I always come here for the crabcakes (even though I usually eat plant-based), & also for the lemon saffron sauce they would serve on the angel hair pasta that came with it. Sadly, the sauce has been changed to a cream one. (I draw the line at dairy!) It seems there are new owners..still Italian! The service isn't polished, (used dishes stacked on the table before removal) but it is prompt. Comfortable booth. read more

Big ups to ARNOLD - this guy is killing it. We came in as a group of six for dinner - Arnold took excellent care of us. Food was great, portions were generous. Pizza was dank. I wish the scallops Angelina had been five pieces and not three but otherwise, really good stuff all around. Note the cheese pull on the slice! read more

Another amazing meal at Carlucci's Italian Grill. Went with a very large crowd. Food was excellent and service impeccable, even with a holiday time packed house. So many delicious choices, so everyone was really happy with their selected entrees! The shrimp chowder and pasta fagioli soups were outstanding and the puff garlic bread is scrumptious! The antipasto platter was delicious, albeit a bit small for the price. Also, personal preference is for the fried calamari to be more well done for crispiness. Only wish is they would expand the appetizer offerings to include more standards like mozzarella sticks or fried ravioli for the finicky eater. With a big party it was difficult to make appetizer selections for the whole table to share. read more

See all

As a family we've been here for holiday meals a few times and recently revisited for a small family lunch. The outdoor seating area was new to me and very nice on a mild sunny day. I was craving pizza. The Bianco pie was ok. I asked for it to be well done and I think that helped. But this is super thin crust, possibly too thin. It did not really satisfy my craving, and was a pretty small specimen too. My 2 cousins enjoyed their veggie wraps more than anything did my pie. And my uncle really liked his pasta Al forno. This one has sausage and meatballs and was plenty for him to get leftovers. I think the key to this place is finding the items that you enjoy and not venturing too far from them. Service was quick and friendly. read more

Carlucci's Grill - West Windsor - Bianca (ok) - Italian Near Me - Princeton Junction, New Jersey

Located in a shopping plaza but you don't notice it even when eating outdoors. There's a nice set-up under a tent or umbrellas. Large indoor space as well. A bit worn looking in some areas but in a way, adds to the old world feel. Enjoyed the appetizers: bread with red sauce, fried calamari, sampler with tomato bruschetta, fried artichokes and mozz sticks. The veal francaise with spinach was good, maybe could use less of the sauce. The crab cake was a bit dry though and bland, the pasta was just plain, with that yellow sauce- with mustard? Staff members were efficient, and plentiful. Also on that Sunday, the place wasn't packed. 3.5 read more

See all

I went here on a recommendation from a friend. The staff were friendly. For an appetizer the fried calamari was spot on delicious and nicely cooked. I ordered a Marguerite Pizza. I assumed it was a full size pie but I was mistaken. The pizza was very good I just wish it made it to the table a little hotter. We also ordered the Italian Rustic Cod, this too was not as hot as expected and tasted a little fishy. No cocktails, only two seltzers for which we were charged $8.00.......Not a terrible experience, just a little disappointing for the price. read more

Carlucci is one of my favorite restaurants in the area! Always great food it's really cute. I like the outdoor area as well! I would highly recommend it! read more

Carlucci's Grill continues to deliver an excellent dining experience with delicious food and great service. I came here for lunch this week to celebrate my friend's birthday. The lunch portions are very generous and come with soup or salad.  Prior to the meal complimentary marinara bread and puffy garlic pita bread appetizers are served.  We really filled up on these breads. I ordered the Rustic Italian Cod (one of my Carlucci favorites) and my friend got the Chicken Parmigiana sandwich.  Both entrees were great.   They have taken the extra effort to beautify their outdoor dining space during Covid with lots of fresh flowers, planters and decor, although that did not apply for my most recent visit.  Overall, inside and outside Carlucci's is a very inviting and welcoming dining atmosphere. read more

See all

Very nice place, a cut above the normal pizza place, a nice restaurant. Very attentive wait staff but not overly annoying. Nice touch is the bread with pasta sauce they bring to the table. Then later they give you a complimentary bread balloon, very tasty and welcomed. I have Chicken and Shrimp Stephanie, which was excellent and a large portion. Partner had Branzini fish which she really liked. Definitely will return to this place. read more

The prices did not match the quality of food. I had high expectations and can compare it to a star above Olive Garden.

I'm pretty sure I have food poisoning from the Capellini Maradona I ate tonight Also, the caprese salad didn't have much flavor.

