We were excited to try their hotdogs as recommended by a family member. We went Sunday evening, the store was very bare, only one pair of customers, having the order counter in the very back was strange. We ordered a few basic hotdogs, tamale, and a bowl of chili to go cuz we wanted to watch football at home. I thought hot dogs were plain with just onions and cheese. So I ordered a bowl of chili. Wrong! They come with chili. Hotdogs were tiny like pinky fingers and didn't taste like beef or pork. Chili was SPICY with thick layer of grease! It was so spicy that made me cough and gag, even though I love spicy food. Tamale was tiny also that I have never seen that tiny tamale that was swimming in chili in a paper cup. Sorry but we won't be back. read more

It's a Coney I-lander, so you kinda know what you're getting into when you walk in. This location seems to be a birthday destination for our extended group, given it's in Broken Arrow. The times we've been in the place has been mildly busy with plenty of staff, but for some reason the place always seems dirty. Floors never really seem clean and the prep line looks like no one is bothering to wipe anything down between customers. Food has always been consistent with other CIL's in the area, so no complaints there. Again, it's a Coney-I-Lander, so there's a pretty consistent baseline to expect. read more

Having been a long-time resident of BA and never trying this location, I decided to stop in and grab a couple of coneys, and I will never be back. 4 employees were cutting up behind the counter, and when I asked where I was supposed to order, one guy rudely said, "He'll be right with you." I looked at the menu for a moment, and no one ever got with me. I was completely ignored, so I left. I will drive 20 minutes to the Tulsa location next time I'm feeling a coney, or just run down to Sonic. read more

All reviews are correct! Love it or hate it, it's a chili dog. If you want to feel amazing, eat a light lunch, have a light salad with some bubbly water. If you want to go into a food coma and sleep it off for and few hours in your bed binge watching Netflix....just order 8 or 9 of these with everything on them. Last time I went here there was a miscommunication or hiccup in the assembly line . Be it my stutter when ordering or a lack of quality control and inspection before receiving my order, my dogs were cheese-less. No matter what happens I'm convinced I'll never stop eating here, it's a guilty pleasure, maybe a few degrees above Taco Bell but I don't care. Coneys are a gift from God. read more

Coney I-Lander - the front of the building - Hot Dogs Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

The Tulsa metro has a TON of Coney I-Lander locations and this is one we get to enjoy in Broken Arrow. Upon entering to dine I was surprised at how clean this one was. Often times at a coney spot there is a 'welcoming' coat of grease on every surface you can see and a shine to match. Where the interior is basic, as it should be, it was CLEAN! The menu is limited also, as it should be which makes ordering simple. I always go with a cheese coney with onions and jalapenos. I also like a tamale with chile on the side too, because why not right? Overall very friendly service with a team of smiling faces behind the counter. Where I'm not a huge coney fan, if I get a hankering for one while in BA, I'll be coming back here. read more

See all

I absolutely love the coneys here It's becoming a regular place to visit when I'm back in town. It's hard to find good coneys east of here so it's nice to be able to come home and get some awesome coneys! read more

Absolutely love grabbing coneys from this spot in BA! Always clean with smiling faces serving you! I've cold strawberry Fanta with your coneys is always the best option! We swung in over the weekend with our kids to get some coneys! This place never disappoints ever when it comes to great service and delicious coneys! Of all the I-landers in Tulsa area this one is far the best in my opinion! I'd your in the area swing in and get ya a bit of greatness! read more

The lady behind the counter making food yelled at employees both on the clock and one trying to return from lunch. The food was a good value, but the chili was greasy and tasteless. Having seasoning and hot sauce on the table is a good choice. read more

Coney I-Lander - Regular Coney Small Regular 3-Way - Hot Dogs Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I really had high hopes, but I was unimpressed. Very greasy chili. Did not do great things to my stomach. Basic dine-in location. Should be good for anyone with a bullet proof stomach. Convenient location in BA off hwy 51. Excellent food presentation. read more

Coney I-Lander - a table of food - Hot Dogs Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Coneys are a tradition in Tulsa, so I felt like I had to try them at one point or another. Chili cheese coneys are good from here, but I don't see what makes theirs better than other coney joints? Definitely go on Sundays when they're discounted! but prepare to wait in line. read more

The food is so good, workers are very nice, and is always busy so 10/10 for me! I've been going here for over 10 years and this place is amazing. read more

