Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    City Mill

    3.6 (244 reviews)
    ModerateHardware Stores
    Open • 6:30 am - 8:00 pm

    City Mill Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - City Mill

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Olfa Touch-knife....One of the handiest things I have!...
    Lyn L.

    I was initially disappointed that they no longer have drive up delivery. The cashier was kind of curt but the young man, Jordan, who ended up helping me was very nice and polite. Thank you.

    Tin Lung C.

    Support local! Well, if you want to find your item, going to Home Depot will be the best place to go to, they have a lot of items that covered almost most of your need for construction, however, I make it a point to go to City Mill from time to time because we have to support local. City mill has been around long before Home Depot and Lowe's come to town. Actually, shopping at City mill is much more leisure. Their service is good, the price may be a bit higher for some items but can be compatible too. They do have a couple of locations that close to where I live, so, it is always nice to have other choice for me to go to besides the big box stores. Once again. Please SUPPORT LOCAL

    The Screen Shop is located through the Lumber department in the far left corner of
    Joni P.

    Over time, screen windows can take a beating - pests, sun, weather, cleaning - and replacement is just the ticket to make you fall in love with a room(s) again. City Mill on Waialae was recommended to me by my contractor. I checked out other places, but the location was convenient and a great value. Burt took detailed measurements of my existing screens, while explaining the process and timeline it takes (their screen guy works part-time, and has a robust demand for his skill set to make replacement screens or repairs necessary. It would take up to 3 weeks to complete (5 screens, varying sizes). 5 days later, I got the call that my screens were ready! Not only were they perfect, but the timeline exceeded my expectations, and the price was great. When I went in to pick the screens up, Tom W. was the professional who assisted me - with the new screens, as well as with the original screens that I left as examples. I also purchased screen clips that needed to be replaced at the house. Overall, very happy with the quality and overall value of this service!

    Eric S.

    I've been a loyal City Mill customer since 2000, always choosing to support a locally owned and operated business over big-box stores like Home Depot or Lowe's. I've made it a point to check with City Mill first before going anywhere else -- that is, until my most recent experience. On my last visit, I needed to have two keys made -- one house key and one motorcycle key (with my own blank) -- as well as purchase some lumber and two saw blades for my circular and miter saws. The store was quiet, with only one other customer at the key counter, so I patiently waited my turn. When it was finally my turn, the older gentleman assisting customers at the key counter -- who appeared to be in his late 70s -- greeted me with no smile, no warmth, and a clear attitude of annoyance. I placed my keys on the counter, and he immediately picked up the blank motorcycle key, saying he couldn't make a copy and that I "might as well throw it away." I thought he was joking, but he slammed the key down on the counter and said, "How do you think this company makes money? Do you think we make money taking your blank and making copies?" At that point, it became clear he was serious and extremely rude. As a former business owner of nearly 20 years, I would never have allowed anyone representing my company to treat a customer that way. I told him I'd take my business elsewhere, and he dismissively waved his hands and said, "Go right ahead," as if I were the problem. Still in disbelief, I spoke with the manager to share what had just happened -- but unfortunately, she was less than helpful and offered no meaningful resolution or apology. After years of supporting City Mill, this experience completely changed my opinion of the company. I've decided I will no longer shop there and will instead take all my business to Home Depot or Lowe's from now on. This was a one-star experience from start to finish -- rude service, poor attitude, and no accountability from management.

    Before image
    Hélène C.

    This review is long overdue. Today Thomas in the paint department solved something that no YouTube video could answer, that the big box store made horrible recommendations for, to the point I thought I'd have to order a new desk and pay $168 for shipping plus the cost of my fav desk. I gave him photos and materials the desk was made of... he recommended paint - even had someone help to find the bright white to match - they opened new box and found perfect color and product!!! They are always helpful in every department sometimes there's a wait but they have great customer service skills - aloha all the way. Thomas also helped me last year to match touch up paint when I was moving out of an apartment match color perfectly and taught me what he needed to match it ... always above & beyond at City Mill!!! My goto place for hardware & garden help. PS they are locally owned and operated. Prices ... you get what you pay for. First photos cost me - time etc I was at Costco so I figured it was right there - never again totally wrong unprofessional solution!!! I am loyal to City Mill forever!!! They always serve with aloha from the keys department... to helping with garden supplies ... 2 pests & growing. Prices are good & Little tip you can find great savings & pieces of wood & materials in their leftover box.

    Rebecca T.

    Pretty good local hardware chain store with great selections and reasonable prices! The staff were not easy to locate but at least they were friendly. Quite a few people were shopping here when I went on a weekday. Found what I needed here - safety goggles, lightbulbs and gorilla super glue. Lots of different choices for safety goggles! I love how they arranged lightbulbs by lumen. Makes it easier to choose the right bulb quicker, unlike Home Depot where it's all over the place. The bathrooms were located in the gardening section at the back wall and you'll need a code to get in. A sizable parking lot too just for the store so it was easy to find parking. I used to go to Home Depot for all my house maintenance needs but now I have another choice too!

    Sanitizer

    See all

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 7 of 7

    City Mill Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - City Mill

    Review Highlights - City Mill

    “I'm a big fan of City Mill because it's a perfect mix of a local hardware store and giant home depot type place.”

    Mentioned in 6 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hardware Stores 3,408 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Industrial Hardware Hawaii - How  do you Load this ?

