Amazing meat!!! They really know how to cook and the BBQ sauces are fantastic. Best hush puppies I have ever had anywhere. Friendly locally owned and the source local for products they use and meat. Look for the list on the tables. They get the food out to you fast too. read more

We were first time customers today 3/26/21. I ordered a one meat dinner with turkey, green beans and cole slaw. I rec'd 4 slices of turkey from an incredibly salty institutional turkey roll. Not real turkey, not shredded, not smoked, just salt. The green beans were mushy and covered in a butter sauce so thick that I couldn't taste any bean flavor. Disgusting. The cole slaw was " o.k." The barbeque sauce was somewhat peppery, but that is a very individual preference for people. I literally threw my dinner away. I do not recommend this restaurant. read more

I recently moved to Warren and was looking for a new place to go for dinner. I'm so happy that I picked Cockeye BBQ! It was so good! I love the atmosphere and the owner came out to talk to all of the guests- very friendly! I will definitely be back read more

Deliciousness. Hometown folks serving up the best BBQ around. The people are fantastic and the food is always hot. Cheesy potatoes on the menu? YUM read more

The best BBQ around hands down. I would recommend trying their handhelds and burgers. I think they put a lot of thought into creating their menu items. Always be on the watch for new clothesline specials! Overall the customer service is the best I've ever seen and the owners are constantly in the restaurant working too. Wide menu selection and delicious food. Well deserving five stars! read more

What an amazing experience at this local joint from the moment I walked in the assistant manager Ariel took great care of me at the register, advising me as a first-timer. Even something as simple as walking to the napkin dispenser an employee quickly pulled out three napkins to hand them to me, kudos to the owner and management for holding such a high standard. Special shout out to Kim who took a few minutes to talk with me about the quality food and great ice cream next door. Beautiful, kind,& caring why go anywhere else do yourself a favor get take out or eat in patronize this great local business. read more

Visiting from Dallas Texas and had brisket, ribs, and sausage. Absolutely amazing - better than any BBQ I've had in Dallas. You have to go to Austin to find Texas BBQ this good. read more

Such great customer service the owners are soooo nice and the food is awesome!! Highly recommend their ice cream too!

We eat from here just about every Sunday. It's so delicious, always hot and served from friendly staff. Make sure you stop next door at Cockeye Creamery for amazing ice cream too. read more

Had my wife's birthday party catered Saturday. Nothing but good complements from our guests. First time using Cockeye BBQ. Will be going back. Prices fair for what you get. read more

Very friendly atmosphere, clean and the food is good. The bbq is seasoned and I love that they support the local suppliers! My faves are the cheesy potatoes and the bbq brisket! read more

I absolutely love love love this place!!! Their pulled pork is the best around! Never a bad meal or bad service anytime I been in there... great place to at... the area isn't the best.. but the place it's self makes up for that! read more

Order from here frequently and like to "spread it around." I'm a brisket guy and there's is the best around. Have had the ribs, the "slaw-TER house" burger, and pulled pork all without complaints. Let's be honest, it's a BBQ place... the meats SHOULD be pretty damn good, and they are... what sets them apart are the sides, service, and menu. I'm an Irish kid, so potatoes are pretty important to me. The Joe-Joe's have some sort of magical coating that sets them far above anyplace else in the area. (I'm suspecting some sort of crack, but that's just a hunch!) The cheesy potatoes are simply sublime (Sorry mom, they gotcha beat!) and the hush puppies... oh, the hush puppies. 2 with each dinner plate, are enough to make ya order a few more. The standards are really well done too; baked potato, slaw, and collard greens all are worth their weight! Enough about those though, let's talk about the real showstopper.... fried cheese grits! Again, I'm suspecting these are real grits, cooked to perfection and given to a Southern voodoo queen to concoct a potion of unforgettable crunch and flavor. I imagine it goes something like this, cook grits, apply magic, viola! side dish heaven. My dad, the vegetarian, had no trouble ordering just sides (and taking home a doggie bag!) The people here are amazing, just the right mixture of checking in on the experience with enough "self-serve" options to make it an enjoyable experience. There has not been a time when I was not greeted by an owner. However, I can also say I wouldn't know the difference between the "owners and employees." I think this speaks volumes about the way the place is run. The menu itself does not appear to be that large, until you start reading it. There is a simplicity to it really makes ordering a breeze. The ability to mix and match makes for the large combination of items. They also keep a small but very well-rounded cooler of unique Pop and microbrews. Any good beer snob (myself included) should find a bottle to their liking. My suspicion is that this place will very quickly outgrow it's surroundings. I hope not, but the word is out... Cockeye is the real deal and so much more. read more

