Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Corner Slice

    4.2 (46 reviews)
    Closed 12:00 pm - 8:00 PM
    Updated 2 weeks ago

    Corner Slice Photos

    CORNER SLICE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Corner Slice

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Menu
    Darren S.

    Finally made it to Corner Slice! Been wanting to visit this spot for a while, and finally got a round. It's VERY EASY to miss, no jazzy sign or anything --- I just followed my Google Maps to a T. This business serves up awesome sicilian square pizzas (NOT DETROIT). I arrived at about 6:15pm, and much of their pizzas were already sold out. Luckily, I got to try a few items --- the white pizza, the pepperoni pizza, and their famous garlic *NOT. The employee was super helping in explaining what was in the white pizza (you guessed it...lot of mozzarella and ricotta --- but also: a touch of LEMON!), so I got that....and it was super delicious. This type of pizza can only be eaten HOT. The dish is automatically elevated once it touches the heat of the oven. Pepperoni is pepperoni....but lets talk about THAT CRUST on these pizzas. It must be sourdough --- that's my guess. There's a lightness to the crunch that normal sicilian slices do not have. Owner, am I right? Now --- onto that Garlic NOT. What in the layered, buttery hell is this? This is a glutton's dream. I was peeling this NOT like it was a biscuit with layers. It is decadent --- and bigger than a Costco cupcake. But it's only available here --- so you do you, boo. Get it. All in all, very satisfied!

    Upside down pie. Pepperoni. White slice. Garlic knot. (Pizza cut in thirds for 3 people to share on a pizza tour)

    Simply great. Honestly one of the best pizza I have eaten in my 60 plus years. 3 of us went on a pizza tour. We all said this was the best of the day. We can't wait to come back.

    Jonathan B.

    Solid square slice. I had the Buffalo, pepperoni and cheese slice. Great taste, nice and airy - bring from NY I would prefer a little extra sauce but theirs have just enough. Chilled location and ambiance and the staff is friendly. Definitely a go to if you are in area - I recommend. 4 stars

    Garlic "Not"
    Rinny C.

    Every time we go we are not disappointed. The counter staff is always so personable and welcoming. Besides the great customer service the pizza is just ridiculous! The crust is perfection and it's worth the 25 minute drive. The garlic "not" is a must have! I wish we lived closer because we would be there every week.

    Upside Down pie, one half sausage
    Danielle J.

    Tried this place because the Upside Down was rated the #1 slice in NJ. (I wouldn't call it that, but solid slice) Overall good slice, very fresh ingredients and soft, but crunchy crust. The few times I have been the staff has always been friendly and the place has been clean.

    Menu
    Will B.

    We actually left another venue and weren't quite full so we came here. A great local pizza spot feel, the staff were immediately fun and friendly. They make you feel like a "regular" right off the bat. Everyone in there was happy and enjoying the food, the whole experience was a vibe. Parking is terrible, but worth it. The place smells amazing from all of the pizza and other dishes. A worth it stop! Grades: Pepperoni: A Margarita: A Buffalo: B Vodka: A

    Giant garlic knot.  $9.00 each, meh.
    Tim S.

    3.5 Stars. This was our final stop on our NY/NJ pizza tour. We got here super late, right before they were about to close (Thanks, NY Traffic near the Holland Tunnel!) When we arrived there were limited options since it was so late. I went with a cheese slice and a garlic knot. Had a root beer to drink. Total was close to $20.00. How was it? Cheese Slice- Pretty tasty. Light, airy, crunchy, good cheese. Solid square slice. I ate so much pizza during the day, I probably didn't appreciate it as much as I could have, but still a good slice. Garlic Knot- These things are massive! They also cost a lot too ($9.00 for one knot). It was good, but not $9.00 good. Lots of garlic, peel apart like a pinwheel kind of. Tasty enough. Service was friendly enough. I would come back if in the area to try out different slices.

    The white and margarita slices were my favorite!
    Jennifer T.

    The pizza is light, airy, with a buttery tasting crust. The slices are on the smaller side given their higher price. We had the upside down Sicilian, Reg cheese slice, white slice, and their margarita slice. My favorites were the margarita and the white slice. They were very good and flavorful! The white slice can use a bit more cheese, but it still was very good! My husband thought their reg cheese slices were very good. I thought the upside down slice was disappointing. The sauce didn't have any flavor in that slice. Overall the pizza was very good here. I recommend Corner Slice in Maplewood!

    Thomas L.

