Casa Mia

My go to spot for pizza and Italian entrees. Great food and service. Just wish they delivered!read more

It's a Frank's pizza basically a chain pizza. It's good not great. The service is good for a pizza…read moreplace. The set up is pretty typical of a pizza place. If you're just looking for a slice of pizza, it's a safe stop not gonna knock your socks off, but they have a good variety and a pretty expensive menu. Enjoy.

Frank's Pizza & Restaurant - This is the franks special salad used to be my favorite, not any more. Looks great but the chicken is so hard you can't taste the meat

This is the franks special salad used to be my favorite, not any more. Looks great but the chicken is so hard you can't taste the meat

See all

Anthony Francos Restaurant and Pizzeria

3.7(137 reviews)

0.7 mi

•$

They are really nice here and treat their customers well. I have catered food here for parties…read moreseveral times and it is always great and i always get compliments from my guest

I really can't believe the rating of this place is anything less than a four. The pizza is…read moreterrific. There is a great variety and the quality is very good. The restaurant layout is well structured for easy pick up delivery and seating. If you prefer the service is always pleasant. This week I ordered pizzas , a Stromboli and a half tray of hot wings. Generally, I feel like trays of wings always end up soggy and not so great. These were perfect. Everyone loved them. well done!

BBQ Ranch Chicken Pizza

The menu prices

See all

Chicken Fingers

Uncle Sal's Pizza II

3.8(25 reviews)

I've lived in the area for a while and always heard good things about this spot, so I finally gave…read moreit a try. Honestly, the pizza didn't really hit the mark for me, but the fries were decent. The staff was really friendly though, which I appreciated

Excellent pizza and dinner entrees. We love their pizza, anything with their vodka sauce and…read moreeggplant rollatini. Whenever we get delivery it arrives hot and made correctly.

Burnt pizza with bubbles all over it that they delivered to my house

Text message the owner himself sent to me after we hung up after I called to tell them they sent me a burnt pizza...

See all

Pizza and fries

Angeloni's on Lake Mohawk

2.7(51 reviews)

I had loved Il Porto in this spot so when I saw a new place opening on Lake Mohawk I had to give it…read morea try! Still a nice cozy interior with gorgeous views (big win if you're there when the water ski team is practicing - great entertainment!). Service was great, polite and timely! The star of the menu is the pizza - the "thinny thin" had a great Barstool Pizza rating and I see why! SUPER thin and crispy pizza with great cheese all the way to the edge. Also had the risotto and penne vodka and while good, the pizza is for sure what you should go for. Will definitely return!

My vision of tonight's (Saturday) dinner with my wife was: outside table to watch the sunset. Had…read morereservations for inside at 7:30pm because they don't take reservations for outside (??). They say if something is available at 7:30 outside you can have the seat. We arrived 30 minutes early to hopefully sit outside. Reality: they sat us inside at a small table next to the wait staff area entrance. I had my back to the lake so I didn't see anything but waiters and waitresses bringing dirty dishes into the kitchen area. We waited 15 minutes before our waiter came to our table. We ordered Cesar salad for 2 and a large thinny thin (half plain, half pepperoni). We never received bread and butter while all other tables did. I tried to ask our waiter or any but they wouldn't make eye contact (all busy). Our waiter nowhere to be seen. We received the pizza. We did not receive the salad. When our waiter finally showed up again, we told him to cancel the Cesar salad. Which they did. He was apologetic but the dinner was ruined. Crappy experience. Angeloni's service in Caldwell was much better. Pizza was great though. 0 stars for service, ambiance, salad and bread&butter. 5 stars for the pizza.

