The food and staff are excellent , already have plans for a repeat Visit. They have a really good happy hour also. read more

Loved our two visits to this hidden gem owned by a fellow Maryland native. The food and staff were excellent.

Not a good experience. Photo shows my pizza - cheese wasn't even melted. Very rude people. Maybe it is a northerner thing, but not one person was hospitable there. We will never go back. read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - I am holding the pizza cheese - not even melted. - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Terrible service! Took 1/2 hour to get salad, took Another 10 min to get silverware, which we had to ask for 1 small piece of chicken for Marsala. Crab cake is deceiving... lump crab on outside and breading on inside! Waitress never came back to see how the food was read more

We arrived only half an hour before they closed, but the staff was welcoming, and we never felt a bit rushed. The crab ball appetizer was outstanding with lump crab meat almost the size of my thumb. The portion sizes were large. Our crab & shrimp macaroni and cheese easily fed the two of us. They have a very good adult beverage selection and don't gouge you for a glass of wine. Although it's in a strip center, don't let the location fool you. Casa Mia offers a casual and comfortable atmosphere that is well worth the visit. read more

Finally Myrtle Beach has a REAL crab cake restaurant!! Food and service were excellent. read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - Crab cake - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

The crab cakes are TO DIE FOR! Best on the planet! Great staff & service, nice clean venue

First time dining at Casa Mia. We had the Maryland crab soup, Lasagna, Fettuccine bolognese, and the spa pasta, Napolitano pizza. Everything was very good, our waitress was attentive and friendly. We will be back read more

The worst business ever! Can't place a phone order! It's 2:300 on a Friday and no one answers the phone!? They just opened, made my decision easy! Will order from a different pizza place. Hell of a way to start a business! Never again! read more

First off, we are from Maryland SO, the crab cakes are LEGIT super delicious. The ambiance is very cozy and "neighborhood-like". Stevie was our waitress and she was very kind and accommodated our requests. We took friends and they loved it. I've had the Liz's before and it's very good. read more

Had heard that this new restaurant had opened near my home and decided to check it out on a Thursday night with a friend. Enjoyed a well-made, lemon drop martini, wonderfully delicious Gorgonzola salad and a pizza with arugula and prosciutto. Our server was very sweet and attentive. Checked back with us often during our dining experience. Portions were large enough that I was able to take home for lunch the next day. I would highly recommend and hope to be visiting them again sometime soon! read more

First time experience went awesome. I would've given five stars, but it was takeout so I can't really judge the service and ambience. We had firecracker shrimp, the double portion of Maryland crab lump cake, grouper bites, and the Greek salad. The crabcake is spot on and lives up to its billing. The condiment portions of remoulade sauce and house dressing were generous . Can't wait to go back in person. read more

I have had their crabcakes, cream of crab soup, the grilled veggies and the Caesar salad . Everything was delicious, truly MD style crabcakes and cream of crab soup. Friends and family have gotten the seafood salad, very large, and the pizza, all said they were very good. Can't wait to go back. read more

The crab cakes were good, we are from Maryland and the crab cakes are the best we have had here. However, I had the lasagna last night and today I am trying to figure out what they possibly could have put into the ricotta for a thick gluey texture. I feel like it is stuck on my chest and not digesting. I think in the future I can make my own crab cakes and pass on this Italian (NOT) menu. The service was good, the majority of patrons were drinking heavily and not eating. read more

We've given this restaurant three tries. Service is terrible. Food was cold 1. The hostess is the worst. She's the first person that you meet at the business. As a local business owner it's her job to greet customers and make them feel welcome and comfortable when they walk in the door. Be engaging and congenial instead of rude and commanding. Each time she has tried to get us to sit at the bar even with reservations. We don't drink. I'd rather have a nice quiet dinner at home than sit at a bar to eat. 2. I can't speak for all the wait staff but several of them still need training. One of them told us her life story. We couldn't get away. 3. All 3 of my dinners were completely cold in the middle. One of them was Spanakopita and the other two were lasagna. One time I can ignore but 3 out of 3 is a strike out! read more

Delicious food, great service, and the inside looks awesome! The crab cake is fantastic! Can't wait to try out more of the menu! read more

See all

The food is amazing. Service and atmosphere were. great! We have eaten here several times and each time it has been wonderful. We are originally from Maryland and have frequented their Maryland location also. Great restaurants! Enjoy! read more

Allison and her staff do a fantastic job! The food is top notch! I would highly recommend!!

