Wells Brothers Pizza has been a Racine institution, and after eight years of living here, I finally…read moreunderstand what all the fuss is about. Shame on me for waiting so long! From the moment our food arrived, it was clear this place is special. The homemade soup was an absolute delight, rich and comforting. But the star of the show was the pizza. The crust is paper thin and perfectly crispy, sturdy enough to stand on its own while somehow enhancing every topping in a way I've genuinely never experienced before. It's a masterclass in simplicity done right. We paired it with a wonderful glass of wine that rounded out the meal beautifully. And the service? Phenomenal. Nakiya took great care of us and made the whole experience even better. Eight years without Wells Brothers was eight years too many. We will absolutely be back -- and often. If you haven't been yet, don't make the same mistake I did!

Awesome visit here for a Wednesday night. Wasn't too busy at 5:30pm but definitely picked up a bit…read moreafter that. They have a guard outside to keep tabs on the lot and maintain security, which was kind of nice. Plenty of parking. The staff were friendly and quick to help with our orders but also gave us time to consider. We opted for the Wed special (large pizza w/ 2 toppings for $16.50) and another large pizza with extra toppings on half and half. They've got great prices for wine and beer and it's easy to feel relaxed in here with the ambiance and vibe. The smell of the pizza was amazing, too! Tasted even better! The crackers thin crust was delicious and you could easily eat a few slices. Will definitely come back. It's great here!

Great food and service! Adding needed characters!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'nnnnnnnnnread more

Unfortunately, we had a very disappointing experience. Our initial server Mary appeared impaired…read moreand was difficult to communicate with, and we waited an extended amount of time for our drinks and did not receive them until another server came around to our table. When our food arrived, all of the burgers were incorrect. We sent one back because my boyfriend has a cheese allergy, and it took about 15 minutes to receive the replacement. The replacement also came with toppings we did not request. Overall, the service from Mary was inattentive and awful given every time she came to our table she forgot she was our server. Unfortunately, we would not recommend this restaurant.

I don't understand the hype. I've tried this place a few times and I continue to be disappointed…read more My husband ordered a salad with his entree and the lettuce came out black/brown and wilted. He sent it right back. The waitress never apologized. She never bussed our table throughout the dinner- we actually just started stacking our plates on an empty booth behind us to make room. The pizza sauce is too sweet, and I'm not a fan of the cracker crumb crust. Prices are pretty high ($3.50 for a soda???). And there's quite a smell when you walk in that I can't figure out what it is.

Kind of an old school grandmas kitchen vibe to the restaurant... food was pretty standard, if I'm…read morein the area and I want to sit down for some pizza I'd probably stop in again but nothing crazy to report here. I will say the sauce was a little bland but threw some salt on top of the pizza and Parmesan cheese and it filled the gap for sure. Cheese curds were really good and the basket size was huge! Do not attempt solo LOL. Staff was super friendly (seems to be a Wisconsin thing everyone here is really nice, all the time) also restaurant was very clean.

We were welcomed immediately. The place was decorated with cute 4th festivities. We ordered a dirty…read moreShirley and a Captain and Coke. The waitresses, Avril and Becca, were very friendly and good at their jobs. The food came out hot and delicious. Three of us ordered: fried mushrooms, onion rings, a side salad, a cheeseburger, and these delicious pretzels.

Holy delicious. One of the best meals I've had in all of my days. If you find yourself coming…read moreacross the depot on a Tuesday, you must stop and try the chicken pot pie. Only available in the winter time.

Always great pizza. Love them. Best in Caledonia I think. Great delivery too. Also fabulous ice…read morecream concoctions!

Ordered through UberEats and made the silly assumption that a Roast Beef Dinner at a restaurant…read morethat has "Steakhouse" in the name would be cuts of a roast. Nope, it was the same beef that goes in a sandwich, curly thin slices only in gravy sauce, served with mashed potatoes that had no flavor and would drip off the fork. I couldn't believe that anyone would even consider calling that a Roast Beef Dinner.

Great food, great service ! Highly recommend this place to…read moreanyone looking for a solid Italian restaurant.

Our service was good. The atmosphere was good. We tried the deep fried ravioli and they certainly…read morewere frozen not made from scratch. Just luke warm on the inside. Was not impressed. Pizza was alright. We have had better. 16 inch cheese pizza was $19.50 and the toppings cost us $17.50 which was way, way overly priced! Will not go back.1 16 inch Pizza and toppings , 2 Pepsi's and an appetizer with 20% tip was $73.00! Pizza does not come close to our favorites. Mike and Angelo,'s and Infusino's. Can't say we didn't try it.

Good pizza, always hot, fresh, and delicious! .read more

We live on the far west side of Racine in Mt. Pleasant so this is our most frequent go to for Pizza…read moreand lasagna. Their chicken is very good too. Yes, we like Wells Bros. too but carry out from there is cold by the time we get home. For warm satisfying family pizza gatherings, it is close and excellent.

So sad to see that they have retired and permanently closed this location. I wish I had given them…read morea 5 star review sooner. I live in Racine, and I have enjoyed their pizza since we moved here in 2019. Like many Southeastern Wisconsiners,I am an Illinois transplant, the land where the best pizza was born, so it's often hard to find comparable or even acceptable pizza elsewhere. Needless to say, I am very sad that DeRango's Pizza Palace will no longer be a contender for Friday night pizza night :'( I wish them well in their retirement years!

The BEST Lasagna is RACINE! Yes, I tried all the locations around Racine and I still can't find…read moreanything better than this! There pizza is good, but the Lasagna is the best with Garlic Bread + Bread and butter! Always keep coming back, great job at filling it up and keeping the taste the same goodness!

Worst sub I ever had. I told him a little mayonnaise and a little French dressing and what I got…read morewas a mayonnaise in French dressing sandwich one of the worst sub sandwich I have ever had and I remember back in the day Jerry had the best and the older ladies after him, but this place won't make it for another two years I guarantee that

Absolutely fantastic New owners are Rocking it!…read moreKeep up the great work! Everything is great and they have more options!

We had the buffet for a funeral luncheon and the food was really good. The chicken had great flavor…read moreand I couldn't tell if it was fried and broasted! Whatever the cooking process was to prepare it, it was phenomenal! I had the mostaccioli too and that was very good also. The meatballs were some of the best I've ever had. I'm sorry I took only 1! They also had Italian sausage and two different kinds of potatoes, and both kinds of potatoes were tasty and seasoned really well. There were other things on the buffet that I didn't try, but everything I did have was very good. The service was friendly and they paid attention to what our group needed throughout the luncheon. We were very happy with the food and service and would definitely recommend them.

It was better than, I figured it would be. Great food My Marsala was a bit on runny otherwise…read moretasted good. Pizza can't beat it. Good service, nice inside.