Awesome pizza and great service , worth the drive from Akron. The owner Andy Morse is a great guy . We are inside , large dinning room lots of options besides pizza and staff is super friendly. read more

Worst pizza ever Cappy Favorite . Guys change supplier of Pepperoni. If it's grease then it's not properly aged. Lack luster flavor . If you think this best you probably don't get out much. Brought appetizer out with pizza. Biggest waste of $26 this entire trip! read more

Cappy's Pizza - the menu for the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - London, Ohio

I've traveled across the U.S., from Chicago to New York, many pizzas have crossed my pallet, but none quite compare to that of cappys pizza. A simple slice of pepperoni, with the grease gathered inside the pepperonis, and you have yourself a winner. Cappys never disappoints, great for late nights after a football game, or getting a party pizza for your next gathering, cappys is the best pizza. Period. read more

We were passing thru the area and stopped here for dinner. First time eating here. Food was great and place was clean.

This place is pretty fantastic. It has become our local go to during or after long bike rides. The pizza is glorious. Thin(ish) crust, a little spice to the sauce- really a contender for the best pizza I have had in central Ohio. The service is generally friendly, though the place could definitely use a touch up or two. They have beer. Good, cheap domestic beer. read more

Great pizza,,,worth the drive! Personal are all friendly and very helpful! Love the veggie pizza!

Use to be pretty good pizza! Not so much now. It is just average, the crust is either not done or burnt! The consistency is just lacking. It is pricey for the quality. I would rather drive out of town for a decent slice! read more

Nothing short of amazing!! 7.50 for the buffet and it's well worth it. The pizza is delicious l, fresh ingredients made in back for salads and if you catch them on wing day your in for a treat! Juicy wings and great staff. Will recommend always Cappys pizza read more

Great lunch buffet and includes wings on Thursdays. It's great pizza and a great value. They do struggle to keep pizza out during the prime time lunch rush. read more

The family that owns this place is really sweet but the food is simply not good. Pizza is kinda mushy and the chicken parm sandwich tastes microwaved. Only thing I would recommend is a philly sandwich or grabbing coffee here read more

This place is a staple of Ohio pizza places, and really makes you wonder how the other places in town are still in business. The only nock is the buffet needs to grow as they grew into a bigger building. I really hate the swarm of hungry people in the dining room as a small pizza comes out, and it disappears instantly if it is a popular one. There is a charm to the other stuff people might not like. For example the mystery items in the chafer, which can hit or miss. Truly this is the best place to eat in London, but I wish somebody would man up and open a successful non pizza, Chinese, chain, or Mexican place. read more

Three stars is the highest your going to get in London, OH even though Cappy's has been a family favorite my whole life. I don't think I've ever had anything besides the classic pepperoni and cheese but it's all a person needs from this family owned pizza joint. Out of the 8 pizza options in London Cappy's and Donatos are your best options. Personal preference takes it from there as Cappy's Pizza has a little bit of a chewy, doughy crust and the pepperoni's become little grease bowls. Overall it's a decent pizza choice from a small town. read more

Cappy's pizzas are absolutely phenomenal! Perfect crispness with amazing quality toppings. It was definitely the best pizza I have had in years and I am very picky about quality food! read more

We tried the buffet and were pretty pleased with the quality of the food. The buffet doesn't have a wide selection, but their side dishes change depending on the day, so it's not always the same stuff. I definitely plan on returning. read more

Used to be one of, if not the best Pizza places in town, but it's on a rapid downward spiral. It seems as if it has been overrun with employee's that are more interested on what they can put in their veins than what you want on your order, so you should steer clear of this place until the owners can get some new management. Last few times I've called I couldn't even get through, but the several orders I placed before that were always late getting here, the food was just warm or even cold and some of it not even cooked thoroughly to start with, not to mention some items were missing. No discount or anything offered either when I called in to complain. Just a Sorry and I don't know what's going on response. Personally I am done with the place, so if you eat there you eat at your own risk... read more