    Industrial Hardware Hawaii

    4.0(4 reviews)
    6.7 mi

    I have been looking for 3in washers forever and My husband finally found them here! They were fast…read moreand efficient and we couldn't ask for better service. We went up to a service window, told the worker what we wanted, and he went to get it. It's been so stressful trying to find these washer everywhere else but this was nice and easy. Thank you!

    My rating would be -5 stars, my over the phone experience was horrible! Called business to find out…read moreif they had a item that I needed person by the name or Ariel answered, I tried to provide him with the SKU number they had listed on their website so it would link it to the correct item, He said I need the description I cant pull it up by that SKU number, I asked wouldn't a SKU number be more efficient? he started to get upset, So I asked for a Manager on duty. Manager Maryann picked up the phone I tried to ask her the same question about the item I was looking for she had the same rude attitude not willing to address my concern nor providing me with any customer service. I asked Maryann to speak to the GM, She told me to call back at 7:30 and then hung up the phone not providing me with information on what I called the store for. Called the following morning to speak to the GM and Maryann had picked up and said he is not in and don't know when he will be in, so I had asked her, why did you tell me to call at 7:30am to speak to the GM she replied " are you calling to make trouble? your a trouble maker! stop making trouble you GIRL!" and hung up. This is not how any customer should be treated at all, I hope that Mike Cunningham the president and CEO of this store takes this kind of treatment from his staff towards possible customer's serious.

    Photos
    Industrial Hardware Hawaii

    See all

    City Mill - The original City Mill on Nimitz Hwy.

    City Mill

    3.8(184 reviews)
    4.2 mi
    •$$

    Generally not my first choice when I think of construction stuff, but when I need specific small…read morethings, they have a good selection. Batteries for you key fobs or any remotes, they have some of the best options. They also have a few aisles with all types of special screws or smart parts for furniture, appliances or caps etc. The parking lot is big, I've never seen it full. Check the hours before stopping by, they have less hours than the big box stores. Overall, I'd recommend them for hard to find house or construction related items.

    I have duplicate keys made in City Mill majority of the time. I had 2 keys made, somehow, it did…read morenot work. I had to go back and have it redone. In the past, I had no issues. Today 9/21/2026, somehow, I felt that I was being interrogated, or felt like I was stupid and did not know how to use the key. I was even asked what machine was used to make the key. Good thing I remembered. Then I kind of heard a comment by them saying that the "Machine may be sensitive". I was also thinking it could be the person that mad the key. I am the innocent customer just wanting to have the correct key. If possible , I do not want to spend precious time going back there to remake the key. A manager or he seemed like a manager, made the keys with the old machine. I came home and the 2 keys worked fine. Next time, I will just get a refund and have my key/ keys redone. Less interrogation. Please trust the customers. !!!

    Photos
    City Mill - Paint department

    Paint department

    City Mill - Furniture for your home

    Furniture for your home

    City Mill - Hello Kitty !!

    See all

    Hello Kitty !!

    Lowe's Home Improvement

    Lowe's Home Improvement

    1.9(1.2k reviews)
    4.4 mi
    •$$

    Growing up I pretty much recall people shopping at City Mill when it came to pick up items for home…read moreimprovement and gardening. But step in powerhouses of Home Depot that opened in Iwilei in 1999 and then Lowe's Home Improvement (LHI), that took over Eagle Hardware and Garden in Waikele and then opened this location in Iwilei in 2011. LHI originated in North Carolina in 1921 and has expanded to over 1700 locations nationwide. They also tested their home improvement business in neighboring Canada and Mexico but currently only focuses in the United States. I've been to LHI a handful of times and although I'm not a professional, I've noticed the pricing here is more economical than their rivals but lacks in the customer service. It can be very challenging at times so reach out to a sales associate for assistance. I do like there's also ample parking and multiple entries to LHI as Nimitz Highway can be congested during peak hours so it's better to enter here from the back entrance. I recently came here to shop for refrigerators as they also carry a large selection. Luckily my BIL accompanied me and he's quite knowledgeable with the different features and various companies. There were some questions we had and unfortunately it wasn't easy to flag down an associate. We did come across several not to far away but they were either huddled up socializing or not available as this guy was busy with his cellphone. Although LHI had a model that I was interested in as well as less expensive for an identical model, i ended up selecting a refrigerator with their main competitor. It doesn't hurt to do due diligence. LHI is a great option for those who are knowledgeable in this field and don't need much service. But for your everyday average Joe, customer service could be better here to address questions and concerns to home improvement.

    I visited Lowe's today to exchange a broken Kobalt 3/8" ratchet because they tout this lifetime…read morewarranty... Go to customer service, you have to go select it and bring it back for exchange. Of course, there is none in stock. Have it in stock? Nope... Can you order it for me? Nope.. if it's not in stock there is nothing we can do.... WHAT? What about the warranty? Sorry, nothing we can do... So much for the Lifetime Warranty! In my years of visiting this Lowe's, this was the worst experience I have had! Rude, short, and not helpful!! What a disappointment! Normally, they are pretty good, today should be zero stars JUST FOR POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE!

    Photos
    Lowe's Home Improvement
    Lowe's Home Improvement
    Lowe's Home Improvement

    See all

    City Mill - hardware - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...