Beautiful restaurant/bar! Friendly staff and great service. We went for lunch... We ordered the crab cake sandwich and a pepperoni pizza. My husband said the crab cake was "the best" he's ever had! And I loved the pizza; it was delicious! read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Best crab cakes in state. Loads of fresh crab meat like you would find in MD. Great service too.

Excellent wings! Service was great! Atmosphere was top notch! We stopped in to watch the Ravens game. We felt like we were back home in Maryland. I will have to try the crab soup and cake next time. read more

So happy to have found an authentic crabcake all lump meat crab- delicious. Both soups were awesome will get more for take out frequently. i love my soup and have tried most soups in mb- this is worth the order! The calamari were cooked to perfection tender and tasty. The marinara sauce excellent. Bartender knows how to make a real dri k. we ordered a white pizza also to take home and will for sure recommend their pizza!! Cant wait to go back for other menu items!! read more

I've been to Casa Mia's twice and each time was a great experience. I love the decor, there's a large bar area, several high top tables and then additional booths and tables towards the back. The staff is extremely pleasant and offer their input on the various menu items. The food is wonderful. The first time I had the crab cake appetizer and it was sublime. The second time I shared a pizza with a friend. The pizza is thin crust which is my favorite style of pizza. I will be going back to Casa Mia. There are so many other items on the menu I want to try! Highly recommend. Their prices are comparable with other restaurants in the area. read more

We came here for the first time and we were impressed with the atmosphere and interior design. The waitress was very friendly, comical and knowledgeable. We ordered the lasagna and the Crab balls both were delicious. The sauce wasn't overpowered with garlic and the portion generous. The crab balls were full of actual crab meat and seasoned well. We recommend you try this place. read more

Crab cakes taste just like home from Baltimore and the duck wings were amazing. I enjoyed every minute and i can't wait for my family and friends to enjoy the same experience that I had. Also my mom is 101 yrs old and she loved everything. read more

The food was first rate. We shared the 8 oz crab cake and a Greek pizza, both were delicious. They are less than a month open, so still a few noticeable hiccups and delays, BUT the food was excellent. read more

Visited Casa Mia for the first time today. It was excellent IMO. Casa Mia wins any Md crabcake competition in MB. Their Cream of Crab Soup was also delicious. Service was quick and courteous. I will definitely be going back to try the pizza and other entrees, as well as more crabcakes. Yum! read more

There food is delicious and good service. The cream of crab soup and crab cakes are Excellent

If you want a great experience and great food, this is the place for you. We are familiar with their restaurant in White Marsh, Maryland and had to see if it compares. No disappointment here. Cream of crab soup and crab cakes are fantastic. Jumbo lump crabmeat and no filler. Calamari was excellent as well. Large dinner salad was fresh. Our waitress, Stevie, was great. Hostess Lori was so pleasant and accommodating. Truly a wonderful staff. read more

Worst italian food I've had in the area. Minumal sauce, undercooked fried ravioli, meatballs chewy and tasted like breadcrumbs.