    Excellent pizza close to home. I saw this place in NJ.com as one of the best pizza places in NJ, so I gave it a try. I ordered Upside Down pizza at a specific time, 3:00 pm, from their website. I got a text message around 2:50 p.m. stating that the pizza was ready. Pizza is awesome. This is now my favorite place. I will try garbage pizza next time. The place is spotless and everything looks perfect. I recommend it if you are looking for a great pizza in the area. A gentleman who handled my pizza was a nice guy, very friendly--service with a smile. There is no parking, only street parking, but it was easy to find since the neighborhood is well-organized. The reference article is https://www.nj.com/entertainment/2025/09/new-jerseys-101-best-pizzas-ranked-for-2025.html

    Pepperoni slice, garbage slice, upside down. All exceptional but garbage was my hands down favorite
    meron R.

    Amazing square pizza. I highly recommend going here if you enjoy super crunchy flavorful square slice pizza. The menu is pretty simple as is the seating at corner slice. Of the slices I tried my top choice would def be their garbage pie which has red onion sausage jalapeño. This is just so flavorful. Can't wait to go back

    Krista B.

    They do what they do really well. Their slices remind me of Pizza Hut pan pie back in the 70s/80s if you're old enough to remember that. Crispy, light, airy, and the bottom of the crust is slightly oily, in a good way, as in not dry. I'm not usually a crust eater but I actually ate a fair bit of my crust. Service is good and they bring it to your table if they're not busy. The vibe is classic corner pizza joint with some funky touches like the old sign from their former city spot. Make sure to check out all the cool stickers in the bathroom!

    Corner Slice Garlic  Knot
    Big Dudes Big Foods B.

    After almost 6 years of supporting #SmallBusiness one bite at a time, @BigDudesBigFoods has reached our 1000th post. We headed down to #MaplewoodNJ to @Corner_Slice , an awesome pizza slice shop with a top notch selection of square pies. Mike and his #CornerSlice crew hooked us up with a flight of slices from their famous upside down to Margherita to #BuffaloChicken. My favorite was this week's special, #ChickenBaconRanch and Joe's was the #GarbagePie . The mouth watering #GarlicKnots are #BigDudesBigFoods sized for sure and delicious. This shop also has some great desserts. Today we tried the #KeyLimePie and were not disappointed. Corner Slice is a #MustStop for any pizza lover. These slices are soft in the middle and crunchy on the bottom and cooked perfectly. As you walk in and see the giant, nostalgic "Pizza" sign, block walls and church pews, it feels like a Pizza Speakeasy. You've got to get to @Corner_Slice #SupportSmallBusiness #BDBFCertified #BDBF #Foodie #Foodies

    Restroom decor
    Ronald K.

    This place is sure innovative! Owners experimenting in the back room with flavor combos...some perhaps not exactly what you would expect or want (hamburger slice, Pizza Hut style slice) but all ingredients are fresh. Pepperoni was the favorite though the white slice could have used a bit more flavor. Outside seating under the mural has Portland vibes and a nice addition to the neighborhood for sure!

    Pizza options

    See all

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Great restaurant - pizza was awesome crispy crust - right amount of sauce and toppings - going back soon!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Delicious sour dough pizza. Prices on the high end but delicious pizza and worth it for something unique and tasty.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Good crust. Friendly staff. Ok location. Nice selection of pizzas. My grandson loved it

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of O G.
    0
    2
    0

    1 year ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Michael B.

    Michael B.

    Thanks for the tip!

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Corner Slice

    You might also consider

    Osteria LK

    Osteria LK

    4.5
    (65 reviews)
    1.5 mi

    Elegant and cozy Italian restaurant in the heart of Maplewood, boasting homemade pastas, pizzas and…read moretraditional Italian entrees. Service is warm and accommodating. Quality of food is top notch. Ordered a pasta dish with roasted eggplant, garlic and basil in a tomato based sauce. It was savory, and eggplant was very tender. I also tried some of the chicken parmigiana (crispy with perfectly cooked pounded chicken cutlet) and margherita pizza (thin crust and melt in your mouth cheese). Wonderful dining experience!

