Grew up in a pizzeria! First of all would you buy tacos from a place that had cartel or MS 13 pictures up on the walls?? It's an insult to our culture that you think this is acceptable. Grew up in a Philly pizzeria and calling 20 mins before closing and getting denied an order is just pathetic. Real pizzerias take orders till 15 after closing....when it literally takes 8 mins to cook and pizza and you say your all booked out till 8pm tonight!! This is an American food establishment and not a pizzeria at all. This is from a east coast first generation Italian who orders plain slices. Your burger place is even worst! The fact that you claim best burger on earth just shows your lack of understanding of food. The owners Def drives big trucks with 40s ! Lol Get a life your pizza is the worst and always undercooked. FYI even if you read this and decide to order get it we'll done or prepare to eat a under cooked dough taco with ketchup read more

Best pizza around, and if you like crust you won't find any better anywhere. And don't forget about their roasted garlic!

I have always loved this pizza but the last few times I have ordered the middle of the pizza is always super paper thin and extremely flimsy?? It is still very flavorful but just wish you guys could add a little more volume to the middle of the pizza and cook a little longer then the pizza would be 5 stars !! read more

Mr. Kupcakes LOVED this pizza. I swear he would give it 10 stars if he could. He talks about going back to Bend just so we can get this pizza. He even wanted to get another one for the road. I thought it was really good, as well, but not the best I've ever had. Poor Mr. Kupcakes has never had pizza in New York. Our order was taken quickly and our pizza seemed to come out just as quickly. We were there later at night so there weren't any other costumers besides us. The pizza was huge and we didn't even order the biggest size. It was enough for us to eat for dinner and two other meals. The crust was thin and crispy, just like I like it. All the toppings were really fresh and tasty. We were very happy with the bacon that came on it. Yes, real bacon. Alright, Mr. Kupcakes may be on to something. I'm wanting another one of their pies while I sit here thinking about it. I guess we will be going back to get another one of these yummy pizzas some day. read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - Meat Lovers! - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

Great spot for a New York style pizza. One of my favorite things they do is provide pizza by the slice which is handy for those on the go, just make sure you call ahead if you're in a crunch for time. read more

We've been coming to Redmond for over 20 years. We have been coming to Cibelli's almost every one of those years. I grew up in NY and love a good NY style pie and this place usually fits the bill. I have to say their place is always nice to visit, have usually had great, friendly service and good food. But when someone is spending $35 for a combo pizza to feed the family, I would expect some toppings on the pizza. This year's pie was NOT indicative of a good NY pie. Very disappointing and not sure I'd be eager to come back. read more

Wow....I'm not sure how this place doesn't have 5 stars? The service was great. The couple of kids that helped us were so sweet and very informative! We got the stuffed crust, large, half bbq chicken half pepperoni. I've never had such good pizza in my life and I grew up in NY for a few years of my life. My Husband and I were super impressed, thank you for the great pizza! read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

See all

Will never, ever eat at this pizza joint. I know businesses need to make money. I get it. But the complete rip off...... no! 12.50 to add a topping and substitute one other.. pure gouging. Too many other good pizzas in the area. We will spend our $$ elsewhere. Also NO BEER!!!! Obviously, some low ranked employee, sold beer to a minor. Class act!! My advice, In redmond, any pizza but this. read more

Excellent pizza. What a treat to have classic NY style pizza in central Oregon. Our family enjoyed the largest size pepperoni, it was so fun to see the kids eyes when it arrived at the table. I have also tried their smaller sized cheese, very rich and good. The service is quick and friendly. The facilities are clean and well kept. I recommend this restaurant for the next time you get that monster pizza craving. read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - He ate the whole thing!!! - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

See all

Delicious NY style pizza. Love to watch them throw the dough in the air. They were all very friendly and the service was very fast

Something has changed and this pizza is no longer worth the money. Pizza was burnt (pic attchd) and this wasn't the first time. Not worth the $22.00. This was our "every Friday" dinner but we won't go here again, read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - Cibelli's Redmond 11-21-11 - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

