Absolutely the best cupcake shop around. I am not typically a cupcake person whatsoever, but Abby Girl Sweets consistently does an amazing job and has for years. In my box in the picture I had red velvet, Oreo, coconut, and vanilla with sugar cookie cupcakes. My all time favorite is the reeses peanut butter cup one which is a chocolate cupcake and peanut butter frosting. All of their frostings are delicious and very rich, unlike most cupcake frostings you would get at the store. If you're looking for a quick and easy dessert this is the place to go! read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - 4 Cupcakes - You Choose Flavors - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

We ordered 5 dozen cupcakes for an event last week. Everything was boxed up ready on time and I even got some help carrying the boxes to the car. The cupcakes were scrumptious and beautifully made - a real hit at our 60th high school reunion. Highly recommend. read more

This is my go-to place for cupcakes, and this is HUGE coming from a sweet tooth. I've been a couple times to the Downtown one, but last weekend, I just grabbed one from here because I was in the area. I love carrot cake, and their carrot cake cupcake does justice (in my head). The cake is soft, the icing is perfect, and it's not toooo sweet. The amount of spice in it is right (as per my preferences). I wish they used walnuts instead of the lone Pecan, but it's not a deal-breaker for me. I've tried their coconut and red velvet previously as well, and they are good too. It's hard to be disappointed with their cupcakes. read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - a hand holding a cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Noah was polite cheerful and helpful with a beautiful smile!! Cupcakes are the best in Cincy!! read more

Wait...I haven't reviewed my favorite Cincinnati cupcake place?!?!? Cupcakes are hands down one of the best in the city. ALWAYS consistent and moist. ALWAYS fresh and you can taste the REAL ingredients. My favorite one is the strawberry delight. Yea...I usually even get the leftovers pieces off the paper when no one is watching me. read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - a variety of cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

The best place for all your cupped cake needs! Every half and whole birthday for my son brings me here. You MAY not like every flavor. However, ask yourself: do you really expect to like every flavor if you have tried literally every flavor? Best of all: they won't ask how many people will be eating the cupcakes. They even give you a special box so the cupped cakes stay upright on the way home! In your car! The cupcakes are probably soo good, they could drive better than the average Ohioan? read more

Was given a 4 pack of cupcakes as a gift. They were very good. Carrot cake and cookies n cream were very good. My wife liked the chocolate ones. read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Gift box - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Thank you Abby Girl Sweets for your delicious cupcakes and superb service!! My sister received your outstanding cupcakes for her sixtieth birthday yesterday and was pleasantly surprised and one very happy lady!! I live in Toronto, Ontario (Canada). Thank you for helping me bring sweetness and joy to my sister on her big day! Well done. I highly recommend this cupcakery!! Valerie K. read more

Very hyped. Terrible customer service. Cupcakes were moist. They were ok tasting cupcakes.

Delicious and light. Always fresh and tasty. A tru 'go to place' Yelp says I was too concise so let me reiterate - they are great. read more

I got 2 cupcakes and a mini key lime cheesecake. I ate the black raspberry chip cupcake.....DELICIOUS! Just the right amount of sweetness, black raspberry flavor, and chips. I also got a triple chocolate cupcake.....ALL were fabulous. In case you get confused, it's inside Jungle Jim's in Eastgate. read more

I've gone to this place a few times since it's close to work, and it has never disappointed. It's not so easy to make a standout cupcake, but this place does. The building entrance is in a strip mall, so it might be easy to miss, and the inside is just a counter to order and go. The workers are always super pleasant and helpful when making the difficult decision of what to get. I got the peanut butter cup and the sugar baby. I've gotten both before and they're so good I had to go back. The peanut butter cup has the perfect balance of peanut utter frosting to chocolate cake, and the cakes are always baked to perfection. Plus it has a mini Reese's pb cup that somehow disappeared before I managed to take a picture . The sugar cookie one has a small cookie on top, and is really a pretty basic vanilla cupcake with buttercream, but it's soooo good. I need to go back and try all the other flavors! read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

