We have been coming here for a couple of years now and I just want to say our last experience on (8/13)was the best we have ever gotten here. Our waiter was very attentive and checked back on us. It was particularly slower for a Thursday but our server was very talkative and gave us great service. My husband gotten a Buffalo Chicken Wrap and I gotten a Buffalo Chicken Sandwich they were both to die for. 10/10 recommend to try. Normally dessert isn't offered to us however it was even though we were stuffed it was still nice to hear the options and he even showed us what they looked like it was very tempting but next time we will be back just for the dessert. read more

Enjoyed a delicious meal here. My breakfast was the farmers bowl and it was sooo yummy. I chose raisin toast and it was delicious as well. Unlimited coffee was great too. Lots of seating and parking. One star removed because we could not flag our waitress down and it was tough to get her attention for more coffee hot sauce etc. read more

Castlewood Cafe - Inside - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Hartford , New York

See all

Castlewood Cafe didn't turn up in a search for breakfast places nearby, but it was recommended to us by our server at our previous night's dinner. It turned out to be very good. I ordered the "King's Breakfast", a feast with excellent pancakes, eggs, hash browns, sausage and bacon. Overall this is a nice, modern place. Service was attentive and cheerful, food came out quickly. The restrooms are particularly nice. During our stay we went back a second time. read more

Everything was amazing! We were sat right away and service was excellent. The food came out quickly and was delicious! read more

Castlewood Cafe - Reuben & french fries - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Hartford , New York

Nice clean place with average food. Good potato salad but dry chicken in chicken corn salad

As soon as we pulled into the driveway, we knew that it would be a good place. It was obvious that it is frequented by the local population. We were seated quickly and given both the breakfast and lunch menus. We enjoyed the wide range of choices. We were with friends and we were able to have a conversation without raising your voices at all. The food was delicious. The service was quick and we would definitely come back. read more

Great service and a cute place. Had a cheeseburger and fries. It was very good and served fast.

We stumbled across this place on our last vacation. It's our second time back on this vacation. Great food! read more

See all

Who knew that this was my Grandma's favorite restaurant? Not I, but after a recent family event we came here for lunch and it didn't disappoint. I had the Chicken Marsala which was prepared very well (though the side of red-sauce spaghetti was forgettable), and the sausage & greens soup was tasty (though extremely salty). They had a great selection of pies and the slide of bourbon cheesecake was well done. I don't know if they made it in-house or not, but I would order it again. Others enjoyed their meals, though another person's appetizer platter (essentially deep fried everything) wasn't touched much. Apparently, it tasted heavily of used oil which had previously cooked fish. Our server was pleasant, though after she delivered the food she never checked back with us again and I was dying for more water. She walked by many times but never asked how we were doing, whether we needed anything, etc. That was disappointing. A fun place that I would be happy to visit again. read more

Whoever said "Breakfast is the most important meal of the day" is a kindred spirit of mine. As such, a classic diner is somewhere you may find me on a random weekend morning. Recently I had the chance to check out the Castlewood Café, situated not far from Utica University. Upon entering, you'll realize it's not going to win any style points. The interior is a bit dated, though not in the charming 50's diner sort of way. However, seating was plentiful, and seeing many of the tables with patrons was a good sign. I ordered the classic "Queen's Breakfast" - 2 eggs any style, hash browns, toast, a sausage patty, and 2 bacon slices. This is a pretty classic order for me and a good way for me to decide if it was worth the drive. We wanted to try a grilled blueberry muffin, but they had run out. My counterpart ordered the fruit crepes - a bit too much sweet for me in the morning, but they were very happy with their choice. The food arrived fairly quickly, a bit of a surprise with the crowd they had on hand. The eggs were perfectly cooked, the rye toast was great, and the breakfast meats were on point. The only disappointment was the hash browns. They were cooked very well, a bit crispy on the outside, soft in the inside, but were lacking in much flavor. Our server was attentive, though busy, and seemed a bit flustered at times. Overall no issue with the service we received though. I'd be more than happy to recommend the Castlewood for those looking for some good breakfast comfort food. read more

Castlewood Cafe - Crepes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Hartford , New York

See all

Very busy on a Saturday Morning... it's a big place... bigger than it looks... it has a great atmosphere, clean, including the restrooms , I had a skillet...delicious, my wife had a breakfast sandwich with coleslaw on it... looked amazing ... and our youngest had the French toast... WOW !!!! ... $60 for the three of us ... not bad for what you get ... read more

Castlewood Cafe - Skillet - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Hartford , New York