Awesome pizza. The prices are a little shocking at first, until you see the portion sizes. These pizzas are huge and one piece would be more than enough for anyone shy of a offensive lineman. If you like thin crust NY style pizza, this place is great. They hand toss the pizza and I found it to be very good. The crust was chewy, but not overly so. We got the stuffed crust, and it makes a single piece a solid meal. We were staying at the Eagle Crest Resort and called in our order. They said it would be ready at 7:20 and we walked in the door to pick it up at 7:19 as they just pulled our pizzas out of the oven and called my name. I am really picky about pizza, and I have zero regrets about this place being chosen for dinner. read more

See all

I went in for dinner with the kiddos on a Tuesday not realizing that Tuesday is half-price beer night! That was a great surprise. The pizza was tasty and even my daughter who is not a big fan of pizza liked it. We will most certainly come back probably on a Tuesday haha read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

See all

I was so disappointed. I had to move away from home after my divorce and just moved back a few months ago and this is the first chance I have had to come get my favorite slice of pizza. Well it used to be my favorite. I wanted a slice with pepperoni, mushrooms & red onion. They suggested extra cheese to keep my toppings on. When I got back to where I am staying with my slice (which is only a mile or so away). I pulled my slice out and it wasn't hot. It so wasn't hot the extra cheese wasn't melted & the onions were raw. I had to pick them off. It was gross to have raw onions on a pizza. It's three hours later and I can still taste those stupid onions. I guess quality has slipped while I have been gone. Well one lesson is enough for me. With great Pizza available in town by Pappy's & Abby's there is enough choice for great pizza. read more

I first tried Cibellis New York Pizza 5 years ago and it was pretty good. You could get a big slice for cheap, with average products used. Now, it's a toss up between a chain restaurant and Cibellis as far as quality goes. I know that the management behind Cibellis tirelessly works to find THEE most profitable ingredients, no matter the repercussions. In this economy an established business (especially food service) cannot afford to lower their quality in goods. Yes, it's tough... but even your most loyal customer will come back even after a small price increase. I can guarantee that Cibellis margins would increase if they abandoned such low quality ingredients. You simply cannot have high quality food with low quality ingredients. In conclusion: Yes, the pizza is big... the dough is hand tossed - cool. But really, go to Little Pizza Paradise if you want high quality at the same price. Their 18" pizza literally outweighs Cibellis 24" and you can immediately see why when you look inside the box at the generous amount of toppings! read more

After reading other reviews this must have been an "off " night for the teenage boys running the show. Ordered pie at 6, "be ready at 6:40", pie didn't even see the inside of the oven until 6:50. I received numerous apologies (as did every other customer- doesnt that get old?) about the delay and was told that they were slammed. Really? There were 7 people in the place and the tip jar was virtually empty... First thing the counter guy did was offer to cancel my order. ("No, my family is waiting for pizza!! ) I understand that things can go sideways when it gets busy, but it didn't appear busy. Watching these guys it was hard not to think of the Keystone Cops, everybody was doing everything, taking money, answering the phone, throwing dough, making salad, checking the oven, bumping into each other, serving pizza. And only one person wearing gloves. Complete and utter disorganization. One guy actually checked the same pie in the oven 5 times! Seriously you don't how long it takes to bake a pizza? I understand checking baking progress - but 5 times? I think the most memorable event was when an employee "showed up" (looking like he had slept in his clothes for 3 days, gotta love that "pants about to fall off - look at my under wear" style) washed his hands, walked over to the freezer/cooler lifted up his shirt, scratched his chest and opened the cooler got out a dough and proceeded to make another crust!!! wow - hope that oven is hot enough to kill the cooties. It was painfully obvious that this place offers poor training and doesn't teach any systems. NIce kids working there, not their fault. Noah was great, friendly, helpful. Pizza was good, not great. read more

Must be missing something here. The pizza is so-so at best, usually with soggy crust. Living proof that bigger is not always better. Do yourself a favor and travel a couple of extra miles to Jersey Boys! read more

Amazing pizza!!! Good customer service! Every time I've gone in the staff is friendly. I love the managers specials!

