As soon as we walked in we were welcomed and helped right away, everyone was very friendly and positive! The place was clean and had good vibes. We got takeaway we got cheese & ham pizza, calzone, cesar salad, and garlic bread. Everything was amazing (coming from a jersey/new york household). Highly recommend this place! read more

Inconsistent and overpriced, pizza quality declined from what I had a few months ago, I requested extra crisp dough but they failed miserably, the cheese is not quality like I'd expected or experienced from others. I added pepperoni and it's really not worth it, not fresh and way overpriced to my surprise an additional $5, making this average pizza over $30, not worth it and may not return with better options in the area. read more

Capo Pazzo - Overpriced White pizza, pepperoni was a $5 ad, not worth it with better pizza in the area. - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Today we were craving pizza. After seeing a number of positive reviews of Capo Pazzo Pizzeria we decided to give it a try...WOW. The upside down Sicilian was fantastic as well as the traditional cheese. We will be back. read more

See all

Our last night in Sarasota we wanted to try a good pizza place. Well we found it. Best pizza I have tried in a while. Three pies for our table were off the charts good. We had the huge margarita pizza which was great. The pizza dough makes the pie special. Lite and airy, thin but firm. Crust was cooked to perfection. Fresh tomatoes and great mozzarella were tasted with every bite. The second pizza was a white pizza. It was a clam pizza. Off the charts. Gives New Haven a run for its money. My favorite was the Donny Brasco. Loaded with pepperoni and spiced Italian Sausage. I'll be dreaming of this pizza until the next time I get here. We had Zeppole for dessert. Nice and original. Reminded of Noni's on those Christmas eves. The service was fast, very nice and professional. We wanted to be quick and easy. The building was unique made me feel like I was in New York. Great pizza start to my new year!! read more

Forgot one of my pizzas. The one they remembered was cold and tasted like cardboard because it was sitting for so long. Still charged me for it too. Won't be returning. You doubt it? Way to take responsibility! Great owner can't even take criticism. Improve your takeout business buddy it's lacking over there. read more

Ordinarily, I would return to a place that's 4-stars. In this case, I'm not sure we will. No sense in repeating others' reviews of this great pizza (dough, sauce). It's very good NY style. Prefer pinched or crumbled sausage, but sliced is NY style so they are staying traditional. But the beer---or lack of it. It's all InBev (ie, Anheiser-Busch) products. Today's restaurants should focus on craft beer like the vast majority out there. Have a least a couple of decent IPAs or specialty-style beers. The wine options looked good--but wine is boring to us. Great place, service, atmosphere, but the above is lacking. Hope the beverages can improve. Thanks. read more

This is legit NY style thin crust pizza. Excellent! As a New Englander and connoisseur of some of the best pizza in the country, this is the best we've found in Sarasota. Highly recommend! Service team is fantastic! read more

Capo Pazzo - Enjoyed a cold beer while we waited for our take out pizza. Pizza is fantastic! - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Really friendly crew and great toppings (fresh, high quality) but the crust on all of our pizzas was a disappointment. Dry and flavorless and overcooked. We would give it another shot for the toppings, but wish the crust had lived up! read more

Pizza and starters were delicious and delivery was on time! Very consistent quality. This is my go to pizza place

This place is absolutely amazing! The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the food is nothing short of fantastic. From the moment you walk in, the hospitality makes you feel right at home. I'd recommend this place 110%! Thank you all for such a wonderful experience I'll definitely be coming back! read more

Good pizza, just make sure all your items are on the pizza before you leave which was my mistake. Got home and the pizza had no pepperoni which was ordered. I understand though..it's was new years eve and they were busy as all get out. Mistakes happen. I still enjoyed it. read more

I've had their pizza (and it is quite good!) but last night I ordered their Capo Supreme Hero sandwich for take-out. Terrific! Meaty with sweet peppers and perfect bread (so much so I could only finish half). I'm looking forward to the other half for lunch today!. Capo's online ordering is easy and gives a countdown on when your food will be ready (although ive had to wait a few minutes longer if they are busy -which they most always are.) Their pick-up counter service is brisk but personable and friendly...and they seem to genuinely appreciate your business. Keep up the great work Capo! I'll be back many more times! read more

