We had my mom's 80th birthday at the Mill Creek Tavern and had the best time. The food was…read moredelicious and exactly as we discussed in the planning, many choices and plentiful. The room was the perfect size for the party and had a nice nautical theme which we added our own party decor to. I can't say enough about the service. Vanessa was the easiest coordinator to work with planning the event, and did everything she said. She and Jeanne and the other servers at the party kept the drinks flowing, the food coming, and were so nice, it really made the evening. I highly recommend Mill Creek for any event you have or just for a delicious dinner and a fun night out

The staff is friendly and the food is delicious at this neighborhood treasure. Check out their prix…read morefixe menu and their daily specials. On Wednesday they offer bottles of wine at half price. Come here to meet friends and relax.

The food here is fantastic! Came here one evening with my…read moregirlfriend for some drinks/dinner and we had a great time. I ordered the buffalo chicken sandwich with fries and she got the nachos with cheese and chicken and it was phenomenal! It was easy to get to and the service was A+. Definitely hit them up next time you're in the area, you will not be disappointed.

Not busy initially and service was sparse Water has to be…read moreprompted to be refilled Hamburger wasnt a good portion and side dish sparse Then it's became similar to Applebee's/ friendlys... There was peace/quiet which Became families galore. Good 4 them bad to hear one another talking. Parking wasn't available.... had to park around back and locate spot They had a rear entrance Place was clean Toilets had paper Won't be back there's taby's with better taste and Freshness and ample portions next door Costs were a bit high even for my neighborhood

Great food, service and views! Lobster roll was great - Connecticut Style. Definitely will be back!read more

Stunning view!!! This restaurant is located right on the beach and offer outdoor seating that…read moreoverlooks the beach. It's absolutely gorgeous! The staff here is very friendly and attentive! Drinks are amazing! They use to have a frozen rose but it's been replaced with a marg. We prefer the frozen rose haha! The food here is great. Will def be back!

The Homestead has become our annual spot for celebrating my dad's birthday and a belated Mother's…read moreDay with my mom and grandma. Each time we've come we've been taken great care of. Lisa the bartender and Katie our waitress go above and beyond to make the experience special and make sure we have everything we need to fully enjoy our meals. The interior of this restaurant features an expansive bar with plenty of tables, plus a private party room. Ample parking here is appreciated as well -- hard to come by in the town of Oyster Bay! The menu features elevated pub fare and includes all the staples (think wings, a giant pretzel, plus burgers and sandwiches) along with seafood and steak options if you're in the mood for something a bit fancier. This year we started off with drinks at the bar - my Moscow mule was ice cold and served in a copper mug. Next, we moved on to appetizers. The fried calamari was crispy and fresh, the baked clams were cooked perfectly and served in an incredible sauce that we lapped up with their signature garlic bread (a must order!). The pretzel was warm and fluffy, the tuna tower was fresh and invigorating. The lobster bisque is another must try - served in a fancy bowl with a lid to keep it piping hot. The wedge salad has just the right amount of toppings to lettuce ratio. I was stuffed at this point, but was happy to have half of my French Dip sandwich with impeccably seasoned fries waiting for me the in the refrigerator next morning (had one Moscow mule too many, they were too good).

Horrible set up: handicapped parking is in the back, but the back entrance has stairs. The only…read morealleyway is too narrow for a wheelchair. We had to walk way around and even the main entrance is almost too small for a wheelchair. Horrible supply: asked for a few different drinks and they had no supplies to make them. Terrible food: was there for a funeral after gathering, only 4 food items, they were cold, no regular soda, the server behind the buffet basically "slopped" it onto the plates in small messy portions.

Fabulous place to eat!! This is our second time here and the food is great, the presentation is…read moreperfect and the drinks are good as well. I had the special soup, the Calamari and the Tuna. My wife had the Calamari, salad and the firecracker Shrimp. The food and service was great!!! The seating and music are all good. I strongly recommend coming here!

Clean restaurant, good service but the menu was limited, but what they did have was very good…read more Good atmosphere and the bar looked busy.

Everything about this place is on point. Staff is excellent. Attentive, informed of the menu and…read morerecommendations. Ambiance is cozy, romantic and quiet. Prices are at the level you'd expect for this class of restaurant and service. Change nothing about this place, it's perfect.

Decided to eat here for my anniversary dinner on a Sunday night. Nice atmosphere in a side street…read morejust off the main drag in oyster bay. We opted for the 4 course pre-fixe for $105 which includes two appetizers, entree and dessert. We had oysters, bucatini with clams, cheese board and roasted mushrooms for apps, all good. Branzino and pork chop were up next, also quite tasty. Apple strudel was good tho the banana pudding was skippable. They comped us a champagne toast which was nice. Only ding is very limited wine by the glass menu. Otherwise, a solid choice for a special occasion dinner.

Came here with a friend to try after hearing great things. This place was HUGE…read more There was a lot of different beers to choose from and they let you have six beers in the flight which I thought was great. The bartender had great recommendations and was super friendly. Service was super quick and all the beers were delicious. I had a great experience and would absolutely come back.

Had a great time here. They have plenty of good beers and they also partner with other vendors to…read morehave wine and liquor to drink for those that don't do beer There is a pool table and some games as well if you want to have some fun. Came alone and met some great people. Both the workers and those who came to drink gave me local recommendations of things to try out. I will definitely come back when I'm in the area