Found this place through Facebook and it was impressive !! Had the ribs, cheesy potatoes and corn casserole. I have NEVER had better BBQ around here ever !! The place was beautiful on the inside and the owner went over everything we needed to know. BBQ sauces were out of this world. Will definitely be back very soon ! read more

Cockeye Bbq - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

See all

Best BBQ in the area, pretty good portions too. We drive 40 minutes to eat here. Get the brisket, but save room for some icecream, delicious. read more

Nice atmosphere. Pretty decent bbq. I had a brisket dinner. The brisket was pretty dry which is about the only reason for 4 stars and not 5. Sides were good. I would go back if in the area. Service was very good. Short review but not much to say on this one. Also the sauces were pretty decent. read more

Very cute place, love the asmosphere and decor! Food was delicious, got the Messy Plate, wil get it again. Highly recommend. Followed by Jackson 5 ice cream cone from the Ice cream shopin the back! Delicious! read more

Brisket - 5 stars Pulled Pork - 5 stars Pork ribs - 3 stars (kind of dry) Mac and cheese - 3 stars (kind of dry) Cheesy Potatoes - 5 stars The Pitmaster burger - 5 stars read more

My first visit to Warren for business, and had time for lunch. Lucky me, cuz I found Cockeye BBQ. When you walk in, no actually before you get in the door, you will be blown away by the aroma of the Smokey goodness cooking inside. I'm definitely coming back cuz I couldn't try everything. Judging from the fact that it got packed quickly with the lunch crowd, I'm sure it's one of the BEST places in town. Judging from how good everyone else's plates looked as the waitress delivered them to the table, I've got lots of dishes to try on future visits. read more

Cockeye Bbq - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Great BarBQue! Cheesey potatoes, corn casserole, baked beans and green beans...yum, yum Friendly, clean atmosphere. read more

Best BBQ in the area!! Omg! Delish! Cool atmosphere, friendly people. Owners are there every time we go and are very welcoming.

Every time we would try this place the brisket was so overcooked and dry. BBQ is average at best.

Cockeye has the potential to one day achieve Hot Dog Shoppe/Sunrise status in the Warren area. The bbq is absolutely amazing. Everything I have had there has been good, but the brisket especially is absolutely out of this world. The smoky flavor, burnt tips, and amazing sauce all come together to achieve perfection, and I'd recommend it both on a sandwich or as dinner meal. Be sure to combine it with their amazing cheesy potatoes. I moved away to CA, and Cockeye has joined Hot Dog Shoppe as one of the "must-do's" when I am home in Ohio. It is really nice seeing a local restaurant do well, and I am excited to see Cockeye become a Warren staple! read more

One of the best places to eat at in Warren. My boyfriend and I can't get enough of it. Our favorite is the mess plate with fries, so good! And the staff here are very helpful and friendly. read more

Cockeye Bbq - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

I love the food here definitely something unique! And has great potential for people around the city to sit and enjoy the goodness!

Family outing. Food was not bad, decent. People super-nice. Place was clean but could have been cleaner.

Incredibly tasty BBQ. We had pulled pork, baked potatoes and hush puppies. Offering BBQ sauce on side is a very good idea. Not to mention it's a very cheap place. Totally worth it. read more

Cockeye Bbq - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Awesome place. Great food! They even have their own ice cream. Highly recommended for any BBQ lover!

Yum Yum Yum..... We are from out of town (PA) and were in the area for the Thanksgiving Holiday and came across Cockeye's. We are so glad we did. I got the pulled bbq sandwich, my daughter got the fried chicken and my husband got the bbq platter w/ribs. Everyone enjoyed their lunch. There was so much food with each platter we didn't eat again until the next day - true story! This place was such a good find and we are glad we found it. read more

Good barbecue they have sweets beer and anything bbq related it's there they also have a ice cream shop with homemade ice cream the wait isn't long at all either you might wait up to 35-40 minutes if they are really full it's not on the best side of town but if you live close it is worth the try read more