Reviewed April 5, 2018 Health Score 66 out of 100 Average at best. Nothing at all about this place is above average. Hot dog, chili, cheese and onions. Quick food and it is seldom crowded. Note: This review was originally posted on Tripadvisor by Spike S. read more

Great Coneys! We got cheese coneys (mustard, onion, chili, and cheese). 3 of 'em, 2 chips, 2 small drinks. $10.00 even! Steal of a deal!! Pretty tasty, maybe a smidge heavy on the onions for my taste, but no complaints. read more

Coney I-Lander - Cheesy Coney (mustard, onion, chili, cheese) - Hot Dogs Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

We went for coneys tonight and Kevin and Guy were very friendly and it was a great experience! Our favorite Coney Islander, we will be back :) read more

I LOOOOOOVVVEEE Coney I-Lander! Always have, always will. The menu is simple, the restaurant itself looks like its stuck in a time warp, but this is the taste i've known my whole life. Great steamed buns that are always soft, hot dogs grilled on a flat top right in front of you, and simple but great toppings. This place doesn't need fancy gimics or a buffet of toppings to get you in the door. They're cheap....I mean they're small so they should be cheap, but they're a great value especially if you have a coupon. read more

The best dogs in BA and they're cheap! Not all Coney I-landers are created equal, but this one if my favorite in Oklahoma. If you've never been to a Coney I-lander, be sure to order at least 3 dogs. They're simple yet delicious. read more

I had to go back for a second order of 2 with everything. No regerts, but maybe a little regurgitation later. read more

Something about these dogs just do it for me! I'm not sure what that hint of spice is that I continue to taste, maybe it's love :) I've been to this location and only this location about three times now and all have been consistently good. Nice fast friendly service too! I always get the cheese coney and today I did it times 3. I recommend getting at least two and if you're feeling extra get three. Small but filling little bad boys!! read more

I don't know how anyone can say that this place serves great hot dogs. The hot dogs suck and the chili sucks. That's the end of the menu. Oh yea. You can get chips and a soda also. It looks like anyone can get a Coney Island Hot Dog franchise for under $500. It can't cost much more then that to open up one of these places. There's nothing on the menu and the place is as bare as can be. They don't even serve ketchup or relish. What's a hot dog without ketchup and relish? I believe the little tiny hot dogs they sell are turkey dogs. They definitely aren't beef. They say the chili comes from an old family recipe but it tastes like it's straight out of a can. I'm sorry but I love hot dogs and really wanted to love this place but I can't. I can't even like it. I'd rather eat gas station hot dogs. read more

To the Owner, ate at your restaurant 06/02/22 about 2:45 pm not a table clean. Not busy with customers. I am from out of town and eat here whenever I am in town once a month. First time I can and appreciated how clean it has been over other Coney Islanders I used to go to. Please keep up on what is going on to keep it a nice & clean place. read more

Great service and good hot dogs! Friendly people always feel welcomed. Classic coneys with a quiet atmosphere.

First time at the Broken Arrow location of this Tulsa tradition. Coneys are great. Small steamed buns, unique chili, lots of onions and cheese. Always good. Usually get 3 with chips and drink for $7.14. Knocking off a star for the drive thru which slows down service inside. If you are in Broken Arrow, give this place a try. read more

Coney I-Lander - 3 cheese with everything. Don't forget the cayenne pepper! - Hot Dogs Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I heard that this place had a good corn dog so I decided to give it a try. I went through the drive-thru and ordered 4 regular corn dogs. The Clerk repeated the order of 4 corn dogs. When I got back home, I opened the bag and to my surprise I found 4 hotdogs with Chili and onions! When did corn dogs become hot dogsI You would of thought that the clerk would have said "that we do not have corn dogs. Did you mean hot dogs?" The hotdogs wasn't that great and the chili was very greasy. I will never go back! read more

We went there this evening. When we got home we couldn't find the chil on them. We finally dug down and found a smear of chili. They tasted awful! Threw them in the trash. Don't think we'll ever want another coney. read more

I've been going to this location off and not for many of years. My most recent visit was on 3-12-2017. They redesigned the inside giving the dining room and updated look, Which looks good ( I sort of missed the older look because it reminds me of my childhood visits for coneys). The food has always been consistent and good. The staff has always been friendly. Overall, I have not once had a bad experience and enjoy their good food so I have and will continue to dine here. read more

Simply put, this is my favorite place to get a chili-cheese coney. Basically just small coneys with mustard, onions, chili and cheese. They put the buns in a steamer, so they are extra chewy. When I eat in the restaurant, I'll add some chili powder and hot sauce for an added kick. I recently moved to Dallas and the first place I go when I come back to visit. read more

