We stopped by here on Saturday night after the recommendation from a few people…read more The menu offers a lot of options. You can choose their custom creations or build your own pizza (which we did). As well, there are 3 different options of crust consistencies. For those that are gluten free, not to worry they have that as a choice and a cauliflower crust too! There's also some tasty looking pastas, salads & sandwiches. We started off with a few adult beverages & wings Did the two sauces (12 ct) buffalo bbq & buffalo garlic parmesan. So surprised by the taste of the buffalo garlic parmesan. Best one "flavor wise", we've had out thus far. Great wings! For our pizza again we did the build your own. Went with the thin crust topped with pepperoni, garlic and fresh basil. It came out piping hot, fresh and fantastic. The crust was amazing. Light & crispy and held up to those ingredients perfectly. The way that the pizza is presented and cut into those grids gives it a stylish dimension & easier to share amongst others. A genius creation to make it effortless to handle. Atmosphere was fun. Even had time for a karaoke tune! Our server was polite and always on top of things to make sure we were being well taken care of throughout our experience. Superb customer service! This location is a family operated business. You can feel the presence of that right when you walk thru the doors. These are the best types of restaurants as you feel the comfortable warm hospitality while at the same time pleasantly enjoying a good authentic Italian experience. If anyone is missing excellent midwest cuisine, please visit. You will not regret it!

I live nearby an have always wanted to stop in and have some pizza. Yesterday was the day…read more The inside is small but they make the space work. They have a wrap around bar, a lot of low level tables and high top tables. They also have seating outside. They had freezing cold AC blasting but also offered heaters for the outdoor seating in cooler days or nights. We were seated right away and the waitstaff were all very friendly and attentive. We ordered a small Caesar salad, 6 buffalo wings and a 10 in Sears Tower pizza. Everything was good no complaints.

4.5 out of 5. 1st…read moretime trying this place. Saturday afternoon. Pretty much a ghost town. It's a shame, cuz it was very good. They had some college basketball on TV but volume was very low, which was great. I was able to think, chat and listen to my music in ear after conversation was done. Place was clean. Service was excellent. Young lady at the register was learning but diligent and got the help she needed. Robert was personable and kind and conversational. Ordered 3 slices while i waited for a to go order. Barbecue Chicken, Hawaiian and Margarita. All three had amazing crust and undercarriage, almost zero bend. Margarita isn't my favorite pizza in the world but it was pretty darn good. Mozzarella was fresh, cherry tomatoes were good and just enough olive oil. 4.5 out of 5 Hawaiian is one of my favorites and this was great. Lots of ham and pineapple. The flavor was strong. 4.5 out of 5. Barbecue Chicken and Bacon was very good but had a tad more barbecue sauce than i need. I will ask for about 25% less next time. 4 out of 5. Garlic knots and half pepperoni and half supreme/combo to go. Wife really enjoyed the pepperoni. I had a bite and thought is was pretty standard. 4 out of 5. Combo was good, but the crust was soft in the middle (water from the veggies?). Undercarriage was weak but was better towards the crust. 3.5 out of 5. The garlic knots were top notch. Garlic and buttery, but not too strong. Crunchy on the outside amd soft on thr inside. Overall, this was a very strong showing. It's gonna be a problem for me that this place is 5 mins from my home. I will likely eat in or just do the by the slice to keep that strong crunch. I may ask for some jalapeño on the Hawaiian or barbecue chicken to get a little heat. I appreciate that all their pizza is available every day. The last place i ate at didn't have some options available except on specific days. I will be back!

Check your order before you leave…read more This restaurant is notorious for getting orders wrong, and unfortunately, it happened to me again, this is the second time. I ordered two orders of meatballs (4 total) and only received 2. They did offer to remake the missing order, but I would've had to go back and pick it up, which wasn't convenient. When the mistake is on their end, there should be a better effort to make it right. They also didn't offer anything extra for the inconvenience. no complimentary order next time, just a credit for the two meatballs I never received, which is the bare minimum since I already paid for them. Between the repeated mistakes and the lack of real customer service, I won't be ordering from here again. There are plenty of great Italian restaurants nearby that get it right the first time, I'd recommend going somewhere else.

Amazing food and service. This food truck came to our community Tuesday night and it was our first…read moretime trying. I ordered 1 pepperoni and 1 Margherita. It was the best pizza I've ever tried. Crust was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. All the toppings were fresh and delicious. Highly recommend this food truck. Can't wait to try other pizzas on the menu.

Wasn't that bad, Wife and myself goes to the Queen Creek…read moreFood Truck Festival every Friday. This week, Nicastro was there and since we are always willing to try pizza from a business we haven't tried yet. We ordered two pepperoni pizza's well done. They cooked it to perfection, crispy and with some chard ends. The pizza was pretty good, not the best we have had, however it was pretty good. We really liked the pepperoni and the cheese. Those two ingredient is what made the pizza good. Glad we had the opportunity to try their pizza, both were very nice and courteous.