The air in the shop smells so tantalizing and sweet! I knew I wanted a cupcake with filling, and the baker made a suggestion that did not disappoint! The tuxedo chocolate cupcakes with vanilla bean filling was delicious! Cost was $3.50 for 1 cupcake. The cake portion of the cupcake was not simply a carrier for the topping. The cake was so spongy and homemade. I'm incredibly picky when it comes to chocolate cake- this cake was top notch! read more

I cannot love Abby Girl Sweets enough! I've been getting cupcakes here since they opened their first location and I've had great service ever since. The cupcakes are delicious and they've fulfilled my request for a special order for an event. I've never had a better cupcake than the ones from Abby Girl Sweets! read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Vanilla cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Around my birthday, I started dropping some hints to my husband that some fancy cupcakes would really hit the spot. Well, he took the hint, and showed up for lunch with two boxes full of Abby Girl Cupcakes! He picked out a variety of flavors, including Strawberry Delight, Strawberry Frosting, Cookies N Cream, Peanut Butter Cup, etc. As much as I love fancy cupcakes, it seems like they are always just too sweet to really enjoy. NOT the case here! The icing was perfect - not too sweet and not hard or flaky. The cupcakes themselves were moist and delish! I would definitely return and have more cupcakes! To be fair, I haven't visited the location myself yet...although perhaps that is safer for my waistline. ;-) read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Abby To Go - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

The cupcakes here are amazing! They're so moist and flavorful! My family got some for me last night to celebrate me leaving for college the next day and they were so good! My cupcake was the peanut butter chocolate one and I loved it, especially the frosting. I would definitely come back to this place and recommend it. read more

Best cupcakes and chess cake flavors around!! We gone 2 weekends in a row and by one for each day of the upcoming week. read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Best cupcakes in town!! My husband loves their cheeses!! The staff is friendly too. - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Seriously the best cupcakes I've ever had, and I've done the research . I used to drive all the way downtown for them but I was so happy when they opened the Blue Ash location. My husband, family and friends are now hooked on them too. Their cake recipe is so moist and the flavors are amazing. I like that they keep favorites on the menu but add special flavors weekly. Some of my favs: cookies n cream, double trouble, s'mores, sugar baby etc. we love these cupcakes so much we get them for every special occasion, birthdays, showers, including a cupcake tower at our wedding. Seriously a gem in Cincinnati read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Vanilla and strawberry cupcakes we ordered for bridal shower. Toppers purchased separately. - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Delicious CuppyCakes!! I appreciate the variety and that they are just so yummy. I don't have a favorite because they are all so good. Traditional Chocolate and Vanilla to Carrot Cake!!! I also like that they have mini cheesecakes, which are rich and creamy. They aren't cheap, but they are well worth the price. This is definitely a go to when i want to treat someone to a little something special. read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Raspberry Chocolate Chip Abby Girl Sweets Cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Who doesn't like a sweet treat? I was super excited to try one of these little gems, heck maybe 4. I was super disappointed with this cupcake on many levels. First, the cake portion of this cupcake was super oily. That is not a mistake for being moist. The frosting was slightly hard and extremely surgery. I came to this shop mid evening so does that mean it was sitting out all day? Maybe the reasons why it was as explained. I would give this place a 5 star for the flavor combos and names. The perfect balance between cupcake and frosting was proportionate. The packaging was great. The box held our little gems and they were easy to get out when we arrived to our hotel. Very sad to give this the rating and willing to try again. I live out of town so it may not be for awhile. I would recommmend you give it a try and decide for yourself. Seemed like the timing when I purchased these. read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Best cupcakes in Cincinnati and believe me I have had my share of cupcakes. Their cupcakes are fresh tasting, moist and the icing are delightful. I have been coming to this place for years now and I wouldn't go anywhere else. They are great at what they do...cranking out delicious cupcakes. read more

Wonderful cupcakes, slightly overpriced but they worked perfectly for an impromptu birthday weekend. The vanilla bean is one of the best. It's great to shop local. read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Variety of flavors - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

