I crave this meal and go at least once a month to have it. I usually sit at the bar and have a glass or two of their Sauvignon Blanc. You can't find this specific dish in most restaurants, and once you have it you will definitely want to have it again. Service is always very good here too read more

See all

We had another great dining experience at Catullo's. I love how the manager comes by and checks on every table. They have a large staff that helps each other out. I peaked in the kitchen and they were working it in there. Our sauces were so tasty that had to be a secret sauce recipe. I had the pasta del ponente sausage very good. My wife had the shrimp rosato that she loved! They kept bringing us this delicious bread! Both dishes we dipped the bread into the remaining sauce in our dishes. We ordered a very good bottle of wine. Our waitress was top notch with great named Danielle. The place is very romantic for a date night. It was freezing when we got in but we were fine after a few minutes. read more

See all

The food was absolutely amazing!! Sat at the bar and service was friendly and knowledgeable. Can't wait to go back!!

I've been wanting to come here for a while now and finally had dinner mid-week. Ordered the Shrimp Rosato mid-spicy and my friend ordered the ravioli. The rosato had ample shrimp, fairly large and it had good sauce/pasta ratio. My friend enjoyed his ravioli as well. You can tell their ingredients are fresh. They also provided slices of bread to use to sop up the sauce. If the bread was warm, it would've made it a bit better. For dessert, we shared the seasonal pumpkin cannoli. I loved that it wasn't too sweet and had a strong pumpkin flavor. Service was attentive and very friendly. Restaurant was quaint, intimate and pretty quiet. Great for dates and conversations. Would go again to try other dishes! read more

See all

I looooooove the pear fiocchi and get it every time! I wish the water wasn't so awful - I hated having to buy a soda just because the water had a terrible aftertaste. The server even acknowledged it's a common issue. I also wish the bread came with butter - I tried to ask my server quite a few times but she kept walking away before I could keep her attention to ask. The food is amazing but $40+ for one entree, drink, tip is spendy to do it outside of special occasions. I know the ingredients are very high quality, so I do appreciate that - just wish the water was drinkable. read more

How have I not left a review for this location yet?! If you're wondering whether the quality here matches their original Jax location--the answer is a resounding yes! I came last Wednesday for a small birthday dinner with two foodie friends who had never experienced Catullo's before. Let's just say, they were blown away--so much so that they were already planning their return visit before we even finished our appetizers. Speaking of ambiance, I love the black-and-white accent wall that was added recently. It adds an elegant, upscale touch that enhances the entire dining experience. What We Had: A bottle of red wine for the table Fried Mozzarella (always fresh, never frozen) One of the appetizer specials: fresh mussels (served with incredible bread that was different from their usual pasta accompaniment--would've gladly ordered more just to soak up all the juices but I did not want to fill up on bread) Three entrées (only mine is pictured: the pear pasta with scallops) Three desserts (two shown in photos): the featured sorbets and gelatos, plus the cannoli The Service: Our server was attentive, patient, and knowledgeable, offering great recommendations without ever making us feel rushed. It was clear she genuinely cared about our experience. We also had a visit from Mark Catullo which was such a treat. He generously let us try the secret housemade limoncello--an absolute delight! Both he and our server went above and beyond to make the evening feel so special, and I can't thank them enough for their genuine hospitality. Why I Love Catullo's: Beyond the warm, welcoming staff every visit, what truly sets Catullo's apart from other Italian spots in Jax is its authenticity. The dishes aren't drowned in cheese just for the sake of an Instagrammable cheese pull--every ingredient is thoughtfully balanced. Don't get me wrong, there's plenty of cheese, but it's done right. If you appreciate top-notch service and high-quality, real Italian food, you must give Catullo's a try. Just remember: they don't take reservations, so arrive early, beat the crowd, and savor a truly unrushed dining experience with your loved ones. read more

By far my favorite restaurant in Jacksonville. My wife and I have come to know the staff well, and frequent Catullos. The food is out of this world. The motz sticks are made with fresh beautiful cheese as are all the other dishes that use it. There are always daily specials which are a smash hit 9/10 times. The pear fiocci is my favorite dish but I've been blown away by the duck and other fun specials they do regularly. The service is what really makes this place special and they make it a point to treat everyone like family. You'll never be ignored here or just another table, as the small and intimate atmosphere is a focus of their brand. While everything on the menu is great, don't be afraid to order outside of your comfort zone here to have a truly great experience! I trust the staff will take care of you! read more

