So happy you came to the neighborhood. We dined at Conchiglia last night and everything was terrific. We made a reservation. We were seated on time. The service was excellent. Everyone was very friendly and professional. The food was dynamite. We started with the beef carpaccio and the burrata. Both delicious. The star of our entrees was the pear and ricotta tortellini. Fantastic!!! We also got the stuffed shells, the pasta with the veal ragu and a pepperoni pizza. All extremely delicious. Highly recommend everythig we had. We can not wait to come back and being only 2 blocks from my house, I think we will be back a lot. Thank you, everyone at Conchiglia. My only complaint is that you apologized to a Karen who wrote a stupid review. She's a seaward kind of person. Y'all are doing great. read more

My bf and I came here the other night to try this new restaurant out. They did a fantastic job decorating the place. It looks really clean and nautically themed. It's hard to believe it's the same space we used to visit for the previous restaurant before them, it seems bigger! To eat we ordered a couple things to share: the Duval Sunset Mezze, the Portabello Wellington Al Forno, the La Conchiglia Verde and the Amalfi Lemon Veal. The Duval Sunset Mezze was cute in theory but wasn't really practical. It was just a lot of bread and then you had to lift it up to get the dips in/underneath it. The flavors were good though I would say I would just rather the bread be separate to avoid the mess of eating the dish this way. The Portabello Wellington al Forno was our favorite dish we tried. This was flakey and flavorful and the arugula salad on it was refreshing. We almost got another one it was a hit. The La Conchiglia Verde (kale salad) was very bland and not memorable. The dressing was good but it barely had any. Wanted to order extra dressing but the waitress didn't really come to our table much to check on us. Lastly we got the Amalfi Lemon Veal entree. The veal was cooked to perfection, you could cut it with your fork but the flavor was bland. The potatoes it came with were perfect though. Crispy on the outside but soft inside. I would come back and try some other items (and get the Portabello Wellington again). read more

See all

Relatively new restaurant and crowded during prime time dinner hours. Sitting in back of restaurant in garden area is tight seating and not enjoyable listening to other's conversations. Cacio e Pepe transported me back to Rome. Creamy, cheesy, and not overly peppery. Amalfi lemon veal was just ok. The rosemary potatoes were average. The chicken was incredibly juicy and carrots some of best I've ever had. I will say though the chicken is salty from the brine, so consider when ordering. Selena was server. Solid job; friendly, just vanilla and monotone. read more

See all

Great experience! Lucas was attentive and helpful. The avocado toast is out of this world. The fresh baked croissant beignets were fluffy and well done and on point. read more

We had dinner elsewhere that evening, but by the time we were heading back to our apartment, we found ourselves craving dessert. As we walked by Conchiglia, we were drawn in by the atmosphere. We didn't realize at the time that it had only opened a few days earlier. The posted menus didn't list dessert, but we decided to ask the host anyway. Glad we did. Food: The regular dinner menu sounded fantastic, with a wide range of options including pizza, pasta, salads, beef, chicken, and seafood. It's definitely a place we'd like to return to for a full meal. Since we were only there for dessert and there was no printed dessert menu, our server did a great job describing the options. We decided on the Midnight Chocolate Soufflé and the Olive Oil Vanilla Cake. Both were excellent choices. The chocolate soufflé was dense and rich, with some pleasant surprises inside, including Bordeaux cherries. The olive oil cake was incredibly moist, with added texture and flavor from crushed almond cookies and a bright lemon cream. Service: Our server was attentive and welcoming from the start, bringing water and explaining the dessert options clearly. Even though we were only there for dessert, we never felt like an afterthought. The staff seemed genuinely interested in making sure our brief visit was enjoyable. Atmosphere: The space is beautiful. Both the indoor and outdoor seating areas looked inviting. The restaurant has an upscale feel while still being comfortable and relaxed. Everything felt fresh, polished, and thoughtfully designed. Definitely a place we would love to return to on our next trip. read more

See all

Lovely new restaurant on Duval with amazing pasta dishes. We had spaghetti in a bolognese sauce and cacio e pepe - both were excellent. We will be back! read more

