This was my first and last time trying this place. I had the jalapeño bacon cheese sticks, white pizza (medium), and stuffed crust pizza with pepperonis (large). The cheese sticks were good, the white pizza was bland and didn't look like the picture advertised on the website, and I thought the stuffed crust pizza tasted the best out of all 3 items. however, after a couple days of having it, I started feeling very nauseous. I didn't think the pizza had anything to do with it until I really examined the crust and realized it was so stretchy, I feel as though it was under baked. A couple days after I stopped eating it, I felt better. I won't take another chance with their pizza again. read more

I have trouble believing what I was told. I called in to order an 18" pizza and family sized salad. For the pizza I asked for a Combo and asked for it to be cut square. I was told they don't do that. Since they did it for me before, I told I know they did do it. I have it done for a member in my family doesn't eat crusts. The person on the phone then gave me to the manager who told me the same. No square cut. I said, "OK, don't cut it at all, I'll cut it when I get home." She said, "we have to cut it, company policy." I guess I'll never again go to Cibelli's if that's their idea of customer service. read more

I would probably give this place 3 1/2 stars if I could, but it was closer to a 4 than a 3. We ordered one of the giant pizzas for our family of 4. We had plenty left over after we were full. The price was reasonable and no complaints about the pizza. It's....fine. It's not going to "wow" you, but it's not likely to be bad. It is what it is - a huge pizza for a relatively low price. read more

Ordered 2 small pizzas over the phone- 1 turned out to not be what I ordered. My servers were awesome! They made me the correct pizza and threw in the mid-make Excellent service!! read more

Male worker insisted I sign up for some rewards program. Like continually. Like not taking no for an answer. Dawg I just want some cheap pizza not be interrogated. read more

Geeat pizza and very fair prices and lots of coupons if ya sign up for email.Been there over 25 times and have never had any problems ever.

We got a large pepperoni that was dripping so much oil it was unappealing, and the pepperoni was so mild it was bland. We both decided it was not worth the calories. Also got a veggie and added sausage. By doing so they switched pricing to charging individually for each topping making the pizza $15.50 more expensive. And they didn't bother telling me. $15.50 for adding sausage! That's a plain old rip off! Abby's makes a much better pizza for the price. Much. Better. read more

We came here for a nice lunch ask for a combo with extra onions and they said " can't do more than seven toppings on a pizza" like you can't just add I little bit more onions and lady said 5 min wait we waited 20 my mom ask for s sausage and mushroom pizza and it only came with sausage. read more

Pizza was bomb, and get the ranch! So good. We made a phone order and picked it up. The guy in the phone was super nice but my only complaint is we asked them to cut the giant pizza into a few more slices because we have little kids with us and will be eating at a park.He informed us he couldn't because it's policy. Idk if that's true but if it is management needs to look into that, thats just ridiculous. I said "do you have a plastic knife", he said yes. I said "ok will we will take one so I can cut it myself". Policy seriously.. no other pizza places do that.. makes me want to take my business elsewhere. You have a pizza cutter you can't just use it a few more times. That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard of. read more

Dinner deal was amazing! 24" pizza was enough for our teen boys , which is no easy feat. Food was great!

Favorite pizza place in town. Rich in flavor, quick turn around, and it's always fresh. 10/10 recommend

Good pizza with many topping options. Fresh cheese. Great dough! Quick tasty!! This is a family establishment so no beer, alcohol or wine.

