Solid pizza! Decor feels like an old school diner. Staff is cool! Definitely worth popping in for a quick bite! read more

See all

Personally the ownership is terrible and food is subpar. Someone should go in and ask Scott how much his terrible pizza will cost once he lets this data center go through. I'm sure he'll brush it under the rug as, "everything is more expensive these days." Ok. Additionally, I'd like to see the LCB in there making sure things are running the way they should be. Beer bonging behind the bar at family restaurant is disgusting and totally inappropriate- especially from a public figure. read more

Food wasn't the best. Go to Rushville Pizza King soooo much better, overall. Got the same thing at this location and not worth it. Rushville pizza king is better. Try it for yourself. The things we liked about this was the taco shell, the breadsticks. Things we didn't like the pepperoni pizza the items inside my taco meat(beef), lettuce, tomato, and salsa wasn't the best. The cheese for the breadsticks wasn't the best. The service wasn't the best The cherry on top they sent me a text message on my phone even asking for a tip or not. It was our first time there the price was over 50 bucks the price in Rushville around $32. You decide where you wanna go. read more

Nice bar and excellent bartender, we always get the best service here. Great selection of craft beer and even better prices. We are old school with just ground sausage, green pepper pizza. Always made correctly. We love that the burgers are hand patted and not frozen. They have daily specials so you can always try different foods. We drive from East Indy once a month to get our Cagney fix. Once again great prices. read more

You cannot go wrong with the pizza at this location. Don't let the fish sandwiches fool you either. Sometimes, I get those and they're very tasty. I always get the pepperoni pizza. I love how their pepperoni is ground and very small pieces. This sauce is also amazing. The service is a little slow at this location, so you may want to call your order in, so it'll be ready whenever you show up. This is probably one of the largest Pizza King's in the state. There is a lot of seating. read more

Pizza King - a pizza box with a crown on it - Pizza Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

We were in the area and was searching for a place that was open kinda late. Found this cute little place and decided to give it a try. The brick building and stained glass windows are beautiful. Love the old town feel of the building and restaurant. They have dine in, carry out and delivery. We chose to dine in. They have coke products, tea and bar service. We ordered a variety as we weren't sure what we wanted 7inch personal size taco pizza had so many toppings the crust was almost nonexistent which isn't a bad thing. The lettuce and tomatoes were fresh the meat was well seasoned. 10 inch buffalo chicken pizza had just the right amount of Buffalo sauce to not be too hot but have a nice flavor. Had lots of chicken and wasn't dry. Spicy cheese cubes. So good and fried to perfection. Served with ranch 10 piece traditional wing with sweet chili They were good could have used a bit more sauce. However they are meaty wings and would get again in a different flavor. Overall great experience and will be back next time we are in town. read more

Pizza King - Sweet Chili wings - Pizza Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

This is a pick up review. We had 6 pizzas and a few salads and spaghetti. They gave us a time and they made it happen. I'm a pizza junky and usually do not like Midwest pizza. This was spot on and very tasty. Be aware that the pepperoni was a ground Pep as was the sausage. If you are ordering for the Team at the hotel, choose them you will not be disappointed. read more

In Shelbyville, we have the popular National pizza chains to choose from for a pizza pie fix. However, the Indiana owned Cagney's Pizza King is the regular place we order from for pickup pizza. They offer dine-in and delivery but they are always timely with the preparation and availability of your order, normally within 20 minutes. We like picking it up when it is coming out of the oven. The pizza is unique in that it is always party cut with a crispy thin crust and plenty of toppings. I have had other gourmet pizzas in Indy and indeed they are good. But, Pizza King pizza is kind of like Grandma's cooking; it's just hard to duplicate and always so so satisfying! The downtown restaurant offers a full bar and complete menu of pub food that is also very good. read more

Stopped after checking into our motel room on a Sunday night. The place was empty, but still making pizzas and had some picked up while we were there. Service was great. Our glasses were kept filled and she checked in on us appropriately. Our pizza came quickly. This was way better than any fast food for a late meal. It hit the spot. Meat and lots of mushrooms. read more

Pizza King - 14" 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 sausage with mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

See all

This food was horrible. The service was awful too... everything tasted undone and it was all disgusting. Do NOT eat at this horrible piece of shit place. read more