The service was spectacular! Our server was playful, she understood that we were about the experience. Unfortunately the food fell a bit short. Although a new restaurant they really need to tighten the recipes together, especially something called flavors. Season your offerings, please. On the breaded veal chop, it needs to be crispy, not oily and soggy. Constructive criticism, I want you guys to do well. The restaurant is beautiful and welcoming, just needs to tweet the product offerings. read more

Conchiglia - Breaded veal chop, soggy breading - Italian Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

We couldn't wait to come back to Conchiglia after our first visit. It was one of our favorite meals in Key West. The pear and Gorgonzola pasta and the mushroom Wellington appetizer were absolutely incredible, so we were disappointed to find that both had already been removed from the menu. Unfortunately, the service made this visit even more disappointing. We were greeted by a hostess who argued with us about our reservation before finally seating us. The hostess is the first person guests meet and the face of the restaurant, so first impressions matter. She seemed scattered, disorganized, and just generally off, making for an uncomfortable and unwelcoming start to the evening. Our waitress was even worse. She was cold, unfriendly, and made us feel like we were bothering her every time we asked for something--even bread, water, salt and pepper, or a simple question about the menu. Instead of feeling like welcomed guests, we felt like an inconvenience. It's such a shame because this restaurant has so much potential and the food we had on our first visit was outstanding. Hospitality is just as important as great food, and unfortunately that's where this experience fell short. We genuinely hope management addresses these issues because we'd love to see Conchiglia succeed. read more

Staff was amazing! Food was equally amazing! Love the atmosphere and overall A great experience. Will absolutely be coming back! read more

See all

My husband and I dined at Conchiglia on Friday, 5 June. What a great experience! We dined at the bar under the inverted boat entrance chandelier centerpiece. The decor is relaxed and inviting with inside and outside dining for large or small groups. We had the Portobello Wellington, couscous di mara allo zafferano, and the Pear & Pine pasta. Highly recommend each. The Pear/Pine Nut pasta is not something I would have normally tried I but took a risk. Worth it! Portobello in the Wellington is a light "meaty" meal for one or a great for a share. Bottom line: Go there for inside/outside ambiance and top shelf, fresh ingredients and service. read more

The food and service were amazing but what really impressed me was when I got the opportunity to talk with one of the owners, Mike. His passion and quest for perfection were evident in every detail of his vision of Conchiglia and to that end he is committed to making it the premier dining destination of Key West. If I didn't live on the other side of the country I would definitely be a regular read more

We get this a new establishment but after two visits we will offer this - overall food is good but still needs some work. The "new" bread service is just odd - like a calzone with nothing in it. Biggest complaint is the wait staff - they seem totally disengaged. No water refills and it takes forever to get their attention when the meal is over. The place has a ton of potential but just need some tweaks first. read more

wanted to love it .... service and food was not on point at ALL !!! :( Loved it the first time when they opened but totally different the second try .... read more

Food was pretty good! Very good, correct italian food. pizza bianca and pastas were great. steak, carpaccio, and fritto misto were good but nothing to ring home about. ambience and decor was super nice, the outdoor patio is lovely. our waiter wasn't the friendliest, though, and we never got bread for the table despite other tables receiving it. also, they were out of many drinks the night we came. they also failed to acknowledge the birthday note on our reservation, despite us calling ahead to remind them of the surprise. overall good experience but nothing too special. read more

See all

The food was lovely and beautifully presented. The service was friendly and spot on. We sat outside and enjoyed the lovely surrounding the dining area. This will definitely be our go . read more

Food was great. Service was slow but friendly. The person who sat us was considerate of the weather and where to seat us. Our server was super nice but seemed to be ran thin at times. Food was great and came out at a reasonable time. I'd eat here again. read more

Greg was amazing! Food and atmosphere are great! Service was fast. Bottomless mimosas read more

Conchiglia - French toast - Italian Near Me - Key West, Florida

What a delightful dinner at Conchiglia! Our party of 6 dined on the beautiful patio. Tables are not too close together and the blue and white umbrellas provide ample shade for dining. Our service was attentive and prompt. We enjoyed the arugula salad, that was large enough to share, as well as the Conchiglia Comfort. The Amalfi Lemon Veal had our guest struggling to not lick the plate. The pepperoni Storm had 6 generous slices, and our waiter was kind in adding a side of Calabrian Chili, that kicked things up in heat...delish. It is so nice to visit a restaurant that is hitting all the keys just right. We'll be back. read more