See all

Husband and I tried Catullo's for the first time to celebrate our wedding anniversary. Our waiter Dan made the experience wonderful. Offered vast recommendations from drinks to dessert. The food lived up to the hype, and we will be back many times. read more

Catullo’s Italian - Pear Fiocchi- unique, flavorful, not overly sweet. Great match between sweet and savory. Would pair well with a protein. - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra, Florida

See all

Great food, great service! The lasagna may be the best lasagna I've ever had a restaurant. Jimmy was our waiter and the entire staff assisted. Easy 5 stars! read more

See all

Came here on a Friday around 5:30pm and I was so glad they were not busy so we were seated right away. Having visited their other location and reviewed the menu beforehand, we knew exactly what we wanted to order--thankfully, because the lighting inside was so dim that reading the menu felt like a challenge without using the flashlight on our phones! LOL! Here's what we tried: Ma's Bruschetta- definitely different from other bruschetta that I have tried. They used crostinis but I would prefer a softer baguette. The toppings were also served too cold for my taste. This was just okay for me. I still prefer the traditional version. Coda Alla Vaccinara - This was the special for the night: oxtail braised for 12 hours. The dish was incredibly flavorful, and the meat portion was generous. I like my pasta al dente but the treccione pasta that came with it was a bit thick and hard to chew. I would substitute it with pappardelle next time. Sunday Suppa - the meatballs were amazing and the pappardelle pasta was cooked perfectly! My husband and I enjoyed this! For dessert, we tried the Ricotta Pistachio Cake, which was light and not overly sweet--perfectly complemented by a cappuccino and espresso. Overall, we had a great experience and will definitely return. My only wish is that they could take reservations for larger groups read more

See all

I love their location on Atlantic, so I was excited that this outpost opened closer to me. A friend had an appointment nearby and we had arranged to meet at that Asian fusion place on US1 but it was closed. So we made a plan B for Cattulo's which was a welcome relief to our hunger. It was a weeknight but the place was packed. Fortunately got a table in the middle of the room. Servers were whizzing around with piles of gnocchi and arancini balls. Started with a bottle of the Fuedo Disisa Grillo which we planned on taking home since we only wanted a glass each. Got the side salads with the Shrimp Rosato and Gnocchi Catullo Sausage. Everything was great. I just love the gnocchi here. And the sausage is delicious. It's a little expensive but the quality is top notch so totally worth it. read more

Fabulous Italian food. Cozy and inviting. We visit on special occasions. Love the Chicken Pesto

This was our fourth visit to Catullo's in Ponte Vedra, and while the food is generally good--our friends always enjoy their meals--I've had a few ongoing issues that make it hard to keep coming back. First and foremost, the temperature inside the restaurant is freezing. This has been the case on all four of our visits. The last time, I had a coat and two towels wrapped around me just to make it through dinner, and everyone seated nearby felt the same way. Even the hostess mentioned she was cold. It's uncomfortable enough that it's the main reason I wouldn't return. Second, as a diabetic, I really wish there were more options beyond pasta. A chicken, fish, or other protein-based entrée would be greatly appreciated. On our most recent visit, I was both cold and hungry but couldn't find anything suitable on the menu. I ended up ordering the tomato soup, which arrived lukewarm and, after being reheated, was unfortunately so salty it was inedible. My husband's lasagna came out the same way--lukewarm and overly salty--but he ate it anyway. Our friends had the pear pasta and said it was delicious, though it could have been hotter. The mozzarella appetizer was another miss. It had an unappealing presentation and looked like something prepackaged rather than freshly prepared. On the positive side, the bread, wine, and cocktails were excellent, and our server was outstanding--friendly, attentive, and quick to help. Maybe it was just an off night in the kitchen, but since it wasn't particularly busy, we expected the food to be hot and consistent. Overall, I'd love to see the restaurant adjust the air conditioning to a more comfortable level and add at least one non-pasta entrée, like a classic chicken marsala or grilled fish. Until then, we'll probably stick to recommending it for those who don't mind a cold dining room and a pasta-heavy menu. read more

Food is visually appealing and very tasty. Service is helpful and accommodating to children. Prices are reasonable for the types of dishes. read more