This place is awesome my wife and I have tried different items and we have been blown away by it. There white BBQ sauce is amazing, this place is a drive for us but is well worth it to anyone that wants killer bbq read more

The best food ever. Worth ur trip. Clean. Safe. Awesome. Call ahead to pick up. Never prob. Even ice cream in back

I dont care if you're in Cleveland or Pittsburgh. Columbus or Erie. NAKE the drive to Warren, OH and get Cockeyed! This is BBQ done right! The sauces are fabulous and homemade, NOT out of a store bought bottle! The Smoke ring is perfect and the meats are tender! At Cockeye BBQ, they DON'T put the sauce on your food, if you want sauce YOU put it on but again the sauces are FABULOUS! They also serve Cheerwine Soda. That's a Carolina favorite Cherry Soda! Love me some BBQ and Cheerwine!!! read more

Phenomenal flavors! Lots of variety on the menu. Friendly service. Had the ribs, brisket, collard greens, Cajun fries, and fried green tomatoes. I want to eat here every day!!! read more

Simply the best BBQ.... The sauce is pure goodness... The turkey,brisket and the ribs were made to perfection.... read more

Fantastic BBQ...GREAT pulled pork and brisket. The corn casserole is to die for as well as the cheesy potatoes! read more

See all

One of the beat bbq places around! Great meat and sides!! And great service! Then when you are done make room for their ice cream !!!

Absolutely great BBQ. Friendly staff , clean dining room, excellent menu. Very refreshing to see a local non-franchise establishment succeed. read more

Super good food put the pulled pork in my top ten. But the sides are where its at. This was my second time there and i don't have a complaint yet. I recommend you will not be disappointed. read more

Best BBQ I've had outside of Kansas City and the South. Great, smoky ribs and brisket, delicious sides, terrific sauces and good iced tea. If you're in Warren, you likely won't find better food -- especially if you're there on a Sunday. read more

Really good barbecue. Although you can eat in, it's set up as more of a takeout place. Really no wait staff on duty, but the food is good enough that it does not matter. I have had the chicken brisket and ribs, and all three are exceptional. read more

We've eaten here probably 20 times since they opened. We've also ordered carryout several times. Only once was one of the meats dry, so I'll call that a fluke. We've recommended it and had friends come from Canton and Pittsburgh. They all loved the food like we love it. The owners and staff are always friendly and place it cool and clean. read more

Hands down the best barbecue I've had in this area. I had the two meat dinner with 1/4 chicken, ribs, Cajun fries and Mac & Cheese. Everything was cooked perfectly tender and juicy. I got sauce on the side and the strutter sauce was incredible. read more