Meat lovers thinny thin

See all

The outside seating

Pizza One

3.5(80 reviews)

My wife and I stopped here at about 7:30 on a Thursday evening. We were both fairly hungry and had…read morenever tried this place so... boom,. We were seated quickly and Anthony, our server, stopped by right away with menus, a bottle of water and glasses, and a tray of bread, olive oil, olives, and cheese. We hoovered up everything that he'd brought to us- the bread was fantastic. I mean- wow.... seriously good bread! We both ordered a pasta dish, I got linguine with bolognese sauce, my wife ordered a seafood penne dish. She had originally opted for the lobster mac and cheese- but they were sold out... :-( Being from Queens and transplanted to NJ as a kid, I'm very pasta savvy. The linguine was perfectly cooked- just a little bite. The Bolognese sauce was also on-point. So many NJ pizzerias think that mashing up a meatball and adding it to a ladle of sauce is ok.... This was the real deal. Both plates had huge portions, as well. We were both slightly disappointed- no bread, no spoon, no cheese. Anthony made his way back to the table and rectified those issues. More of that fabulous bread, ha ha! Look- I can absolutely say that i'll be back. Food was good... Place was nice...

Pizza One was an INCREDIBLE visit. The restaurant is nicely decorated, there are options to either…read moreplace an order for take-out or enjoy a meal in their indoor/ seating areas. The ambiance was very relaxed and the service was quick and helpful. Our order were specialty slices of chicken/shredded spinach/cheese/balsamic glaze and a Chicken Francaise slice. Both slices were DELICIOUS, at the perfect temperature, and the slices were large. The chicken slice had a crunchy underside and I haven't had too many pizza slices this good. If you're in the Sparta area, do not hesitate to enjoy a meal at Pizza One. If that's too out of the way, there are other locations in Wayne, NJ, and in Scarsdale, NY.

Indoor seating.

Good bread & dips

See all

Villa Capri II

2.5(38 reviews)

1.1 mi

•$

Food is usually cold and unappetizing. Their fries are particularly bad and always ice cold and…read morestale. Chicken tenders are usually insanely small and they don't make up for it by giving extra.

I got penne pasta with pesto and chicken and my chicken was undercooked. My bfs chicken alfredo was…read morewatery.

See all

Burnt

Krogh's Restaurant & Brew Pub

4.0(400 reviews)

0.0 mi

We stopped for coffee earlier in the day and had a craving for wings and beer. Since we were in…read moreSparta, we stopped in to Krogh's. Our server Day gave me 3 different beers to try before I settled on their Three Sisters Golden Ale while hubby opted for Sullivan's Irish Stout. We ordered the traditional wings and split a delicious brisket burger with American cheese and fries. All the classics with the brews. The bar was full of happy people and the vibes were joyous. They have a great menu, be sure to stop in and grab some food and awesome cocktails. When the weather is nice, you can sit outside or on the rooftop bar. The town is super cute!

Nice exterior and interior, some booths have wood carvings…read more Sat immediately and waiter came over quick. Ordered pretzel appetizer, but had to remind waiter after 20 min of waiting. Seems was mixup and app came out with lunch. In fairness manager came over and comped the appetizer due to their mistake. Fish and chips were ok. Spicy rigatoni with home made sausage, we were told spice level of sausage varies since home made.... however...the whole dish was too spicy for us, blew out our palette on each bites finish, could not even dent the meal. However, if you do like alot of heat this may be your dish!

Wood style seating

See all

Exterior - a historic building

Sparta Classic Diner

3.1(341 reviews)

0.2 mi

It had been quite a few years since I'd been to this diner in Sparta. Since then, I believe there…read morewas a fire and it was rebuilt. Well it's much nicer now than it was back then. Modern inside but still has that classic Jersey diner feel to it. I ordered the traditional breakfast of 2 eggs over easy with bacon, hash browns, and toast. Plenty of bacon and the hash browns had a nice crisp to them. Multi grain toast was a nice option. Good place to stop if you're around Sparta. Large menu, good food!

Went here for breakfast and food did not disappoint. We ordered the Florentine omelet with…read moremushrooms and the Texas breakfast bowl. Portions were huge so we both left with leftovers. Atmosphere was nice with retro style booths and bar stools. Waitress was pleasant and attentive. Will definitely be back to try their lunch/dinner menu

Booth seats

See all

Tj's Pizzeria Cafe

2.4(15 reviews)

•$$$$

Another strip mall pizza joint, the Sparta branch of this very local chain is a big aesthetic…read moreimprovement over Sparta Pizza who used to be in here. There are a few tables and there are slice pies, but this is mainly a take out and delivery place. Orders are taken and kept accurately. I've gotten delivery from here more than once, and they always make it on time. The best thing TJ's has going for it is their combo deal: Large cheese pie, a dozen wings (more on those), garlic "bread sticks", and a 2L soda for $19. It's a good deal. For me, the pizza's a little doughy, but I like their sauce. Very tomato-y and a little sweet. They bread their wings, and I'm not a fan of that. But their sauces are tasty. Their garlic bread sticks are deep fried little strips of dough. Not really bread sticks, and they're decent when they're hot, but don't expect much from them.

