Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cookie Plug

    3.8 (4 reviews)
    Open 10:00 am - 8:00 pm
    Updated 1 week ago

    Order Cookie Plug Takeout or Delivery

    Cookie Plug Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Cookie Plug

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Leah S.
    310
    776
    1604

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 3

    7 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Cookie Plug

    Sweets By Ladawn - My wedding cake

    Sweets By Ladawn

    4.2(48 reviews)
    2.7 mi
    $

    LaDawn never misses! Enjoyed the cupcakes I secured for my husband's birthday. The edible fondant…read moremicrophones were adorable! Always quality and delicious taste!

    I am severely disappointed with the experience I had at this bakery. I've heard, for years, this is…read morethe best in Cincinnati, so I decided to use her for my wedding cake. We went to the wedding tasting and I was underwhelmed. We paid a deposit anyways and planned use her despite being underwhelmed because the cake was our least important thing. However, we decided to cancel our wedding and elope in another country, thus no longer needing a wedding cake. I called her to let her know, didn't ask for our deposit back even once, although she made sure to repeatedly tell me that the deposit is non-refundable. I never asked for it. Instead, I asked to apply my $75 deposit towards a birthday cake for my son instead. She said I would just have to pick it up no later than our originally planned wedding date. No problem. His birthday was the same weekend anyways. About a month before I was supposed to pick the cake up, I got a phone call telling me I hadn't shown up to a design session, but I had nothing on my end saying I was ever scheduled. I had canceled the original session, and the day she called me wasn't even close to the original date, so I was very confused and apologized because I thought that maybe I had made a mistake. Fast forward to yesterday, I called to see if my cake was ready for pickup, as I like to confirm things before wasting my time and gas. She told me that "all cakes for today are ready" but never even asked my name or tried to confirm my cake was there. I hung up with her a little surprised by her lack of professionalism but still trusted that she was on top of things. The next day, today, I went to pick up the cake and she didn't have it. In fact, she didn't have any of my paperwork or anything. I had to call my fiancé to have him send me a photo of our original paperwork (which I didn't bring because I was no longer picking up a wedding cake). Eventually, she found my original order attached to someone else's order. She said that we have the same initials and she must have mixed them up. To me, that's just poor observation skills. So there I was, picking up a cake that wasn't made but "lucky" for me she had a 1/4 sheet chocolate cake in the back she would ice and write on. Knowing that this was pretty much my only option at this point, I went with it. To say I was disappointed is an understatement. My deposit was $75, the cake actually cost $45, and I bought 2 number candles for $8.50. I was very overcharged for this plain, ugly cake and was still charged for the damn candles. Never again will I recommend this bakery. I had wanted to support a local, woman-owned business, but I can't in good conscience support this one. She's disorganized, rude (she told a customer in front of her brand new employee that she wasn't good at using the register -- the look on that poor girls face broke my heart), and doesn't pay attention to important details, which is why this mess happened. I've attached a photo of the cake I got. I'm giving 2 stars because she did, at the very least, provide me with a chocolate cake.

    Photos
    Sweets By Ladawn - My wedding cake

    My wedding cake

    Sweets By Ladawn - My wedding cake

    My wedding cake

    Sweets By Ladawn

    See all

    Ferrari's Little Italy and Bakery - pastry case

    Ferrari's Little Italy and Bakery

    4.1(309 reviews)
    3.0 mi
    $$

    This Italian gem is always amazing! My family and I have eaten here several times over the years…read moreand it has been consistent every time. The inside is so cute and well decorated. The huge fireplace in the first dining area is beautiful! The service is always friendly, fast and attentive. This past visit we got the bread for the table like always and it was fresh and delicious. We like that it is a selection of different breads from the bakery! I got the mushroom ravioli and it was incredible. My parents got the linguine carbonara to share. It was fantastic as well. Everything is very well-seasoned plated nicely. The portions are very large so the ability to share is nice. For dessert my parents got the spumoni and I got the toasted almond after-dinner coffee. I cannot wait to return the next time we are around Madeira!

    3.5! Venue is tucked away in an unassuming part of town. Restaurant opens to their large ovens and…read moredisplay case of deserts, very classic Italian cookies, cakes etc. Venue is leaning towards the older fashioned Italian decor, lots of brick and dark wood, charming in a way that you know these recipes are tried and true. Chicken picatta was served slightly soupy with the butter lemon sauce, and I prefer a creamier sauce. The pasta and bread were solid and we came on a half off wine bottle day. Patio out back was romantic and will request seating out there on a cool summer date night.

    Photos
    Ferrari's Little Italy and Bakery
    Ferrari's Little Italy and Bakery - The breads were different and tasty. This is the olive bread.

    The breads were different and tasty. This is the olive bread.

    Ferrari's Little Italy and Bakery - Patio

    See all

    Patio

    Golden Hands Bakery - Schnecken

    Golden Hands Bakery

    4.9(95 reviews)
    1.4 mi
    $

    This place is heaven!…read more I am not the biggest donut person so I love a place that has donuts and baked goods alike! This place doesn't disappoint - there is so much to choose from and the options rotate daily ! I personally love the blueberry fritters - They are huge and layers of blueberry yet they are only 3 bucks (that's so cheap). The strawberry cheese pastry was also delicious and flaky. The only thing I ordered that I wasn't a huge fan of was the pretzel - it was big and the price was right but it didn't taste better than a wawa pretzel twist. The donuts also come warm since the case seems to be a warming case which is a nice touch. The workers are so nice and they will explain every flavor to you if needed since there are no labels. The place is small and so is the parking lot.

    Amazing local bakery that my friend recommended to me! They have a large variety of breads, stuffed…read moreand glazed donuts, and pastries. I went late on a Sunday morning and the small parking lot next door was full. There was a short line in the small shop ahead of me and some of the best sellers were sold out. The person who helped me answered all my questions and I enjoyed everything I tried, including a small cinnamon roll-like pastry and palmier. Best of all, I bought 3 items and the total was less than $6! I look forward to coming again to try more.

    Photos
    Golden Hands Bakery - Chocolate filled donut

    Chocolate filled donut

    Golden Hands Bakery - So many choices, so little stomach room!

    So many choices, so little stomach room!

    Golden Hands Bakery

    See all

    Cookie Plug - desserts - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...