I've ordered pizzas multiple times and every time I show up and I give a 10min grace period pizza is ready at 7. I show up at 7:10 and they haven't even started my pizza. It's not because they are busy. This happens on a Tuesday at 3pm. It's literally every time. 5 plus people working just standing and talking. I'm literally the only the person here getting pizza and some how a hour long window isn't enough time. read more

If you want a pizza slice for $5 as big as your head, here's your new place to go Delicious pizza, even friendlier staff read more

Well, let down again... Two stars for some decent flavor but twice now the order has been wrong. Let's try and repeat the phone order back to the customer to confirm accuracy. My gut told me to check it before leaving but I really didn't want to wait for another whole pie to cook as I was on a time schedule. Seems that there is a reason for the empty dining area. Sad. The guys were pleasant and hooked up the parm, chili flakes and extra ranch for the pie, but I REALLY was looking forward to that stuffed crust goodness I heard about. Time to move on from here and try somewhere else next time. read more

great food must come if your craving authentic NY pizza. the service was great and quick loved the vibes the place gave!

If only they would cook the pizza well done. It would be amazing. They under cook all their pizzas.

They won't even let u pay for double toppings on a large pizza, against policy. And the people there refuse to let the company know that the people would pay for it. Thats what they want. Order a double hamburger, what do u get read more

Cibelli's is the best! I have literally made at least 3 10+ trips to get some Cibelli's! Where to even start? First, they hand toss their pizzas and not only does it make for a great show, it also makes the dough perfectly distributed. As it is a New York Pizza, it is a thin crust and the crust is my favorite part! It's always cooked to perfection with a soft inside and the perfect amount of crispy-ness on the outside. They use the highest quality of ingredients and they seem to have only gotten better over the 10 years that I have been visiting this establishment! They make a 24" Pizza; it's gargantuan! It can easily feed an entire of family with plenty of leftovers! They also sell an 18", 14" and a 10"! If you just want to stop in for a single slice or two, they do that too! The slices come from the 24", so it is pretty filling! They also make their own white sauce and, in my opinion, it's the best part of their pizza! I get a white pie every time! The red sauce is also incredibly good! The staff are fast, friendly and polite! I've never experienced anything but fast, excellent service, even during the busy lunch rush when all the high school students from across the street come over and flood the place! If you are looking for the best pizza you'll ever eat, stop at Cibelli's New York Pizza! Food: 5/5 Stars Service: 5/5 Stars Wow Factors: Size (24 inch pizza) and the white sauce 5/5 Stars Overall: 5/5 Stars read more

Never have I gotten the chance to eat here because every time I want to, but I can't find a freckin' menu. Then I said whatever I'll just call and ask, but you can't get through or it's just static. Your open till 9 why shut your phone off at 7:30? You don't want business, your loss. read more

Go here for authentic pizza the way they make it in NY and for the entertainment! These folks know how to throw a pizza dough. But most of all, the flavor is fabulous! They are accommodating and kind, fast and good at what they do. Extra thumb up for these guys along with a hearty tip! read more

The stuffed crust cheese pizza is amazing. Didn't think it would be good but it was soooo good. Definitely surprised but pleasantly. read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

My last review was 10 years ago. Time fly"s when your havin fun and eating at Cibelli's. I ordered a 24" white margarita pie and a 14 " cheese pie. I've grown to like their white pizza. The olive oil, garlic sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, and shredded parmesan has my taste buds dancing on every bite. I'm not running to Cibelli's as I did 10 years ago. But I am driving just as fast. read more

If you avoid this pizza, I feel sorry for you: NOT TO BE MISSED! There are now 3 in Bend, PLUS satellites in Sisters + Redmond... read more

Cibelli's, Cibelli's, Cibelli's. What would we do without a infamous pizza or pie, if you will, to attain our favorite flavors of pizza?? They are professIonal, courteous and very timely in their bakings. We missed our favorite pizza establishment in Terrebonne named Base Camp Pizza but low and behold, there's one that matches the flavors, if not better! Keep up the great work, Cibelli's!! I recommend this place to order out or dine in. read more