The employees here were VERY nice. The pizza tasted great. BUT...as we were eating, one of the employees started cleaning the ceiling with some sort of spray. The cleaner was so strong that we could smell it from where we were sitting. And then we watched as he sprayed the cleaning fluid and the mist floated down towards the food and prep area; and towards the pizza ovens. Yes folks...there were toxins floating down into the food area and onto the food. Several hours later, even though the employee wasn't spraying while our pizza was being cooked, every single person in my family started having intestinal issues. I don't know if it is the fault of the employee or the employer, but either way, there may be toxins in the food you are eating here. We visit this area every year and will never eat at Cibelli's again. read more

Been a very good customer for well over a year and have always raved to others about their pizza slices. Today ordered a 24" pizza as I have done before and it had half the normal quantity of toppings as on the individual slices. Talked to the manager who could not have cared less. He gets an "F" for customer service. Their other employees are absolutely the BEST. Cassidy is a standout as well as one or two others. I think one is Travis. Hope the manager gets a clue and figures out that the customer (especially, long term faithful ones) are always right. That has been a maxim in business and great customer service for generations. read more

We got a giant pizza, I thought it was pretty good, boyfriend thought it was too chewy. Got a gluten free Hawaiian for mom, she wouldn't eat it because it looked so pathetic. They did manage to not overcook it, which is typically a problem with gluten free crust, but still, she didn't get dinner because of the poor presentation of it. It was pretty sad, cheese and topping were poorly disdributed. I am not super picky, but I agree, it didn't look appetizing. Service is good, very cheerful. read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - a pizza with ham and pineapples - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

Finally a four star worthy pizza. Cost is ideal and warranted. Taste is the best I have had thus far. We went big with the giant pizza and they aren't joking by naming it the giant. The pizza was the same size of my 2 year old daughter who normally can eat three or four pieces of pizza. She finished about half of a slice on this attempt. I couldn't go past two along with my wife, but it worked out because I had lunch the next day. It all started with the ordering call... talked to Kendra who was upbeat and customer oriented, making even the ordering a fun experience. Probably the best customer rapport I have seen yet in Deschutes. Comparative to McKays. Since Cibellis is across the street from our house, this will be a twice a week treat for dinner. Who knows, maybe more. I think this pizza has the ability to turn a frown upside down. read more

Decent pizza Fun, giant 24" pizzas Nice staff We ordered and paid in person for 2-24" pizzas over 7 hours ahead since it was a very busy, holiday and baseball weekend. When we went to pick up, it was very, very busy. They could only "find" one pizza. The same guy that sold it to us 7 hrs prior looked kind of embarrassed. One employee quietly said they had to sell it because they got too busy and we overheard it. By then, it was near 9pm with 18 starving kids. Not good. Wouldn't count on them if you need pizzas for a party fer' sure. The "coupon" they offered me was no use since it wasn't going to feed kids and the next 24" pizza would've been 45 more minutes. Sadly, they'll always get business since it's convenient when vacationing here with a gaggle of kids but they don't necc deserve it. read more

Have been to the Redmond location several times over the last few years Always great service and great food! Even on holidays the staff is cheery and very helpful. Will definitely be back! read more

Pretty good! Fast and yummy, but comparable to just every other regular pizza place for me. They need some cheesy filled bread and garlic ranch if you ask me! The table clothes look pretty tacky and make me wonder if they get cleaned well. But the food. Like I said, mediocre but a good mediocre. read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - Individual chicken and pineapple - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

See all

Great east coast pizza!! Brandon and Alex did a great job delivering a quality product!

Delicious. Giant slices are perfect for lunch. They have gluten free! The staff is very friendly. read more

Cibelli’s Pizza - Gluten free Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redmond, Oregon

See all

I'm an enthiast of Cibelli's pizza but had a horrible experience at this location. I ordered a pizzone and cheese bread. The worst part of the experience was when I brought up that the pizzone was partially burned to one of the cooks. He blamed it on having to cook the thicker part all the way through so sometimes the edges get burned. I admit I'm not a professional, but it sounded like a lame excuse for negligence/indifference to what your doing. Afterwards I found out that the dough was still not cooked all the way through despite being partially burnt and the cheese bread was bland and not up to par with what I've had from Cibelli's before. Really disappointing and never going back to this location. read more

This place is Awesome! Alex was so helpful and friendly! Made sure I got the best pizza and service possible! We will definitely be back!