I have never had pizza like Cappy's anywhere else. The sauce and crust are truly their own. You will either love it or hate it. I love it right down to the pools of oil that form in the pepperoni pieces. They are generous with the cheese and they cut the pie in squares. read more

Well when Bob owned the store, the food was decent. Now the food is atrocious. Andy does not make his employees wear gloves. I was in the bathroom when an employee came in, used the rest room and walked straight back to the pizza table (you can see right through the window into the kitchen and witness this yourself) and began making pizzas and salad! The employees do not wear gloves at all! I complained to the manager who then told me I was mistaken. Also the tables were a mess, there was still crumbs and food stuck the table we sat at. The shakers had food stuck to them. DISGUSTING PLACE. I highly would not recommend! read more

Everytime we order it is never a disappointment. Vegetables are always fresh and bread is great. Quality product at a great price.

Went for the buffet, hardly any options and the pizza was terrible. Don't go.

This place has always been the home town type pizza joint until tonight. Just went in with the family and got a large pizza that me myself couldn't hardly eat because it was so over cooked let alone my young daughter even be able to eat. After asking to talk to someone about it I waited for over 10min to the point that I was just ready to leave. Walking out the door the manager caught me and I told him it was so over cooked that my daughter couldn't eat it and asked him to make it right and he offered me a free 7" pizza for my daughter. That's fine and dandy. But what about the whole large we left behind on the table because we didn't even want to attempt to take it home. The crust tasted stale and was so hard that it couldn't be cut with the metal knives that had there. Terrible since the move. read more

Cappy's is a hometown pizza shop at its best. They have good food a decent price. The pizza is unique and not like the chain pizza stores. The staff knows your name when you walk in the door which always makes you feel welcome. They serve a Lunch buffet from 11:00 - 2:00 during the week for $7.50 per person which is a really god deal. If you leave hungry then you either did not like the food or you just were too lazy to get up for a second trip to the bar. The prices are a bit more on the menu than what you would pay at a chain pizza but you get a quality pizza for the price. If you are in London and looking for pizza this is a great place to stop. read more

Well if you like pepperoni pizza this is the buffet for you because that's about the only kind of pizza they put on it. I expected a few different selections for $8 per person read more

Good pizza! We always get it cooked extra crispy. My husband also likes their wings. Salads are good as well but not a fan of their Italian sub. read more

We just discovered this place and love the thin crust. The lunch buffet is great and the price is right. Pizza, salad,and more. Great! read more

The greatest pizza I have ever had. I grew up with it my whole life and so did my parents. My family from columbus drives to london to pick up a pizza. Just to fill the urge and have the memories they had growing up ful filled read more

I used to work here. The pizza is fresh but the toppings aren't. I recommend that people don't order any pasta as it's usually 2 to 3 weeks old. What's worse is the Buffett, weeks old chili, weeks old wedding soup, powdered mashed potato's with frozen Hamburger patty's as the steak, frozen wings, and finally weeks old pasta. The owners (majority of them) are nice. Management is a joke, really what pizza place needs 4 managers. The worse part about working here was trying to figure out who to listen to 1 of the 4 managers or 1 of the 3 owners. read more

While the pizza was wonderful, the sub was way below sub-par! It was barely cooked except to melt the cheese. we ordered no tomato and H.M. on the side. we didn't get any honey mustard and they put tomato on it! What happens if someone is allergic to tomato and they don't look first?? LAWSUIT!!! Just sayin I payed almost $30 for 3 items you think they could have got it right!!! The wings were decent but soggy. read more

Love Cappy's always have. I feel though they may have done something different with their pizza dough since the new location?? It taste really different. Still love to order from here don't get me wrong but it has a different taste and texture has been more like a cracker versus the dough I remember. read more

I love Cappys. It's been a staple of London since I was a kid. The low reviews are from people with either no taste buds or one bad experience under their belt. Lack of TVs for sports watching sucks especially in their new location but overall I still recommend it to everyone. If you don't like this pizza I almost don't trust you as a human being, and I question your ability to review food. read more

