Cancel

Open app

Search

Colton's Steakhouse

3.3 (81 reviews)
Open • 10:30 am - 9:00 pm

Colton's Steakhouse Photos

Business Info

COLTON'S STEAKHOUSE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Good for groups
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Colton's Steakhouse

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

House salad with ranch dressing.
Christina W.

Nice local restaurant with a cowboy theme. Dined with some friends. We all ordered either the NY Strip steak or Pork Chops. The NY Strip Steak was 12 oz and served with choice of two sides. I chose the house salad with ranch dressing and sweet potato fries. The sweet potato fries were slightly undercooked, not crunchy. So I ate some of hubby's loaded baked potato. After you place your order, they bring out the bread basket. These are homemade yeast rolls that melt in your mouth. After a day on the bourbon trail we just ordered water to drink. Appetizers: fried pickles with spicy ranch dressing is very good and enough to share; JT's Onion Blossom is just like a bloomin onion from that Australian restaurant.

Steak and shrimp.
Christopher W.

Service at this spot was damn good. Zachary took care of me at the bar. He is an ideal server. Timing was perfect checked back often kept the tea full. Food was not great. My first steak was way over cooked. The recook was still over done. Can't say I would blame the cook. Seems like the thickness of the cut is inconsistent, one half of the steak was Med to Med. Well the other thick part was Med Rare. The shrimp were pathetically small.

Good bacon cheeseburger with very decent mac & cheese
Jason E.

Overall, this was pretty good. I got a new peddlers mall booth next to it and so last week, knowing that I would probably want to try this place I went ahead and signed up for their club. I got a free appetizer to begin with. I chose the mozzarella sticks and they were very large. The cheese was very soft and gooey and taste great , they had grated Parmesan on them. That was also delicious. The marinara dip was very good and not too chunky a good size cup of it. I got a bacon cheeseburger well done and it was still juicy even though I got it done and there was very little gristle the bacon was only mediocre, but it was passable, I paid the dollar extra to upgrade my side mac & cheese and it was also at least B+. It was pretty good. It wasn't baked or didn't have any big chunks of cheese in it, but it had a good sauce with perfectly cooked pasta and very buttery. nice flavor I enjoyed the two rolls. The waitress brought me. I am glad they have regular butter or margarine not that sweet stuff like Texas roadhouse Also had more chew and had a good flavor to them very satisfying. I just got water but they do have bonus points for that was very friendly and efficient brought everything very quickly and brought me to go boxes that fit my leftovers perfectly this place look clean, not all crowded nice and wide open and spacious. I'm sure I will want to come back again when I come to check on my peddlers booth.

Crispy, well seasoned, tangy. Perfect 10/10

See all

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Colton's Steakhouse

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Connors Steak & Seafood

Connors Steak & Seafood

4.3(268 reviews)
30.1 mi
•$$$

4/11/2026 On Saturday afternoon 36 residents of Swan Pointe…read moreHOA went to Connors Steak & Seafood. This was the largest record breaker ever! We were very glad to see Kevin Elkins, the GM of Connors there that day. He is a great supporter of Swan Pointe. We sat at the 2 round tables and 6 booths. We were assigned 2 fabulous servers, Julian and Dzenan. Our server was Dzenan and he came around to our table and introduced himself and how he would be setting out water at each person's place setting and then he'd go around getting the drink orders and appetizers and bring out our freshly made rolls and butter. We looked over the menu and many decisions were made. Not only did we have our 2 servers checking on us, there were several chefs that came out to see if we were doing ok. The food started appearing around the room and my goodness it smelled delicious. I walked around the tables and grabbed pictures of pretty much everyone until my food was at the table and my husband was getting ready to text me. The servers didn't hover over us but kept refilling water glasses and pitchers and bringing back rolls and then clearing the tables. Being able to take advantage of smaller meals, and lower prices was really great for our group. That doesn't mean that our group had tiny portions, my steak was a 7oz Sirloin. We had a wonderful time and really look forward to returning again. Many of us come back frequently now that we've been here oftenand know what great service we get, how great the food is and how pleasant the ambiance is at Connors.

Heard this was one of the top steakhouses in Louisville so decided to give it a go for an…read moreAnniversiary dinner. Went in Sunday around 7pm after Derby. No wait and we were seated immediately in a booth. Service was great the entire visit. Our server Renne was knowledgeable, efficient, and kept things moving. Unfortunelky when we sat, our server let us know they were out of calamari, which was a letdown since it is one of their #1 appetizers. Here's the breakdown: Prickly Pear Margarita $15 This was sweet and smooth without being overly strong. The flavor leaned slightly toward raspberry. Easy to drink and well balanced. I liked it Complimentary bread We were served two warm rolls with a herb style pesto butter. The bread was fresh and soft inside with a light crust. Simple but very good, especially for something complimentary and unlimited. Fried mushrooms $13 Good portion size. The breading was light and crisp but not heavy, so you still got the mushroom flavor through it. The texture was tender, almost soft like cauliflower when cooked right. What really made this dish was the sauce, a spicy chipotle style aioli with a creamy base. That sauce was honestly better than the mushrooms themselves. Lobster bisque Included with the entree. Very creamy, smooth texture, rich color. The flavor was solid but slightly muted. There were very few visible lobster chunks, which was the main downside. It tasted more like a creamy seafood soup than something loaded with lobster. Still, as a free included side it was fine. A bit more salt and actual lobster pieces would improve it a lot. 14 oz Ribeye $43 This was the main event and it was great. Ordered medium rare and it came out exactly medium rare. The steak had a solid charcoal grilled crust on the outside without being overly burnt or bitter.Added some really great flavor. Some places overdo the char and it takes over the meat. Inside was juicy, tender, and a perfect mix of fat and meat. Really solid overall. They also split the steak and plated it for two without charging extra, which included dividing the sides as well. I also like how there was a small portion of chive butter included on the plate. It was simple but added a nice touch to the the steak. Most other toppings or flavored butters were $4 extra so it was nice nice to try one for free. Loaded baked potato side Large size and fully loaded with cheese, bacon, sour cream, and butter. It was soft inside with a proper fluffy texture, not dry or undercooked. Pretty standard steakhouse loaded potato. Strawberry shortcake Complimentary dessert with a candle for the special occasion, which was a nice touch. This was easily the highlight of the entire meal. Perfect balance between cake and strawberry filling. The strawberries tasted fresh and had real sweetness rather than being overly syrupy. Honestly one of the best strawberry shortcakes I've ever had and I grew up eating the ice cream pops. Highly recommended. Overall: Service was great, solid food, fair prices, and the dessert was excellent. The biggest downside was the calamari being unavailable, especially since it is their #1 app. I'll be back to actually try the calamari next time.

Photos
Connors Steak & Seafood - Back right dining room

Back right dining room

Connors Steak & Seafood - Spicy Korean-Style Ribs

Spicy Korean-Style Ribs

Connors Steak & Seafood - New York Strip

See all

New York Strip

Colton's Steakhouse - tradamerican - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...