Absolutely delicious! Friendly and professional staff. Definitely recommending if you are looking for some authentic and exquisite Italian cuisine. Main ingredients/dishes such as bread, pastries,pasta and pizza dough are all made from scratch in house. Can't wait to go back to this charming restaurant with its relaxing ambiance when back in town. read more

Service was very good, everything very clean, pizza was delicious . I love the concept of open kitchen. read more

Conchiglia - Best truffle pizza I had ever had - Italian Near Me - Key West, Florida

One of the best meals we had during our stay in key west! Food took a while to get out, but it was worth the wait! The drinks were good, the server (Diana) was super attentive and engaging. The mezze appetizer needs some work, but the pizza capricciosa and couscous di mare allo zafferano were incredible! I was astonished at the amount of seafood in that tagine!!! We dined in the garden and everything is curated so well back there! Very HGTV but warm and not pretentious. Highly recommend for date night and small groups! read more

Best food in town by far! Great ambiance. Staff handled our 13 top (including young kids) with perfection. Will be back!

Great job on opening week. Will definitely be back. Staff was very accommodating. Had a power outage a couple days before and they game me a call to reschedule . read more

Our waiter was fantastic. Wish I could remember his name but it has been a couple months. Food was really good and the back patio was a great spot to eat . read more

Renata offered us impeccable and kind service. Even when the wine we wanted wasn't available, she offered another option to fit our pallet. We will be going back and hopefully Renata serves us again. read more

My wife happened upon Conchiglia while visiting for our anniversary from Charleston South Carolina. We were greeted by the best host very friendly and got us in right away, and sat us at a nice quiet table in their garden area. Our server was Renata she was amazing and did a great job, very helpful and friendly. My wife had the tortellini and I had the crispy pepperoni pizza, both were delicious. We will definitely be back when we make our next trip back down here. read more

Excellent! Delicious food, warm ambience, and welcoming staff. Can't wait to go back.

Great food, atmosphere and staff helpful and like recommendations plus the taste food better than Michelin places in Miami

We had dinner there tonight and it was unbelievably wonderful. The food was extraordinary, as was the service. I had the veal and my husband had the ribeye. They were both flawless. The ambiance is simple and lovely. Unfortunately, I won't be able to write any more reviews as my husband has already made up his mind that we will be eating here for the next four nights. I can't complain, as it truly was amazing. Don't miss it! read more

Went for the new Brunch menu and it was great. From the tiramisu pancakes to the roasted eggplant and the black truffle cream pizza. What a variety of food that you can have from 8:00-2:30. No reservations needed for now. Better get there soon before everyone finds out about this new brunch option 7 days a week. read more

Great new Italian restaurant on Duval, just opened in February 2026. We ordered fritto misto as an appetizer, then split a pepperoni pizza and the tagliatelle with veal ragu. All 3 were excellent, we also ordered a bottle of Valpolicella which was very nice (and reasonably priced). We ate in the back outdoor area which was very nice and also very quiet. For dessert we split the olive oil cake which is almost a lemon pound cake on mascarpone. Our waiter Kyle was great, very attentive and funny. I would highly recommend. read more

Amazing and authentic Italian cuisine. They are still working out some opening issues with front of house but it didn't affect the quality of the food read more

We had a party of 4, and were very excited to try this new place. We had made reservations far in advance, however we sat waiting for over 45 minutes (ended up leaving). They blamed it on a "power outage" and issues with their system, but this should have been resolved before we showed up. We were okay waiting a few minutes, however after over 40 minutes, we had to leave. While it was not expected, you would have thought that a brand new business would have done something to accommodate us, such as a free drink or something, however we weren't even offered water while we waited. Overall, thought we were very excited to try the new place, their poor customer service was worthy of a yelp review. womp womp. read more

Food and service were excellent. Had the seafood couscous. Perfect meal. Portion size was appropriate. Matthew was a great server.