I had always heard good things about this place from my kids, so, while staying at Eagle Crest, I decided to give it a try. My wife and I shared a Cobb Salad, and cheesy bread sticks and my kids ordered a pizza, which I tried one piece of, (one was enough). All I can say is, "Meh." Nothing to write home about. Very thin crust, like NY style, but had oil standing on top of it. Service was good and the kids working there were friendly. It's not great pizza, but not terrible either. Salad was pretty good, even if it was clearly made from stuff chopped up for pizzas. Reasonably priced for what it was. read more

Cibelli's is definitely A-OK. While by no means gourmet pizza, or the best in town, you know what you're getting with their pizza. And that's a consistent, good, and pretty cheap thin crust pizza pie. They're home to the massively ridiculously huge 24" pizza you have to see to believe. One slice is the equivalent of one pie anywhere else. It's a great spot to grab on the way home to feed the family--the kiddos love this place! I was unimpressed one day I stopped in for lunch for a slice. They had the pizzas under the warmers too long, threw the requested toppings on and then didn't event bother to warm it back up in the oven. It was not good. Stick to the whole pies here, and plan on take out instead of dine-in. read more

In town staying at Eagle Crest resort and was looking for a good place for the 20 people in our group to eat for dinner. Found this place by chance and were pleasantly surprised by the great pizza. Definitely will be back when in town again. read more

Short and sweet and to the point. Awesome pizza, awesome staff, fast and friendly service. We saw the sign for Cibellis pizza on the way to the Eagle Crest Resort. My husband was starving from our drive from Portland so as soon as we checked in we headed back into Redmond to try this pizza. This would be a 5 star review if the dough had a little more taste and texture. We ordered an "all meat" pizza, the sausage on the pizza was awesome but it definitely "stayed with us"! One of the best places we ate at while in Redmond, Oregon. read more

Cibellis is straight-up comfort pizza. Better than any other pizza place in town. $22 for a GIANT cheese pizza! Husband and I love coming here and they have amazing ranch- that's a deal breaker for me! read more

Hands down THE best pizza in Redmond. Simple, honest pizza, calzones, and salads. Don't waste your time going anywhere else, there are two locations in Bend and two in Redmond. Salads are crisp and fresh (and they have a large choice of selections). Get your pizza by the slice (HUGE slices) or get a whole pie. Only gripe I have is the drink cups...they're kinda tiny and I find myself having to go for refills often. read more

Their slices are pretty damn good. The dough reminds be of the pizzeria in my hometown in upstate new York. They almost have it! The pizzones are delicious and at least a meal and a half. Good value! read more

I normally like cibelli's, we haven't been there for a while, but when we went there for lunch it was a very dissatisfactory.I don't know what they changed but they're no longer my favorite pizza place yep most of our pizza slices didn't have cheese or sauce on it, it was very dry.so now we just go there for the salads.hopefully next time we go will try pizza again and see if it was just a temporary thing. read more

I found out about this place through my friends from Outward Bound while I was interning there last year. This is is the best pizza joint I have ever been to in my life! I always rave about this to my friends. Who knew Oregon would have the best tasting pizza? I love their perfectly crisp and delicious crusts. Their topping menu is incredible! Everyone must try Spinach and sausage (I believe it was finely grounded sausage) pizzas.... I've never sausage like that before and it was perfect with spinach. the portions of their slices are huge! Please open up one in San Francisco. You would make so much money and I would be so happy read more

Amazing pizza, the way it should have be made. Fast and nice staff. We randomly picked them and my family, from NY, said it was like NY pizza. Highly recommended. read more

Love the pizza. I just don't like sitting there watching the guy at the oven scratching his head and his nose with out washing his hands.then pulling my pizza off on to my plate. read more