My family has been eating here for 20 years. I catered my baby shower with their food. When my three sons were little, every Friday night I'd get off the train from work and pick up a Pizza pie, a large salad and four of their specially bottled root beers. I love their fried calamari, fresh baked focaccia rolls, their garden salad with house dressing (sounds simple but it is the best I've had, ever), shrimp scampi and the best marinara sauce hands down. In addition to their classic Italian food, they also have a "Light Menu" for those watching their carb intake. My favorite is the unbreaded eggplant parm with spinach. I mostly opt for the take out option but I've also eaten in the restaurant many times - with my family, for girls night out and even by myself. Friendly service and a cozy ambiance. read more

Ordered a medium cheese pizza for dinner for the first time. It was light, crispy, and not as cheesy as I would prefer. The marinara sauce lacked depth. It was very lackluster. More oregano, roasted garlic, salt, and pepper would give it a bit more life. read more

No frills pizza spot, efficient service, and very decent pizzas. The pizzas take a while to make but come out hot and fresh. Prices are reasonable too! read more

Village Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Last minute stop with a group of 24!!! The staff handled it amazingly well. Took orders via walk up to counter. And just kept bringing out the food nonstop. NO ONE had to wait long for anything! Salads, focaccia bread, pizza, all were darn good. I actually enjoyed their square better than their regular slice, it was very good! Regular slice was good too so don't let me mislead you. But the square was on the money. This was a solid pick and service was friendly and helpful. Two thumbs up here!!' read more

Hadn't been to this location in a while as we usually order from the one in Summit. We got the BBQ chicken pie which was good but it could be great if they used chicken that wasn't breaded. Still a good pie. My Wife got the basil and mushroom pie and was very happy with it. Lucky to get a spot directly across the street as Maplewood was hopping. Friendly service as always. read more

Village Trattoria - BBQ chicken pie - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Food is fine, but every third or fourth takeout order is incorrect and/or missing ingredients. For example, the Trattoria Salad I had tonight was missing three(!) ingredients - red onions, cherry tomatoes, and kalamata olives (see picture below). I can't stress enough that you need to thoroughly examine your order before you leave the restaurant. read more

Village Trattoria - Salad showing missing items. - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Great food fast service very dependable. Our go to for a delicious meal for takenout

We drive over from Millburn for these pies ! Sauce is light as air and fresh, cheese is high quality, dough is thin and chewy and crispy! Service is wonderful and space is clean. Have been coming here for over 20 years and it was all I wanted Xmas Eve ! So we did our Xmas Eve dinner from them - fabulous gluten free single serve pizzas as-well! read more

my friend and I went into this establishment and asked for a plain slice and a fiesta slice they said OK so we waited and waited for a long time then they said OK here's your slice so me and my friend walked out and then we looked in our bags and they were not our correct slices so we went back inside and asked for our correct slices. They then said they don't have any anymore and they said they couldn't do anything about it. wow what an establishment. And the white guys with tattoos in there is very mean to the customers, anyone in town knows this. read more

They don't put cheese on the pizza. All these places in Orange & South Orange are cheap on the Cheese. You have to order a pizza with Extra cheese to get a pie that you would taste like a pizza from 2010. It is sad. read more

A classic NJ suburb spot for pizza! Have been coming here for years and it never fails. Nowadays I typically do to-go but they do have a smaller dining room to eat in. They have kiosks in the entrance where the pizza is made and displayed, where people typically crowd to order or pick up their pizza. If you're doing take out they do have an online platform but would recommend calling instead as they don't list many of their pies online. The pizza is thin crust and crispy. My favorites are mushroom and sausage, the calamari pizza, and the Buffalo chicken and fries pizza. If you purchase 15 pizzas you get a free cheese pizza, you have to cut out and save the coupons from the pizza box. Haven't had much other food here besides pizzas but will continue to do take out and come here. read more

Village Trattoria - Calamari pie - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Delicious pizzas; great variety. My daughter loved her Hawaiian pizza. Nice causal spot; we enjoyed the sidewalk seating/people watching but their dining room is cozy. The service was good; you have to order your meal then seat yourself. read more