One of the finest Italian restaurants in NJ. BYOB!!! They take reservations on phone, definitely a plus since they are pretty packed. We called them on a Saturday MDW and was easily able to get a reservation. Our server was helpful giving us the vegetarian options. Bread with marinara and fresh garlic bread are served complimentary. The garlic bread is soooo good. For entree's, we ordered the Ravioli Bellini with a side of Pasta Fagoli soup and they were both 10/10. Definitely recommend. The best of all was the dessert - Tiramisu Definitely coming back!!! read more

See all

A great little place for a family dinner. We needed a table for 9 and were easily accommodated. I wish it was warmer out because I noticed they had a nice setup for outdoor seating.. next time! Bread with sauce on top and puffy garlic bread came out for the table. Both, a first for me and both, delicious! I've never had that at any other Italian restaurant before.. it was so unique and great start to a meal. I knew my entree would be delicious based on the red sauce on top of that bread! I ordered the Eggplant Parmesan which came on a bed of pasta. I ate it all. My husband got the Borsellini alla Vodka. He wasn't sure what the pasta pockets would be but he was so happy he ordered it. He said the cheese inside was terrific and the pasta was cooked perfectly. . He rarely asks for a box to take home leftovers but he did this time! I think the only reason why he even had leftovers was because he filled up on bread and some other apps. The rest of the table enjoyed their meals as well.. chicken franchise, penne vodka.....Our niece is gluten free and took her leftover home as well. They took such care in making sure her pasta was cooked separately and that doesn't go unnoticed. The service was friendly and quick.. and very attentive. Our cups were never empty and any requests we had were answered. Great place.. my husband wants to go back for more Boresellini! read more

We had reservations and were seated right away. Before we were seated for even 5 minutes tomato bread was served followed immediately by water and wine opened! We were then approached by our waiter to see what we wanted to eat. TOO RUSHED! We tried to slow it down by saying we were enjoying a glass of wine. He came back 10 minutes later. We ordered. To top it off he brought our entrees before our salad! We were not happy. We felt RUSHED beyond belief. We did not order dessert and won't go back anytime soon! They did not need our table and there was no reason to rush us. We went out to dinner to get out and relax. It didn't happen. Carluccis stop the rush to turn over a table ! Food was good but experience was awful. read more

Very nice place, food was good but typical, service was very good. Would go back if we are in the area again.

Good traditional Italian fare. Very nice ambiance with good service. They give you a very good garlic bread when you sit. Really tasty! read more

In our hastily reconfigured outdoor dining spaces, what passes for idyllic often comes with a world class view of a parking lot or seating so close to the curb you can board a bus without even getting up. Carlucci's in West Windsor has a better idea, create an outdoor patio space that provides sanctuary and quietude that won't leave you inhaling diesel fumes for dessert. BTW my Veal Rollatini was superb as was the Calamari appetizer. Another terrific meal thoroughly enjoyed from this family dining evergreen. Five easy stars. read more

The food and service are the best in New Jersey. We eat from Carlucci's at least twice a week. Love this place!!

They serve yummy Italian food, so comforting. We love their Pasta Fagoli, eggplant parmigiana, ravioli Bellini. Their food is perfectly seasoned and yummmy. Definitely recommend this place read more

we have not been here in years. the food is still delicious after all this time. Great gluten-free pizza.

Pretty tasty spot! We came by tonight and managed to snag a table outside without waiting too long, but the inside of the restaurant looked pretty busy. I would say that the service was one of the downsides of the meal, as our server visited our table very infrequently (we had to wait ~15 minutes for him to pick up my card to pay for the meal!). That being said, at least he didn't totally forget about us, which has happened at some other restaurants :) For food, I ordered the crab maradona for myself (basically a crab pasta) and my wife ordered linguine with clams. I was kind of impressed with all of the extras we got! Each entree came with a soup or salad, and we both decided to get the seafood bisque (which was quite tasty and filling!). The server also brought out some bread with marinara before the soups arrived (which was OK but not great) and MORE fluffy bread with garlic after the soups (better but maybe could use some more seasoning). My pasta was pretty good! I liked the sauce, and there were definitely chunks of crab throughout. My wife was less crazy about her pasta and really wanted more salt, but there weren't any salt shakers on the outside tables so I had to sneak in to grab one from an inside table :) I would have asked our server but he was never around! Overall, it was an OK experience. BYOB, as mentioned by other reviewers, so make sure you bring your beverages of choice. I'm still looking for that legendary Italian spot.... read more

Excellent service and food. Seafood bisque was exceptional. I had the Trio Seafood Verdure and everything was cooked just right. They allowed my husband to change a pizza to make it his way. read more

After golf a great late lunch, plenty of seating good pizzas reasonably priced!!. Had a good menu

Excellent service and food. Raviloli Bellini is our favorite. One of the best Italian restaurant in the Windsor area.

