Everything was phenomenal. The food, service, ambiance, not much more you could ask for besides more parking lol. Would order the puffy bread, pepperoni pizza again, and rigatoni. The dough used was spectacular read more

Cosmica - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

See all

Really disappointed. Honestly will never go back again. The food was not only terrible but the portions were so so small. Overly salty. Not the appetizers and main dishes you would expect from a so called nice restaurant. I honestly feel sorry for the waiters and waitresses. I think they know how bad it is. The prices were insane. 21$ for puffy bread. Fried olives we just small fried olives at an expensive price. Atmosphere was terrible. Basically dim and had lame art on the walls. Knit dream catcher. The glasses were plastic cups that you would see in a high school cafeteria. Unfortunately it didn't make my birthday experience memorable. I will be very surprised if this restaurant survives serving this poor quality at these ridiculous high prices. read more

Cosmica - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

The fact that this spot made the New York Times "50 Best Restaurants in America 2025" list is exactly why I've been dying to try it... but honestly, I left disappointed. The atmosphere is the standout, fun, funky, retro, and very unique. It's everything I want in a restaurant vibe, and I do love that it's 21+. For a second, I thought I had found my new go-to Italian spot in SLC... but I was wrong. The food is way overpriced for what you get. We started with the puffy bread ($15), which was actually great, but the tiny side of dip was $6, bringing bread for the table to $21 for basically a few bites each. We also tried the eggplant parm ($18), which had solid flavor and texture. Then came the mains... and this is where it went downhill.. A friend and I ordered the tortellini in broth ($29), and after one bite, we both said the same thing: it tasted like overpriced chicken noodle soup. There were maybe 6-7 tortellinis total. Another friend's spaghetti was overly salty and felt very basic for the price. The ravioli ($27) was the best of the entrees, but still pretty mid and not worth the cost. Service didn't help either, very slow, long gaps between apps and mains, food coming out at different times, and drinks rarely refilled. There were plenty of staff around, so it was surprising how little attention we got. Overall: the interior is a 5/5, and I'd maybe come back for a drink at the bar if I was in the neighborhood. But for the price and quality, there are much better Italian spots in SLC. read more

See all

Since moving to SLC from Newport Beach two years ago, we've eaten at over 40 restaurants in the price range. Many of them amazing! Cosmica however was the worse meals we have had in the State. The fennel salad was bland and tasteless. The swordfish came BREADED... 4 parts breading, one part fish. Why would you take a favorful fish like this and make it into a cafeteria fishstick??? The puttanesca pasta was so spicy hot it was inedible. My wife ate two bites. Having eaten puttanesca about 100 times, i've never seen it prepared spicy hot, let alone so hot we couldn't eat it. The venue was a dumpy place that could have been tolerable if the food was ok... but... We literally drove through McDonalds on the way home. read more

The place ambience and service were the only nice part about this restaurant. Foods were below average for sure. My salad was so salty. My steak $52, was not good, too bland, too chewy, too much fat in it. My husband's dish was the Tuna. It was bland. Oh and also finding parking was a challenge. read more

Cosmica - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

See all

Great ambiance and service! Parking is a little tricky so make sure to give yourself some buffer time. We ordered two salads and they were very simple but flavorful. The mushroom pizza was great - good and chewy soft dough! Would love to come back and try the rest of the menu. read more

Cosmica - Fennel salad - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

See all

This is a loud, colorful place for dinner. Menu leans Italian. Our table enjoyed a shaved fennel salad, a chicory salad, a flatbread, a swordfish schnitzel with capers, a mafaldine and bolognese bianco, and an order of meatballs. I almost tried a mocktail but ultimately decided against it. At the last minute we remembered to order a puffy bread with pomodoro sauce, which is the bomb dot com. (Seriously, try it on your flatbread!) The restrooms are not labeled to be gender-specific and are decorated boldly in pink. Street parking in the area or take a ride share. read more

See all

Fun place, great place for a date or daily celebration. Food is great, portions are a bit small in my opinion. Although we shared everything so we could taste all the great dishes. It's definitely a place to try and it's in a great location to hit up some brewery's afterward.. read more

See all

The aesthetic of the restaurant was great, but I didn't feel like the food matched up to it. My pizza came out pretty charred and it was just ok. The drinks were fine, but I thought everything was pretty overpriced. Nice staff though. read more