An excellent BBQ restaurant. This places serves up real southern style BBQ. Their secret ingredient is wood and talented BBQ practitioners.

We went here yesterday and the food was really amazing! I especially loved the brisket and the ribs. We all enjoyed our meal. It was superb! Definitely a taste of Southern Cooking heaven! The wait staff are very friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere was awesome as well. Very cozy and warm! I would love to come back for more. For those who haven't been here, it's definitely a must try! read more

We ordered takeout and everything was awesome! Fried shrimp, pulled pork, turkey, cheesy potatoes, Mac n cheese, and a pulled chicken sandwich. Everything was great and the entire order was prepared correctly/as asked. I was glad my husband got some takeout containers of sauce to try as I like a lot of sauce and they were all great. The restaurant itself looked very nice and it was busy. We will be back for sure! read more

Really good BBQ for this area. Meats (brisket, pulled pork, chicken wings, breaded catfish) were all cooked perfectly with some great smokiness. However, the sauce was a little sweet to our liking, personal preference. The hush puppies were some of the best we've ever had. We also ordered some pig ears in a 3-pepper aioli that was simply fantastic. A really well-balanced meal. Will likely return when we're in the area again. read more

This is how a business should be run! Cockeye's brings delicious BBQ to the Westside of Warren. The owners are on site and just as pleasant as can be. They care about your experience...a lot and it shows. They also buy locally when possible and genuinely care about their neighbors and city! Pride in what they do and how they do it would be enough to set them apart but their food is beyond amazing. Big helpings, good prices and fantastic food. I am proud to place them up with Warren's best and famous. I have had everything on their menu though not every special, and I can truthfully say I have loved everyone of them. How many places can you say that about? Stop in, feast and make sure to add some corn casserole as a side! read more

No beating around the bush. I kept hearing word of mouth buzz about Cockeye's. Took the wife, stopped in; was expecting "less" in seatability and dining in capability based on some reviews, but in reality plenty of room, booths, tables and the such. Saturday night, place was buzzin', but our orders were placed promptly.... Place your order, grab your plastic cutlery and whatnot, and have a seat- you're food's brought out to you (also, side note, very helpful pleasant young lady greeting customers at the door, assisting folks with the menu, answering questions, etc) I had the two meat platter (pulled pork and brisket) with cheesy potatoes and fried okra, the missus had a hand held pulled pork......OMG, delish. Okra was fresh, crunchy and not "greasy", the potatoes tasted oh-so home made. My meats were perfect. I haven't had bbq this good in quite a while. AND, glad I only opted for the 2 meat instead of 3, which I was contemplating, as the portions were very generous. One observation, tho, was my wife's pulled pork sandwich, excellent as it was, could have benefited from some more sauce on it. A minor pecadillo, but I'd simply make a note to order some sauce on the side my next trip. And there will be a next trip, as the restaurant definitely merits another round. Well done, Cockeye!!! read more

Cockeyed BBQ is the best BBQ in town. I got the BBQ chicken dinner with cheese potatoes and coleslaw. I was delicious! The chicken was very juicy. My husband also got a pulled pork sandwich and it was very tender. The prices are reasonable. read more

Nothing negative to share. Love the food. Very quick on filling lunch orders. Eric and his staff are very friendly and are the go to place for BBQ. They also have their own ice cream now! read more

I found this place via a recommendation from a friend. So far, I've only had the wings and they are phenomenal. The bbq sauces are heavenly, the service is prompt, and there's a good variety of options on the menu from sandwiches to wings to brisket. Pricing is pretty good as well, you won't break the bank going here. read more

