Lived in New Milford for a year and this was my go to pizzeria. Pasta and soup is also good. If you're in the area, you can't go wrong with ordering here. Delivery is pretty quick too. read more

We wanted to try a different pizzeria in the area, so we headed to Calabria. We took a table near the front and received a friendly welcome from everyone. After looking over the menu, we ordered cheese fries and heroes (grilled chicken with roasted red peppers & mozzarella, and meatball parm). Once we ordered, a bowl of garlic knots was brought to our table. They were absolutely delicious! Light, not greasy & just enough garlic...the smell was incredible! The heroes were also very good (you could taste the freshness of the bread, which makes all the difference). Cheese fries were perfectly cooked, again- not greasy at all, not overcooked, although I wish there was a little more cheese. I love cheese, so the more the better, but I realize this is a personal preference. We will definitely return...we have yet to try the pizza;-) read more

Best place in town ! Franco will always take care of you and the food is amazing! Slices to go or sit down outside on a nice night and enjoy a meal. Food is always hot and fresh and they can make it how you like it. read more

First time customer Online order : Smooth Delivery 45 to 60 minute ETA : Time Delivered 60 minutes Quality : Very Good Portions : Very generous Repeat : For sure read more

Great food and delivery time tried the garlic not sliders and loved them. Didn't think there was any decent food in the paramus area for delivery but I stand corrected. Great food descent price and hearty servings read more

Wow! Ordered food from Calabria for Christmas Eve. We were all very surprised. Great food and presentation. Their Calabria antipaste is excellent. One of the best in Bergen County. And everyone went on about how great the bread was! They did an excellent job. Will order from then again! read more

This is my go to pizza spot, never disappoints. Pizza is great, garlic knot sliders are awesome. Always happy with whatever I order from here. read more

My wife and I ordered dinner on 3/31 at 5:45 pm. Food was set to be delivered between 6:55-7:05. by 7:15 I called and asked about the status. They apologized for the delay and said the food would be out the door in a few minutes. 40 minutes go by, still no food. I called again and was told AGAIN that the food would be out the door in a few minutes and they apologize. Over 2 hours waiting for this food; ridiculous. Food finally arrived, cold. Going to call for some sort of refund. Never ordering from them again. read more

Very simply, a good Pizza place. Since I moved to New Jersey from New York, it's been a struggle to find a good Pizza place for my Italian cravings. Calabria Pizza handles it all. Definitely try the grandpa slice and garlic knot sliders! read more

Calabria Pizza - Boys on the dock! - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

Terrible chicken Marsala, can't believe it took over an hour for delivery. Never ordering from here again. Thank god for the other 1000 pizza shops in our area. read more

I lost my wallet on the bus and had to go to the bus station. I looked for local places nearby where I could pay with Apple Pay. They said they did but we're having problems with the internet at the moment so they gave me my slice and coke for free! Very caring people and plus the pizza is delicious! read more

I've seen this place advertised on EAT24 constantly so decided to give it a try. Meat lovers roll was the highlight. My wife ordered the Shrimp Scampi and we were surprised to find out that it's $17 for 5 20-25 sized shrimp and a side salad or side pasta. I could understand eating at a 4 or 5 star italian restaurant paying that but a pizza shop? Just didn't seem right. Doubt we will order again. read more

I love this place! We order from here at least one a month. I wanted to write a review because of their excellent customer service. There was a mistake with my pizza--it should've has pepperoni and mushrooms but forgot the mushrooms. Since my son already ate two slices, I just wanted a refund for the $2 extra topping fee. Instead, they are giving us the right Pizza and didn't want the original one back! If you're in the New Milford area, Calabria is the best! read more

Very good pizza. No extra charge for delivery. I've never been disappointed with any of the menu items.

Moved here almost two years ago and we were not happy with any of the places we ordered from until we found calabria's! Delicious pizza, grandma pies and stuffed rolls! The stuffed mushrooms are made exactly the way we like them and the service is excellent! read more

One of my favorite places for delivery!! They're always on time and the food arrives still hot! Some of the BEST Penne Vodka around!!

I ordered for delivery last night. I asked for a large pizza, half Margherita and half peppers and onions and a small plain pizza. I said at least three times on the phone, half Margherita and they forgot it. Pretty disappointing. Other than that, it was ok. The pizza was good at least. read more

Easy to order online thru Yelp. Delivery service was awesome, pizza was hot and scrumptious. Would recommend and order again read more

Calabria Pizza - Absolutely scrumptious. Perfectly well done, just like I asked! Delivery service was awesome. 10/10 would order again :) - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

Like a few other reviewers, my food arrived late... 1 hr and 15 mins after ordering through Eat24! This was the 2nd time the order has come that late. The food is decent, but definitely not worthy of a 3rd try - will stick with delicious, much more reliable Savinos from now on. Eat24, by the way, is full of crap...they never actually do anything at all when you request an order check or ask for help... Beware! read more

Amazing margarita pizza and the veggie roll is delicious. Has become our go-to delivery place

Placed my order through Yelp and it took a while to come. Yet, the food was pretty good. It was a hearty sized veggie wrap with fries (the irony). However, the mozzarella sticks were exceptional. I've ordered them in from many other spots and am always dissatisfied. But they were pretty great. Aside from the long wait, I think the meal was overall good. I'll definitely try some other stuff in the near future. read more

Calabria Pizza - Yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

Ordered online for pick up, asked for half chicken cutlet 1/2 plain, they accidentally made the whole think chicken cutlet and went ahead and made me a personal plain pie to go along with it for free! Appreciate that, za was good - 7.3 if this was a barstool review read more

Calabria Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

See all

Great margherita pie. Delivery is quick and pizza is hot. Very easy to order thru Yelp.