If I could give more stars I would! From start to finish, this is one of the best meals and service I've ever had. We had an early dinner as I wasn't sure how long the wait would be on a Saturday night. We were seated right away and our server, Naveah was perfect! Super nice, helpful and checked on us, also was super quick to refill our drinks. I had the scallops with truffle sauce and it was delicious!! My husband had their special, short ribs ravioli with pesto sauce and he, who's very picky loved his meal as well. Everyone who works there worked as a team and helped each other out and that says a lot. My only complaint which is a super tiny thing is that it was a tad too dark and my old eyes had a hard time reading the menu. Other than that, everything was 10/10. I plan on going back and work my way down the menu and try everything! read more

Catullo’s Italian - Scallops with truffle sauce 10/10! - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra, Florida

Delicious Italian, homey and comfortable vibe, family-owned. This is one of my favorite kinds of restaurants and we have loved supporting them as they opened their Nocatee location. Service has always been excellent for us - at both locations. We are checked in on multiple times and never are left waiting or wanting. Everyone is friendly and takes good care of you and your party. No reservations, so be prepared to wait in line depending on what time you arrive. We have been lucky the last few times and were able to squeeze in at the bar (for just two of us) or had a very short wait for a party of 4. No matter what, it's worth the wait and who knows, maybe you'll get lucky, too! The food is super fresh and it feels like Nonna is cooking these excellent dishes with a modern twist. The pear fiocci is one of my all-time faves -- something different and special and just oh-so-good. We love the arancini for an appetizer, plus the fresh bread, of course. I always like to try their specials! I have been impressed pretty much every time and it gives me the chance to try something new. The duck ragu I had last week was outrageous. I ate almost the entire thing and it is not a small dish! I have no shame :) The cannoli is perfection. Crunchy. Sweet. Fully loaded. Extra pistachios and just great flavor. There have been a few dessert specials we tried and the toasted almond cream cake was probably my #1. Grab a coffee, get a glass of wine, and eat all of the amazing things. Just trust me. read more

See all

Italian is my favorite so I love having this option so close to home. Great variety on the menu for such a small, family owned restaurant. Food is always fresh and made to order. We did have to wait a bit for a server. Once they figured out who had our table, Jimmy provided great service. We started with the fried mozzarella which was perfect. Love their marinara! We each ordered an entree and then shared the Pear Fiocchi (our favorite). Other than the wait, the only complaint is how cold it is in the dining area. Maybe bring layers if you're cold natured like me. read more

See all

First time here and we are so happy we came. Fresh delicious food. Pear fiocchie is delicious, the sweetness of the delicate pear really compliments the saltiness of the pancetta. The special of the night - local red shrimp with olives, capers, tomatoes in a white wine sauce was spectacular. Thank you Ryan for taking such great care of my husband and I. After a long day at Mayo was nice to have a special meal and be treated so well. Ryan - thank you for everything including checking me and a sample of the pistachio dessert (so delicious) and coffee. I will always remember you taking great care of us. Highly recommended if you love fresh authentic Italian cuisine. read more

Best Italian food in jax. It is a small place. Expect to wait for a table. Go early or late. It is worth it. Their menu changes with the time of year. Thanksgiving is the best time., they have unique specials. read more

Catullo's is a great spot for authentic house made Italian food. Since all of the dishes are made to order, it is very easy to "customize" the dish to your liking (protein, sauce, pasta, etc.). We will be back! read more

See all

Good Italian place. There is no ambiance. Does not compare to the original one on San Pablo rd in Jacksonville. Service was fine read more

O M G yess! We had an exceptional dinner experience from the wonderful lady server & her personable service to the food. To start, She was very helpful with wine choices as we weren't familiar with some of our options on the menu. We took my older parents for Mother's Day. My father & I are Sicilian so we grew up with his mother's best food ever! No one can beat my Nonna! So we are picky! Catullo's has variance of choices with fresh pasta. It's not common traditional so to speak choices. In other words if you're looking for veal dishes or chicken Parmesan that won't be here. The Pear Fiocchi or "Little Purses" is recommended and is light and amazing. Add the scallops I swear it's ridiculously amazing. My husband got The Peposo with stewed beef I think that day it was the only beef offering dish. This is a family owned restaurant with 2 locations. This one & Jacksonville. We had gone to Jacksonville once before also having an amazing experience. Their family photos are on the walls. The relative forgive me, grandson I believe came over to our table and spoke with us which I love. Shortly before we were done he came back and toasted with us. The Cannolo dessert was gorgeous and delicious I didn't want to share. Thank you Catullo family we will definitely be back. Word to the wise. No reservations. Both locations are intimate but we don't wait long. Get a glass of wine and have no fear! read more