While on vacation in New Jersey I stopped at TJs for some pizza and was appalled at what I just…read moresaw. I watched the owner verbally abuse his young female employees.. Even calling one of them "bitch". Completely unacceptable on so many levels. Never again will I come here.

La Vita Italian Specialties

4.5(33 reviews)

0.3 mi

My dad frequents this place. We enjoy the friendly service, fresh bread, eggplant heros, and…read moremozzarella. The sandwich has generous fillings! They have items such as Lady Fingers and other Italian goodies. The place is cute and cozy although we choose to take our goodies to go. It's a great please to have in the neighborhood.

I don't know a single Italian person who makes their cutlets with panko. It's honestly an…read moreabomination and I don't know what they were thinking with this, but I sincerely hope they reconsider. You can't call yourself an Italian deli and use panko, period, end of story.

Counter

Rosemary & Sea Salt Focaccia

See all

Broccoli Rabe

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Ray A.

391

2 years ago

BEING FROM NEW JERSEY, THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA I'VE EVER EVER HAD IN MY FUCKING ENTIRE LIFE!! Do not sleep on this place!! How dare you give this place a bad review you will never ever find a place that has better pizza in the fuckin world, Italy, NY, anywhere. I am not kidding. I wish I lived closer to this place!!! read more

Karen S.

10 years ago

I ordered food for my dad's birthday. And the food was great! The delivery was free. And the driver was very pleasant and helpful. I highly recommend Casa Mia for your next Party. I will be using them for all my parties. Thankyou Casa Mia!! Look forward to doing business with you again! read more

Kirsten C.

14 years ago

I don't even like pizza that much, but their fresh baked bread is SO DAMN GOOD!!! I keep coming back and eating it, and gaining weight; but can't stop eating that fresh warm crispy bread... I hate you Casa Mia, but I love you... Now serve me some more bread please! :) read more

Jessica S.

130

12 years ago

Generally the food is fabulous. Specials are the best. Always cooked great. They will accommodate special requests. And special diets or allergies. Once service was so slow read more

Dennis S.

7 years ago

Always great pizza and a good selection of other meals! I've never had a bad meal and we eat there a lot and do take out!!

Thomas M.

9 years ago

I atmosphere is great, excellent service, Food is even better, courteous staff what more could you ask for, we loved it.

Amir C.

8 years ago

Everyone there is incredibly nice, everything is fair priced, and they do NOT skimp on how much food they give you

Jonathan S.

16 years ago

Fantastic pizza. You must try their "margarita" pizza!

John U.

14 years ago

Good prices ok service so so food

Casa Mia - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Casa Mia also viewed

Anthony Francos Restaurant and Pizzeria

3.7

(137 reviews)

•$

They are really nice here and treat their customers well. I have catered food here for parties…read moreseveral times and it is always great and i always get compliments from my guest

Frank's Pizza & Restaurant

3.3

(53 reviews)

My go to spot for pizza and Italian entrees. Great food and service. Just wish they delivered!read more

Dominick's Pizzeria

3.5

(133 reviews)

First, I would like to say thank you to Facebook for posting an article that voted Dominick's for…read morethe best pizza in New Jersey. They were not wrong. They've had me since the first bite and I love going back again and again. It's very hard finding good pizza these days; but Dominick's nailed it! Chefs kiss

Great food and fine ambience! Enjoy the tasty choices &…read moreappreciate the recommendation to have a gathering at Dominick's!

Uncle Sal's Pizza II

(25 reviews)

Excellent pizza and dinner entrees. We love their pizza, anything with their vodka sauce and…read moreeggplant rollatini. Whenever we get delivery it arrives hot and made correctly.

