This was a throwback to a time when I was much younger and really enjoyed Captain's Pizza. It has been a while but it brought me back to my childhood. It reminded me of the pizza joints I visited when a kid. The pizza was good. The young lady who took care of us was good. read more

Captain's Pizza No 5 - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Connecticut

See all

We just last night ordered dinner, delivered. After the indicated time of delivery passed, we looked outside to see if the driver may had been trying to find the house. There was the food, on the front porch in front of the door. The food was cold, no idea how long it had been there. No notification, no knock, no door bell. The chicken in the Gyro was overcooked and no tzatziki sauce. I would not recommend. read more

Wings are crispy with sauce on the side. Chicken gyro my go to. Always plenty of service and seating Ambiance Good for quick lunch or dinner Chicken Souvlaki another favorite read more

We've been going to Captains for years. I can't believe Captains doesn't have more stars. captains Pizza is dependable and delicious every time!! read more

Captin's pizza is always consistently good food. We order it for home delivery and my partner also gets it her work on a regular basis. This week I ordered a Greek salad with grilled chicken and a medium pizza with 3 toppings. The staff are always friendly and delivery is reliable. read more

This place is a guilty pleasure of mine. We love the pizza pies that they make but also the absolutely delicious Greek style salads as well. Get the chicken pizza! You will not be disappointed read more

Captain's Pizza No 5 - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Connecticut

See all

This pizza is very good. We (mothers) from Fairfield Ludlowe high school ordered recently for the boys basketball pasta/pizza night and senior night. Everyone loved the pizza, the crust is amazing. The prices are also very good. read more

Every time my grandchildren come to town they want to go to Captains Pizza ...one loves the pizza and the other one loves the chicken marsala and I have to say they're both very delicious! The pricing is good too. I have to say in my opinion they have the best pizza around. read more

I have had celiacs disease for over 20 years. Many foods have dropped off my favorites for lack of being able to create safely or replicate to taste like food and not cardboard. However I found HOPE with Captain's Pizza gluten free Pizza. Guys, I don't know how you do it.. but you have succeeded in creating a masterpiece. And the truth is in fact that I don't get sick after! It is truly Gluten Free!! My immense thanks! read more

Food was good! Service was awesome! Super friendly and made us feel like home. Shout out to Breta! PS Can't Wait To Go Get Steak (The Waitress Told Me To Say This!) read more

I've been coming here practically since the place opened up. Service has always been good and the food was great! But lately that's been on a down slide. The delivery service has not been nice even though I've tipped them. Over a week ago I ordered an Italian Combo and a small chef salad. Not only would my driver not come into my building but he was kind of rude even though I pre tipped him. 20 min after eating the Italian combo I got sick with a stomach bug. Everything was fine up til then. I was sick most of the weekend but eventually got better after taking Immodium AD. There are 15 pizza places between Black Rock and Southport. I haven't gotten sick from them. I've complained about this before and nothing seems to have been fixed. Maybe it's time to move on. read more

I order a large sausage pizza with extra sauce and it's amazing EVERY SINGLE TIME. I love this place.

I live in NYC where, for some reason, supreme pizza is not a thing and when it is - is made with that weird sausage as opposed to italian, fennelized sausage. So, when I come to CT to visit friends, I always make it a point to get pizza delivered from Captains. The pizza is always tasty, delivered quickly, and reasonably priced. Last time I ordered, half hawaaiin and half supreme, there was an error on the supreme side. When I called to report the error the dude on the other line was like "no problem" and replaced the supreme portion with a free small pizza which was easily the same size as the replaced section, if not bigger. read more

Thought I would try this place again, as it had fairly positive reviews, and I feel it's a challenge to find a good pizza place these days. Tucked off the beaten path on a side street by FTC, the location has nice parking and safe surroundings. The menu offers a large variety of foods. However, I decided to go with the classic cheese pizza. Upon opening the box, I decided I would need either a heart stent or a side of Plavex, as the grease was excessive like engine oil, and had soaked through the cardboard box. Because I was so hungry, I managed to get down two salty, slick slices. My stomach felt like I had swallowed a bucket of Crisco. Won't be returning. read more

Grub Hub is THE WORST! But the staff at Captains saved the day!!!!! After waiting over an hour for our food, we got the delivery only to find that one of the pizzas was missing. Which one? The pregnant ladies! My husband literally opened the box and said, "god I hope this one is yours..." Calling Grubhub is useless. The staff at Captains must have heard the fear in my husbands voice and offered to drive it over for us. AND they called back before they left to ask him what kind of cake I like. That is epic customer service! read more