Woah! This place is amazing and definitely worth a visit. The freshness of the pizza was top notch and the toppings high quality. The crust has the perfect chew to it too. We will make this a must stop anytime we are in Sarasota. read more

We are happy to find an authentic NY-style pizza, which we have been searching for a long time. The pizza was ready before the promised time, and it was hot and fresh. We ordered a large pepperoni, a large margarita, a deep dish with Mike's hot honey, and a clam pizza. Everyone loved the pepperoni and deep dish. However, beware of the clam pizza. It was very disappointing. We tried two pieces and threw the rest away. read more

food is much better at restaurant. take out to 85min, but on time. ordered blue cheese . didn't come (extra charge) ordered marinara sauce didn't come (extra charge) ordered a couple orders of garlic knots (didn't come). I called and asked them to bring them , they couldn't, they asked me to come pick them up. I received a refund for the garlic knots but it wasn't even the full amount that I paid. Food was cold when it arrived, pizza was a flop. truly disappointing because every time I've gone to the restaurant it's been amazing. read more

They say you can't find good pizza in Florida...this officially couldn't be further from the truth! Capo Pazzo has the best pizza I have ever had in my life! My daughter ordered the Arancini and Penne ala Vodka - cooked to perfection! I will be recommending to all of my friends and family! read more

Ordered take-out. Pizza is excellent. Nice thin crust. Fresh tasty toppings. Finally, a restaurant caesar salad with freshly made dressing. Garlicky and delicious. Easy online ordering and speedy delivery. our go-to for pizza in south Sarasota. read more

Great NY with slightly burnt crust, perfect. Homemade creamy Caesar dressing. And the desert was so good. Can't wait to go back and try more items. Chris our waiter shared all the specials and was excellent. Eric came around to say hello and thank you. Not many businesses say thank you! We will go back soon to try more items on a great menu! Cheers read more

See all

Ordered on line, told me it's 50 minutes to prepare, arrived 45 minutes later to find very cold pizza. Will not do this again, better pizza places in Siesta Key, very disappointed. read more

This is it!!!! We're locals, but originally from the New Haven CT region where pizzerias like Pepe's, Sally's and Modern are rock stars. Like so many here, we feel there ain't been nothin close...until now. Partners Steve & Eric, and their team, are killing it. Tonight we had a large sausage pizza, which rocked. Is it a Weight Watchers approved meal? Hell no! Is it to die for? Hell yeah. Run, don't walk...and report read more

Capo Pazzo - Sausage pizza, has a little kick which I love. - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

pizza was pretty good, fried calamari were awful! rubbery, too much batter, sauce was like tomato soup. if you can't make it well, don't sell it! read more

Pizza is amazing (sauce is so fresh and taste is perfect) and the service is terrific. This place is special. And thats coming from a Chicago guy who doesn't hand out compliments readily on pizza :-) read more

Our pizza was a huge 18" (closer to 24") and delicious. They delivered it exactly on time, and the young lady could not have been nicer. we would for sure recommend them to anyone. read more

Amazing first time here and this coming from a chicago Italian boy. I got to meet the owner gave us an extra NY leftover pie for free so big props. Super friendly. Great undercarriage with solid crust on all. Ordered online with perfect timing ready when we walked into the door. The 12" Nonna meatball was the bomb with perfect blended meat wonderful sautéed onions with the right mix of ingredients. I always order different pies to test any place out. Prosciutto with arugula was great my base testing for any pie myself. I'll be back . Till then, thanks to the cooks. read more