See all

We got out to breakfast every weekend, we seen the news article on WKTV that they were opening up a 2nd location and we never heard of them so we wanted to try. Here's how it went: 1. My husband had lipstick on the side of his coffee cup. 2. We waited 45 minutes for our food. The person dropped it off and immediatetly turned around. Even with us having empty cups on the side. 3. Took 20 mins for waitress to come check on us after getting our food to get drinks and syrup for my husbands now COLD pancakes. 4. We paid for pancakes he took 2 bites out of because they were cold. I was done with my food way before the waitress finally came over. I hope they re-evaluate their waitresses and how they run it before opening a 2nd location. We came, we saw, we tried it, we wont return!! read more

We started at the old location about 3:15 on a Wednesday afternoon. It was closed with a sign that said please visit the new location. So, we went to their new location in New Hartford. Stood waiting to be seated for a full ten minutes. Our presence wasn't even acknowledged. 3:30 in the afternoon, not a busy rush hour time. An employee did see us waiting but ignored us and went on her way. I would have expected at least a "Be with you shortly" or something. But nothing. Yes, there was a sign that said Please wait to be seated. Will I be going back? Not likely. read more

I've been at both location and the food is awful. Fish fry so greasy you could grease wheel bearings on my truck. Mozzarella sticks not even cooked only reheating value was the coleslaw which was good. The roll that came with The fish sandwich was like a sourdough roll, hard and absolutely no flavor. I always considered a soft roll like a brioche roll the best. I will never eat there again!! I have know idea what anyone sees in this awful place! read more

Went on June 21. Called made reservation for 11 for 4 early in the day. It was pretty quiet and they took as back and told us we were to sit at 3 different tables. I said why? He said did you tell them you wanted to be seated together? So finally after telling us it would be a fire hazard they put three tables together after acting like it was our fault. So we get seated about 10 minutes later waitress came got the drinks, another 15 minutes goes by she came back to take our order. About 15 minutes after that they brought out bread which was very good. So when the order came two of us got corn and when i looked at it it looked brown and old and tasted horrible, almost everyone on the table tried it and said it was bad. So I asked for something else told her it was horrible so broccoli it was. That finally came out like mush it was also horrible and couldnt eat that. The waitress never came back asking if we wanted another drink. Besides how bad the vegetables were everyone said their food was okay, I had Pot Roast and that was good. The other food was good, nothing special. We noticed that all the staff was all younger where the ones at the old place were middle aged and seemed to care more. We are not a needy party we are actually pretty easy but this was not good and will not be going back any time soon. read more

Walked in and had a server make eye contact, then quickly turn away to finish whatever she was doing. Another server came up to seat us just minutes later, but took her time coming back to us at the table (there were only 2 other tables sat in the entire restaurant). The appetizer, Castlewood Sampler, came out quick and tasted good. The main meals took forever to come out...The meatloaf and riggies were not the flavors we liked, but not bad either. The kiddos didn't complain about their meals, but between slow, unfriendly service and mediocre food, we see no reason to return. read more

See all

I had a peanut butter granola waffle that was really good. Not crazy on the Jesus decor though. Service was great

Friendly service and staff. Food is very good every time. Normally prompt seating even when it is busy.

Waiter was sooooo nice BTW the cutest paintings in the bathroom and nice knight waiting for u read more

Castlewood Cafe - Pretty picture - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Hartford , New York

See all

Breakfast had great choices! Food was great! Service was wonderful! All around great experience and we will be returning!

Hands down one of the best places in the area for breakfast. Came here on Easter and it was packed. Surprisingly didn't wait that long, about 5 mins. It seemed like everyone was out with their family for breakfast. I ended up ordering the King's breakfast; came with two eggs, two strips of bacon, a sausage patty, hash browns, and two pancakes. Everything tasted delicious. No complaints on the food or the service. I couldn't even finish the pancakes, that's how filling it was. The staff was quick and friendly. I'll be back. read more

Castlewood Cafe - The King's Breakfast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Hartford , New York

After eating breakfast out in all the local places scores of times, I have concluded that Castlewood is exceptional. The breakfast is very good, with some really different and interesting choices on the menu. I normally get an American Cheese Omelet - and its awesome. I think they make a really thin omelet and then fold it in, making several thin layers of egg with cheese in between. That results in a great tasting omelet with a texture that is pretty awesome. On Food TV they would call it mouthfeel. Its served with a slice of orange, toast and home fries that are awesome. We've had other things like fried eggs - simple you say? Yes but they always come exactly as you ordered them - over easy, medium or hard - they get it and it's perfect. The food is always hot and they obviously care about how it looks on the plate. It's never just slopped on like many place do when they get busy. Castlewood pays attention to details. The place is large with tables and booths and plenty of parking too. Very clean and service is fast with professional waiters. We have never been there for dinner but will be very soon. Easily a 5 star place recommended by this often picky writer. read more

See all

The food is acceptable. Asparagus was over cooked and the salmon was dried out. Rest of the meals were fine. A good stop, just not great.