I had mistakenly parked in their parking lot to shop at a store next door. There were no signs that said no parking. An older man that I'm assuming was the owner opened the door of the restaurant and screamed at me like I was a child (I am 30 years old) and told me to move my car. I apologized and moved it immediately, since I was not aware it was a no parking zone. If that is any indication of how he treats people, especially potential paying customers, I will never be dining there. read more

I'm obsessed with their pizza! I literally travel from Bridgeport (there are 2 Captains pizzas in my city) to come to the one in Fairfield. The pizza is less greasy and the employees are so nice! Recommend extra cheese and sausage yum!!! read more

Captain's Pizza No 5 - Extra cheese and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Connecticut

If you order on Grubhub, beware. The prices on the menu aren't correct and they will charge you after the fact saying "menu prices are wrong". I won't be wasting my time with this place again. read more

I don't what the problem is with these clowns. They are more worried about their parking lot than running a business... parked my car in a parking space to go grab some wings I had ordered from Archie Moore's... Had a friend in the car who was more than willing to move it if it was such a problem (parking lot was empty, by the way). Had this older guy with dark hair come out and yell at me as I was walking across the road. Explained to him I was grabbing some wings real quick and that my friend was in the car and they would move it if he asked them too. Saw he look at our plates and go back inside... As I came out I had some weird pale looking kid with a beard and glasses and some chubby chick with black hair (guessing waitress or son and daughter of older guy) immediately start swearing at me asking me if "that was my f***king car?!?!" Apparently the older guy doesnt know english and misunderstood when I said my friend would move the car if it was that much of a problem... I intimidately asked this weird pale kid why he was swearing at me... Apparently the older guy doesnt know english and misunderstood when I said my friend would move the car if it was that much of a problem and mistook it as me saying it "wasn't my car" (who else is it going to be if you saw me get out of it?) Got into a shouting match with the chubby black haired chick and the weird pale kid complete with them calling me a "F*cking liar" and threatening me with violence after seeing how upset I was with them swearing at me in the parking lot. Message to them: Just because you probably yell at college kids from Fairfield all day, doesn't mean that everyone who crosses your path at your crappy restaurant is some punk Fairfield U kid. Watch your mouth and learn how to run a business. Your garbage attitude is why Captains Pizza is going down the drain and your fake "tough guy/girl" attitude is a complete joke. Spend more time fixing your business and less time eagle eyeing your parking lot for minuscule things.... read more

I have never experienced such bad food and service. Clerk and delivery driver both gave me an attitude for no reason I found hair in my pizza and i spoke to them calmly, but I know i did not deserve an attitude for that I'm never eating there again I put a picture up for all to see. read more

Captain's Pizza No 5 - Hair, then both the driver and cashier gave me an attitude terrible service i will never eat or order from there again! - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Connecticut

Let me start by saying that the pizza is very tasty and I really love the crust and I usually do not eat the crust and found myself eating every bite. The problem was the size of the pizza. I bought a small which was more like a mini personal pizza. I could easily finish a small myself where as usually I only eat 1/2. Not sure what the larges are like. I might have to try one of those next time. read more

I've been to a few of these locations. My fave is this one. I ONLY get the eggplant pizza. I prefer when they cut this Greek style pie into squares- trust me it makes all the difference bcz of its "thickness". If you get a hankering for Greek pizza- u won't be disappointed. Tight small parking lot. I get take-out- as the decor is lame. read more

Best pizza --- love the crust. I have also tried the eggplant and chicken parm and both are delicious.

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza. Great taste and great crust! read more

Captain's Pizza No 5 - outside of restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Connecticut

See all

I love this place!! I go here at least twice a week for their Chicken Souvlaki salad - so bomb!! Ilhan, the owner, is super nice and the staff is also very friendly. I've got all my coworkers addicted to their salad and I am sure you will be too once you try it!! They have tasty Greek style pizzas as well. If you are looking for a new place to try def do it you will not regret it! Filling and yummy :) read more

Captain's Pizza No 5 - a chicken salad in a plastic container - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Connecticut

This is our go-to place. Friendly staff. Great Italian food, but they also have Greek and Turkish dishes. I love the meatball parmigiana hero and the chicken adana. read more

We have been long time customers of captains pizza but we were beyond disappointed when we got a large cheese pizza delivered last night. Not only did the pizza arrive an hour after the order was placed (we live within 1.5 miles of the restaurant and it was placed at 7:30pm on a Tuesday...) but the pizza was the worst we've ever had. It was all bread and barely any sauce or cheese. We will be going to Mike's for our Greek pizza fix from now on. read more

I love these guys. Get the Greek salad with chicken slouvaki - its the house dish - amazing meal. Great pita bread too. He makes his own balsamic Italian vinaigrette that is outstanding. I like their pizza too. Its the greek style pizza, not Italian, so smaller more cheesy yummy slices. I like both styles every now and then, and this is my favorite choice for that Greek style pie. read more