    I attended a baby shower here over the weekend. I was immediately impressed by the simple elegance…read moreof the dining room. The staff gave ample time for my family and I to say our hello's before greeting us with drink options. Upon sitting down our server brought us fresh bread and butter with flakey sea salt on top. For appetizers we had The Ralph Piccolo Pizza, Ricotta Crostini, Cacio E Pepe Fries, and Prosciutto Di Parma. All were insanely incredible. Great flavor, crispy where it needed to be crispy, soft where it needed to be soft. For my entree, I had the Crest De Gallo Pasta. The pomodoro sauce was on the savory side. It was a set menu and I am vegetarian, it was my option. It was good! I would love to return to try the Spicy Vodka Sauce Rigatoni. I am a spice lover. For dessert I had the most wonderful, rich, smooth chocolate mousse. The dish was called The Chocolate Spuma. It came with crumbled pistachios and fresh raspberries on the side of it. The flavors and textures together were perfect. The staff were so kind, had great humor, and fabulous manners. They held themselves very professionally. The head server for the event and the manager were lovely. I just had to pull the manager to the side and compliment all. I live 1.5 hours away but I would gladly book a weekend trip up to Maplewood, just to eat here again.

    Photos
    Osteria LK
    Summer tomato salad
    Summer tomato salad
    Fresh baked bread

    See all

    Fresh baked bread
    Artie's

    Artie's

    4.4
    (977 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$

    Delicious food, bright and relaxed atmosphere, and great service all around. Artie's is a fantastic…read morefamily-friendly restaurant that not only specializes in wood-fired pizzas but also baked goods like breads and pastries. I always love trying something off their seasonal pizza menu; during my most recent visit, I loved their maple bacon pizza, which had the perfect balance of sweet and savory. They don't accept reservations, so expect it to be pretty busy, especially during the weekends. Note that they also only have a limited cold food menu during the off hour between lunch and dinner.

    Still easily my favorite pizza in NJ, no contest. Since moving to the new location, Artie's is…read morebetter than ever!! The restaurant itself is spacious and has an inviting atmosphere. Love going in the warmer weather when they open up the doors and have the bar serving on the patio. And let's face it, if you know anything about Arite's you know that there will always be a wait on the weekends. Having the bar and the patio makes waiting a breeze! The food is seriously better than ever. I actually think the pizza is even better at this new spot than the previous location. The sleeper favorite for me is the maple bacon pizza. Takes the white pie to another level and has become a go to for me. Always, I repeat always, order the meatballs and save the sauce for your pizza crust. The farmers salad is always a must for me as well. No one does a salad like Artie's. Give this place a shot because trust me, you won't be disappointed.

    Photos
    Almond croissant
    Almond croissant
    Caciocavallo with Jalapeños
    Caciocavallo with Jalapeños
    Manhattan

    See all

    Manhattan
    All' Assassina

    All' Assassina

    4.5
    (31 reviews)
    2.3 mi

    We tried this place on a whim and happy we did! Used DoorDash and placed an order for pickup, so…read morecan't speak to the ambiance, but the young lady at the counter gave us a friendly greeting and wished us a good evening. Got the GARLIC-CHEESE FLATBREAD, the EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA, and the MAKE YOUR OWN with penne, meatballs, roasted garlic, and Napolitana Tomato sauce. 4/5 on the first two, 4.5/5 on the MYO. Flatbread would be really good if it were had at the restaurant instead of takeout, however air frying it to crisp up the bread would definitely address that. My GF said the eggplant was good. And the MYO I got was really good. Nice flavorful meatballs, really good sauce, and the roasted garlic was perfect a perfect addition. There was enough of a portion of each dinner for two nights of meals so value-wise, this was an excellent dinner spot. May have to try dine-in next time we come back (and we will be back).

    I finally got the chance to eat here. I ordered the carbonara special. Compared to the rest of the…read moremenu, which was very good value with pastas priced under $20. This special was a bit pricier but no problem at all as I really like carbonara. My thoughts on it was that I thought it lacked a bit in flavor but was still pretty good. I don't think I would ever get it again, but the spaghetti was all Dante and I could tell that it was made homemade and fresh and the quality of the pasta was very good. One stand out quality was that the pasta came out within five minutes of me ordering which is impeccable service. The waiters were also very friendly and asked a few times if we enjoyed our meal and if we needed anything which I appreciated. This restaurant is close to where I live and I look forward to trying it again as I think the value is very good. I would probably get something different next time.

    Photos
    Enough space for groups too
    Enough space for groups too
    La Creazione (make your own) - pappardelle, sausage, grilled zucc., capers, mushrooms, pesto sauce. Good!
    La Creazione (make your own) - pappardelle, sausage, grilled zucc., capers, mushrooms, pesto sauce. Good!
    EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA

    See all

    EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA

    Corner Slice - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...