First of all when we walked in the door our party of 4 were greeted by a very rude cashier, strike one! Our first waitress Amber was very nice when she took our order but then the service went down hill. A young lady by the name of Morgan took over our table and half of our table got their food while the other half waited another 15 minutes to get a pizza. Then when Morgan brought the pizza and I asked for plates she said " I only have two hands". Then we had to beg for leftover containers and our bill. Because of the rude service we won't be back. It's a shame too because the food was decent. read more

The place to go in Shelbyville. Anyone that says otherwise is lying. BLT pizza, Taco pizza, tacos, spaghetti, garlic bread - all perfect. read more

Pizza King - Taco Pizza ... so good! - Pizza Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Wonderful experience at Cagneys for our table of 14 in the private room. Our waitress was prompt and attentive. All of our orders were complete and she checked on us frequently. The pizza is a local favorite - doesn't matter what kind, it is consistently good stuff. I love the stuffed potato skins and get them every time I go. We enjoyed the junior Sicilian salad and don't forget to order the shrimp cocktail for $1.99 . Wow! Such a deal! Also they have lots of craft beer on tap! The prices are more than reasonable and there is plenty of parking. The bar area is for the over 21 crowd, with family dining in the main room. One more reason to dine at Cagneys Pizza King: They are very benevolent in the community and support all local causes. Paying it forward, that's what it's all about. Thank you for all you do for Shelbyville. read more

I've been to many Pizza Kings in Indiana. This is by far the worst one. I've tried it 3 different time because I always want to make sure it wasn't just that one crew. From what I've tasted I'll drive 30 minutes to Greensburg or Rushville for a better pizza king. read more

We were in town for a softball tournament and snagged a carryout for the hotel. The pizza was terrific and perfectly cooked. If you like Pizza King pizza Cagney's will not disappoint. read more

This is a really cool little joint off the square in Shelbyville. They have many different items to pick from. It's way better than the Pizza King near me that has not so great pizza and a train that brings drinks. This pizza king does not have the train but it does have tasty tacos and a cool speak easy vibe to the decor. Will definitely stop here again. If you come on a Friday night prepare to wait. This place gets crowded. Also has a bar in the back for grownup time. read more

See all

I love Cagney's. The waitstaff is always friendly and who doesn't love Pizza King! I would suggest getting their stuffed bread sticks. As well, they have drink great specials in the bar section. They also have food specials throughout the week! read more

They refuse to deliver to the Pilot truck stop. I don't care if they have good food or not cuz their service is non existent.

Yum yum yummy absolutely love their food. We normally do take out so I'm not sure on the service

Not really a fan of this place. I've eaten here a couple of times with groups of people and they did a great job serving us but their food is pretty sub par. Get the pizza if you go. I got their tacos with rice and beans and everything tasted like it was from a can straight to the microwave. But my friends had nice looking pizzas. read more

Disgusting. Do not order delivery, it was horrible. Visit the area of Shelbyville and this is NOT where to order from. Overpriced for very bad food. Phone customer service ordering was painful, sorry for making the call. This place completely has no clue. read more

Pizza King - No care for quality, just a F-U on delivery. Stay away. - Pizza Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Their food is amazing. The bar is amazing. The owner is awesome!! Also, he makes this place such a dog friendly establishment. If you have dogs or a service animals bring them by. The more the merrier. read more

Been going there for years. Pleasant servers, good food, reasonable prices. Every Tuesday 5 guys workout or play racketball and go here afterwards. read more

I've been staying in Shelbyville for a couple months a few nights a week, and I've noticed Cagneys Pizza King is always busy in the evening. I ordered a 14 inch deluxe with added jalapeños. Timing was good it only took 20 minutes. But when I got back to my hotel room, I found they only cut the pizza in one direction, so rather than square pieces I had long strips which meant I had to tear the pieces not having silverware, in myhotel room. Also I thought the sausage would have more flavor, it seemed a little bland. I'm not saying I won't try again it just really wasn't what I was expecting read more

One of my all time favorite pizza's is Pizza King. I usually get delivery, which depending on the night can be fast or slow. More times than not when I eat inside this location the service is extremely poor. Whoever trains the servers, or doesn't train them, desperately needs trained themselves, because most people would not come back after such bad service, even if the food is amazing. Drinks don't get refilled, takes forever to place your order, and you can't find the server when you're done eating and ready to leave. A self-serving buffet would be much better in this scenario. The pizza's are awesome, but expensive. Tacos are average, salads are average, bread sticks are good but expensive, hot wings are above average, but their hot sauce is more like mild, and O'yeah, there's a bar in the back with separate entrance if you just like to drink. I think this is where the servers must hide, lol. Order delivery or carry out and all will be great. read more

Pizza King - Pizza Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

The crust was nice and crispy. The decor was a little old timey, but nice. The sauce and toppings were nothing to get excited about. Breadsticks come with a jalapeno cheese sauce that is reminiscent of the jalapeno cheese spread found in MRE's from my military days. The cheese sauce was room temp and congealed. It's not the worst pizza I've had, but I can't see a repeat visit in my future either. read more

I have loved Pizza King since I was a kid, and, every time I walk in this place, I'm reminded again and again why it's the best pizza ever! read more

Pizza King - This was my birthday pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Great pizza at very reasonable price. The server is very pleasant!

