was enough fresh strawberries in that little cup that it was present throughout! The graham cracker crumbs made up the last layer that completed this cheesecake masterpiece! The serving is big enough for 2 people so lucky me I have dessert for tomorrow night too! I am thrilled I found you Dirty Cheesecake! Next time I visit you in person as there are so many different types of desserts and variations of each kind, I need to see everything vs reading them off of a menu! I just know I will most probably have the same reaction as when a child walks into a candy store....intense excitement, awe, sensory overload, jumping up and down, shouting wow or look at this but the adult version of it all!!

Decided to try The Dirty Cheesecake last night as I was looking for a sweet after dinner treat…read more This is such a cute dessert place that i thought only served cheesecake but had so many more options! The brookie bar dessert that i got was absolutely delicious and satisfied my craving beyond what I could have imagined! The counter person Lyn was nothing short of amazing as well with her kindness to help me especially since it was my first time. I love that it is open till midnight daily! Definitely recommend and I will definitely be back.

Photos

My usuals. snickers bar cheesecake and Lilis cheesecake

See all

Steve's Hot Bagels & Bakery

I'm a native NYCer, so I don't like these gigantic airy bagels that are all over Long Island. I'm…read moreused to Ess-A-Bagel, Zaro's at Grand Central Terminal, Bagel Nosh, Russ & Daughters, and many others. I went to Steve's bc I was dropping off a package at the store next door. Someone once told me the term "hot bagels" on a store meant they were "authentic" bagels. So when I saw Steve's, I was intrigued. I got six excellent bagels: two onion, two garlic, two egg-everything. They were not huge. They were normal size, perfectly baked and had plenty of seasoning on both sides but not too much. They were delicious. We liked them so much I sent my husband there on a Thursday a few weeks later and he came home with the same types of bagels. They were undercooked. They were overly large and they did not have much seasoning on them. Most of them had nothing on the bottom and a few barely had any seasoning on top. I understand that they use different bakers on different days, so whoever baked the bagels for Wednesday, April 8, 2026? He or she should get a raise and teach the others how to make bagels. The service was fine, btw. I wouldn't say "friendly," but it was attentive.

This place is really good. I ordered a sausage egg and cheese on an egg bagel. It was delicious and…read moresuper cheesy and gooey. Bagel was fluffy and crunchy! I also got an apple turnover. Very tasty! The ambience is very homey and personal! Highly recommend it.

Photos

Cream cheese display

Sausage, egg, and cheese on an egg bagel

See all

Salpino

Was searching the internet looking for Prosciutto Bread came across your site. While looking at…read moreyour site noticed Prosciutto Bread. Noticed you ship it anywhere. Well and behold you ship to Florida. Once it arrived I followed the directions. Heated it up and oh boy. Tasted great and yes it was filling and tasted great....So if anyone interested in good Bread give them a shout. Wish I was closer to the store would by more items. Florida does not have that great of food Charlene

We purchased two sandwiches which were great. I then returned to purchase some of the antipasto…read moresalad they had, only to take it home, serve it and realize it was spoiled. The veggies were spoiled and sour.

Photos

Great Price on Eggs 10-19-2025

Eggplant Caponata

See all

Fried eggplant

First Class Bagels

The bagels are good. The service is nice and I have always been met with a smile and warm greeting…read morefrom the people working there in the morning.

Excellent rainbow cookie cake. I have been buying it here since my children were small. It is the…read morebest.

Photos

See all

Titan Bakery

4.5

(18 reviews)

1.4 mi

From the sign, I expect a traditional bakery this is quite different. This is a in and out bakery…read moreoutlet but looks like a small store. I ordered the spanacopita. It was cooler temperature, I did ask if it was warm but no response. The spinach was tart dominate along with the the ricotta cheese. I have had the round spanacopita with more dough on several occasions and was not expecting such bold taste. I also tried the custard pastry that was next to the spanacopita and it was much warmer than the first dish. HOW? I'm thinking! The custard pastry was delicious and crispy. Not too sweet! The cashier provide subpar service, the cash out was lengthy and she needed assistance as the register was not cooperating. If I'm in the area again, I may stop by.

Love this place I'm able to get all my Greek things that I'm looking the Service is outstanding…read more It's a little store so ambience is great. Some of their food is absolutely delicious.

See all

Sweet Sophia's Bakery

3.2

(18 reviews)

2.1 mi

I have never been to the store location but purchased their Cinnamon Crumb Cakes on a regular basis…read morefrom my local ShopRite. Unfortunately, they no longer carry them. Their Crumb Cakes have a not-too-sweet buttery flavor and just the right proportion of crumbs (lots) to cake. I miss them!

You may have bought the White Eagle name for Chrusciki but not the recipe. Now that Rapacki has…read moreclosed down you may want to get the original recipe used for their Remember Momma's Chrusciki. You'd then be selling the real deal.

