Food was great! Definitely recommend a reservation because place is always packed. Server Maille Rose was so attentive. Lovely atmosphere! read more

See all

We had a great time at Claudios for lunch with the kids. Great atmosphere watching the boats The service from our server Maille was outstanding and made the trip all that much better. read more

Matt and Careen were terrific! The food was delicious and the service was top notch. We had both of them as servers and they did not disappoint. They were fun and engaging anf kept us on our toes! read more

Amazing service and food!!! Rob was the best Hell yuh dis place goated no cap (from Jack, age 16) read more

My husband and I made a day trip out east to enjoy lunch and spend some time walking around town. When we arrived at Claudio's, we put our name on the waitlist and were told the wait would be about 30 minutes. After returning, we waited another 15-20 minutes at the host stand before being informed there was a kitchen issue and that they were no longer seating guests. The host assured us that we would still be able to order food, but after finally being seated, our waiter told us the kitchen was no longer serving food because of the same issue. After waiting roughly 25 minutes just to place an order and watching food continue to come out of the kitchen the entire time, our frustration kept growing. We eventually received our meal, but it was honestly mediocre. There are likely much better places to eat in the area. The waterfront setting and live music were enjoyable, and that's really what you're paying for. Unfortunately, the poor communication, long waits, and overall experience outweighed the positives for us. read more

Service poor. Took a while to get silver ware, napkins, etc. only came to check on how things were after we were done. Waitress not knowledgeable about the menu. Food bland. Prefer Billy's by the Sea read more

Nice location - large and on the water. Service was great, very quick. Food portion sizes were extremely large. Both Cesar salad and nachos were huge. Went with friends and couple cocktails ( smaller size for espresso). Enjoyed other dishes such as lobster roll and fries. Overall good and recommend read more

Claudio's Waterfront - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

Tourist trap serving fresh from the freezer bag to microwave oven food. I would rather eat at a gas station

Claudio's is a great place to have some drinks, food and listen to live music on the water. The food is always good and reasonably priced. It's always great to see Tara, Tiffani, Anthony and Dave behind the bar as well. The four of them know great service and are always very friendly. There have been plenty of very busy weekends this summer, Tara and Tiffani hold it down! read more

We just stopped by for two beers and calamari and our experience was really bad. First the beers are being served in a 10 oz cup for $10 and the calamari were super over fried and not eatable. That was $28. I shouldn't have accepted the food but I wasn't quick enough to return it. For those prices I expected a better quality. read more

Claudio's Waterfront - Receipt - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

Food bad Service incompetent Ambiance spirited Charged twice for each dish and refused to correct the bill read more

Had an IG push for Captain Claudio's Bloody Mary which is a pitcher of Bloody Mary with a lobster, shrimp and bacon in it so we HAD to do it with our friends. It did not disappoint and just seeing it before drinking/eating it was a great experience. We enjoyed the bloody with a side of mimosas and then a bunch of food. The food (chicken wrap, Mahi tacos, chicken fingers and pasta with the last two being for the kids) was pretty good. You're truly coming to this place for the scenery and some drinks. Easy to bring kids and enjoy a convo with friends. Our waitress was wonderful and kind getting the kids orders in first, finding some coloring sheets and crayons and dealing with our party of 8. We had a lot of fun and left fill and tipsy! read more

Claudio's Waterfront - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

The appetizer food and service was great for lunch service. Olivia was attentive to our needs and very friendly. read more

Claudio's Waterfront - Half oysters, fries & calamari with dirty martinis - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

Valetin was very friendly and made a great drink. I would recommend going there. Can't wait too come back.

Pay in cash or they will charge your credit card an extra 200$. Not really sure how to expect to get paid back but they have done this my past two times attending- the first time I thought I was going crazy but gave them the benefit of the doubt. My friend was charged an extra 150$ as well. read more

Almost anything open-air and by the sea will get thumbs up from me. Claudio's is such a place situated in a cute village on the far north fork of Long Island. A summertime excursion is making a day of visiting the town of Greenport, where Claudio's is located and shopping is abundant. Oftentimes, we take the ferries from Sag Harbor. On the return trip, we have the ferry option and/or driving through the towns to our final destination. Since Claudio's is usually busy, I made a reservation prior to shopping. I asked if Steamers were available. The hostess confirmed they were. Twenty-five minutes later, seated at a table looking out at the dock and sea, I asked the waitress about if Steamers were available. Her reply, "As of this morning, no they are not." Although we enjoyed the scenery, good service, our seafood wraps, tacos and French fries, I remained disappointed. read more

See all

The service by Amanda was wonderful! She was extremely nice and attentive! We took my Dad and he absolutely loved the raw clams and mussels!

