Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    CarMax

    2.7 (93 reviews)
    Open 10:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Services - CarMax

    Car buyers

    CarMax Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - CarMax

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    A mouse nest in my car
    Erin M.

    I had, without a doubt, the most insane experience with this Carmax. I almost never post negative reviews, but it's been messing up my life since I got my car from them back in Oct. In fact, I'm posting this everywhere bc it's so absurd. So first of all I want to say the person that actually sold the car was cool. His name was Vivek. We're leaving him out of this. Buckle up, this is long. So I got a Kia back in Oct. When I first got it, we all noted a strange smell. We decided to get it re-detailed that night and bring it home the next day. WE LET THEM KNOW ABOUT THE SMELL. So we picked it up and there was a ton of air freshener that they'd bombed it with. But when we got home, we realized the smell persisted. My fiance decided he'd try to figure out where it was coming from. So he went in the trunk, popped off one of the little panels covering the tail light, which was super easy, you dont need tools to do it or anything. And what did he find? MOUSE NESTS. WITH AN ABUNDANCE OF MOUSE PEE AND FECES. (Pictured) I need you to understand that mouse waste can lead to hantavirus, which can KILL YOU. Clearly, we took the car back and let them know what was up. Now, we only had one car at the time, and after 4 days of Carmax still working on our car, because apparently they had to order a whole new trunk, since it was SO SOAKED WITH MOUSE PISS, we asked if we could have a loaner. Enter Mitch. So my fiance calls and asks VERY POLITELY if we could possibly have a loaner car until my car was fixed, since we were spending money on Uber. Mitch was super rude and shut it down. Said no way. So my fiance then called a higher up who said it would be no problem whatsoever and gave us a loaner. So Mitch was...just being an a-hole I guess? It takes a week to get our car back. But then! A couple months later? The AC dies. In hot Virginia. So we take it in. They say it's fixed. No a couple months later, it dies again. We take it in. They say its fixed. Guess what? Its wild, a month later IT DIES AGAIN. So finally we take it to one of their contracted garages. They say that Carmax didnt even check the line for a leak. They work some magic on it and tell us when it dies again to show Carmax the bill. But it was $400 up front. Im disabled and my partner works at a non profit, $400 is a lot. It could've been used for food, or gas, or bills, but no, it has to be stuck in limbo until the AC dies again bc for whatever reason Carmax can't fix the AC. Or find a very obvious mouse nest. Or do anything, apparently. PS we are paying for MaxCare, which covers non routine car services. So we're also wasting more money. We thought MaxCare would take care of issues, but instead its just wasting our time and cash. Don't go here, my entire experience has been so absurd it's laughable. I'm out of money and out of patience because of them.

    Nicole N.

    I was surprised how straightforward it was for me to sell my car here! I first went in for an appraisal and they were pretty quick with the evaluation. Scheduling the appraisal was quick and easy online. When I was ready to sell, I just walked in with my offer and the staff took care of everything for me. They were pretty clear with their instructions and staff were all super friendly and respectful. When you first walk in it might be a little overwhelming cause the facility is big but there is someone at the front desk to orient you. To the right, there is also a small waiting area with some chairs, basic drinks, TV, and bathrooms. While there was a pretty limited selection of drinks I appreciated how clean the area was kept. Only thing is that some of their instructions were a little outdated (ie for me the instructions to inform the DMV etc were not the right contacts).

    I'm sorry that some had a bad experience. As far as me, it was seamless buying a car from CarMax in Richmond. My car was delivered from another CarMax. I was able to track the car entire time. When I got to call to go take for a test drive. After seeing the car I didn't even take for a test drive. The car was absolutely spotless. I purchased a 2017 Volvo S90. You expect some flaws in a 2017 right!? No flaws at ALL. CarMax even put 4 brand new tires. No cheap tires. High performance tires. It was the best car buying experience of my Life! Oh yeah, my state inspection was already done and I had hard tags already on car!

    See all

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    The staff is very pleasant and courteous. Great selection and helpful. I have been coming here for years with no problems.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of CarMax T.

    CarMax T.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - CarMax

    Review Highlights - CarMax

    Laurence and Errick at the West Broad location were very accommodating and made the process very simple.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    tesla

    tesla

    2.4
    (18 reviews)

    This was my first visit to a Tesla dealership. The dealership wasn't the cleanest I've seen, but…read moreoverall, it offered friendly customer service. Perhaps it was a bit messy because it was the end of the day. We arrived for a 6 pm appointment, and it was so busy that the Tesla agent, Trey, couldn't get to us for 30 minutes. He was incredibly helpful! I had heard before visiting that the service is quick, but perhaps because it was the end of the month, it was busier than usual. Once the agent arrived, after approximately a 30-minute wait, the service was quick and smooth! They did exactly what they said, and we left the dealership satisfied with our experience. I hope the service request will be faster and more efficient for our customers. By the way, the auto-buying process is simple because Tesla agents do not make commissions on selling cars, so they are not pushy or annoying.  I wouldn't recommend picking up a vehicle in the evenings, as the agents are usually tired and running out of energy.  Tesla cars are mostly reasonably priced and considered to be of excellent quality. They are the new iPhones of the automobile industry. I hope to return to this Tesla again someday soon!