Little Nicki's

(160 reviews)

It's a family style restaurant with some great food, casual atmosphere and some very friendly and…read moreattentive staff! They treat you like family! We've never been disappointed with a meal!!

After spending the morning enjoying some water sports, my family and I (a party of 7) stopped by…read moreLittle Nicki's for lunch--and it was absolutely fantastic from start to finish. The service was truly top-notch. The staff was friendly, attentive, and went out of their way to make sure we were well taken care of. It's not easy accommodating a large group, but they handled it with warmth and ease. We ordered a variety of dishes, and everything was delicious: Two fresh, crisp salads Perfectly fried calamari Flavor-packed arancini balls Comforting and indulgent buffalo chicken mac and cheese A grandma pie with vodka sauce (a must-try!) Decadent desserts: classic cannoli and cannoli cheesecake Refreshing drinks including a homemade lemonade (so good!), iced coffee, cappuccino, and a macchiato. The portions were extremely generous--we left with plenty of leftovers--and the prices were surprisingly reasonable for the amount and quality of food we received. I wish I took more photos of the food before it was eaten. I only wish we lived closer so we could return more often. This place is a hidden gem, and I would highly recommend Little Nicki's to anyone looking for amazing Italian food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere.

Paesano Pizzeria

3.2

(93 reviews)

Great experience overall!…read more I first noticed the lack of foot traffic, however despite the amount of people, the experience overall wasn't bad at all. The chef was welcoming, unsure if the restaurant is short staffed or not, however all the staff members were very polite. As for the ambience & interior, it's a classic Italian restaurant. Nothing too special about it, a little outdated but nice overall. The tables were clean, and it's quite spacious. It's kept organized & clean and that's all that matters to me. The food did take a while, yet it was PHENOMENAL. Hot, fresh pizza with just the right amount of sauce that truly compliments the cheese with just the right texture, and a dough that doesn't taste like pure cardboard. Overall, I'd definitely return! Great prices, great food, great experience.

Friendly staff... Food was made to order but just ok. There's plenty of seating inside for a…read moretypical pizzeria.

Carlos Cucina Italiana & Pizzeria

(9 reviews)

Ordered lunch the other day, a personal pizza and appetizer combo for two for takeout. The pizza…read moreitself was hot when I picked it up, but the crust was a bit dry. The appetizer for two included fried mozzarella sticks, mushrooms, zucchini, and chicken tenders. Overall the fried vegetables and chicken were pretty oily, especially the zucchini which were basically oil filled pockets. However, the dish was filling and the oily-ness not unexpected considering the appetizer is fried. The mozzarella sticks had a different type of coating on it which made it more bland and oily than the rest of the appetizer, unfortunately. The pickup experience was quick and easy. Overall, I would order again due to the restaurant's convenience, but I'm not sure I'd go out of my way.

Always a pleasure to stop into Carlos Cucuna, today just a quick slice and meatball parm for lunch…read more The best employees, always so friendly and hard working. The dining area is always spotless and clean. Confidently located in the Shop Rite mall in Byram,NJ

Arturo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

(45 reviews)

Food excellent, Service terrific…read more True old time pizza place. My husband and I will definitely go back very soon.

Stopped in for lunch the other day and it was great, good food, nice staff and a great drink…read moreselection. If you want pizza in the area stay away from pizza one and come here

Three brothers pizza and italian restaurant

3.7

(15 reviews)

I had a few slices of pizza from here once again. However, they did forget pepperoni on one of the…read morepizzas that was ordered. I had a few cheese slices as well as a sausage slice this time around. The cheese slice was very similar to my last time eating this (see previous review for similar thoughts). One trait I did notice was there was not lots of tomato sauce present or the cheese overpowered it because of the amount. The sausage slice was solid. There were a good amount of sausage rounds present, and they did not overpower the overall taste of the pizza.

The service was excellent--they truly went above and beyond! The pizza was delicious, featuring…read morehigh-quality cheese and a perfectly crisp crust, love that the sauce was not heavy. The absolute highlight for me, however, was the pesto pasta. Hats off to the chef!

Dominick's Pizza

3.7

(24 reviews)