Nice place for lunch. They sell individual slices or whole pie of pizza. They also have different pasta and sandwiches, too. I was surprised to see seating area full. You order it at counter and they will announce that food is ready for pickup. No dining services, but that's okay since this is casual friendly pizza place. I would definitely will return again. I had a slice of chicken cutlet pizza which was very good. read more

See all

Ambiance is typical and service is quick but I am always amazed by the food here. I have been to both of the Summit and South Orange locations and I realized there was on in Maplewood so I decided to stop by on my way passing through and the grandma pie did not disappoint! Highly recommend! read more

Nice idea, poorly executed. Valentine's day...makes heart shaped pie without notifying the customer. Now no one gets an equal slice! Smh. It's not what i asked for or wanted and now i'm dealing with ppl not getting a equal slice because of the shape. Smh read more

Village Trattoria - Poor execution. This is ridiculous. No one asked for this. - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

This place is just excellent. Just spot on Italian food. Big portions, reasonable prices, good variety. Really just can't go wrong. Nice pasta dishes, good cheese steaks, good salads, chicken Murphy, chicken savoy. All very solid dishes. read more

Ambiance: super noisy!! Food: not as good as back when original owner Service: very poor..silverware and napkins should be first thing to bring to the table as well as bread and tap water, servers need to be better trained to know specials of the day and answer basic questions about the menu. Overall a 3 star dining experience and I don't plan going there for dinner specially on weekends when restaurant is taken over by dozens of rowdy teens to grabs the few tables to hang out over a slice of pizza. I now understand why unlike years ago when families and friends woukd be seen dining and able to enjoy a conversation now you see only a few! Time to go elsewhere!! read more

Great pizza, Italian dishes, sandwiches, salads, soups! Quick, easy, convenient. Nice location. Friendly staff!

I love this location. I've been to the one in South orange too but prefer and make the commute to this one instead. For some reason the food taste better here and the have more options. Ie my favorite shrimp francese s.o say that's not an option but maplewood makes it all the time. Service is typically better here too. The food food is flavorful and great portions read more

Village Trattoria - Shrimp francese - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

I kept hearing about this place so I finally decided to stop and give it a try. They sell slices so I was able to get a cheese slice to go. It did not take that long and the staff was friendly. The vibe of the pizza was very New York style and I feel like I was eating something I would get on the streets of New York City. A casual pizza place that if I was back in the town I would get again! read more

Vodka sauce was great but the bolognese spaghetti was bland. I would definitely order anything with that vodka sauce for the next visit.

If you want pizza, Maplewood is where it's at. For pizza by the slice, I always go the trat (if you're looking for the fancier fresh Italian pizza, head to Arturo's). I've been coming here since I was a kid, the place to hang out while you grab a pre-movie slice. The quality hasn't changed in 20+ years and my mouth still salivates as I think about buffalo chicken pizza. read more

Village Trattoria - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

I had the buffalo chicken pizza and it was soooo good. I've been going to VT since high school but hadnt been in years. Good to see the quality was still there. This is during Covid so we walked up to the restaurant and there was a guy standing outside the restaurants. No walk ins. Reminded me of being at the club actually lmao. Told him our name he handed the pizza over and we left. Great safety precautions. I'll definitely return. read more

We love this restaurant. While it is a pizza place, their pasta dishes are excellent.

There food is sis so good.. you must try the shrimp scampi.. yummy.. I've been coming to this place for years.. The pizza and the dishes are delicious.. I highly recommend this place... read more

Not the most consistent-- sometimes it's the best pizza ever and sometimes it's just okay. I've never had an outright bad experience though, and the other menu items I've tried have been more consistent (and pretty good). This place is not as good as it was before the original owner passed away but it's still a neighborhood staple. Pretty decent and worth a shot. read more

Very good Pies and a fun atmosphere. For years we forgot it was there getting into the habit of heading to the other local spots. But glad we have found a new habit! read more

This has been our "go to place" for a few years, primarily because of the quality of their pizzas and the wonderfully friendly staff at their Maplewood location. Not any more, sadly. While the staff remains awesome, last night we were given a whole pepperoni pizza that it more closely resembled the cardboard box it was packed in than anything a person could eat. Sad. read more