See all

Fantastic Italian food with great portions! Love the cheesy bread and lasagne! Great service also

Another five star experience at Catullo's! The staff here is like no other and have become like family. Chris at the bar always takes great care of us and Joey as well when we sit in the main dining area. My husband and I went tonight with a friend visiting from south Florida and had a lovely experience. I had the scallop risotto, my husband got the pear fiocchi and our friend got the special which was ox tail. All phenomenal! The dessert special was the peppermint cheesecake and it was truly the best dessert I've ever had. They recently redecorated and the wallpaper and new additions really jazzed the place up. The staff is exceptional and truly goes above and beyond for their customers each visit. Love Catullos! read more

See all

Awesome food in a quaint setting with a family vibe. Mr Catullo made a special trip to our table after dinner to check on our experience and shared a complimentary champagne toast for our son-in-law's birthday celebration. The food is amazing and the service is impeccable. Fresh made pasta and the sauce is delicious! Expect to wait unless you arrive early as it is that good. read more

See all

We came tonight for the first time. The service was absolutely OUTSTANDING. Everyone went out of their way to ensure everything was perfect. Both of our meals were fantastic. Chris was serving the bar are and shared the beautiful story of the restaurant and family that runs it. Great for a date night or dinner with friends! read more

Right at the Nocatee Town Center. We arrived at 4:30, pretty much as soon as they opened. The servers were very friendly. Found the time to explain to us the specials for the day and some items on the menu. We celebrated my daughter's birthday. We got seated in a booth at the back of the restaurant which we liked due to less traffic. The menu selection was not like your other typical Italian restaurants. The food we ordered was all delicious. Definitely will return to this place. Come to this place as soon as they open because after 5:00, the place was full. read more

See all

This was a celebratory night and we had a party of 6. We were seated almost immediately and our server Jimmy was super friendly and super knowledgeable about every dish on the menu. We started with fried mozzarella and an order of Burrata for appetizers. The fried mozzarella was just the right crisp and crunch on the outside and the gooey-est stretchiest mozzarella in the middle. The Burrata was super creamy and comes with crostini and honey to balance the peppery greens. This was incredibly delicious. I ordered a clam dish with gluten free pasta. The clams were very well seasoned but they were very chewy and a bit grainy. Our server replaced this dish with his recommendation of shrimp diavolo which was super delicious and the shrimp was plump, juicy, and tender. Everyone else loved their meals and the proteins that they had added. I got to try some sausage which I highly recommend. It is locally made at a sausagery and they absolutely know what they are doing over there. We ended the night by sharing the limoncello cake as well as the olive oil cake. Both were really really really delicious and both are made in-house. I highly recommend Catullo's not only for their delicious food, but also for their impeccable service. Thank you Jimmy for all your recommendations (both food and wine) and for taking really great care of our whole group. read more

See all

An amazing date night pick to celebrate 100 days of marriage! We were worried because they don't take reservations and it was busy when we walked in, but we were sat immediately! Our server was very friendly and happy to make suggestions for dinner. The fried mozzarella sticks were delicious and were a huge appetizer serving. The gnocchi is absolutely amazing. The best part of our evening was when a manager chatted a bit with us and casually asked if we were celebrating anything. We were a bit embarrassed to mention we were "celebrating" 100 days but he was so excited for us and made it extra special! read more

Catullo’s Italian - Chocolate Mousse Cake - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra, Florida

The BEST Italian food in Jacksonville!! We were absolutely blown away by our meals here, they were incredible! We started with the Arancini, which was insaneee! So cheesy and delicious! We ordered the chicken basil pesto which had such a flavorful creamy sauce. The pear fiocchi dish was 10/10, one of the best meals we ever had! We added the scallops and they were some of the best! We were absolutely shocked out how amazing it was! The service was also fast for Italian food!! The place is quite small, we were lucky with coming on a weekday but it still was totally full and we can see why! This place is so worth the wait for a table. There is no reservations so plan to arrive right at opening on the weekend. We will be back very soon because we are already craving the pasta again!! 5 stars across the board!! read more

See all

Amazing! Service is off the charts, Catullo's staff deliver the best service one can desire. The staff is super friendly, attentive and knowledgeable. We visited for drinks and appetizers and loved everything. They have a great variety of local beers on tap, karate in the garage from southern swells and the Belgium pale ale from Aardwolf... some of my fav! They also a great variety of wines by the glass, the Sangiovese is delicious! Enjoyed arancini and bruschetta! Can't wait to come back and have a full blown dinner! read more