I love the ribs, pulled pork, baked beans, coleslaw, and potato salad. Have only ordered carry out so far but I love the atmosphere and want to try dining in too. Service and employees are great!! This place is the real deal! read more

Tried cockeye bbq for the first time today! Our dinners were amazing, you got so much food!! Hubby had the pork with Mac & cheese & coleslaw and I had the pork & brisket with fries & corn casserole! We have enough food for 2 more dinners!! I highly recommend it!! Can't wait to order again soon!! The meat was so tender & delicious!! read more

A hidden gem for great BBQ! Menu has great choices for meats and the sides are just as good! I had the brisket, while it wasn't as smoky flavored as I've had before, it was juicy and great tasting. We all shared sides of cheesy potatoes, Cajun fries and corn casserole which were all awesome! I wish we lived closer so we could visit this restaurant more often! read more

I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but my husband and I both ordered 2 meat bbq dinners and the best part was the pickle. The brisket was horribly dry (we did ask for sauce and got about a tablespoon worth) and tasted like it was roasted (not smoked) for minutes ( not hours) in the microwave, the bbq chicken was dramatically flavorless, the ribs were stringy dry and overcooked, the corn casserole was basically crumbled cornbread with extra corn and the coleslaw tasted straight out of a container bought at GFS. We have heard rave reviews for this place for years and finally decided to indulge. Couldn't be more disappointed and let down. Never again. read more

We first heard of this place through a friends Facebook post, we decided that we would try it out. As soon as we walk in, everyone is as friendly as could be! They gave us plenty of time to look at the menu and get our drinks. They also have really cool t-shirts! We ordered so much food and for so cheap! They have very great prices! The food service was the quickest of any restaurant I've ever been to (not lying). And the food did not let us down, AMAZING!! 10/10 would totally recommend!! read more

I absolutely love to eat here. The staff is friendly and makes you feel at home. No pressure on ordering, a kind of "take your time to decide what you want" place. The food is excellent; I have enjoyed every meal that I have ordered. It is rapidly becoming my new favorite place to eat. read more

See all

What a pleasant surprise in Warren . . . top, local ingredients; properly smoked and total good production from a good kitchen; varied and interesting beer selection; and . . . the prices . . . I'm not in New York anymore. . . Definitely worth a lunch or dinner stop read more

Good food and prices, you have to buy cans or 2 liters of soda to drink which seems a little unorthodox but it's no biggie. They also have a couple different sauces but their not that good. Overall it's good food and ok service. read more

There is BBQ, and there is life changing BBQ. I've had some pretty good stuff in Memphis, St. Louis, and Alabama, but this was some of the best anywhere. I had a 3 meat plate with brisket, pullled pork, and ribs with slaw and corn casserole sides. Every single thing was amazing. Great attention to detail and awesome flavor and texture. Great beer to boot, place is damn near perfect. Seriously. read more

Cockeye Bbq - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

If you're looking for great tasting local barbecue, certainly stop by Cockeye BBQ. When you walk in, you feel as if you could be related to the owners and you become a part of the community culture. You cannot go wrong with any of the sides they offer with your meal. They have many meat selections and their sandwiches are delicious. I also would recommend just a veggie/side meal, as their sides are phenomenal. High recommend. read more

what a wonderful asset to the smithfield area! this charming local restaurant is always a pleasant, clean & a safe place to grab a variety of delicious meals. their servers are constantly wiping tables down while wearing their face masks, not just to comply with the virginia laws, but also to protect their customers. they are all thoughtful, courteous, & efficient. the menu has something for everyone including gluten free diners. veggies are fresh each day. orange juice is fresh squeezed & delicous! they serve breakfast & lunch foods all day & are opened 3 nights (thursday. friday, & saturday) until 8 pm with varying dinner meals. i highly recommend!! sharon, smithfield read more

My hubby and I love to try new places. I seen this place a few times on Yelp and decided to give them a try. Nice little place, quick friendly service. The good was great. We shared the 3 meat dinner with the cornbread casserole, cheesy potatoes and added the Mac and cheese. Our meats were the white meat chicken, pulled pork and brisket. Everything came out quickly and was piping hot. The chicken was covered in their bbq sauce and very moist and flavorful. The pulled pork was smokey and my personal favorite. The brisket was hubby's favorite. We had enough for leftovers to take home. We will definitely be going back read more