We are in search of a real 5 star pizza restaurant near our house. Cibelli's Pizza was good but not even close to 5 stars. We were greeted by a young man at the counter who, after we consulted the menu, took our order for a Combo Pizza. He told us that he needed to get a time for us. He returned with a, not unreasonable, time of 25 minutes and handed us cups for the self service soft drink machine. We picked a table and, after a few minutes, moved to another table because the sun was shining in our eyes and I could not find anyway to block it. Our pizza was delivered to our table, after 22 minutes, with two very flimsy paper plates and small containers of crushed pepper and cheeses. After a short search, I found plastic knives and forks. The pizza was hot. The crust itself was very good as was the pizza sauce. The toppings were best described as sparse. Essentially, what we were served was a pizza crust and enough toppings to provide flavor. My idea of a combo pizza is that the purpose of the crust is to support a mountain of toppings. A couple of reviews called this New York Pizza. I have enjoyed real New York Pizza in New York City, this is not New York Pizza. Cibelli's Pizza will do in a pinch; but, for me, is not a go to restaurant. read more

The pizza here is damn great, and the cheese sticks are pretty amazing. I can't review them positively because they aren't requiring masks inside their stores. They will not require masks, even after the state mandate. After Covid started, I wasn't comfortable visiting inside their store to grab my order, so I'd request they bring it out to my car. I always tipped 15-20% for the trouble. After mask mandates started, I called to place an order and requested it be brought to my car. They couldn't accommodate my request because they were busy, and asked me to come inside to grab it. I asked if they were requiring masks, and they said they 'were leaving that up to the cops or whatever to enforce'. I canceled my order and I won't be back. If you are an at-risk person, I would suggest not eating here. Their customers' health and safety is not their priority. If you think masks are dumb, this is the place for you! read more

Happiness is hand tossed pizza crust. Fun to watch and delicious to eat, Cibelli's New York Pizza is a great spot in Redmond. Although they have 10 tables, the dining area isn't a big selling point. Filled with New York iconography, it is pretty bare bones. I'd recommend ordering your pizza to go since they don't have delivery service. Most of the diners eating in order pizza by the slice, which is a deal for $3. You create your own pizza from standard meat, cheese and veggie options. A large 18" pizza with a few toppings is around $20 and can feed 3-4 people. They frequently run specials for a foot long slice of pizza and a soda. This is not artisan pizza with crazy ingredients, but you can order the standard pizza or have it made thin and crispy or thick and chewy. Their house specialty is a White Pizza with four cheeses and garlic sauce. I'm a fan of the pesto sauce and the dinner salad for $4 was a good deal. They have four beers on tap, red or white wine and a soda dispenser with free refills. The staff is very nice and this is becoming a regular spot on our visits to Redmond. read more

Used to be my favorite go to place. Last trip got take out spent more than$30.00 for dried out, burnt pizza. There was no cheese on the veggie pizza either. read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

See all

I am an out of towner who stopped in for a couple of slices today for lunch. I was shocked to find slices far better than the entire Portland metro area!!! Thin slice with a beautiful crunch and perfectly cooked. It totally reminds me of East Coast pie. I will be going back tomorrow to visit the wonderful staff and enjoy 2 more slices!!! It is a must visit if you are in Redmond! read more

Cibelli's offers a variety of pizza options ranging from personal sized pizzas (10") to group sized pizzas (24"). The staff are really nice and engaging, they also offer brews and wines from what I have seen. We got a 18" large pizza for only $16! Which isn't bad if you've been to other pizza joints. It has a small pizza joint type of feel, good vibes and good pizzas which reminds me. The Pizza here is pretty good by all standards. I would say it is above average! What stood out to me the most was the dough. It is very doughy and soft and cooked just right like a pizza should. Their pepperonis were also pretty good, it tastes like real legit meat! Cibelli's of Redmond is overall a great place to try pizza whether you are with family, friends, or solo! I'd definitely recommend it to anyone who is really seeking to find good Zah. read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

Rey good pizza. We had five of us including 3 teenage boys- we got an XL chicken pizza that was on special and a large pepperoni. XL is very XL! I we had more than enough for dinner plus late night snacks and breakfast for the boys. We stayed at Eagle Crest and it's only a 10 minute drive. I recommend! Also there are coupons on their website if you sign up to get a text! read more

