We've been to Casa a few times over the past year and have also ordered takeout, but this visit was a little off. When we first arrived, we were greeted by a gum-chewing hostess and seated right away, which was fine. It took a few minutes for our waiter, Juan, to come over and take our order. We didn't order any appetizers, so our salads came out quickly. After that, we waited...and waited...and waited. The delay was long enough that the manager came over to ask how everything was and whether we were interested in dessert. I had to tell him that we hadn't even received our meals yet. When the food finally arrived, everyone else enjoyed their dishes--veal parm, chicken franchise, and a few others. I ordered the special, described as a porterhouse pork chop with potatoes, vegetables, and a mushroom cream sauce. Thankfully, I asked for the sauce on the side, because it was very sweet--even the waiter mentioned that. The pork chop itself was cooked the way I like it, but it was not a porterhouse cut. A true porterhouse pork chop should be bone-in with both the tenderloin and loin sections. What I received was more like a pork loin cut, and while it was listed as 16 oz, it didn't appear to be anywhere near that size. Moving forward, we'll likely take a break from Casa read more

Went there recently with a friend. We got the chicken parm & red/white pizza. Both were very good! The gentleman who was there singing was quite entertaining. He walked around & got the crowd involved. The place is a bit small and costs a little more than other restaurants in the area. read more

The service was a bit slow as it looked like they only had 1 server so she didn't come over for about 15 minutes after we were seated which was fine since I couldn't find a menu online to check ahead of time. They had a pineapple burrata appetizer special which was something I haven't seen before so that immediately caught my attention. It was a decent size and ate like a salad for my husband and I to share. We got the bubble bread for an appetizer too since we've never had it before. For my entree, I decided on the Chicken Frangelica which gave a sweet and savory flavor. My husband had the butter fish which was tasty. Give them a try if you're in the area. The decor inside was nice and they have an outdoor seating area. read more

See all

Ordered a cheesesteak. The sandwich was tasteless. Meat was tough, it was obvious that it was cheap meat. Dry,dry. Cooked to death. The cheese was not the tasty Cooper sharp other shops use. Based on the meat it was probably a cheap processed cheese. Expensive too for the quality and taste I ended up throwing half away. If their dinner entrees are like the sandwich I won't be eating there. read more

Cosa Nostra delivers again as usual The variety on this menu is unreal, from the appetizers (langoustine, calamari in saffron broth, burrata and prosciutto) to the entrees (steak and pasta dishes, I got the gnocchi with pork ragu) to the desert. This place is hands down best in the area. Portions are great size, prices are very fair and staff is friendly and hands on. Also a BYOB which is bonus If you haven't been here yet then you need to get moving read more

See all

Food is okay Service is rushed cold atmosphere never feel welcome, even with previous owners.

Holy crap - my bestie lives minutes from here. Since we are watching ourselves, we only ordered salads, but oh what salads they were!!! I had an incredible Caesar salad with added (succulent) shrimp and avocado. Homemade dressing and fresh croutons. My girl had an avocado salad that she adored as well! We were drooling over other Yelpers photos and are definitely going again but in the daytime when we can truly indulge (pasta dishes and bread!) CAN'T WAIT !!! read more

Casa Nostra - Excellent Caesar!!! - Pizza Near Me - Marlton, New Jersey

Our favorite Italian restaurant in the Marlton area. Whether it's pizza to go, or dining in, it can't be beat. Delicious food and the friendliest staff. Some of the best pizza I've ever had; I'd say a 9.3 on the Portnoy Scale. The crust is amazing; airy yet crisp, almost like a focaccia meets a pizza dough. The pizza sauce is phenomenal, the freshest and tastiest I've ever had. As for dine-in fare, I'd have to recommend their calamari for appetizers; fresh and crisp, served with their tasty marinara and a sweet pepper relish (if you're afraid to order calamari at restaurants because you're afraid it's pre-packaged generic frozen kind, worry not, this is the REAL DEAL!) I'd also recommend their crab soup, it's absolutely delicious, you will not be disappointed. And last but not least, for an entree it has to be the aracino pasta dish; ravioli in a brandy cream sauce with crab meat. I get it every time, it's just lick your plate delicious. read more

Went with another couple and all four meals were enjoyed by all. I had the black cod and it was perfectly cooked and the taste was amazing My buddy got the rigatoni. He said it was amazing as well. Service was what it should have been. Ambiance nice lighting was just right. We will be back soon read more