    Note: I'm not blaming anyone, but buyers should know that seeing a 0.99% APR advertisement or…read morehearing promises from Tesla employees means nothing unless it's actually approved in writing. Don't pay a non-refundable fee based on what you're told. Learn from my mistake. I visited the Tesla dealership in Richmond to compare the Model Y base and Model Y Premium. The salesperson showed me the financing offers on the app and website and repeatedly assured me that with a credit score above 720, I would qualify for 0.99% APR on the Premium model. Based on those assurances and being told rates could increase after June, I paid the non-refundable reservation fee and applied. Tesla's own documents show my credit score is 736, and my income is more than sufficient, yet I was offered nearly 11% APR. After multiple calls and transfers between departments, I was simply told that financing depends on more than just credit score. If that's the case, why wasn't that explained before I was encouraged to pay a non-refundable fee based on repeated promises that I would qualify for 0.99%? Even the Sales Manager in Richmond only said, "I'm sorry if that's what happened, but I've never received a complaint like this from my team." This has been, by far, the worst car-buying experience I've ever had. I expected transparency and honesty, but instead I made a financial commitment based on terms that were repeatedly presented and assured, only to receive something completely different.

    Richmond Ford West

    Richmond Ford West

    2.7
    (78 reviews)

    When I called the dealership, I had already test-driven several other makes, but because we've had…read moregreat experiences with Ford vehicles, I was happy to keep an open mind. I had been searching for a hybrid or PHEV for quite some time and noticed they had one of each listed online, so I scheduled an afternoon test drive. From the moment you arrive, you realize this dealership is extraordinary. They aren't just focused on making a quick sale--they are genuinely committed to building relationships. Daniel greeted us right away and brought us two bottles of water, then escorted me to the vehicle with my name literally written on a large tag displayed in front of the store. That level of thoughtfulness immediately stood out. Daniel walked me through the exterior features and we began the test drive, during which I was able to test multiple functions and features at my own pace. After returning, he gave me a tour of the dealership and shared the many President's Awards they've earned over the years--clearly well deserved. When it came time to talk numbers, they offered me a great deal. I wasn't quite ready to commit, but then Joey, the manager, came over and asked if I wanted to drive the car home. I was already seriously considering purchasing it, but that simple act of trust and kindness sealed the deal. I'm almost 50 and a school teacher. The car is safe, but the respect I was shown in that moment was priceless. This dealership truly wants customers to feel confident and satisfied with their purchase, and they work hard to build lasting relationships. I can absolutely see why they win awards year after year. They have my vote as one of the very best Ford dealerships out there.

    If I could give negative stars I would . Waited almost 3 hours for my Explorers very first service…read moreappointment , no one texted me or spoke to me about why the wait . I went over to the service department and found out my car had never even been started . This was an appointment service , 12 pm . It was almost 4 pm when it was ready and all I was told was they didn't know what happened . I am a repeat customer of Richmond Ford West and Richmond Ford , a 20 plus years customer and this is what I get . I bought my 2023 Bronco at a different Ford Dealer because of this kind of service . I've purchased my last car here and my cars will all be switched to Parrish Ford in Goochland instead .

    Pearson Mazda

    Pearson Mazda

    3.0
    (96 reviews)

    Had a wonderful experience buying from Peter today. He was extremely helpful and communicated with…read moreus throughout the process. We had scheduled an appointment the day prior and took his time showing us around. Buying a car is a long process and he made it very enjoyable with small talk and his presence! Dealership was clean and all the employees were very friendly.

    Review of the Service Department…read more I'll start with the one positive: the pricing for factory-recommended maintenance services was lower than what I've seen at Flow Charlottesville. Unfortunately, that was the only aspect of my experience that stood out favorably. Customers should pay close attention to any additional services recommended beyond the manufacturer's scheduled maintenance intervals. I would strongly encourage anyone visiting this service department to review their vehicle's factory maintenance schedule beforehand and carefully evaluate any suggested add-ons. During my visit, I was presented with approximately $1,000 in additional recommended services and repairs. While some items may have had merit, several appeared significantly overpriced. For example, I was quoted roughly $800 for tires. After doing some comparison shopping, I was able to purchase and install name-brand tires from another reputable local shop for approximately $430. One recommendation that particularly raised concerns was the replacement of a battery tray. I was quoted $187 for the repair and told that the condition could cause the vehicle to fail Virginia state inspection. After researching Virginia inspection requirements, I was unable to find any specific guideline indicating that a loose battery tray alone would automatically result in a failed inspection. While inspection interpretations can vary depending on the circumstances, the explanation provided felt questionable and came across more as a sales tactic than a clear safety concern. My overall impression was that the service department places a strong emphasis on upselling additional repairs and services. As with any dealership service department, I recommend reviewing all recommendations carefully, obtaining a second opinion when appropriate, and comparing prices before authorizing non-routine work.

    Nissan of Richmond

    Nissan of Richmond

    1.4
    (12 reviews)

    I bought a 3025 Murano SL yesterday with about $8,000.00 off Total Price. Great deal. When I was…read morepresented with the purchase order I saw an item TLP for Total Lost Protection that will give you $2,000.00 off a new vehicle from them. I told the finance manager that I did not want it but I was told they could not take it off because they have to make everyone take it and can't remove it. I was very pleased with the price, but I should not have to pay for something I don't want.,I did them a favor buying the car because there is too much inventory for the 2025 Murano. I am thinking of going to make a small claim's court complaint. If anyone has fought this TLP charge successfully let me know. If it was not for this one thing I would have been a 4 or 5 Star customer.

    This place is a joke. after going back and forth for 3 months trying to fix a part on my car they…read morebroke, still not fixed. They lost the part then ordered the wrong part, say it's fixed and only a couple days go by and same thing. Keep getting the run around when I call phone rings and rings till it hangs up. call back , same thing. no one wants to take my call because they know I'm pissed. I'm about to get channel 6 involved. This place needs to be put on notice. most incompetent repair shop I've ever been to. When this problem is resolved and I'm never going back here again. I'll drive 45 min out of my way if I have to. it's been a nightmare ever since I walk out the door with my car just wish I went somewhere else.

    CarMax - usedcardealers - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...