What a little gem. If ambience is your thing, then this might not be your cup of tea, but if…read moreexcellent Italian food and good service is what you seek, then this is a place for you. I was forced to choose a restaurant for lunch after a funeral from several hundred miles away. I had nothing to really go on except Yelp reviews. I wanted to try to find a place within 10 to 15 minutes of the cemetery. I chose a dozen different places and oddly, eight of the 12 were closed on Tuesday. Three more places didn't open until late in the afternoon. A Little Pizza Heaven was my only good choice. However, I was comforted by the fact that their reviews looked good and their menu looked extensive. The restaurant is located in an unassuming strip mall, and it doesn't look like much from the outside. However, one should not judge a book by its cover. We had 16 people which took up about half the seats in the restaurant. Nonetheless, service was very well done. There were no prolonged delays. The food was outstanding. Not one person had a complaint. Everyone ordered from the menu, so there was wide range of dishes, chosen, including pizzas, pastas, etc. I personally had chicken piccata, which was excellent. The chicken was cooked perfectly and sauce tasted just right. Portions were generous, and the price was extremely reasonable. If you are in the area and you enjoy Italian food, you really should give this place a try.

Food was excellent, pizza was close to NYC Pasta fagiloli…read moreand tortellini in brodo top notch Meatballs where very good. Can't rate it 4.5 but all in all very good9

First and foremost, especially for the out-of-towners, THIS PLACE IS CASH ONLY. Yes they have an…read moreatm but you should know this before you walk in, unlike myself. With that said this still should've been a five star experience if not for a couple tiny hiccups. First off, I started off drinking at their bar and bottle shop across the parking lot. In fact, I was going to get a pizza over there, except I wanted to be all healthy and get a salad as well, which was not offered on the limited, pizza and snacks only menu available at the bottle shop. I closed my tab and walked across the parking lot only find a very interesting set up of a to go area very much separated from a sit down only restaurant. Quickly figured out I need to be in the to go area, where I was able to get a draft beer while I waited for my pizza and salad to go. Luckily I asked for a min to settle my tab as I wanted a can to take with me, at which point I found out about the cash only aspect. Last part of slight disappointment resided in the fact that they let me sit there with an empty glass without telling me my pizza was ready, until I finally went to the counter and they asked if I was ready to go. Uh yeah I was actually. By the time I go back to the hotel 14 minutes away, the pizza had gotten cold and required reheating. Fortunately, it was good enough that even with the reheat, revealed itself to be one hell of a pizza. Subtract another fraction of a point for not putting any plastic silverware for my salad. By the way, salad was fine, but pizza slaps.

If you're looking for solid pizza spot this is the one. They had so many different craft beers and…read moretheir tap room was huge! They even had a store full of craft beers you could take home at reasonable prices. Their pizzas are great. We tried their plain which was like a sweet sauce and the buffalo chicken. Both were great!

Probably the closest thing to a NYC pizza slice in the area. Solid bottom that doesn't flop down…read morelike a flower at night. Family owned business and local staple. They hand write cute messages on each box. Makes you feel like famiglia (family). Highly recommend if you are a local or visiting. PS. Love you too, Armetta's

I ordered through this restaurant while staying at a local hotel. It was delivered through DoorDash…read morethe pizza arrived hot and fresh like it just came out of the oven.

Service was fantastic. Food was fresh. Sausage and peppers were great. Bathroom and dining area was…read moreclean. Pizza and garlic knots were fresh. My only negatives was that initially the place smelled like smoke. I think an employee was smoking near the back door and smoke may have snuck in with him. And my sandwich was a little light on the sausage. Prices and portions were reasonable too.

Chicken franchise was not tasty at all! Pasta tasted like it was in chicken broth and raviolis…read morewere tasteless. Never again

It's a nice place and atmosphere is good but I'm sad to say the Chicken Parm hero I had was…read morehorrible. The menu states "chicken cutlets". It is not cutlets. It's pieces of what seem to be frozen tenders smothered in cheese with hardly any sauce. I don't understand how you can put out a product like that.

I've gone on a couple dates here and the employees are very nice and the food is pretty decent for…read morethe price.

Heard Salerno's was for sale or was going to be sold, so when I was back in Scranton my family…read moreplaced a pickup order for old time's sake. This was never the best pizzeria in Old Forge but I've probably eaten here a hundred times and have spent 15 years defending it, so it holds significance in my food journey. The late 2025 experience was between sad and insulting. Flat dough on 3 pizzas, chintzy toppings, only half the soup container was filled and didn't include bread, sloppy sandwich, and the woman on the phone sounded like she wished she had retired five years ago. Nobody ever said that this was the most consistent restaurant in Old Forge, but when your restaurant reaches the point where you're dragging down the reputation of the town's food scene, I think it's time to close.

The red pizza was really good and service was good would recommend them we will be back for more.read more

I ordered pizza to be delivered to my hotel room from this location. I told the guy to put $10 on…read morefor delivery and when he arrived he charged me $15. I told the deliver driver that was not correct so he told me he was going to get me $5 so I would sign the credit card receipt. I'm the meantime, the store called me and told me I told them $15 and they would prove it via their recording. I told them to play the recording so we can better understand what I said and make it right. He didn't have the recording and argued with me. Then he sent the driver back to the hotel to take pictures of our family in the pool area, underage kids on the pool were having their picture taken by a delivery driver. STAY AWAY!!!! NOT HONEST PEOPLE.

I ordered a large plain cheese and one with special ingredients. I was really disappointed. It was…read moretoo sweet, too small, and didn't have enough cheese in general. Will not be ordering again as we have already had much better pizza in the area. Also, cost came to almost $40 for 2 pies with Delivery (less than a mile away).. so not worth it.

So glad we decided to stop in and try a new place today. A longtime player in the local pizza game,…read moreJay has been running his own joint here in Dunmore for many years, slinging out some of the best Old Forge red and double Crust white trays I've tried in a long time. Better than some of the big names down in Old Forge! Small space inside for take-out only. Friendly guys answering the phone and serving orders out the door. We will be back again soon!

Best Italian Hoagie and pizza in town! Jay makes his own sausage for the pizza and it's awesome!!read more