Haven't been able to stop in in a few months. Always great. They had lots of double dog products in…read morestock.

My husband and I stopped in for a late dinner after running some errands and were welcomed by the…read moremost pleasant staff. They were very friendly and even offered a few recommendations, which we appreciated. I went with the Italian stromboli, while my husband opted for the meatball, sausage, and pepperoni stromboli. Both looked fantastic, but we agreed that the meatball version had more flavor and was much heartier. The Italian stromboli was a little light on meat, making it feel a bit too bread-heavy for my taste. We also ordered the garlic cheese knots, and those were pretty darn good--soft, cheesy, and full of flavor. Overall, we had a great experience and enjoyed the welcoming atmosphere. Despite my stromboli not quite living up to expectations, we'll definitely be back to try more items on the menu.

Pizza is always my favorite tried the wings this last time and they weren't terrible sauce could…read moreuse some improvement.

Our experience was pretty bad. From ordering at the counter (the staff gossiping, ignoring…read morecustomers, and using bad language in front of kids), the food being incorrect, poor customer service, and mold in the red pepper shaker! Things were bad enough but not worth saying anything until my family realized the red pepper shaker had moldly food stuck on the inside of the shaker. I asked to speak with a manager who just simply asked us if we wanted a new shaker?! I told him that this was a health code violation and he said, "well we wash these every week. Maybe a kid opened it up and put something in there". No offer to make anything correct, refund, apologize, or anything. I ended up calling later and requesting a refund. Horrible customer service which is a bummer because the pizza is pretty goo

Pizza thin crust was great and friendly and good service planning to go back and try their deep…read moredish and roast beef sandwiches

I didn't want to give too bad of a review because it seems like it's a family business. I had the…read more10" New York style pizza and it was almost cardboard-like, not much taste at all. A couple next to me ordering a pan pizza and it took over an hour so they left, upset. It's rare that I ever give a low score but the rating would show that this would've been a better place than it was.

I just want to give a huge shoutout to Christian at the Queen Creek Pieology. Despite the store…read morebeing out of so many essentials--several toppings, cups for the soda fountain, and even small containers for sides of ranch--Christian handled everything with grace, professionalism, and a kind heart. He apologized sincerely and did his best to make the experience a good one, even though it was clear that he was let down by things beyond his control. It's rare to see someone stay so composed and customer-focused under pressure. He truly went above and beyond! Pieology, I hope management sees what a gem they have in Christian. He deserves recognition and support--because employees like him make all the difference! Management failed him!

Growing pains. Eventually, they might be amazing but right now they are not quite ready for prime…read moretime. There were a couple of irate customers in front of me who had trouble with their online orders. Both were given refunds. The speed at which orders were processed and food prepared was much slower than competitor Mod Pizza. My wife was disappointed by the puny container used for the custom salad as well as the limited options for greens. My veggie pizza looked amazing and they added ricotta cheese per my request. (Mod Pizza doesn't carry ricotta anymore.) Flavor wise, I was disappointed with how bland my pizza tasted. Fortunately, the bites with fresh basil were flavorful. After two pieces, I concluded it was their red sauce which lacked flavor. They have limited indoor seating (three tables and a bar) but do offer outdoor seating too. The background music of pop hits was nice. One of the servers checked in to make sure we were enjoying our meal which was nice. She also brought me a box. I will probably try them again in a few months.

Pretty busy on Wednesday @ 5:30. Seated immediately. Would have preferred booth with less light…read moreshining in our eyes but it all worked out ok. Our server was very sweet and efficient. Ordered a glass of Chianti for me. Hubs and I shared large Caesar salad and spicy specialty medium pizza. Both were absolutely delicious and 9/10. Especially enjoyed the buttery croutons, thin yummy crust, sauce and fresh generous toppings. I visited restroom and it was clean and well-stocked. Very important for any eating establishment. Noticed a separate large area for group seating. Good to know. We are yearly AZ visitors and plan on coming here again. Highly Recommend! ~EG Eats

Just okay - we went for happy hour and I'm not sure if I'd go back. The bacon wrapped scallops were…read moregood but the garlic bread only tasted like toasted bread there was no flavor to it. The drinks are limited if you don't like sweet drinks so I paid full price for a cocktail off the list. When the bill came the price of the cocktail in the receipt was different than was was in the menu on the table. The waitress did change it but a customer shouldn't have to tell you the price is incorrect. The service was good. She checked on us frequently. There was nothing special about the restaurant so I wouldn't go here for date night but I did see other couples there for date night. It's a decent family restaurant.