We love their menus, the quality of their food is consistently wonderful. We moved out of the area, but love to go back whenever we can.

The garlic bread alone is worth going here for. I enjoyed a delicious meal while out with a friend at this BYOB establishment. The waiter was kind and the food delicious. I had a delicious piece of grilled chicken and my friend said her pasta was fantástic. I will definitely return! read more

I decided to go back here for my birthday dinner. Now I had called ahead to see if we needed a reservation and I was told I didn't bc it was early enough for dinner. What I didn't know was they had parties going on. We get their and are seated in the outdoor seating nook. Our waiter didn't give us menus so we had to ask and he gave us one? So had to ask for another, which took a little longer. We ordered our food. First we started off with the mussels which are still delicious, I decided to order the Spicy Cauliflower- One word. DON'T. It was heavily breaded in some kind of battered mess, it didn't taste good, the spice was meh disappointing. Now the server we had was really horrible. I understand that they are doing tables inside and out, but most of the time he was nowhere to be found. Thankfully the other female server was around more and she was able to bring us more water and other things that we needed. I wanted to give the tip to her not our server. She was better than him. I ordered the Veal Rollatini alla Bergamasca, Yuck. Its like an updated and new way of basically making Veal Saltimbocca. It was like a veal croquette and served with mashed potatoes? It should've been with pasta bc their was so much sauce covering it up to hide the ick, the jersey fresh veggies were delicious, but the dish was not worth $24. My mom ordered the Eggplant Arnaud, which was a spin on rollatini, but with sauteed spinach on the outside. It was floured eggplant, which is not her favorite. Everyone makes it different, some people use bread crumbs and some use flour. Its all in a preference. Now hers didn't have much sauce on it at all not even enough to cover it. She wasn't thrilled with it at all and said the cheese didn't seem to be completely melted inside either. Obviously, our server was nowhere to be found. I drink a lot of water and he finally left me a pitcher of it bc trying to find him to get a refill was next to impossible, hence the other waitress (poor girl) was probably tired of helping us and we weren't even her table. So we ordered dessert which of course was the best part of the meal and we left finally. we were there almost 2 hours, which was ridiculous. Will I go back after that disaster meal and service? I would tread lightly on what I order and play it safe. I guess I will stick with Mussels, Ravioli and dessert, Oh well, That's disappointing. One star off for service and one star off for food. read more

Carlucci's Grill - West Windsor - spicy cauliflower...yuck. flavorless heavy over battered - Italian Near Me - Princeton Junction, New Jersey

See all

Just tried Carluccis again after not going for many years. Unfortunately most of the dishes, particularly the pasta, were bland. Service while pleasant was spread way too thin. They need more help and I really don't like when they take my glass away to refill and bring back the same one. Wanted to love it again but it was a struggle. read more

Carlucci's Grill - West Windsor - Italian Near Me - Princeton Junction, New Jersey

It's open during this pandemic- it has outside seating too Ordered the Chicken parmigiana- it was perfectly breads, the sauce and amount of cheese were great. Loved it. My girl had the bolognese pasta which she also loved.. they serve you a huge bread with garlic, and I had to order the cheese sticks. Yummy read more

This is our go to Italian place. Less than 2 miles from our house. We go there very often. Their puffy bread is the best. You can skip the first bread with orange goop on top because they will soon come withe the delicious puffy bread. Entrees and appetizers as expected at a local Italian restaurant done very well at a fair price. I probably average eating there every other week. read more

I have been here numerous times and never had a bad meal. Their dinners are always good, and tasty. Love their bread they give and the rolls. The pizza is also good. The owner is always nice and also the waiters. If you haven't tried this place I would give it a try. read more

If you want to "speed eat" this place may be for you. They rushed us - kept grabbing plates away from us-!even when we weren't done. Not a place if you like a leisurely meal. Not an ideal experience. read more