We got take-out from here, and it was great. When we ordered on the phone, they said to come in 5 to 10 minutes, and it was really ready that quickly. Though we ordered less than an hour before closing (on a weeknight), they weren't out of anything. I loved my brisket, and our chicken, pulled pork, mac and cheese, and joe joes (like giant fried potato wedges) were good too. read more

We celebrated father's day one day early because my dad was going to visit his dad on father's day. He was in the mood for BBQ and wanted something that was close to us and he found this place. It was only about 15-20 minutes away from us. We decided to try it. First the parking lot was just redone by the looks of it and so there are no lines marking where to park. It's also a fairly small lot. We walked in and it's a fairly small place with some seating. It is not a sit down and order from a wait staff sort of place. It is an order at the counter and if you sit in dining they are supposed to bring it out to you or you stand around and wait for them to call your number. They have a small menu which is fine. I don't remember seeing the prices for their canned/bottled beverages anywhere, so we did not know how much we paid for our drinks until after we got the receipt. I know for sure they were not on the menu. They do let you have unlimited water, I think. It could have been iced tea or lemonade that you pour into a cup. I can't really remember. In any case the prices for them were pretty much what I expected them to be. Anyway, my mom decide to have a fried chicken sandwich and fries, I decided on their Pitmaster burger with fries, and my dad got a cup of Brunswick stew, baked beans, and the chopped brisket sandwich. My dad enjoyed his meal. My opinion was that they could have added a little more brisket to his sandwich and the side of baked beans could have been a little bigger. To me it looked like just two scoops and they were gone. The stew was a perfect portion and he said he liked it. It's because of this they get 1 star at all. My moms' sandwich had two chicken tenders, which were not all that big. I believe I saw two slices of tomato, which were perfect size, and some lettuce. We asked for no mayo because she isn't too crazy about mayo. She said her bun was cold, as in just thawed from freezer, and the chicken was not as hot as she expected it to be. I believe she said it was luke warm. Now, my buns were pretty much the same as hers. I expected thin burger, it was a 1/4 pounder after all, but it was supposed to have brisket on top. I got one small slice of brisket. It was topped with a fair amount of thin crispy onions and BBQ sauce. It had cheese on it as well. The sauce was all I tasted. If I hadn't seen the small slice of brisket I never would have known it was there. All I tasted was sauce. It was not worth $8.99. Now to the fries. They came out in a bag. The amount of fries was perfect if not for the fact they were soggy/limpy as heck. The only good thing about them was that they were not overly salty. My family does not use/eat a lot salt. I saw a couple of people com into the dining area after they placed their order. The one woman behind the counter saw them and told them their order was up and the man got up to get their order even though it should have been brought out to them. Either they are regulars or this place is very inconsistent because it was another 5 minutes before our order was brought out to us and we got there before them. I wonder if our order was sitting at the counter waiting for us to pick it up before someone realized they should have brought it out to us. Don't tell us you're going to bring it out to us if you expect us to pick it up. On the bottom of their receipt it says "slow food...fast!". That was not my experience. One last note before I end this review. About half an hour later I started to feel sick. I'm not sure if it was because it was extremely hot and humid that day or the food, but I certainly will not be going back. If my dad wants to he is on his own. read more

Tender beef brisket and ribs. Quick service. Friendly staff. Seating area is small. If you go during a busy time you may have to wait to sit down. We will return. read more

Good prices. Fast service. Bbq and microbrews. I had the pulled pork nachos. They were great.

The food was excellent, unfortunately I'm just not a fan of the house BBQ sauce- just wasn't to my taste and next time I order the mess plate I'll just switch the sauce. Otherwise I had the mess plate, onion rings, and Jo-Jo's and it was all made to perfection. read more

It's very good! I've had the pulled pork there twice now & it's as good as any pulled pork I've had. The meat is so tender & melts in your mouth & I love the sweet barbecue sauce. It's a must try for anyone who enjoys good barbecue in the area! read more