Cosmica - Margherita pizza - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

food quality: 5/5 service: 3/5 cleanliness: 5/5 value: 5/5 Tried Cosmica for the first time and overall, the experience was ok. I previously tried to make reservations online and the open table app would not allow a reservation for more than 5 people. I tried calling several times during their weekday dinner hours and no one would pick up, so I gave up. Fast forward 3 months later, OpenTable finally had option to book for 8 people, so I booked it. Not sure if there was a glitch or not, but glad they fixed it. The parking is a little rough. I knew that from the previous reviews and knew to not park in the strip club parking lot. Luckily we found a spot in the lot between Cosmica and Dough Miner. We were sat shortly after arriving on a Wednesday night. It was surprisingly busy and the service was pretty slow overall. We didn't get our order taken for at least 25 minutes and somehow a puffy bread order made it to our table even though we didn't order it. Can't complain, it was good! Once we had our order taken, the server checked in a few times but there was a lot of pause between check ins. We spent more time waiting for the server to come back with our food, drinks, and to box up our leftover. We were there for nearly 2 hours from the time we sat down to the time we paid for the bill. The positive side was that the food was good and well-seasoned, and the restaurant itself was well-kept. I'm a little disappointed that even though we were celebrating my birthday that we couldn't even get a free scoop of gelato like most restaurants would happily do. Might have been an off day, hopefully others have a better experience. read more

See all

Food is fantastic! Their bolognese is the best I've ever had. I wish I could eat it every day. I will definitely be coming back to try more things on this menu. I also really enjoyed their slow braised beef short rib. read more

Cosmica - Slow braised beef short rib - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

The person greeting us was very nice and our servers were great. We ordered the House, sausage and salume pizza, tortellini and saltimbocca. The food on the other hand were either terrible or just okay. Wish we had listened to other reviews saying the same thing to avoid an overpriced, far from pleasant dinner. Being that these comments were from months ago, it shows that this place has no intention for improvement. The pizzas were really really salty. The sausage pizza had greens on top and it tasted as though they took a salt shaker and threw extra salt on top of everything. The tortellini pasta skin was very dense so it almost tasted dry even though it's sitting in a broth. Don't recommend coming here. If you are going to spend this much on a dinner, go somewhere else worth spending on. read more

Cosmica - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

See all

Got a reservation a couple weeks in advance. I was very intrigued knowing that it's a New York Times top 100 restaraunts. I liked our food and drink but I think I was expecting more maybe? My biggest con was that parts of my boyfriend's pizza crust was so burnt that you couldn't even chew on it. I liked my bolognese a lot and the puffy bed was really soft and good. The service was super nice and gave us good recommendations for when I was deciding between drinks. Parking deffo is a struggle to find in their small lot. So we just parked at a paid lot a couple minutes away and walked from there which wasn't too bad. read more

See all

Came for a birthday celebration and was wowed with the pretty pink undertones of the space. We were seated promptly by friendly staff, and was able to put in all our drinks immediately even with a larger group. Most everything is shareable and delicious. The eggplant dish was unique with its spicy pomodoro which I loved! read more

Cosmica - Seasonal pumpkin pasta and eggplant parmigiano - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

See all

Run don't walk, Cosmica is a restaurant you want to experience! The ambiance of this Italian diner is so warm and welcoming, and the colors and decor reflect that. From the hostess to our server, service was top knotch. Our server had great food recommendations and was regularly checking in to see how things were going, if we wanted another drink, etc. The food and the drinks were incredible! I had a delicious espresso martini and while each dish was great, you MUST get the shrimp linguine! It was the best pasta dish I've had in a very long time. I will dream about it until my next visit! read more