As someone who lived near NYC for several years, this pizza is fantastic. Hands down the best pizza in central Oregon. Really good soft crust. I don't know why the place has 3.5 stars. I think because they are lax on masks as is Redmond. Shame people can't give a restaurant an objective rating anymore without their corrupting it with their personal bias. Oh yeah the pizza. The pepperoni is slightly greasy and full disclosure never had anything but their cheese and pepperoni. 10/10 recommend the cheese pizza, and the cheese pizza is how you judge a pizza place. Not too saucy, perfect amount of tang, good mozzarella cheese, and great tasting dough with a soft but slight crisp on the underside. read more

The largest pizza here is huge! Do not underestimate the size of the pizza. I have heard that this company takes care of their employees and pays them well, which is always good to hear. The pizza will not disappoint, but it is a bit greasy at times and the toppings can fall off easily sometimes. read more

7:15....over an hour before close and they aren't doing dinner slices. I can see why the inside is dead and no one is there. No liquor license so no beer and a slice. Staff is friendly though. Only thing that saved the 1 star. read more

Great pizza, if you don't like a lot of toppings. Soft, yet crispy but chewy crust that's awesome just by itself...I really do love the pie here...BUT I ABSOLUTELY HATE THE JUDGMENT that comes with every beer order! Apparently, the owner is a devout, strict, Mormon-- and he doesn't approve of anyone having more than 2 beers at his business-- SO they will absolutely cut you off at 2 beers!! SERIOUSLY?!?!? (I asked why after i got cut off, an employee who i won't name told me this about the owner) I'm sorry, i dont care how good your food is, if you are going to judge me for liking beer with pizza, you can kiss the fattest part of my %&$! That is entirely uncalled for, very offensive, and extremely unprofessional! Oh yeah, and they used to have THE BEST STROMBOLIE...but sadly, the owner was so brainless, he stopped making them because he said they dripped olive oil and grease in the oven making it smoke. UMM....HERE'S A SOLUTION-- USE A PAN OR PIZZA STONE GENIUS!! Couldn't figure that one out? REALLY??? read more

I got a piece of pizza to go and asked for mushrooms and olives added as topping. When I got home to eat it... the toppings all fell of the pizza. I went back a few days later Ryan's told them about it. They told me that is what they do.... Told me to call the corporate office and talk to them about it. No desire to make it right with me. read more

First of all, I did tip 25%. Thanks for working during a pandemic! Second--and this is really just for the one female employee who wasn't wearing a mask--not wearing a mask is a major sign of disrespect, both to the community generally but specifically to those of us who work in healthcare during this crisis. When you come into my place of business, I'll be taking appropriate precautions to safeguard your health; please reciprocate in yours. This pandemic will end sooner if we all make an effort. read more

Grew up in a pizzeria! First of all would you buy tacos from a place that had cartel or MS 13 pictures up on the walls?? It's an insult to our culture that you think this is acceptable. Grew up in a Philly pizzeria and calling 20 mins before closing and getting denied an order is just pathetic. Real pizzerias take orders till 15 after closing....when it literally takes 8 mins to cook and pizza and you say your all booked out till 8pm tonight!! This is an American food establishment and not a pizzeria at all. This is from a east coast first generation Italian who orders plain slices. Your burger place is even worst! The fact that you claim best burger on earth just shows your lack of understanding of food. The owners Def drives big trucks with 40s ! Lol Get a life your pizza is the worst and always undercooked. FYI even if you read this and decide to order get it we'll done or prepare to eat a under cooked dough taco with ketchup read more

I have always loved this pizza but the last few times I have ordered the middle of the pizza is always super paper thin and extremely flimsy?? It is still very flavorful but just wish you guys could add a little more volume to the middle of the pizza and cook a little longer then the pizza would be 5 stars !! read more