You absolutely MUST stop and try this cupcakery. We actually stumbled upon it trying to find another store and wanted to treat ourselves. I had heard of Abby Girl many times but had never been given the chance to try it. We decided to "split one cupcake between the two of us," which means we left with two for me and two for him. I opted for a New York cheesecake and a double trouble cupcake, my boyfriend got a peanut butter cup cupcake and a cookies and cream cupcake. First of all, my cheesecake was absolutely mind blowing. Seriously some of the best that I've ever had and the fact that it's able to be eaten without a fork makes it an A+ in my book. I haven't tried to double trouble yet, but it was recommended by the cashier above all of the other cupcakes so I feel positive that it's going to that I'm going to be satisfied. My boyfriend already ate both of his and liked both of them so much that he was making borderline inappropriate noises. He says that Abby Girl are the cupcakes he's ever had. And he went ahead and repeated this three or four times on the way, in case I didn't hear him the first time. As for me, I am INSANELY partial to The Bonbonerie as I want to take a dive into the opera cream ... But Abby Girl probably ties with Bonbonerie. Seriously. Go. If you happen to pass this shop or if you're like me and will willingly drive forever away for a fanastic cupcake, go to Abby Girl. read more

See all

This gal has an inner fat kid that will never say no to a cupcake! No surprise that while in Cincinnati for work my sweet tooth kicked in. Thanks to Yelp I discovered this cute little cupcakery very close to my hotel (dangerous!). After picking up dinner I made my way to this place. It is located in a shopping center with plenty of parking. There was not anyone else in the store when I went. The lady working (who I might guess was the owner) was nice but not overly friendly which was fine. I ended up getting the peanut butter cup and sugar baby. The cupcakes (yes I ate them both...do not judge me!) were pretty good and not dry at all. There was a good amount of icing but not overload. The flavor was pretty good and basic which was fine but I've had better. Overall I'd definitely go back to this cupcakery. They do close what I consider to be early (6pm) so if you get an after dinner sweet treats craving there won't be any stopping at this place. Plan ahead for that sweet tooth craving. read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Abby Girl isn't my favorite cupcake spot in Cincinnati, but this location is very close to my office so when we need to celebrate, this is our go-to stop. They usually have 8-10 flavor options, ranging from chocolate stuff to fruit stuff. The cake is usually very soft and the icing is a good 3 inches on top. I just don't feel like the flavors are as strong as they could be, and I do like a little a cupcake to be a little more dense then soft. Just personal preference. ANd they only have cupcakes, no cakepops, cookies or any other variety. I would recommend going earlier in the day for a better selection. But its a quick in/quick out...I don't believe there is anywhere to sit inside. Nice place to stop and grab something sweet after a lunch next door at City BBQ. read more

My boyfriend and I wanted to do gender reveal cupcakes and they agreed to do them. The staff was so genuinely excited to do these for us and couldn't wait to know details on when the reveal was going to take place. Not only did they do a wonderful job making sure the secret was kept, but the cupcakes were beautiful and absolutely delicious. Our families could not get enough and I'm sure you guys gained a few more customers because of it! Jerry and I really appreciate it! read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - Gender reveal cupcakes...perfectly done and so yummy! :) - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Went here for dessert to bring to a small gathering. First time here! I went later on a Saturday afternoon, so the selection was dwindling. Snagged the last red velvet cupcake :o) Also selected the double chocolate and triple chocolate, the sea salt caramel, peanut butter and chocolate, cookies and cream, and one that looked like a Hostess cupcake! Everyone at the gathering loved them :o) We cut them in half so that we could sample a few. I tried the red velvet and double chocolate. Both were moist and not overly sweet. DELICIOUS! The Hostess cupcake look alike was also a fav among tasters, as was the double and triple chocolate. The reason I subtracted a star was I started driving away and realized that I did not know how to keep them until the party. Did I need to refrigerate? So I had to turn of the engine and run back in. read more

I have to say, I just wasn't impressed. Yes, they have cupcakes in their name, but they do not sell anything but cupcakes. Unfortunately, the afternoon I visited, they only had about six different types of cupcakes, with only one type of chocolate, which to me, just isn't a heck of a lot of variety. For the price, I believe $3 or so, the cupcakes are very small. The icing didn't even cover the entire top of the cupcake. To me, the icing is the best part! The icing itself was somewhat thin, almost a whippy type icing, which I'm not a fan of. The cake itself was moist. I simply expected a lot more. read more

