Sandwiches are insanely good! I absolutely love this place. The composition of the sandwiches are made the perfection. Definitely a place to travel to. The pastas are made fresh and the sauce is amazing. They never fail. read more

See all

The garlic bread was nice and crispy, the chicken cutlet was the perfect golden brown and a great complement to the penne vodka. The chicken sausage was a great meal with a delightful light sauce. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Rigatoni / Vodka Fried Chicken Cutlet (side)Garlic Bread w/ Basil Butter and Parmesan - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We stopped into Carmenta's and tried a little bit of everything: vodka pasta, the spicy eggplant parm sandwich on garlic bread, and the rice balls. We overall had such a great experience. They accidentally charged me for a side of garlic bread and made the sandwich incorrectly at first, but the staff was incredibly kind and proactive about fixing it. They remade the sandwich, refunded the extra charge even though I had already paid, and really went out of their way to make it right. I sincerely appreciated that & don't think most places would go that extra mile. The garlic bread deserves its own shoutout...some of the best I've ever had. Perfectly seasoned, crispy, buttery... just amazing. The rice balls were also a star of the table: super flavorful, cheesy, and garlicky. My brother loved the vodka pasta, and while I was a little bummed there's no vegetarian option for it, he said it was delicious. I got the spicy eggplant parm sandwich and really enjoyed it. The flavors were bold and had a nice kick. There were a few bites where the eggplant breading got a bit soggy, but overall it was satisfying and unique. Affordable, flavorful dishes, great people, and a cozy vibe. Despite the small hiccup, I appreciated how attentive they were. I'll definitely be back to try the pesto pasta! read more

See all

Cant wait to come back. The turkey salsa verde sandwich was divine! Had it with a Yerba mate soda. $20 bucks. There were so many other tasty looking things in the menu and the staff were super nice. At the time some 90's hip hop was playing. Im legit excited to return. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - All the tasty stuff in addition to the standards - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I was recommended this restaurant by a family member during my quick trip to NY. Talk about an absolute delicious sandwich and awesome customer service! I would definitely put the chicken parmesan sandwich among the top 10 sandwiches i've ever eaten. The bread was super delicious, crunchy, and perfect for this sandwich. The chicken and the sauce were equally delicious. I highly recommend this spot to anyone in the area. read more

See all

This is a genuinely exciting plate of pasta in a place where the staff make you feel incredibly at home. It has a really chilled out and relaxed atmosphere but the details give you immediate confidence as soon as you walk in. read more

Came on a Sunday around lunchtime and it wasn't busy, so we easily grabbed seating. Meatball parm sandwich was awesome. Will have to come back for the rigatoni! 4.5 stars. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Meatball Parm - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This place is incredible. The homemade pasta, the sandwiches, the eggplant everything is so good. The rigatoni vodka is some of the best pasta I've had in Brooklyn and the Italian combo hero with housemade mozzarella is unreal. You can tell the food is made with real care. Easily my favorite spot in Bushwick. Go here. read more

The eggplant Parmesan hero here is like an Italian torta ahogada - drenched from head to toe in their piquant tomato sauce, and very difficult to eat from a practical standpoint. The breaded eggplant is separated into delicate thin slices adorned with a relatively light layer of stretchy white cheese. Maybe it's because I'm a hater and it's easy to dislike Major Food Group's empire of overhyped restaurants, but I'm going to say that Carmentas' eggplant parm hero is better than the one at Parm. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Authentic shop that we stumbled by and had handwritten menu and daily pasta and sandwich specials. We got a paccheri with guancale, buttered cabbage and white wine, and also a red sauce ragu pasta. Took a bit of time but we could tell everything was made to order from scratch. Personally, I liked the San marzano sauce a bit better due to the acidity of the tomato. The paccheri ended up being a bit heavy and dense to eat due to all the butter. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Paccheri with white wine and guancale - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Went twice with in two weeks and I'll be back again. I got the chicken parm and spicy rigatoni each time. I definitely do wish the rigatoni had more pork, but regardless the food is really good. The freshness, the sauciness, and cheesiness bring these meals together. The guys there are also kind. It's a cute storefront with limited seating so you might have to go enjoy the food somewhere else if it's the packed. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

What a treat and wonderful experience! Food was amazing and staff was kind! Loved that we found this jewel on our short trip to NY! Hoping we can visit it again! read more

See all

Our household is obsessed with the spicy rigatoni and the chicken parm sandwich here. I should probably try something different but it tastes so good it's hard to want to switch it up. And they have awesome customer service. Highly recommend!! read more