See all

Called to inquire about the garlic knots because they were not listed on the app order menu. The kind guy threw them in for free after I mentioned how everyone raved about them on reviews. You gotta love family owned and operated businesses who cares about customers. So, how nice was that?!?!? We tried the Sicilian M.V.P., the Nonna, Zeppolos 'fried dough" and of course the complimentary Capo Garlic Knots. Yelp friends, let... me... tell... you... the Sicilian M.V.P. Is definitely delicious and one to try. The appearance reminded me of school lunch pizza... pure nostalgia. All the flavors work very well together so hands down the best pizza I had eaten in a while. The Nonna was my least favorite only because the dollops of ricotta was too much for me BUT my friend had no complaints and thoroughly enjoyed it. The Capo Garlic Knots and fried dough were both good as well. When in Siesta Key or Sarasota give Capo Pazzo a try. You won't be disappointed. I have pics but we had already devoured half of the pizzas so I will pass on posting them. Lol read more

Capo Pazzo has the best pizza in Florida.... hands-down. The restaurant also has a cool vibe..

Found a new place outside Siesta Key. Fantastic pizza! Order the Mommas Margarita. You will love it! read more

Capo Pazzo - Mommas margarita with meatball. - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

My friend wanted pizza while we were visiting Siesta Key. She found this place and they delivered! She was able to communicate with the driver and knew exactly when our order would arrive. We had a cheese pizza, a meatball and ricotta pizza, truffle fries and a gluten free truffle pizza. We all loved everything. The next day we had pizza reheated for dinner and it was, might I say even better the next day. I reheated my GF pizza and fries in a skillet and they reheated theirs in the oven. So good. Definitely recommend! read more

NY style pizza and Italian food. If you're from there, this place is for you. We've random sampled the menu, no disappoints .

Great food! Fresh and delicious. Everyone enjoyed it. All tasted great. Deliver driver was also very kind and respectful.

"bravo"...our first time here...totally thrilled w everything.. 1..had 2 pizzas...ny style and sicilian style or "the brooklyn."..absolutley perfect...plus a glass of wine... of course .. we couldn't finish them, but we have another 2 meals to look forward to... 2...the service was outstanding...from welcoming us as we walked in to "parmesean don" checking on us throughout the meal ..we really liked the attention...thank you...j 3...just a cute little place...there is a bar area w a few seats and tables inside and outside...(we chose to eat in to see all the action...) wish you had another place north sarasota closer to us... u read more

Capo Pazzo - THE BROOKLYN SILCILIAN STYLE AT CAPPOS PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

The pizza was the best? by far that I have had in SRQ. It was old school NY style with great sauce, crust and undercarriage. The staff couldn't have been more sincere. read more

Pizza was excellent. Loved their red sauce. Service was quick and all of the waitstaff were friendly. Nice little hometown feel to the restaurant. read more

Went here a few weeks ago and had 3 pizzas everyone of them was great. We will be back soon.

We had pizza and arancini. Both were excellent. The staff was fun and very accommodating when we asked to eat in instead of taking the food with us as originally planned. Will definitely be back! read more

Must try. Excellent pizza Nona was one we selected. Got large and had enough for lunch next day. Split the Caesar salad which was excellent and plenty to share. Garlic knots a must have. Waitress Emma took great care of us. Pinot Grigio was great and a full pour, unlike many restaurant in SRQ. One star short only because the air conditioning was not fully working but it didnt hamper our ability to enjoy a relaxing and delicious meal. Many reviews talk about place being packed but with end of season it was not. SO if you are thinking about going do it now while we enjoy less visitors to our area. Check out my photos read more

I went to Sarasota, Florida to visit my nephew and a friend suggested I stop at Capo Pazzo for lunch because it reminded him of New York. The Pizza and the food were great. Found out that the owner is from Queens, New York and he made us three pizzas that were fantastic and would easily best any pizza place in New York City. read more

just had a delicious meal with my family, 3rd time in 7 days counting pick up. Everything was perfect! Food and Service, keep up the good work! read more

There is no other place to get pizza than Capo Pazzo. Tastes so good and staff is great.

First time trying after reading many recommendations and was very disappointed given the hype. The pizza (Donnie Brasco) was very average, the toppings were decent put not generous. Perhaps we just don't enjoy this style of pizza given the other reviews. The wings are breaded and were mushy and tough (we did get as a to-go order). The meatballs were also just okay. Used the online ordering and it was convenient. Staff were friendly. read more