I am not a huge cake fan (probably because I ate too much of it growing up), but I love a nice sized, delicious cupcake! Abby Girl has some of the best in the city! They offer almost 20 regular flavors along with a variety of specials added each week. I seriously stare at the flavors as if I'm making a life or death decision because there are soooo many great ones! They're soft, they're moist, and they're delicious! read more

Abby Girl Sweets Cupcakery - When you can't pick just one! - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Abby Girl Sweets has the best cupcakes I have ever had! We had them for our wedding, come to the store on random trips, and just had them for my husband's 30th birthday! No other cupcake store even compares! read more

I was going to try this cupcakery downtown and saw on their site that they have one in Blue Ash which is closer to where i live. Went there and ordered 4 kinds: Strawberry Delight, Cookies-n-Cream, Double Trouble and Classic Vanilla Bean on Vanilla. After we taste tested them, we decided that Double Trouble and Classic Vanilla were our favorites. The Double Trouble is reminiscent of a Hostess chocolate cupcake filled with white cream except this was topped with ganache which made it worlds apart; the vanilla one was excellent. The strawberry one wasn't our favorite - it's color looked a bit too pink! I'm a sucker for background stories of how places got their name and this one is named after the owner's daughter's nickname. While it is not our favorite cupcakery in the Cincinnati, it runs a close second. read more

I love this place like you should only love another human, but I am not ashamed! I mean, anything that gives you butterflies and increases your heart rate is love, right? My 'Be the Change' class asked for red velvet cupcakes for our end of year party. Could I make 'em, yeah, but do I need to prove it, no. So I went to Abby Girl, which I have decided was a serendipitous moment in my life. Doing my due diligence, I can report that I have tried nearly all the flavors and have loved each and every bite. From the banana pudding to the key lime pie, there is nothing else like Abby Girl cupcakes! Is is just me, or do cupcakes seem guilt-free? read more

Never thought I'd write one review for cupcake joints, let alone two reviews. I just don't remember cupcakes as a kid tasting remotely like these delicious little orbs. I do recall repeated episodes at neighbor kids' birthday parties: lurching toward the sink to wash down a mass of Duncan Hines dryness, partaking precious water just prior to choking. Pretty much the same ritual over and over. So what's a smart kid to do? I gave them up for a couple decades. And then along came my wife's introduction to me and Abby Girl. Amazing attention to visual detail; very moist cupcakes; flavors like they invented the word flavor; and a visual appeal that transforms some of these babies into edible art forms. Yeah. They are that good. The cupcakes are decadent and great tasting. No water chaser needed, to say the least. One negative: The girls who work there in the afternoon could afford to smile and be just a wee bit friendly. read more

I wanted to love this place. I really did. I bought 4 vanilla cupcakes and 2 coconut cupcakes. I assumed because of the reviews I'd love them, so I bought six of them. I don't like them at all. They have a play-doh taste to them( it tastes exactly how play-doh smells) maybe it was a off day. But I'm disappointed. It was clean inside and the staff was quick. The lady thoughtfully packed my cupcakes. That's why the two stars. I wish the cupcakes tasted good read more

After seeing all the rave reviews for this cupcakery, I decided to make a special stop there on my way home from work to pick up some treats to celebrate my wedding anniversary with. I went arrived around noon. The shop is very small, but there were two or three tables in there if you wanted to sit and enjoy your sweet purchase. The decor is very cute. When I got to the counter, I found about 8-10 different kinds of cupcakes to choose from, but I felt like the majority of my options were chocolate in some way. Not a big deal, but chocolate cake isn't necessarily at the top of my list. I left with four different kinds: 1. Salted Caramel 2. Peanut butter cup 3. Cookies'n'creme 4. Double or triple chocolate something or other--it looked like those hostess cupcakes. My husband I both agree the cupcakes were good. The cake was soft and moist, which is great. But that's kinda where the greatness ended for us. My husband ate the salted caramel cupcake and he said there was no caramel flavor to be tasted. He said it was like eating a regular cupcake with a sweet and salty cream frosting. The rest of the cupcakes were inundated with absurd amounts of frosting. The frosting may have been good, but gosh, does there have to be so much? Also, price. I spent nearly $12 on four cupcakes. This may be completely reasonable for the industry, I have no idea. But if I'm going to spend $12 on frosted pastries, it's going to be on a dozen donuts at Holtmans, where every bite blows my mind and the frosting never overtakes it's doughy vessel. read more