Service is terrible. Will never go back. Waitress was completely inattentive, never brought water for table as asked for. She never brought pepper as requested after she offered. Pizza served was cold. Beer brought was not what was ordered after specifically ordering twice and confirmed. Billed for incorrect beer, so waitress knew it was the wrong beer. Pizza had the wrong toppings. Salads were not correct... ordered 1 Caesar and 1 garden received 2 Caesar. Will not be returning. read more

Worst service ever! Someone recommended this place to my girlfriend, who is from Maryland, for their crab cakes. The food is actually very good, and she did like the crab cakes, however, I'd recommend take out. First, we made a reservation, when we arrived, the hostess told us we could sit at the bar, because it's "first come first serve." I said: "we made a reservation." To which she replied: "let me see if I have a table in the back." She found a table and we were seated. About five minutes later our waitress came by and asked what we'd like to drink. My girlfriend asked for a water with lemon and a cocktail, I said I'd also take a water and a cocktail. After a few minutes, she returned with our cocktails, but no water. She asked if we'd like to put our food order in because they're busy and it may take longer. We ordered the crab dip and said we'd like to look over the menu. I also asked again for some water. About 5-10 minutes later, a young man came over to us with an order of crab balls (after having tried to deliver them to the table next to us), we said: "we ordered the crab dip." Our waitress came over and said: "you ordered the crab balls, here I wrote it down..." and she actually showed us her notes to prove us wrong! We both said "no, we asked for the crab dip," and I again asked for a couple waters (no, they still hadn't brought them. About 5 minutes later, our waitress was delivering food to the table behind us, I turned to her and said: "can we PLEASE get some waters?" A few minutes later, she returned with the crab dip and asked if there was anything she could get us, I said "some silverware and napkins and two waters would be great!" She left and came back with our waters and silverware, 50 minutes after we had sat down at the table!!! When she brought my girlfriend her salad, my girlfriend asked her to just box it up and make our food to go (my girlfriend is a bartender and was totally disgusted at the level of service). The waitress actually asked us: "is something wrong?" I just looked at her. Unbelievable. She spent plenty of time chatting with the table behind us, obviously regulars who know her, and although she said she wanted to know what was wrong, it was pretty obvious she didn't give a damn... read more

we made reservations for Friday night and were seated immediately. our server was very friendly and attentive. we started with bang bang shrimp which was incredible! we got crab cakes for dinner and they were the best we've ever had. we can't wait to go back! read more

Let me start by saying that I grew up in Baltimore and lived very close to the Casa Mia's location in White March, MD, which is more of a pizza and sandwich carry out spot. The MD location was never a hot bed for MD crab cakes. When the Surfside Beach location opened here it immediately garnered rave reviews about their MD crab cakes. We decided to try Casa Mia's for the pizza and Italian specialties. We went about 2 weeks after the resaurant opened. All of the menu prices were higher than other Italian restaurants in the area, but that is okay if the food is exceptional compared to the other restaurants. The pizza was excellent. I decided to try the linguine bolognese, which also was excellent. Possibly the best I have ever had. It was a huge portion with great flavor and loads of ground meat. It was served with a very good Caesar salad, nicely plated. The dressing was drizzled on top of the romaine, with shaved parmesan mixed in the lettuce and also sprinkled on top. The following week my wife and I decided to go out for lunch. She suggested we go back to Casa Mia's. I said fine, but I would have to get the linguine bolognese again. The pizza was just as good as the first time and the bolognese was probably the worst I've ever had. Sauce tasted like it came from a jar, hardly no meat, The caesar salad was a bowl of lettuce with a sliver of cheese and what tasted like vinegarette poured over the lettuce, it was horrible. I brought it to the attention of our server, thinking that maybe a manager might stop by. When our server returned she simply said that the bolognese was made to order, implying that the quality of the dish was dependant on who prepared it. I emailed the restaurant on October 11th and informed them of our 2 visits and never received a reply. Trying to be fair, we decided to give it a third try. Again the pizza was very good. The bolognese was better than the last, but still nowhere near as good as the first time. I have had much better, and cheaper at other Italian restaurants in the area. The first 2 months of operation at Casa Mia's has been all about the crab cakes. Soon the novelty of the $29 crab cakes will wear off and then the rest of the menu will come into play. If it is more expensive and not as good as the other local, established restaurants, Casa Mia's will not survive. I gave it 3 shots, and I will not be back. read more