Photos

Great Crumb Cakes

See all

Chip City

4.4

(33 reviews)

1.2 mi

Got some cookies for an afterschool treat for my kids…read more I ordered the sweet potato smores, blueberry cheesecake, and cookie butter cookies. These cookies are massive! My favorite was definitely the blueberry cheesecake. I would rate it a 10/10. The s'mores is a 8/10 and cookie butter was a 8/10. I will definitely be back to try other flavors

When you walk in, the smell of fresh baked cookies wraps you in the most welcoming hug! Inside is…read morefilled with seating and photo opps as well. There is a good selection of cookies, and you can add ice cream to the mix as well! Staff is really helpful and friendly...patient as well! The cookies are thick, and a portion of them are stuffed as well! I would say these are like a shortbread consistency. Absolutely tasty and so addictive! Definitely get your money's worth. Parking is not the best, but there is an extra parking lot by the bank (behind Chip City).

Photos

Interior ad wall

No chocolate chip cookies, 15 minute wait. PASS!

See all

Crazy Billy's Fine Wine & Spirits

Here we go, So many of you may know that Crazy Billy's is…read morelocated on Deer Park Avenue in Deer Park. Im a wine drinker so I love something smooth and sweet ,but not overly sweet. Red wines do the trick. When I visit Crazy Billy's they always have something new. Yes .... my mouth water as I write this review lol. Here are a couple of reasons why I love this liquor store. Customer service - Amazing. The vibes from everyone there is A1. Prices- Reasonable not under price and not overpriced. No pressure to buy. Variety- They have everything you can think of. Wine, Beer, Liquor, Just to name a few. From old to new. Even flavors that you wouldn't even imagine Crazy Billy's has it. From the time you walk through that door someone is there to assist. I love it. The music is mix,Hip Hop, R&B, Soft Rock, Pop etc. Imagine shaking your butt down the isle as you shopping lol. You walk out that store satisfied every time. Well least that's my experience. Store very well organized and clean. Hubby loves this place. If you want to get your drink on have a great experience on a budget go to Crazy Billy's. You will be happy you visit. Happy yelping.

Crazy Billy's has a beautiful selection of Wine & Spirits with very reasonable prices. I had the…read morepleasure of meeting Veronica & Chris who both have great knowledge of directing customers towards the right wine or Spirits they're searching for. The store is well organized and the customer service is 5+ stars. Tastings occur on weekends that are complimentary.

Photos

1800 Mango flavor Egg nog Grey goose Peach wine

See all

Lindt Chocolate Shop

5.0

(7 reviews)

1.4 mi

While Christmas shopping at the outlets, I was craving a sweet treat and decided to stop by the…read moreLindt Shop since they have my favorite chocolates. I was surprised to see they had a whole Ice cream bar with different options, and sold coffee as well! I was intrigued and decided on trying the soft serve chocolate ice cream cone and it was AMAZING. Different than other soft serves I had and the cone with the chocolate rim was perfectly sweet. It also came with a little chocolate piece on top which of course was great. Everyone at the shop is also so helpful and friendly! If you're in the area it is worth stopping in and giving it a try. There is so many options and stuff for everyone!

My husband had a craving for a hot chocolate so we popped into here. What a delicious treat and…read morewhat a great store they gave us a sample of the Dubai chocolate and man was it delicious.

Photos

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

14 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Michela C.

10 years ago

best homemade gelato around. Just like Italy it's authentic, delicious, and made with the best ingredients. The gelato is fresh if your lucky sometimes you will see the gelato being made right in front of your eyes! The staff is incredibly nice and helpful! The flavors are spot on taste exactly what they are! Your allowed to taste any gelato you want for no charge. The pastries are amazing they fill the cannoli right when you order it ( no soggy cannolis here!). And delicious incredible Italian cookies, chocolate! The owner is from Italy so he knows what he's doing. The coffee is amazing they have expresso, capahino, cafe de nonno which is amazing , ice coffee and much more! THIS PLACE IS AN 10/10 I TOTALLY RECOMMEND!!!!!!! read more

Nigel C.

4 years ago

If I could give them zero stars I would. The owner is a rude pompous arrogant jerk. I refuse to spend my money with this place. I'm surprised he is still in business. His employee is very nice and tried to help me learn about their menu today, then this idiot decides he wants to rudely interject with an abrasive tone... total turn-off as a customer. read more

Christopher C.

1 year ago

"I decided to check out Cafe Italia again today, about a year after my last visit. Honestly, it was kind of a disappointment. I remember their desserts being amazing, but this time around they didn't look so good. It's a shame, since I had such a great experience last time." read more

Beth E.

7 years ago

I've never been to Italy but I imagine this is what it's like! The gelato was so fresh and pure, it has ruined me for all other ice cream forever. I had the mocha oreo, vanilla, and chocolate, and each layer was an experience i'll never forget. I'll be back! read more

Maria C.

7 years ago

Great service. Amazing gelato better than most places in Italy. Also great espresso and coffee. Owner and Manager are nice and friendly and willing to accommodate!! Would definitely go back again. read more

Alyssa P.

8 years ago

Absolutely the best gelato in New York by far!!! I have had gelato many different cafes and this one is the best I have ever had! Truly felt like I was in Italy! read more