Me and my family come here every Father's Day for the wonderful water front dining and also the great food.... But this visit was something that was not worth any of our time. As soon as we get there me and my family can see CLEARLY 8 tables open for sitting, the host tells us that there is a 1 hour and 30 minute wait. Okay fine, we put our number on the wait list and do some traveling around greenport. We wander back about an hour and 10 minutes later... and tell me why I see the SAME 8 tables open? Are you serious, we ask the host kindly why those tables are still open after we waiting and she rudely gives us attitude and tells us "there's 7 people ahead of you give me 5 minutes" okay tell me why she sat us 2 minutes later... seems to have caught someone lacking... okay now we are seated and our waitress is taking her sweet time coming to take our order. At least 15 minutes go by and she FINALLY makes her way over and takes our order. Now tell me why it took us 30-40 minutes to receive our food and when our food came to the table, only three plates came out instead of four. Our waitress says she would get the plate right away. Lies. She had another plate and went to another table and still made my mom wait another 5-10 minutes FOR HER PLATE. One of our orders was overcooked and charred. My order had a side of fries and I only received about five french fries. And tell me why we had to ask for ketchup3 times when the table beside us was already served ketchup before their meal came. We had an order of four fries and we had to ask for ketchup about 3 times. The cherry on the cake for this unfortunate experience was the fact that we watched a table get seated while we were waiting for our food and get their food in about 20 minutes. It's been a long time since I've had such poor service from a restaurant. I understand that it was a holiday, but you guys should be on your a game. be better. read more

This is a sad review for me and my family to write. I am 52 years old and have been coming to Greenport for nearly 45 years. My first visit was as a five-year-old child in the 1970s, when my immigrant parents would make the trip from Jackson Heights. Over the decades, we made this journey countless times with family and friends. One of my fondest memories of Greenport was the constant presence of Claudio's--a family-owned institution that, despite not being a local resident, made me feel connected to the community. Sadly, that connection is gone. My wife and I recently chose Claudio's to celebrate our 30th wedding anniversary, expecting to revisit a place that had been part of our family's history for decades. Instead, we found a restaurant that bears little resemblance to what made it special. The menu was extremely limited, with surprisingly few seafood options. The ambiance was cold, sterile, and uninviting. On a Sunday afternoon, the restaurant was nearly empty, which was not a good sign. What saddened me most was not even the disappointing menu. It was the complete absence of the warmth, character, and sense of place that once defined Claudio's. The restaurant feels like an empty shell of its former self. The history, charm, and personality that made generations of visitors return year after year seem to have disappeared. For those of us who have loved this place for decades, it is genuinely heartbreaking to witness. Claudio's was more than just a restaurant--it was part of the fabric of Greenport. Seeing what it has become is deeply disappointing and, frankly, very sad. read more

Had a great time while there. The service was awesome and this was directly related to the two servers (Matt and Careen). I can't say enough on their engaging personalities and quick service and fast replies. This also goes for the manager ( Kevin ) who was also very pleasant and helpful. All I can day is thank you!!! Matt, Careen and Kevin for making our visit feel like a lihht family get together. David read more

Visited on June 19 during the USA World Cup game. The crowd was fun cheering on the USA. We ordered nachos, raw clams, baked clams, coconut shrimp as apps. All delish. Ordered fried tacos, lobster Mac and cheese, Cobb salad and lobster roll for main meals with a side of onion rings - all great. Margaritas and the blue drink (forgot the name) were delish. Too full for desert. Stephen was our waiter. He was on it, kind, everything came out as ordered. They're lucky to have him!! Highly recommend Claudio's and asking for Stephen as your waiter!! read more

Claudio's Waterfront - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

Olivia was the absolute best!!! Made my night, great service, so attentive. Thank you!!!!

I want to be fair and honest here, we stopped in last night with a party of 11 and were seriously underwhelmed. Let's start with the positives; staff was friendly, weather was outstanding and the vibe was very relaxed. Now the criticism; service was painstakingly slow starting with the bar and following to the table. Getting drinks and food within a reasonable timeframe seemed outside the staff's capabilities. Food was below my expectations. I ordered a marinated steak which for the price point was poor. The requested cook was acceptable but there was no flavor. I would have expected a better quality meat with a proper marinade at $42. Nacho appetizer was average, Fried calamari was very good but the thimble of sauce was insufficient, chicken wings never showed up. The overall bill was fairly priced for a waterfront experience but I'd be in no rush to return. read more