This is one place you don't want to miss. It a small restaurant with seating for maybe 50 people. It is not fancy, pretty plain. But do not let the looks deceive you. We started with the bruschetta which was the best I have ever had. Everything was so fresh and tasty. For our entree, I had the Pear Fiocchi. I was a little apprehensive because I couldn't imagine mixing pears with Pasta. Wow, was I ever wrong. I can not even describe the flavor of this amazing dish. I can't wait to go back and order this again. And we ended with the salted caramel cheesecake which was a bit too sweet for me but excellent taste. The staff was very friendly and attentive. Thanks to my server, I ordered that fantastic entree. Don't miss this place. It is amazing. read more

Catullo’s Italian - Pear Fiocchi - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra, Florida

First things first, when you get a girls night, you must go out to dinner. My sister and I headed to Catullo's in Nocatee because we hadn't visited in a while and we were eager to get some pear fiocchi. When we arrived around 6:45 pm on a weekend night there wasn't a line, which was a pleasant surprise. Originally we were going to sit at the bar, but then the hostess said they had a table for two, so we opted to sit at the table. When we arrived, we were greeted by someone filling waters, who was friendly and smiley. A few moments later our server came up, handed us a few menus, and we asked for a few minutes to decide. She wasn't the friendliest, just handed us the menus and asked if we wanted anything besides water to drink. When she came back we ordered our app, and asked for a few more minutes to decide our entree, and truth be told, we wanted to wait and not rush our dinner, since we rarely go out for girls nights together. She came back and asked us about entrees and we asked for a few more minutes. She came back again and asked for our entree orders and I asked for a few more minutes, because I didn't want to be rushed and she wasn't super pleasant about it, she said we space our food out, so it's not coming all at the same time. I was a little taken aback, only because every time we've been here, we've only had great servers. We just ordered because we didn't really want to be asked again, but I felt a bit like I was being scolded. Our arancini came out and was delicious. Two perfectly cooked rice balls that were rich, crispy and creamy all at the same time. It's a must have! A little bit later our entrees came out pear fiocchi, which if you haven't had it before, order it. It's little pasta purses filled with light airy cheese, covered in a cheese sauce and pears, then topped with crispy pancetta. It's so delicious. I give Catullo's food a five out of five. It's quality, it's delicious, and it's homemade. As for the server, I docked a star. This isn't a typical experience at Catullo's so if you go, I'm sure you'll be raving about the food and service. read more

Delicious food love the scallop risotto and the service. Have been here a couple times and they also do a great job of your celebrating someone's birthday and bring everyone champagne. read more

Catullo’s Italian - Scallop risotto so delicious! - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra, Florida

Food is good. Service was good... a little toooo good if that makes sense? Our girls night was interrupted an obscene amount of times. Super tiny... meaning you feel like you're in on your neighbors convo and ontop of your own party. Ridiculously dark. It's genuinely hard to see in there. Maybe some lights on each table would help. No liquor... which was really a negative for our party. I wouldn't return for a sit down dinner, but perhaps get takeout. Lots of room for improvement read more

First visit at the new location and it's almost exactly like the one on San Pablo. Not a huge place and the lighting is horrible for taking pics. LOL. The food is as scrumptious and the service is as fantastic as the original too tho :) The place is cozy, not great for a big group. Table of 6 is ok, 7 or more...you'll be waiting a bit unless you're first in line. read more

See all

Always my go to. Consistently fantastic food. Menu choices are plentiful and food comes out timing and staff is top notch

Eat here if you like real ingredients, small business, and amazing italian food. Glad to see them expanding because for the longest time it was one small location at San Pablo that was hard to get a seat in for obvious reasons. read more

4 of us had a very nice dinner here last night. We were able to be seated within 15 minutes on a Saturday night which was a pleasant surprise. Normally the wait times here on a weekend are longer. The food was delicious, I just had to try the pear/pasta dish based on all the reviews & it was as great as everyone says. They have a really nice wine list & even some really good craft beers too. Service was top notch! The place is a little on the small side & that makes the tables a little close together but we were comfortable. I wish they would serve some olive oil with the bread they bring to the table but otherwise a great dining experience. We'll be back read more

The service is great! The employees are very attentive. I always have the Pear with Gorgonzola and gnocchi! It is delicious!