It is my first time at Village Trattoria, and I am pleasantly surprised. The quality and taste of all piazzas I've tried were sensational, and the staff members, especially Windy, are welcoming, proud of their work and establishment. Together with the food, the service and ambiance deserve a high rating. Village Trattoria has just gained a loyal customer out of me. I highly recommend this place. read more

Village Trattoria - Pepperoni and Vodka Sauce Pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

The pasta was good. I'm glad I went with vodka sauce, which is superior to their Alfredo (always needs some salt). Broccoli was crisp, pasta al dente, and blackened chicken is flavorful. I took a star off for the bread, which was so tiny compared to what I get when I order pick up read more

Village Trattoria - Vodka sauce, blackened chicken, broccoli, bow tie (very small bread was all I got) - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

My favourite pasta place, havent tried their pizza yet...Lol once a while, come to buy pasta, this is the 6th time maybe. Portion is big, enough for me to have two meals. so far I only tried their Trattoria Carbonara x 3 and Shrimps, asparagus, tomatoes x 2 and spinach ravioli small portion with grilled chicken and bacon in garlic and oil sauce x 1. I want to try all of the specail pasta. will come to update my review soon. read more

See all

Great place in Maplewood for pizza and Italian! I got the primavera pasta which was absolutely amazing, super filling and delicious. My favorite was the pizza we got for the table though, some of the best I've had in a while. Very classic and had great flavor. I would go back for the pizza in a second! read more

I ordered a chicken Cesar wrap and ended up with a salad in a box. This thing was barley wrapped. It unwrapped while I was trying to pick it up. Avoid the wraps. I should have just ordered a salad. I would have got bread and more fixings. read more

Village Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

So easy to get a slice! Grandma pizza!!!! Wow thank your for the clean mask and making it so quick and easy for delicious delightfulness!!! Can't wait to try the pasta special! read more

Village Trattoria - Grandma's slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

The gourmet slices are amazing. I would recommend getting the chicken tender slice, Tortola i slice, Greek salad slice, and the slice with chicken and arugula (arugula slice? Lol). Today I had my usual - sautéed veggies (light on the oil) with chicken and Shrimp (I usually order blackened chicken or shrimp I was greedy today haha). It was yummy! Just want to say this is one of my favorite spots in town! Glows: -Recently renovated interior -Attentive staff (could be friendlier, but it's fine I get them and they get me :p) -Pizza is amazing and fresh during the week-not sure if they've changed it, but I came one day for lunch on the weekend and it wasn't the same.) I haven't been for dinner, but know it's BYO and always seems busy. read more

Village Trattoria - Sautéed veggies with chicken and shrimp. (Blackened shrimp and chicken - separate or together- is a great option. - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

My first time here and I can't wait to go back. I have to thank my fellow Yelpers for finding it. It's in the quaint town of Maplewood and also BYOB. I tried their specialty pizza "Drunken Grandma" which had Vodka sauce, cheese and bacon on a crispy crust. Amazing! Their Greek salad pizza was one of the most unique pizzas that I've had. The salad was so fresh and tasty. They do not skimp on toppings! Well deserving of 5 stars. read more

See all

Had high hopes, because as always, i need gluten/ dairy free pizza for my son. I specifically ordered the pizza gluten free crust with no cheese and BOOM .. there's cheese all over it. Strike 1... Pizza arrived on time as scheduled however... It was warm at best... Strike 2. It wasn't very tasty even with toppings, had to lay on garlic powder and red pepper to bring it up to speed... Strike 3. Well, after being on a good run with pizza places in Maplewood,i was bound to find a did y, and here it is read more

the Village Trat's small Antipasta salad... it has so much on it! Hot peppers, roasted red peppers, pickles cauliflower, celery & carrots, cucumber, red onions, jumbo black olives and arugula, meat & cheese. I like balsamic dressing for it. Ten times better than the salad served at the place at the end of Maplewood Avenue. The Trat's pizza and chicken wings are great too! read more

Village Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

This pizza is okay in my opinion. Though many come here, I only wanted to taste what a friend of mine was talking and raving about. This pizza to me was nothing to rave about, it's just average. There was no oomph factor for me. However, I would give it another try. read more

Ordered bacon chicken ranch, drowned in ranch, almost no bacon, and had sliced tomatoes. Never seen that in my life and don't know who told them that goes together but I suggest they change that. read more