We had such a great time at Claudio's Waterfront! The vibe, people, and staff were all great. We met so many people visiting and enjoying life. The food was great! We are already making plans to go back soon before the summer is over, and you should too! read more

Claudio's Waterfront - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

I always love coming to Claudios, but my most recent visit really was amazing due to Rosie's great service at the bar. Rosie made drink suggestions for me and everything she suggested was delicious. I really don't see myself coming back here if Rosie is not here. read more

Claudio's Waterfront - Mudslide - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

$57 crab legs overcooked and not edible. It was the only thing my celiac girlfriend could eat. Her stomachs now hurting prob due to poor quality. I'm not a frequent complainer, this is new. I wouldn't recommend ordering anything here that requires elevated levels of cooking experience. read more

Service was a complete disaster, extremely slow and inattentive. Disappearing server - here for 2 min gone for 20. Draught beer was warm? How? The food? The food you ask? Absolute piles of slop resembling hospital cafeteria quality ingredients. Shrimp cocktail was putrid, cocktail sauce was so weak I could have used it as off brand ketchup, no flavor at all, shrimp were soggy like they were laying in water for two days, disgusting. The fish and chips appeared to be deep fried roofing shingles, fried beyond recognition, French fries are from a bag frozen, unseasoned and flavorless. If I never come here again it would be too soon. Total rip off, prices are very high for the piles of shit you get on the plate. read more

Claudio's Waterfront - Seafood Near Me - Greenport, New York

This place is gross. Food is the worst you can find out in Greenport. Should probably not be in business.

We bookmarked Claudio's Waterfront after seeing a photo of the Captain Claudio's Bloody Mary. We didn't end up ordering it (it's $115). But it is a 35 oz drink that comes with a 1.25# lobstah, 8 shrimp, bacon, olives, celery, and grilled jalapenos. Def sharable. Claudio's is a popular spot for pier dining in Greenport right on the bay. Only one of us ordered food-the beau got the fish and chips-while our drink order consisted of a very strong dark and stormy, a frozen marg, and a frozen lemonade. The lemonade wasn't too frozen, but my frozen marg was great! Even better was a Casamigos promo gal walking around giving away shots/samples, so I topped off my drink. Music was kinda a vibe kill. Made the place feel like a loud bar in Cancun. If you park on the pier, you'll pay for parking, but Claudio's has a 50% off coupon at the host stand. read more

So good and so fun! We had the smash burger and fish tacos and loved them. Carine was our server and she was amazing!

It was a fun time but my friends toe was gushing blood. No exaggeration. All over the bathroom floor and me and 4 other friends were asking all bartenders and bouncers for a bandaid or a first aid kit and no one at the bar had one or anyone nearby. That is a OSHA violation. The best thing we got was blue painters tape and napkins. 20 mins later. So hopefully a manager sees this and they get a first aid kit at least because that's unacceptable. Blood everywhere on the bathroom floor. And no one seemed to care besides the girls in the bathroom asking if she was ok. But no workers could find a bandaid read more

Rosie is the best bartender ! Sweet and attentive and makes mean a negroni! Keep on her all summer long !

The Lobster rolls were the best we've ever had!! The service, exceptional!!Careen was wonderful!! She was so attentive, polite and so happy and upbeat! Wonderful experience we hope to repeat very soon! read more

I've lived on Long Island for forever and can't believe this is the first time I've been here. The CT lobster roll was so good and the vibes were amazing. Our waitress Careen was so sweet and friendly and consistently checked on us even on a busy afternoon. read more

We had a great early dinner , I had a great warm lobster roll a lot of lobster. It was delicious! Our server Victoria was extremely attentive and friendly. We are definitely coming back. read more

Stephen was fantastic!!!! The food was delicious!!! We loved the calamari and tacos. We will definitely return.

Rosie is the cutest bartender I have ever met! She was so sweet and helpful, I have decision anxiety and she made me such a good cocktail. And my friends margaritas were perfect! read more

Came in with a group and had the most pleasant experience. The atmosphere was perfect for our get together. Our server Emily was the sweetest and so attentive to our needs. One person in our group had an allergy and she was very knowledgeable and accommodating. Shared some apps and everything was delicious. After we finished dining we headed to the bar where our bartender Hannah served us tasty cocktails. Great time all around I will definitely be back! read more

We visited Claudio's on their opening day this season for a birthday celebration. Matt, our server, was so kind and took such great care of us. Can't wait to visit again! read more

Service was excellent. Food was fantastic. Brianna was our waitress and knocked it out of the park. We'll be back.