When I eat at Cockeye BBQ, I think two things: 'this flavor IS Youngstown,' and 'I wonder how long this place can stick around,' but for the reasons that guests might not expect. One of the reasons that Cockeye BBQ has become my favorite place to go is that the atmosphere is welcoming and folkish: part antique, part modern, low-key, and all blue-collar. Globe string lights hang above the dining area, which is a testament to the art of barbecue with things such as steer skulls on the wall. There's a hint of vintage, but the wood-and-steel feel is all Mahoning Valley. The restaurant's crew operates on a line that's visible to guests, which is reminiscent of something between a classic diner and an assembly line. A variety of craft beers and craft sodas are offered, highlighted is Cheerwine. It's a testament to Cockeye BBQ's attention to detail. As top pasta houses might offer a wine to pair with their best bolognese sauce, Cockeye seems to have almost hand-selected a diverse range beverages, from the standard Coca-Cola to Jamaican Ginger Beer, to go with any of their dishes. Drinks are priced well: less than you'd expect from a restaurant, but on-par with what you might pay in a grocery store. But all prices are reflected like that; a standard meal will cost you a little less than you'd pay in a chain restaurant downtown--and you'll get larger portions here, no doubt. The drinks are enough of a reason to seek out Cockeye BBQ, but their food knocks the competition out of the water. As an enthusiast of smoked meats and bbq, I don't think that the competition is even close. I'm guilty of seeking out a good brisket, and their hand-held shaved brisket is and has been my go-to, but I've had everything from a smoked reuben (which was great with their cajun fries), a little-bit-of-everything mess plate, to their "two bones and a slice." The bread is soft and fresh. The meat is juicy, smoky, and tender. The ribs fall off the bone. In the six or so times I've been there, I've never had one dish that was full of fat or gristle, which is a much-welcomed rarity for this type of restaurant. The meat is worth the price of admission, but the 'real deal' at Cockeye BBQ is the sauce. Cockeye's standard barbeque sauce is a perfect blend of spicy, smoky, sweet and tangy. It has a taste and texture of honey. Nashville has their spicy sauce, Kentucky has their smoky sauce, Memphis has their sweet sauce... but Cockeye's sauce has defined a new flavor: Youngstown barbeque. It's a new breed, and it's as diverse as the Mahoning Valley. Outsiders comment on the grit that folks have around here, and this sauce reflects all of it. For those seeking a little extra kick, they offer a spicy variant, and they have other inventive bbq sauces as well, including a mustard sauce that's every bit as unique as it is flavorful. For the at-home enthusiast, their rubs and sauces are sold in jars. Another unique reason to love Cockeye BBQ is their 'clothesline specials' that are offered in addition to the standard menu. Crafty, creative items with their signature spin have included poutine to the aforementioned smoked reuben. For the enthusiast who likes something aside from the standard fare, the clothesline always has 'something different.' Not many start-ups are given a standing chance to "make it" in this area. This especially goes for local restaurants who have plenty of competition, but Cockeye BBQ certainly will make it. Their food is delicious, fairly priced, and dining in offers a great atmosphere. Cockeye BBQ buys many of their ingredients from local vendors, so they're helping other "small guys" succeed in our corner of the rust belt. Their attention to detail is all 'blue collar,' and even in a location just outside of downtown Warren, they stay remarkably (and understandably) busy. I wonder how long they can stick around, but only because I wonder if they'll have to move; before this particular brand of food, its sauce, the small-batch mentality and attention to customer service becomes mainstream, and the crew has to adopt a larger and possibly more central location. If you're in the valley, and you haven't already, stop by this place. It's a winner, if not the next big thing to come out of our valley. read more

My favorite place right now. I love the bbq sauce and the mesh plates so much I haven't tried other items .. yet. Always friendly and always something new when I go in. We like the family size extras and always get the corn casserole and the sandwiches are unreal. read more

We love going to cockeye! Everything we've had from here has been amazing. The prices are extremely reasonable and the management is even better! Cannot wait to see what's in store for this business! read more

This is a family owned bbq joint. No table service order at the counter and sitdown. Food all served in takeout containers but plentiful, delicious and reasonably priced. Not much to do in Warren but this place was great. read more

I went for the first time yesterday. OMG the food is delicious. We had no idea of what to order, but the clerk she was sooooo helpful, she first asked if we wanted a hand held or an actual meal, then kept on going getting our likes and dislikes and we each got just what we were hungry for. I got the spare rib meal, and they just fell off the bone. I normally don't like hush puppies, but I'd eat these any day of the week. This is definately our BBQ joint from now on. If you've never been here, Go, don't hesitate, they've got just the right sauce for your taste. Well, what cha waiting for, I said GO!!!!!!!!! read more

Great food with large portions. You will not be hungry when you leave! Great craft beer selection.

Their food is to die for. Best BBQ I have ever had, and they are always friendly and polite. Just a really nice place to eat. The side dishes are really, really good. read more

Really nice staff. Had a big order and they had it ready early and rang me out ahead of a small line. Amazing food.

Very good food, not very good for you. Love the fried bologna sandwich. Has grilled hot pepper on it. Owner is great and helpful deciding what to get for dinner. read more

I'm a huge BBQ fan so as soon as I heard about this place, I had to try it. The first time I tried Cockeye's I fell in love! We've been back multiple times since and I can't wait to come back. Great food, great prices. Edit** I'm also a huge hushpuppy fan and no one seems to make them as good as the South does... except for Cockeye's! Only good hushpuppies around. read more