Came here for a late lunch/early dinner on a rainy Sunday, and there was only one other table of people. It's a pretty small space, but there's nice seating along a counter so you can people watch while you're eating. You order at the front, and then they bring it to you when your order is ready. We shared a spaghetti dish as well as as a side of marinated artichokes. The spaghetti was absolutely delicious, and the sauce was so good. I wish that I had extra pasta to finish up the sauce with. The artichokes were not bad, but we did both get stomach aches after, so we are pretty sure it might have been the artichoke... I can definitely see myself coming here when I'm craving Italian food if I'm in the area! read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Spaghetti Daviola and Marinated Artichokes - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I came here with a friend on a Sunday night for dinner. We got there around 7pm, and all the tables were full. The inside is like a deli, so there isn't a ton of seating. We decided to get our pasta to-go. By the time our food was ready, some tables had freed up, so we took a seat with our take-out containers. I had the mafalde with beef bolognese. The pasta was incredible; it was homemade, texturally very exciting, and al dente. My friend had the radiatore with kale pesto, which was also very good. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Mafalde with beef bolognese - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I give this place a 4.1/5 it was a good taste but I like my pasta cooked a little more. The sauce was so good and the beef tastes like it's been cooked for hours in a good way and the flavor is very rich with real flavors. The chicken parm was amazing even tho I took it to go and ate it the next day because the portions from my pasta was so large. The service was a little slow in my opinion but that's how it goes when they are focused on making every order right. The place isn't fine dining but more of a convenience place you can pop in eat some amazing food with cool tiled floors and red colors. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Menu - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Order: - Chicken parm sandwich (5/5) - Meatball parm sandwich (4/5) Pros: - Great tasting large sandwiches - You can upgrade your sandwich to garlic bread for an additional $2 - Menu includes pastas and desserts Cons: - Small restaurant with limited seating Overall: A great local spot to grab a hero or some homemade pasta read more

See all

Food is fresh and tastes amazing. The service is excellent. I had the chicken parmigiana hero and it was the best tasting sandwich I've had compared to half a dozen other places I've visited. Went back for a caeser salad and a pasta that they recommended and I was left really satisfied. Had to buy. Jar of thier sauce to try at home which I did and it was the best tasting pasta I've made in a long time. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Caesar Salad, pasta - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

On a Saturday, there was a good amount of people there but not much seating so ordered to go. I ordered their spaghetti fra diavalo with added meatballs and pesto radiatori with added fried chicken. Loved both of the dishes I ordered! read more

Yummy things only at Carmentas. I've been twice for the same Italian special here, it's THAT good. Great bread, great meat, veggies, and perfectly sauced. Unless you have a massive appetite this is a good size to split with another person. I'm so interested in trying the pastas here soon as well. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Absolutely amazing food and excellent staff. Homemade pastas are delicious and the sandwiches were fantastic. Can't wait to go back!

Love this spot the vodka sauce and rigatoni is to die for, the guys who work here are always really friendly and used to be super nice to my dog Arthur when we'd stop by for pick up. The broccolini was also yummy. Same thing with the sandwiches. The meatballs. Really you can't go wrong here. Definitely delicious. read more

Arrived on a Saturday just as it hit 5pm. It was not busy but it was starting to pick up. By the time my food was ready, I was able to score one of the few tables they had. I ordered the pasta with the red sauce, and the pasta pesto. The pasta with the red sauce was perfect- the sauce tasted very fresh. The pasta pesto was just okay. I'm not sure what they use in it, but I don't think there's any basil. The flavor is different than I expected, but topping it with breadcrumbs was a nice touch. I was also hoping to try their vodka sauce, but as it turns out it's not freshly made there? or for some reason they were unable to make it without meat. I suppose this is my one major disappointment. Otherwise, good experience overall and I'd probably return for the red sauce if in the area again. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - pasta pesto - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great and delicious sandwich! Ordered the turkey one and it is probably the best Italian sandwich in all Brooklyn. Will definitely come back. read more

Super slow on orders, even though there was hardly anyone in the shop. The pasta is unremarkable, simple and expensive. What Carmenta's is known for is their subs. We got the spicy eggplant parm sub, but after waiting 20+ mins for it, we were disappointed to receive a soggy, greasy sandwich. Don't think we'll be coming back. read more

Such an unassuming spot but wow the food was AMAZING! The eggplant parm sandwich was spicy and one of the best ones I've ever had as they tend to be super oily or super cheesy - this was anything but. Definitely suggest substituting the normal bread for the garlic bread for $2. The pasta was INSANELY good! I actually couldn't believe how good it was, better than a lot of those really fancy and famous pasta spots. You could tell the pasta was made fresh, it had a new chew to it and the sauce was creamy and topped with crispy bread crumbs. Huge hit! read more