Okay, it's a matter of personal taste I'm sure, but this is my favorite pizza in the world. I love this place, it is a classic pizza place. Nik, the owner, is a great guy. The employees have all worked there for years. Nik's son is also there. They have great greek salads, beer is on tap, the location is convenient. The prices are very reasonable. They have the best crust ever. read more

I should start this review by stating that the waitress was excellent, attentive, apologetic and then eventually mortified on how the food was completely botched up. We ordered pizza. Wow, that should be simple until it was brought out. First, they didn't put meatballs on the entire pizza and garlic on half of it. To be polite I said, not to worry We will eat it. This was an obvious mistake. I suppose you could kill someone with the crust if you really wanted to. Sent it back and got pizza number 2. Just terrible. The mortified waitress suggested we order a wedge. Eggplant was excellent and my friend had the meatball which he said was just OK. Final review is one star or less. read more

We have been long standing customers. We had an issue with an order and the only time in 8+ years we called to inform them of an issue (food completely inedible) they were horribly rude. This is not surprising as the experience dining in the restaurant has always been substandard which is the reason we order take out. Beware- they do not treat customers well. read more

Ordered delivery from here plenty of times, Love their mushroom pizza, not too oily and not too thin crust either, just right basically!

Great little Greek Pizzeria. The bad first...It does appear a little run down outside and inside. There is also limited seating and generally only one waiter working. They make up for this with the food. The kitchen is exposed and is clean. The pizza is great Greek Pizza and is cooked to perfection. They will take off-menu orders upon request and the food is always cooked well. This place has a very homely feel to it and it feels good to walk in, grab a table and eat some good food. Staff is friendly and delivery time is reasonable. read more

Very rude driver. The food is great but they need work on their customer service skills.

I miss the old Captain's pizza. They must be under new ownership because recently the service and the food has been awful. The delivery guy gave me an attitude after being an hour late with my food which was the wrong order. This used to be my favorite place to eat, I'm never ordering from them again! read more

Okay so I don't usually post reviews but today my boyfriend and I stopped in before he had to be at work since we are usually always in and out. We were the only ones inside besides a table who had already been served and was getting ready to leave. Ordered a garlic bread and two sodas and a small pizza. Garlic bread came out quickly. No plates or napkins though. Then group of 5 came in and seemed to know the owner who immediately became more worried about their service than ours (who had now been sitting for 20+ minutes). Maybe another 10 minutes later our pizza comes out of the kitchen.. burnt and black, crust hard as a rock. Owner said sorry it was "well done" and would bring another out shortly. Problem with that was we didn't have time to be waiting longer. As we told him we didn't want it he still tried to charge us for the pizza! We ended up paying for the garlic bread and drinks and left. I understand things happen but we were the only ones in there and we felt as if our order was not enough and he was only worried about the next order and money. read more

The BEST chicken souvlaki salads!! Pizza is great if you like Greek pizza... Great little place!

I would love to absolutely give them five stars because I feel that they (the owner and staff) are incredible based on service alone. However, in terms of pizza I must say they are what I consider our go- to pizza. This pizza is like that old comfy slipper that always seems to fit just right. I am definitely a foodie and have high standards when it comes to good pizza. I didn't grow up in Fairfield and find most restaurants to soar in customer service where they lack in tasty food. Captains pizza has good sauce and yummy cheese, it is always piping hot and the crust doesn't need to be saved for my moms dogs. The prices are reasonable although they should throw in a free 2 liter every once in a while if you ask me, they never seem to have specials...but that isn't the biggest turn off. All in all, I think it's the best pizza your going to get in Fairfield. read more

I pulled up to captains with my friend in a different car - we were picking up a pizza for my mother before my friend and I went somewhere else. Before I could get out of the car, this extremely rude waitress stormed outside saying I could not park there. Confused, I looked back at my friend in her parking spot as the same lady said 'and your little friend needs to leave too' I was shocked an employee was referring to two customers in such a hostile manner. I asked the lady why she had such an attitude towards me and before I could finish the sentence she called me a bitch as the front doors were being shut on her by the owner in order to make her stop. Bottom line, I have never met this lady in my life! For an employee to call me a name and be completely hostile to two customers she's never met before is ridiculous. After leaving without the pizza my mother called the place only to hear excuses from the owner that I only parked there to go somewhere else. Obviously, the employee and owner were mistaken because of the separate cars. Due to their incredibly rude behavior and conclusions they have lost a customer. When you go to pick up a pizza at captains, be careful where you park - apparently their own parking lot is off limits! read more