Was in there last week and ordered a pizza to go. Specifically told them extra cheese and light sauce. Got it home and it was completely opposite, heavy sauce , hardly any cheese. It seems thay have a hard time listening or maybe they just don't understand english. This has happened before but tried to give them another chance. We went there because they were close and the weaher was bad, read more

Great food, cool atmosphere, good value. Recommend getting a reservation Yummy Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm Mmmmmmmmm read more

We have been here many times and our women's club also uses them to cater our off-site affairs. Everything here is delicious and generous in portions. Their bruschetta salad is ones if my favs with chicken and fresh mozzarella. Their pizza is also very good...also chicken Franchase and vodka pasta. I could go down the menu and say the same about everything.nice ambiance and plenty of parking. Service is exceptional. A little pricier than some other Italian restaurants around, but it's a BYOB so that helps. read more

Went there for NYE dinner. Food was ok but way over priced due to taking advantage of the holiday. Also very loud and not so good singer all night. Could not hold a conversation at our table due to the volume and being interrupted by the singer. read more

It was surprisingly easy to get a table on a Saturday night, but they seemed quite busy. The food on the menu looked great as did the decor of the restaurant. Unfortunately, that's where the good ended. We waited about 20 to 25 minutes after being seated by the host but no luck getting any service from the wait staff. Obviously, that is way too long of a wait, and it's only worse with two young children. The restaurant was filling up, so we got up and told the host we were giving up our table and we left. If we go back and are able to get service, I will certainly update the review. read more

Very good Italian restaurant and pizzaria. Great selection of appetizers, sandwiches, pizzas, pastas. There is something for everyone. The red and white pie is delicious. Great wings. The lasagna is delicious. Fast friendly service when eating there. Indoor and outdoor seating. Delivery is also usually fast. read more

See all

We had dinner there 11 guys on our trimonthly get together Good and service excellent Homemade Cavatelli and shrimp dish was a great surprise to my plate. App where way above par (try old school meatballs yum yum) not one of our 11 gentleman had a negative cooment and that is a big win seeing the youngest guy is50! Will do it again The Gym read more

We dined here based on a recommendation on a good lBYOB in the area. Walking in, I immediately liked it. The places was packed. Server was super friendly and acknowledged us immediately. Food presentation not only looked good, it was delicious. Intend on returning again soon! read more

We like their food, but I ordered online and they automatically added a 20% tip to my order. I wanted to tip cash and had originally made the correction but needed to change something on the order. When I went back to make the change, the site automatically processed the 20% tip and I didn't know until completed the order and saw the updated cost. Tips should not be automatically added, and their lower rate was 17, but that wasn't the default. read more

A great place for a great meal. The food is outstanding and the service is great. From the delicious brick oven pizza to the wonderful homemade Italian dinners, everything was sensational. read more

Food was very good but the manager or owner, not sure which, was extremely rude and unprofessional

We order take out from here all the time as it's close to home- but we finally sat and had dinner with 7 friends Sunday night and I have to say all of us loved our dinners! It's a great little place in a strip mall! They do have outdoor seating also which we didn't do , nothing fancy but the inside is nice and I understand they have a singer on Wednesday nights-so will check that out! The pizza there is also terrific- we ordered from There again last night and have highly recommend the Red and White pizza! We had a great waiter named Juan Sunday night who had two big tables but we never lacked for anything- no bar BYOB- do check it out! read more

Good Italian food in a pleasant environment. Plenty of parking. Clean restrooms. Service was slow from start to finish. It took too long to take our order. The last meal for our party arrived a full ten minutes after the first. We had to ask the bus boy to clear the table and waited another 15 minutes for a check. As far as I could tell there was one waiter for the entire restaurant. They had a solo singer. While I understand the desire to attract people on slow weeknights, a restaurant is not a cocktail lounge. People go to eat, not to listen to music loud enough to impede their conversation. It was made worse when the singer strolled the room, like a bad mariachi band, and reached its nadir with Sweet Caroline. A restaurant is not the 7th inning stretch at Fenway. Lose the singer. Gains some waiters. read more

This classic neighborhood restaurant is a true gem. Absolutely delicious food prepared perfectly. They accomodate all requests and have great flavoring, and beautiful presentation of dinners. I really love that it is 10 minutes from home. Every bit or better than Collingswood faves and much closer to home.Will be celebrating my husbands 70th there next week! Great selection of Italian faves, including Southern & Northern specialties. Veal is cooked perfectly, thin and tender. Chicken is tender and very tasty. Pasta is cooked al dente.Reservations recommended for evenings but not mandated. We especially love the musical presentations with our fav opera singer! read more