Great service and food this time. Everything tasted great and the new bagels are awesome. read more

See all

If you're looking for a great place to have breakfast, this place does not disappoint!! Good food ,good service and good prices ! You won't be disappointed. I go at least once a month read more

I've been dining here since they opened. And it kills me to say that their level of service has taken a plunge. I've been there with absolutely nobody in there at 8am and my waitress was ambivalent towards me- her only customer. Ignoring me as she walked by, and later, l(literally 10 mins.),when she had other tables she totally ghosted me. Brought coffee refills to the others but not me. I figured maybe a bad day ??? But no, it wasn't, every time I've been there since, I've gotten the same treatment from her. I am polite i tip well, and my order is very simple. So i guess we'll travel a bit further for breakfast from now on. read more

Great food and service! We always make a trip to castlewood cafe when we come up to see our college kid. Breakfast menu has a large variety and reasonably priced. read more

Castlewood was great. We loved it more because they believe in Jesus. They believe Jesus died for our sins. The food was awesome. Atmosphere was nice.we certainly will go back!!!!!!! read more

Hair in the fries, they were also cold and soggy and unsalted what so ever and the wait was very long and the waitresses are very rude and unwelcoming and extremely unprofessional. I've tried this place before and last time it was an hour and 45 minute long wait. This is a very terrible place to go to. read more

Castlewood Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Hartford , New York

First time there. Ordered the greens as appetizer. I thought they were good with lots of things in them but for the price the portions should have been bigger. Got the fish fry for dinner, and by looking at the picture - yes it was very overcooked. It was your normal fish fry with choice of side and etc. This one in particular was very overcooked though. Someone else got the side of pasta with their fish and there was 95% pasta with 5% sauce on top. The waitress was nice but she didn't come back to the table much. Could've had a better experience. read more

I've been dining here since they opened. And it kills me to say that their level of service has taken a plunge. I've been there with absolutely nobody in there at 8am and my waitress was ambivalent towards me- her only customer. Ignoring me as she walked by, and later, l(literally 10 mins.),when she had other tables she totally ghosted me. Brought coffee refills to the others but not me. I figured maybe a bad day ??? But no, it wasn't, every time I've been there since, I've gotten the same treatment from her. I am polite i tip well, and my order is very simple. read more

Great place to eat food is great to people are friendly and great place to eat service is great to

I have been to this restaurant just about a 100 times, if not more. I have nothing but great things to say about this restaurant. The service is a 10/10, always attentive and respectful towards you. No matter what time of day it is, the people are always very accommodating. I have never had a bad meal here, the food is always good. The atmosphere here is very welcoming, and overall a great place to enjoy a meal. If you're close by, I definitely recommend that you try it out. I promise, you won't be disappointed. read more

Great place to have lunch breakfast dinner prices are reasonable and the service is excellent

They have GLUTEN FREE BREAD! I repeat GLUTEN FREE BREAD! And it was excellent to pair with my Reuben sandwich. We love castle wood! Great place and we can continue eating there since learning about my gluten sensitivity read more

Excellent diner! The breakfast is a great portion of food. Mom and I split this huge omelette that had Italian sausage and peppers and such in it! we also split Canoli Pancakes which were a special going on, loved them!!! Service was spectacular, been there a couple of times now, never a bad time. read more

Castlewood Cafe - Canoli Pancakes! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Hartford , New York

See all

This is a best kept secret for family- owned, family dining in Utica. Very spaceous and peaceful setting for a diner-like eating experience. If you like spicy with your breakfast, try the chorizo hash. I have enjoyed many different breakfast dishes there, alone or with my daughter. read more

After coming back to this place countless amount of times, it seems that as time went on this place improved even more. First of all the food is great as always and they even redecorate their carpets which look much better and also their staff has improved even though they were always very good. Best of all there is no long waits to get your check anymore. All in all this place has great food and great staff as well as an amazing experience. read more

Nicole, my server was awesome!! She was very attentive and I didn't have to wait for anything. My drink came fast, my food came fast, and my condiments came fast. It wasn't busy but she served like it was. That's a commitment to service. I had the Giambrotte (sp*) skillet...and it was everything I needed this morning. It was a lot of food and very tasty. I was full half way thru but I had to keep eating. Next time I'm in Utica, I'm coming back. read more

Castlewood Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Hartford , New York

Ordered takeout (2 fish fries) at 5:10, was told it would be ready in 30 mins. Waited over a half an hour, no food. After watching numerous people come in and leave before, one who mentioned ordering his food at 5:25 and who got the same thing, I asked if they could confirm they had my order. The woman at the register talked to someone and after another 10-15 minutes I got our food. All told I did not walk out of there until about 6:20. The food was hot and good but I am pretty sure are order was skipped of lost. It was Good Friday and I understand them being busy, my issue is that when I finally checked out there was no acknowledgement of my wait. Also, numerous people working could see me waiting and had I not asked about my order, I would probably still be waiting. I am a very patient person, and would not gave had an issue if they were a little apigetuc about the wait. read more