They moved into a larger building just down the street. More people but they didn't scale the buffet. 15 minutes waiting in a buffet line for some chincy little pieces of subpar pizza. Slow service on ordered items. Poor arrangement leaves lines of people standing next to tables. Credit card machine not working. There are much better options for pizza in London. read more

The food was good, but the service overshadowed it. We always like to try different local places rather than chains. When we first walked in we sat down at the table for about 10-15 minutes and THEN realized we needed to order then sit down. Meanwhile workers were cleaning and could have said something while we were just sitting there. Maybe a "hey you need to order first!" Rather than just letting us sit there. The food came promptly and was good. For being a newer restaurant you really think they would go out of their way to provide the best service, but we did not witness during this visit. read more

I would give this place zero stars if I could. Came in on a Sunday afternoon from the Dayton area with my husband and two young children. Besides another person dining in we were the only ones in the restaurant. I actually called before we went to make sure they were open because the parking lot was empty. We placed our order for one small cheese pizza, one XL pepperoni pizza, one large Meathead pizza, and 4 fountain drinks. The person taking our order was the only pleasant experience we had. We decided to sit in the back of the restaurant where it was quiet and away from the front doors since it is a cold, snowy day. After about 25-30 minutes our pizzas finally came. Not long after that we were asked to move to a different table because a large party was coming in. I cannot stress this enough...the restaurant was nearly empty. Apparently, we were seated in their party room which was not labeled as such. I spoke with the very rude and very patronizing owner who kept calling me "hon" and treated us like we were in the way. He tried to explain that his staff "do not know what they are doing" and forgot to close the room. He speaks about his staff that way? We were paying customers. We paid for overpriced pizza. Never again. Do not recommend. read more

Awesome Pizza! One of the best! The meat head special is amazing! This is a regular stop for us!

Great Pizza, BUT you always have to wait for them to bring out more pizza at Lunch sometimes they will only bring out 1-2 pizza's and there are 20-25 people waiting. read more

We've ordered here several times and the pizza has been satisfactory. However a visit to the buffet last week was pretty bad. They were very busy, but there was hardly any pizza out, if you want to even call it that. The pizza on the buffet most definitely comes from a freezer. The salad bar was actually good. I wouldn't go to the buffet again... read more

The buffet has been horrible since the move, the pizza has went down hill, they always run very low or out. Frankly I used to go at least once a week and I have quit. Waste of my money, , Cappy u need to just walk in one afternoon unannounced about 1 and take a look. read more

The pizza is the best local pizza and I like the little red gumball machine thing . I have eaten at cappys many times with each visit better than the last . Five stars read more

Truly the most horrible pizza. Very skimpy toppings, had to go home and put extra cheese on it myself. Was very disappointed because for that price i expected better.. and especially when it says "Truly Italian" on their sign. What a joke! I had expressed my dissatisfaction on Cappy's facebook page and i was met in a very egotistical manner by the smartass owner. If you do call and complain, I am sure you will be given the same treatment. The rudest person i have encountered in awhile! Bad service. I rather go to any place but here.. I don't appreciate snide remarks by the owner when i give a 1 star review on their fb page. Very unprofessional. I have a feeling they won't last in the new building at this rate.. the "hype" and newness will wear off..and nobody will care to see what it's all about anymore. There aren't many places in London you can take visitors from out of town.. But i will stay clear of Cappy's.. I only invest my dollar in quality places and people. Enough said. If you want to know what a good pizza tastes like.. Try Don Gino's on W. Broad Street.. they have a Monday Large Special.. very good price and awesome amount of toppings.. Now THEY taste like true authentic Italian pizza! They know how to treat their customers too! Go somewhere that cares about their customers and values them spending their money. CRAPPY's pizza and crappy service? Nope, never again! Usually i don't leave reviews.. but after the nasty comments i received i feel that a review is warranted. read more