Carlucci's Grill is a pleasant dining experience in a West Windsor market where there really aren't many options for a sit down place with any sort of ambiance. They have a nice outdoor heated patio which is great when the temperatures dip a little. Meals are generally started off with 2 types of complimentary bread...one topped with tomato (red) sauce and a puffy garlic bread. Neither will knock your socks off, but both have uniquely distinct tastes that are welcome while sipping on drinks and waiting for meals. The garlic puffy bread is very thin and kind of tough to cut. They also have a more traditional garlic bread you can order off the menu which is really good. I've had many meals over the years and the portion size of main courses has been generous, and come with choice of soup or salad. The chicken dishes are generally well prepared..tender chicken and flavorful sauces along with the pasta. There aren't too many vegetarian choices, but the ravioli bellini has been a hit such that it's a regular meal we order. The penne vodka is excellent and in my opinion one of the best preparations amongst Italian restaurants in the area (if vegetarian, you need to ask for it without prosciutto). Pizza is a weak point since every time we've ordered it, the sauce and cheese have been average and unmemorable, with a doughy undercarriage...it would be an improvement if they made a more firm or crispy pizza. Service has been friendly, but can be hit or miss when they get busy. My number one gripe that brings the review down to 3 stars is the multiple price increases they've had over the past few years. I understand the costs have increased recently, but vegetarian dishes have gone up in price from the $14-16 range to $20 and up. Ravioli Bellini is now $22, which is almost a 40% price increase. While I like the food, the prices aren't in line with other Italian restaurants in the area and are at a price point where I really don't consider take out from Carlucci's anymore as it can get very expensive. I guess that's fine if their dine in business is thriving, but I hope the business considers lowering prices. Or if times are tough for the business, they should perhaps institute a temporary pandemic/increased cost surcharge that some other businesses have done rather than increase the prices of basically everything across the menu. I'll definitely be back & recommending Carlucci's to others, but with current prices, it's more of an occasional splurge type place rather than a regular dining option. read more

See all

Atmosphere - 5 Service - 5 Food - 5 I got a coupon in the mail for a $20~ 3 course dinner at Carlucci's but then I realized the restaurant always offers this deal Monday - Wednesday. The interior reminds me of a fancier Olive Garden, and judging from the servers, they seem to treat their diners like family. I was waited on consistently and they always gave me plenty of cheese. The puffy bread was a lot of fun. Very crispy and garlicky. I stuffed some of my spaghetti and veal into it to make a sort of sandwich. The seafood bisque was sweet and rich with oceanic flavors. The veal was very delicate and tender. Fortunately, the appetizer and main course were delicious enough for me to get past the cannoli. I thought the shell was way too hard to eat with a fork and knife and the glaze was very floury and gritty. I would definitely go again if I'm looking to have a good Italian meal. read more

See all

I like Carluccis as a wine maker and a foodie my family and I enjoy the atmosphere and food here. read more

Carlucci's Grill - West Windsor - Italian Near Me - Princeton Junction, New Jersey

Amazing place for dinner! I highly recommend the calamari. I got to try both the regular and the flavored calamari, which I absolutely loved. I also ordered the penne vodka, which was creamy and cheesy. It came in a huge portion that was reasonable for its price. Another huge plus was the service. The waiters were extremely kind and patient, even when our party stayed past closing hours. I would definitely come back again! read more

Carlucci's Grill - West Windsor - Penne Vodka - Italian Near Me - Princeton Junction, New Jersey

We needed a central location for lunch with parents. Nothing to fancy, nothing exotic or "ethnic". Had to be safe Italian (is Italian ethnic?). Carlucci's seemed to fit the bill. Thanks Yelper friends. It was exactly what we were looking for. And...a BYOB! W arrived at 2pm and were seated immediately. The place was pretty empty when we arrived but during our 5 hour stay, yes you read that right, 5 hours, it started to full up. We had appetizers to coffee and everything was very well done and tasty. We all stuck with a variety of pastas, and there is quite a variety. Starter was a specially requested sampler. Good espresso finished it off. The service was also first rate. They never tried to rush us or move us out during our very long stay. F and I are so happy to have found a place that his parents really enjoyed close to their home and our gym. They also have an outdoor patio for nice weather. read more

Carlucci's Grill - West Windsor - Seafood appy. - Italian Near Me - Princeton Junction, New Jersey

Great service and delicious puffy garlic bread! The linguine with seafood, linguine scoglio was excellent.

Always delicious food and great service with a great menu beyond the basic Italian options.

I went to this place in the fall and overall enjoyed it. Very nice ambiance that would be good for a date night or dinner with friends. Got two pizzas, one with mushrooms and one with penne vodka. Both were great, the penne vodka especially was amazing and I'm craving it as I talk about it. We got the rice balls as an appetizer which honestly were just okay, a little bland, but not bad. Nice place and good service, recommend if you're in the area. read more