This place has, bar-none, the BEST cupcake in Cincinnati. It is literally perfect. In fact, here is a list of the things that are perfect: - The amount of icing - The moistness - Their selection of flavors - The fact that 3 days later, it is still delicious Well I could go on and on but bottom line is: resistance is futile. Get thee to Abby Girl and be prepared to start thinking up reasons you need to be in Blue Ash in order to have an excuse to get some cupcakes. read more

It's not often I go out of my way to make buy sweets, so when I do, I like it to be good stuff. And, because I no longer work near The Sweeterie, it was time I found the next best thing in the area. Thankfully, Abby Girl Sweets has set up shop in Blue Ash, in addition to its Downtown location. Location: Abby Girl Sweets (Blue Ash) is located on the corner of Kenwood and Glendale-Milford (right where Glendale-Milford turns into Pfieffer), which makes its location easy to get to by highway (I-71, I-75, I-275, and Ronald Reagan) and by any major surround thoroughfare. I went around lunchtime, which meant it could potentially be very crowded. Conversely, there was sufficient parking, and only one group ahead of me. Atmosphere: The interior of the shop is very cute, but doesn't allow for a lot of space to eat in. The décor is unassuming and fresh, and from what I recall there was a table for patrons to enjoy their sweets in house. Because I was taking my cupcakes to go, sitting in was not necessary. (I have a feeling that sitting in probably doesn't happen a whole heckuvalot, as it's very convenient to grab your treat(s) and go.) Food: Being the awesome girlfriend that I am, I decided what better day to give AGS a try than to swing by and pick up a couple of treats before meeting Date at our favorite lunch spot for his birthday? The nice thing about going myself was that I got to choose the flavors. Fortunately, Date likes just about everything, so it was all but assured he would be okay with whatever cupcake(s) I decided. Naturally, I went with Triple Chocolate and Cookies-N-Cream. The former we split after his birthday lunch, while the latter we split after I took him out for birthday dinner. Both were pretty good but not too rich and, seeing as I don't particularly like icing to begin with, the fact that the icing wasn't TOO rich was a pretty big deal. I will certainly return to Abby Girl Sweets in the future, as I wouldn't mind trying more flavors (or repeating the ones I previously had), and having AGS within close proximity of my everyday life is quite a treat. No pun intended. read more

Here's Abby Girl's new location in Blue Ash. Which is very close to my work...and their cupcakes are the best in town...oh, geez, this could be bad. This location is slightly bigger than their downtown location, so there is a small area with three four-top bar tables. I was pleased to see they are using Square for their checkout system. Makes it easy and quick to pay with your smartphone (or cash, or plastic, too of course). From what I can tell they stock the same flavors at both locations, and they always post their current flavors on Facebook. Makes it easy to watch for your favorites and time your visits appropriately. If you aren't sure what to try, I recommend anything based on the strawberry cupcake. Absolutely delicious! They do custom orders as well, just call ahead. read more

Best cupcakes ever. But - you will pay for it. At $3 a cupcake, it's too expensive. The taste is worth it. Gourmet cupcakes like red velvet and strawberry blast. An occasional treat - because of the price. But fantastic! read more

This place is amazing! I love this location so much more than.downtown. Its much bigger. Also the fact that its close to my job is another huge Plus for me but not for my hips! My favorite is the double trouble and the strawberry. But I often try new ones everytime I stop by. Definitely check their Twitter or FB for updates on weekly specials. The best time to stop by is around 12ish (pm) during the week. If you wait until after work at 5 you will be very upset, as there won't be much to choose from. They also do call ahead orders as well! Enjoy!! read more