4 of us had dinner here on a recent Saturday evening. Though they had a full house, we never felt rushed and the service was impeccable. Appetizers, main courses, and desserts were amazing. This was a great find. read more

First time trying this restaurant based on a friend's recommendation. We were not disappointed. Four of us went and all ordered different entrées. All of us thought it was delicious. Our waiter's knowledge of the menu was very impressive and the service was impeccable. We'll definitely be back. read more

Excellent food and very friendly service. It has become a "regular " for us. I would encourage anyone who lives in the Medford and Evesham area to try this restaurant. read more

Not advertised and not cool that 4% is added to your total for paying by credit card. Prolly a sun big enough to mKe me choose one of the endless other options to get fee-free pizza. Pizza here is decent but would be better if they use a better quality cheese. Not a very friendly guy behind the counter. Kinda mean actually. Ambiance is what you'd expect. read more

Amazing Food and Service! So happy to have found this place. Everything from the thin crust pizza to the jumbo shrimp Parmesan & Caesar salad. We have been frequenting this restaurant and we find that everything that we try is just as good as the previous time. read more

Tried two different specials. The chicken Jerusalem and veal special. The veal was outstanding the mozzarella on top amazing. The chicken with the tortellini amazing. We will be back! read more

Casa Nostra - Veal special so good and so much! Flavor abounds! - Pizza Near Me - Marlton, New Jersey

Pizza tasted okay but $19 for a 11.5 inch pizza is rediculous. It was supposed to be a large pizza but ive neve seen a large pizza this small before. 6 small slices was all we had. My son ate 1/3 of the pizza before I could stop him on the ride home. I will never go there again. There are so many other places in the area that are so much better and cheaper. At least those places you can make a meal for 3 people from a medium or large pizza. read more

Casa Nostra - Large Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marlton, New Jersey

Review is not on the food--it is on the takeout service. Counter person was most unfriendly, and quite frankly, rude! I felt like I was bothering him to place the order. In the meantime, someone walked in to pick up his order and obviously they knew each other. The problem...they chatted for approximately 8 minutes, and early on in their conversation, my order was placed on the counter. I was handed my order ONCE THEIR CONVERSATION ENDED. My first and last time ordering from Casa Nostra! read more

I always got a good dinner, Sub, cheesesteak and I think it has that best tasting pizza in Burlington county the crust and the sauce and the cheese all come together in a memorable pizza. I think the secret is in the sauce. Another thing that gives us a high rating is the people making the food have an Italian accent and you can't get it any better than that... Arrivederci read more

We had a delicious dinner there! The service was wonderful and the ambiance was very nice. We will definitely go back.

Hidden Jem. In a small offbeat shopping strip with not many stores . Great food and service. Best chicken parm I've had in a while. Definitely will be back read more

The place is adorable and the food is ok! The but when it comes to cleanliness in the kitchen that is a huge problem! There is black mold on dust on the ceilings with fans blowing at high speed! No one in the kitchen Preparing the food wears gloves! Meat and fish are not kept at proper temperatures. It is absolutely insane to have walked through this kitchen To have seen the "owner" sweating and smoking a cigarette while preparing food ! I was there interviewing for a position and I walked out! There was no possible way I could be part of this horrible mess. read more

Went on a friends recommendation, and we were delighted. It's such a pretty and warm place to sit back and enjoy a meal. The food was incredible. Everything was done to perfection, and they had many choices. We left, taking home enough food for another meal - really generous portions! The service was superb, and they truly knew how to make us comfortable and special. Can't wait to go back, which will be very soon! read more

Hands down the BEST pizza I have ever had. I order from here frequently for this godsent pizza. I'ts just different from other places ya' know? The dough under the sauce has a nice soft crunch to it and the crust at the end is the same way minus the sauce. If you live around the area and have tried UpperCrust Pizza, then I would give this place a go. I find that it's similar but more perfected. A large plain pie will cost you about $14 and change, plus a tip if you go that route. I would say its adequate size but don't expect that large to feed any more than say 3 people who each eat roughly 2 slices. Worth a try, i've been trying to convert all my friends to this place with success. read more

Always delicious! Service is friendly. I've tried several dishes and can't wait to sample more.

I have ordered from there and it was good , today I ordered 2 pizzas edges burnt and no signs of cheese lots of watery sauce . Did they change owners? read more

My oh my what a pie! The crust, cheese, and sauce are perfect. This is hands down, the best pizza in Marlton and might be the best pizza in south jersey. I'm so lucky this place is around the corner from me and will easily be my go to pizza place from now on. read more

Casa Nostra - Large plain pie - Pizza Near Me - Marlton, New Jersey