The pizza is delicious perfectly cooked right amount of sauce and cheese. Prices are reasonable and delivery is always within time promised. One of the better pizzas in the area has a true Pizza taste definately a must try. read more

I have tried several of the lunch menu items and they have all been tasty. The prices are decent and they have free delivery.

Calabria has the best pizza around. The chicken ceasar was amazing and so were the mussels ! Would have liked more mussels in the order but the sauce was perfect !!! I didn't want it to end !! Call this place next time ! read more

We ordered 2 chicken dishes and a Caesar salad. It came without the salad even though it was printed on the receipt. We told the delivery guy and about an hour later he brought a soggy Caesar salad back to us. Oradell is about 15 min from where we live why would they put the dressing on the salad they forgot in the first place. It honestly felt like they were doing it on purpose as an FU. Not happy with the service. read more

This is our family's go-to local pizza place for takeout or delivery. It's consistently good quality and they are usually very fast!

The VERY BEST pizza and Italian food in North Jersey! Too many great selections to list, but we absolutely love their lasagna and apple-walnut-gorgonzola salad when we choose not to get one of their tremendous, mouth-watering pies. The owner, his wife and crew all go to great lengths to make sure that every order is made to perfection. Thank you Calabria Pizza for all the great food and service over the last few years! read more

Great food for the price, can't complain. All around happy customer. I got a white pizza with veggies and it was awesome, you could tell it was handmade and not from a chain, the ingredients were nice and fresh. I will be eating here again. read more

I notice that all the negative review of CP are related to delivery. If you happen to be as lucky as I am to live within walking distance (so you pick up), then you probably know that this is a pizzeria with both above average pizza and great plate specials. First pro tip - the chicken Cesar salad - very strong candidate for best quick service salad in town. $10 after tax, balsamic marinaded chicken breast, great dressing (probably Ken's brand - that's the mac daddy of all dressing). Second pro tip - house label root beer Third pro tip - the desserts in the freezer case like the tiramisu in the cup or tartufo. Whoa nelly! read more

Delicious pizza. We ordered take-out and the staff was very friendly and the food was ready quickly. We tried a buffalo chicken pizza and a margarita pie with mushrooms added and both were super tasty. We surely will return, check them out! read more

I don't know what these people who wrote the reviews for this place were smoking but the pizza is horrendous. The sauce is bland, cheese was rubbery, and I have never seen so much oil and grease on a pizza in my life. I've live in NYC for the last 15 years so maybe I've been spoiled but this place should not be allowed to sell this garbage. read more

I love their garlic knot sliders!!! Down side for me is their sandwiches I ordered once and their bread was so hard I couldn't bite thru it.. won't be ordering their sandwiches again but the sliders were delicious read more

Been a huge fan of these guys ever since they changed owners. You can tell they put a lot of thought, care and effort into their food. I love the different varieties of pizza they put out.. from the buffalo chicken, chicken w/vodka sauce, chicken marsala and more.. Staff is extremely friendly and wonderful to all the neighborhood kids. read more

Been going here for probably the last 3 or 4 years And it's great pizzas are always great pasta dishes are great really recommend the fettuccine Alfredo hero's are always great staff seems very friendly it makes it nice that there open late too read more

Definitely try this place. Thin, but chewy crust is terrific and the brick oven flavor is great. Garlic knots are wonderful and better than any I've had. Not overly garlicky, but soft with great flavor and comes with warm homemade marinara sauce to dip them in. Just try the place and you'll see for yourself, best kept secret in Mt. Juliet. Nice inside, newly remodeled, cozy, cooks and wait staff were friendly and attentive and showed appreciation that we were there. Nothing like Brick, Pie Five, and all those other cookie cutter places that offer nothing that is homemade. You'll thank me later. ; ) read more

Best pizza in the area by far! We love their margarita pie. You won't be disappointed. And they deliver. Huge plus

To bad I didn't get a chance to try the food. Called at 6:50 (pizza,wings,sandwiches.) was told 30-45 minutes. I call them at 8:20, first girl sounds clueless as to the order then boss gets on phone to tell me oh yeah it will go out in another 10 minutes. We busy. Thanks ****. Good business model. read more

Moved to the area a few months back and we've been getting a pizza from here once a week. We tried the other places in town but this is our favorite. Consistently good pizza with friendly service. This is now our permanent go-to pizza spot. Everyone must have one and you should try Calabria. read more