See all

Unbelievably good rustic Italian. This small, unassuming shop has a few tables & no waitstaff. No bells, no whistles... Carmentas instead focuses on fresh pasta (cooked perfectly) fresh sauce & simple yet bold flavors. I went with "Italian Meat & Potatoes" Mafalde with Braised Beef & a rice ball Just a fantastic culinary experience, do yourself the favor, but don't show up in a rush. Really good food takes a few minutes to make. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Mafalde w/ Beef Bolognese & Rice Balls and tomato sauce - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My first visit to Carmentas to try there famous meatball Parmesan hero for the first time. Dominick took my order and I told him I will get back to him with a review. Well here it is, it was absolutely the most delicious meatball Parmesan hero I have ever had. Will be coming back on a regular basis. Thank you very much Dominick and everybody over there at Carmentas! read more

Wonderful neighborhood spot with casual Italian! For under $20, the generous portion of rigatoni was an 8/10, with a flavorful but well-balanced vodka sauce. Could've been a tad bit more spiced, but hard to complain. Pasta tasted fresh and perfectly cooked. You can tell all the food is cooked fresh-to-order because it's a small open-kitchen in the back, and the dish came out piping hot. It's open seating for a pretty small space, so it got a little crowded on a rainy Saturday night. I imagine it'd be even busier if the weather was better. A definite must-visit if you're in the area, otherwise, it's worth making the trip out at least once if you live farther out. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - rigatoni - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Incredibly delicious and inventive flavors. I'm not easy to impress and it truly is 10/10. Tried the tuna and prosciutto cotto sandwiches, both some of the best I've ever had. read more

Ordered delivery from Carmentas on a night on-call and was really impressed! We had: -Chicken parm ($14) -- make sure you know this is a sandwich, not a dish. I was really impressed, the bread they use is a sesame hoagie and was really good, probably best chicken parm sandwich I've had ever -Rigatoni Vodka Sauce ($15) - comparable to Carbone's, but wish there was a little more sauce. Could have been because we had it in a to-go container that it was hard to mix the sauce evenly so would love to try in person to see if it's any different -Caesar Salad ($9) - absolutely delicious anchovy vinaigrette. Note that the bay romaine wasn't cut so it was a bit hard to cut in its paper box container Easy fast delivery, good packaging and order was accurate. A tad more expensive than Forma Pasta Factory but similar tier: good, affordable pasta in Brooklyn. read more

See all

I am a huge fan and repeat customer of Carmentas in Bushwick. Dom and his staff are absolutely amazing. The food is some of the best and most affordable in the entire area. The spicy rigatoni is insane, the meatballs are so fresh and the ambiance in the shop is so lowkey and great for a dinner with a friend or a date. Highly recommend Carmentas, 10/10. read more

See all

Soooo messy... but sooo good. We went here for their vaulted meatball sub. Honestly, meatball subs are not really my thing. I typically like a well-contained sandwich that I can eat without using too many napkins and minimal spillage (it's my Southern manners and sensibilities, I'm sure ;)... But sometimes... sometimes, you just have to get down and dirty. This bad boy was one of the best I've had- but you're gonna go way, way past the two napkin limit with this one. Totally worth it, though. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Very solid food, I don't know if it especially stood out to me but definitely no complaints. I recommend their meatball parm subs-- fresh basil and mozzarella was a really nice touch and meatballs were yummy. Garlic bread was good and the rigatoni vodka was decent. Good portion sizes. read more

Four stars for delicious rigatoni. This is an old school italian shoppe for take out food or a few tables to eat quickly at. The downside is the price and that service isn't very friendly. You are going to have to ask for utensils and Parnassian cheese on your food read more

See all

My girlfriend and I were blown away by how amazing this place is!! The service was friendly, the interior was cozy, and the food was BOMB! The pesto dish created a raving Carmentas fan out of me. The sheer value of the pasta from price to quality is unbeatable. Highly recommend! read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Radiatore w/ Tuscan Kale pesto and the Rigatoni. - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered the penne pasta (with house-made chicken sausage, cherry tomatoes, basil, etc.) for delivery, and it arrived promptly, hot, and amazing! The ingredients tasted wonderfully fresh, a medley of flavors. I ate half immediately and saved the rest to brighten another day; the portion size is great for sharing or for leftovers for one. Can't wait to order again! read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Penne pasta - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Hands down the best meatball parm I have ever had -- and I've had many. Don't question it; just go eat one. read more

Carmentas Italian Specialties - Meatball parm on garlic bread - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The staff was very helpful even upon my 1st visit, not only specifying what everyone always orders but their personal opinions. Now that its gone far past the 1st visit I want to say, the spicy eggplant hero or the chicken is one of the best in town and thus is NYC people so its one hell of a feat. Appreciate the great sandwich! read more

Very wholesome, traditional Italian food. I've tried multiple of their pasta plates - which are always great. Personally, I love the Chicken Parm sandwich - perfect cutlets with red sauce, mozzarella, & basil. The full sandwich is a hefty meal, but if you're hungry you can add a side. The Fried Rice Balls (Arancini) are great, the Tiramisu is also worth trying. The service has always been great, with very friendly staff. Keep in mind they don't have a large dining space - so don't bring large groups. If you're in 3+ order takeout. read more