If you're craving an authentic slice of New York-style pizza, look no further! This place delivers…read morethe perfect combination of a crispy, foldable crust and rich, flavorful tomato sauce that's just the right balance of sweet and tangy. The cheese is incredibly gooey and perfectly melted, stretching with every bite. I highly recommend them if you're in the area! Customer service was excellent as we had a large order for a birthday party and will definitely order again!

My kids and I love it here. We stop in for slices and it always feels like home. The owner is very…read morefriendly and his staff are helpful. I just wish they offered personal pizzas (wishlist)

Not too expensive. Pizza had nice crispy bottom. Good amount of cheese. The garlic knots were too…read moregarlicky for my wife and son. I also thought it was a little strong but was toned down alot by the dipping sauce. Plenty of parking. Overall a good, relatively inexpensive meal option.

We went back tonight because we had a phenomenal experience last week (service by Aubrey and food…read morewas phenomenal) when we went. Tonight was completely the opposite. This was on a Saturday night this time whereas our 5-star experience was on a weekday. Tonight the service was the exact opposite. Our servers name on the check was Kat, I believe here name was Katerina. She seemed to have an attitude as if she didn't want to be there. Literally she did the ABSOLUTE bare minimum. The food tonight was a huge disappointment. I ordered the Grilled Shrimp and Scallops which came with a side of pasta with mussels. The shrimp were beyond overcooked and the mussels were huge but seemed undercooked. The entire dish was cold to lukewarm. My wife's chicken dish was not hot either. Bread came after our soup and salads but all the other tables were given bread before. From this experience alone, I will have a hard time deciding to go back, especially on a weekend. It's such a shame because when my family really likes a local place, we tend to visit almost weekly. Also, by seeing that none of their reviews have a response from the business, I will assume the reviews aren't paid much attention too. *********************** First time dining here. We absolutely enjoyed our meals. Food was amazing and our server Aubrey was very efficient, friendly and on top of all aspects of our dining experience. We will definitely be back. *********************

my last review I gave this place a 4 today I have to give it a 5!!!…read moreLast time I had a cheesesteak and a plain pizza that were so so good the best I've had so far in this area Today I had a Stromboli and it was amazing going forward. I will get all my pizzas, cheeses, and Stromboli from this place only.!

Well a fav of mine is sliding down the ranks to ordinary…read more This was a place that solidly delivered a monstrous delicious steak sandwich The inside of the shop was dreary and neglected. A sign read pay with cash and get 10% off In other wards if you use a charge you pay 10% more. This is how a discount becomes a penalty I am used to a small percentage added on to help absorb fees from credit card companies The sandwiches were tasty but skimpy. Maybe a change of ownership??? I dunno, I guess I need to find another outlet to satisfy my cravings

Such a fun old-school pizza joint! The vibe is classic, the portions are huge, and everything we…read moretried hit the spot. The steak Stromboli is an absolute beast -- loaded with flavor and big enough to share (but you won't want to). The broccoli bites are crispy little bites of magic, and of course, you have to get the pizza -- it's what they do best. Don't skip the water ice either -- we tried a few flavors and the cherry was hands-down our favorite. This place is a must if you're craving that nostalgic pizza shop experience!

Great food and fantastic service staff, They always make us feel at home. Gus and the crew are…read morereally great!!

I have been to Tomato Shack in Conshohocken a few times now, both in person and delivery…read more The restaurant is located in a convenient spot in Conshohocken, especially if you are using the nearby trail or just driving through the area. There is limited seating inside, but they have a nice outdoor seating area with covered umbrellas. When your order is ready, they call your name over the loudspeaker, so you can easily grab a table outside and wait for your food. I have had the plain pizza here a few times and it is really good! I especially like the personal size. The crust is always really crisp, while the sauce and cheese are both flavorful and go really well together. The pizza has also always come out very hot and fresh, which makes it even better. Altogether, Tomato Shack is a great casual pizza spot in Conshohocken. I have enjoyed it every time I have been here and will definitely come back!

We were in town for a lacrosse tournament nearby and did a YELP! Search for pizza but didn't want a…read moretraditional pizza place - and so glad to have found this sweet place especially being able to eat outdoors with this fine, fall weather before it turns to November COLD. There is limited parking, but since it was Sunday, we parked across the way in a commercial building lot. They make their pizzas with organic dough and the sauce and cheese are amazingly fresh tasting using organic and local produce. It's some of the healthiest and tastiest pizza I think I've ever had.You can tell they are committed to quality and service was friendly and thoughtful. Had fountain root beer and it was perfect with my personal Bella Napoli pizza which was actually larger than I expected (the original large pizzas are 16") and took home with us on our drive back. The cheese pull was amazing and the freshness of the tomato and basil were unexpected and I kept oohing and aahing after each bite. I should have taken the photo before we got in the car and thought i had. Sorry! BUt, trust me, it was really gooood! They are made-to-order, so be prepared to wait for the pizzas. And I dare say, you won't regret the wait once you have that first bite!

no matter the time of day or year, there is always a *cool vibe" and atmosphere. never a fight,…read moreargument or belligerent customers. it is jot tolerated in this place! if you are local, stop in. if you are out of town, stop in.

Tacos were completely tasteless on taco. Tuesday drinks were not made right and waitress is very…read morerude. Went there on a Tuesday afternoon. It was horrible, never again.

I love this place! The pizza is great. The waiters and waitresses are excellent. So nice. My…read moresister and I make it a weekly gathering place. They never disappoint! I highly recommend it.

Solid thin crust pizza. We did take out, but the sitting area was full. Families and couples…read more Not much atmosphere, standard pizza shop... but definitely recommend

9/6/24 poor experience today. I wanted pizza and the server said the guy who does the pizza had to…read morego pick up his son. So the pizza might be impacted. I appreciated her honesty and she was a good server. I asked how the chicken parm was and she said it was delicious so I settled on a chicken parm sandwich. When I got it- it was burned. She explained that the bread crumbs get dark in the friar. I know the difference between dark and burned. She offered it to be re-made. It came out better but the chicken was tough, and flavorless. I'll never take my coal region pizza for granted. I was superbly disappointed tonight and there was also a very strong oregano taste that was unpleasant and over powering. The restaurant seems dated yet nostalgic. I personally won't rush to go back. If I did go back- I would stick with the pizza. Not sure if this was an off day but my friend did not enjoy her baked ziti- very strong unpleasant taste of oregano. I have to be honest in my reviews. I've had lots of great experiences but this was terrible.

This place is right next to Ollie's across from the Sunoco smoke shop, nice bar in here a little…read moredark. Decent selection of beers on tap. The bartender is friendly. Food is always good here and packaged with care, bread is never soggy. Steak sandwiches are excellent. They always use fresh ingredients. So far so good.

SO INCONSISTENT!! one day you get an overall good pizza the next weekend you get something that's a…read morehot mess ... sauce that's too sweet, or has too much oregano. They clearly go through a lot of pizza "chefs" and cook staff.

Had to see for myself and what a delicious, filling, and budget friendly cheesesteak option. Loved…read morethe bread, the meat, the cheese... the whole package! Only took about 10 minutes (maybe less) for takeout. One of my favorites in the area now. Can't wait to get it again when I'm back!