It had been years since I had been back to the Tulsa area. One of my fond memories was eating at Coney Island. Or was it Coney I-Lander? Stayed not too far away from this place and most everything was already closed so we decided to take a trip down memory lane. Arrived just before closing and noticed the options weren't quite like I had remembered. There were not multiple ingredients out to put on your dogs...maybe because it was close to closing. Nope. Dog with onions and chili or dog with cheese onion and chili. I opted for two with cheese and a tamale with cheese and chili. The best thing I can say about this place is that it's about as quality as Taco Bell...but with hot dogs. They weren't bad, just not like I remembered. I'm struggling with the third star just because of my stomach's reactions the next morning, but really, what do you expect from a cheap chili dog? read more

I went to get some coneys yesterday and once I got them I parked out front cause I had some errands to run afterwards and I took a bite and saw at the end a hair was sticking out, it wasn't a small puny one it was a longgg black hair. I'm usually cool about these things and I didn't go inside or anything I was just grossed out and ended up not even eating any of it, I'm not confrontational and I feel like I had no proof after already pulling the hair out from under the hotdog so I just got over it, this is the first time I've had anything like that happen and I won't be eating there anymore read more

I usually go to Coney Island (original company) so this place is a big disappointment. Just bland and nasty. Whoever made the chili recipe knows nothing about chili; it literally looks gray. Not coming back. read more

Coney I-Lander - Hot Dogs Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Don't really write a review on anything but these hot dogs are kind of gross, at least mine were. Normally hot dogs are supposed to have a savory flavor or like kind of salty and good, but mine were like eating a sweet hot dog, not sure if it was the onions or the chili but honestly the sugary taste was just gross. Wanted to try it and did but not for me again. read more

Oh yes. Sweet beautiful Coney Islander. The best Coney I've ever had. It's the best. Its essentially fast food but, the best fast food you can ever find. The only downside is you'll want to eat your hands because they'll smell so good after you eat. read more

My wife and I decided to stop here to eat, and we regret every second of it. The food is always good and it was, but there was a hiccup. The fountain machine was down and that's not a problem for us, but there was an elder veteran in front of us who hadn't seen the sign that said it was down. One of the nicer staff members said that she could make his pop down at the end by the register. However, the one guy working the drive thru said "there's a sign right in front of him". That shook my wife and I to the core. It's so unprofessional and if that's what this establishment stands for, then I don't ever want to eat here again and I recommend everyone to go somewhere else. Terrible. read more

These are the best Coney's in Tulsa and Broken Arrow! I've been coming here with my Grandpa since I was a little kid. The last time I brought my Grandpa, I had noticed they redesigned the place to be more modern: I missed the old style. They had raised their priced as well! Still was great food though! read more

I have friends from out of town that every time they come to Tulsa must go and get some Coney's. I take it for granted because I can eat here whenever I want, but I can appreciate the tasty goodness. If you've never been here I'd say give it a try it's worth it. You can put down 4 or 5 Coney's and a bag of Fritos pretty easy. So live, love and eat. Oh yeah, add some hot sauce to the top for a lil Kick. read more

This place is newly remodeled so it's definitely a lot cleaner. But hey, it's allllll about the coneys. We LOVE this place.

Coneys are always a hit for my family! The kids love them and request we stop by regularly. This location is clean and the service is fast. Affordable too read more

When I walk in it reminds me of my childhood. Play room in the back, real cheap food. The dogs are delish and cheap. 3 seems to be the perfect amount, with chips and a soda. read more

Greasy, greasy, greasy - in case u missed it, this food is greasy. It dosnt cost too much but I'd recommend passing on this one

The best a Coney Hot Dogs EVER! The chili was spiced just right and the dogs were cooked perfectly. The buns were steamed and put together was a symphony in my mouth. The price of the dogs were under $2 each so I had 3 plus a drink. The atmosphere was a little divey but the taste of the dogs made up for it. They don't offer a wide variety of menu items so what they do offer, they do well. If your looking for something to fill your belly, that's delicious and affordable, then this is your place. read more

Walk up order style, not friendly at all. First time there so felt a cow staring at a new gate and the whole time I was trying to determine my order the server just looked st me and never said s word. I should have left then but I was there... Tables were not cleared, wiped down or clean. I will not return NOTHING positive to say! read more