No matter what anyone says, Pizza King is a local Indiana tradition that you can't pass up! I spent my entire childhood eating pizza from Cagney's in Shelbyville and anytime I go back, I drool over a greasy crumbly pepperoni pizza and hot breadsticks! For added taste, try the taco or BLT pizza and it won't disappoint. They have excellent beer specials, so you can have your yummy pizza and a beer for a very affordable night out. I look for consistency in restaurants and they have it here. It is a family owned and operated Pizza King and that feel radiates throughout the place. All the faces are friendly. The decor is dated but makes you feel like you've never left. read more

Pizza King - Pepperoni pizza and breadsticks! Get ya some! - Pizza Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Sat in the back pub section of the restaurant for lunch. Few TV's playing daytime talk shows with a few locals at the bar. Food was better than expected.. but nothing to write home about. You can tell that this place has been a local staple for some time. read more

I only star because I have to give one. We got seated waited forever before we were waited on. I can say our first set of drinks came fast. There were 5 in our party we got 4 plates. No refills on our drinks ever! After flagging a waitress several times with no response and 3 standing behind the counter talking and 1 rolling silver ware. Worst service!!! I am do not necessarily think it was our waitress in general she was struggling to keep up along with another waitress but there were several ladies there not doing anything but wondering around lost. read more

Classic Pizza King with full service and a full bar. The servers are always friendly and quick and the pizza is the same nostalgic Pizza King flavor. Crumbled pepperoni is the boss of pizza toppings at Pizza King. They have great beer specials pretty often and they also have a community room that you can reserve at no charge! We eat here often when we are in town and the place never disappoints. read more

The barbecue pizza is the best!! Have eaten this pizza for years!!! One of my favorite places to go with the fam! Shrimp cocktail, barbecue pizza and french fries are the regular. Oh, yeah...pretty darn good peach margaritas read more

I Love Pizza King absolutely the best Pizza in town! They have something for everyone, we do t always order pizza sometimes we go for the taco salads which as sooo good or the Stromboli which my husband loves. I can only give 4 stars because they won't go the extra mile to deliver to my house and anytime I want Carney's I have to get dressed and drive to town. So unfortunately another pizza place usually gets my business unless I am already in town and just pick it up which doesn't happen often! read more

This is a classic stop for our extended family when we're in Shelbyville. We love the pizza! It's not too big, and we've always had a good experience with the wait staff. Clean, efficient and friendly place! read more

This was the only spot I went out to in Shelbyville. We were desperate for a beer on a Sunday and coming from Southern California I didn't think about blue laws.. Service was good, food was good [huge portion], and a good deal on a bucket of beer My only issue with the place is all the smoke..even the bartender/server was smoking!! But what can i expect in the mid-west? read more

I stopped in Shelbyville last night to spend the night and wanted some Pizza King. I wasn't impressed at all. I called them and complained but I was no longer wanting pizza after this. I ordered a medium with pepperoni, sausage and onion. This pizza was so greasy it's not even funny. I know PK is a little more greasy than most pizzas but this was ridiculous. They did offer to make me another one but I didn't want to make the delivery guy have to make another trip and didn't want to give another tip after spending $30 for 3 pieces and a small breadsticks. read more

Excellent pizza. Get the vegetarian. Well priced So-so salad. They did not have basalmic venigarette I would go there again. read more

Their food is usually decent. The service is awful though. They once messed up our order three time in a row and we're saying some pretty nasty stuff about us. I would not recommend. read more

I'm originally from Elkhart and on my way to Indy for Concord's State Performance at Lucas Oil Stadium. We stopped here to eat and I have to say, not only is the food amazing (huge proportions-had to get a to go box) but the staff is so kind and fabulous! There's a young kid (14 ish) that was hosting and he helped out the waitresses any chance he got. He was also working on his birthday today because they were short staffed! Thank you for the great experience!!!! read more