See all

Cosmica: Warm Vibes, Great Food, and a Few Happy Surprises Cosmica is super cute -- a great vibe from start to finish. Everyone we met -- host, bartenders, waitstaff, and what I'm pretty sure was the manager -- was friendly, welcoming, and genuinely seemed happy we were there. Parking Tip If you're driving, park on the side with the "Maven" customer signs. It's two-hour parking, and we even had a parking attendant from a nearby business check in. Once we said we were going to the restaurant, he waved us through -- kind of nice to know the lot is monitored. First Impressions Cosmica is tucked underneath apartments, with charming windows labeled wine - pizza - pasta. Bonus points for the Pride flag out front -- my other half and I love seeing that when we walk in. It instantly made us feel even more at home. Inside, there's a converted indoor-patio space to the right (adorable), and more formal dining to the left. Definitely make a reservation -- even on a Thursday, the next available table wasn't until 9 PM. We lucked out by spotting the bar and were happily seated there, the only guests at the counter all night. It felt private and special, with our bartender's full attention. Drinks & Starters The menu is a placemat-sized two-sider with tempting pastas, pizzas, and more. I went for the Snake Bite Sangria (perfect choice for the night) while my other half enjoyed a glass of Sikele Rosso. For our starter, we had Prosciutto di Parma with warm, salty gnocco fritte. Delicious on their own, but I later realized the menu lists a pear mostarda -- which we didn't get -- and I think it would have added a great sweet balance. Still tasty enough to box up for breakfast the next day. Salad Win We always try the Caesar, and Cosmica's did not disappoint. Shredded lettuce (so easy to eat), crushed croutons sprinkled throughout, and a balanced dressing with added anchovies. Texturally and flavor-wise, it was spot-on. Mains & A Little Mix-Up When ordering, I asked about the Pork Milanese -- mostly curious about the chili aïoli it comes with. Once I learned it could be a little spicy (and spice isn't my friend), I opted for the Pacific Striped Bass instead. While we enjoyed our appetizers and salad, our bartender came by to say the kitchen was running a little behind and that a few items would be comped because of the wait -- a thoughtful gesture we really appreciated. The funny thing is, we didn't even notice the delay. We're great company for ourselves, and there was plenty of energy, movement, and details to take in from the bar. I even told her the comp wasn't necessary, but she insisted. When the entrées arrived, my other half got his Chicken Scarpariello (tender thighs in a white wine sauce -- delicious). I, however, received the pork cutlet instead of the seabass. By then it was getting late, and since I had been on the fence between the two dishes anyway, I decided to keep it. It was crispy, juicy, and reminded me of a great schnitzel -- though I did have to scrape off most of the spicy aïoli. Still, everything was clearly fresh, hot, and well-prepared. Extra Pasta Because... Why Not Mid-meal, we saw a pasta dish go by that looked too good to skip. Enter the Spaghettone -- perfectly al dente, fresh, and worth every bite. Yes, we were now up to four to-go boxes. Sweet Ending We skipped a full dessert (too full!) but couldn't resist the Lemon Sorbetto. Light, tart, refreshing -- the perfect palate cleanser. Final Thoughts We left full, happy, and impressed -- both by the food and the warm, attentive staff. Next time, I'll make a reservation, aim for that seabass, and maybe bring friends for a laid-back, laughter-filled night. Pro Tips: * Reserve ahead -- bar seating is great, but fills fast. * Park in Maven customer spots and let the attendant know you're dining at Cosmica. * If you see the Spaghettone, just order it. Trust me. read more

See all

Cosmica is one of the best restaurants in SLC. The food is delish, the vibe is great, the service is top notch. It's actually a great price point for this quality. I have been 4 times and I will definitely be back. I just read a review about portions being small. I disagree. The portions are perfectly sized for a balanced dinner where you try from different parts of the menu, share some things, and have fun. This is what SLC needs! read more

If I could give this place a 3.5 I would because it teeters between a 3 and a 4. What's makes it a 4? Service. Our waiters were kind, polite and always checking in on us. The drinks tasted as good as they looked. I was also happily surprised to see a number of dessert items on the menu such as cheesecake and gelato of the day as dessert as it is not listed in their website menu. Plus the vibes are immaculate. They have both an indoor and outdoor seating area but the tables are kinda small so if you're going with more than 2 people and plan on getting more than one dish I'd ask for a booth. What makes it a 3? While they tasted amazing the dishes were inconsistent and portions were too small vs. the price you pay. My friend and I both got pizzas and both our pies were crispy on one end and a bit under done on the other. The pies, like the rest of dishes were just too small compared to what we were paying. The Rigatoni dish in the photos was $22. It made me wonder- it is so expensive because it's fresh pasta? I couldn't see any indicators of fresh pasta on the menu (and normally when a place has fresh pasta they throw it in your face). I give them grace since they're a new place and it seems like they're trying to decide if they want to be a bar or restaurant. If you're going out for a drink and want a place with chill vibes where you can yap with your friend group this is the place to go! However if it's pasta and pizza you're after they'll taste great but you might be let down by the price. read more

See all

Extremely disappointed with this restaurant. Have been several times and have always found the menu friendly. Tonight we arrived to find one of the most popular menu items has been discontinued, the shoestring fries. And, no more rigatoni, lasagna or bucatini. Stale menu items being replaced by unrecognizable dishes. The menu online also doesn't match the menu that is presented in the restaurant. Quit changing the menu. Stick to your roots and offer a few of the new pasta dishes as specials. I will not be returning until the menu becomes more recognizable. Not the same restaurant as as it was in the beginning. read more

The ambiance at Cosmica is really pretty and inviting, especially with its stylish decor and lighting. However, the tables and chairs in the front area weren't the most comfortable for a longer meal. The drinks were great well-balanced and flavorful. The tuna crudo was beautifully presented, though it came as one large slab rather than smaller bites, which made it a bit harder to share. We tried a few of the pastas and a pizza; everything tasted authentic and fresh, but most dishes could have used a bit more seasoning or salt to bring out the flavors. Service was friendly and attentive throughout, which made for an overall pleasant experience. Cosmica has potential and a lovely vibe, but I found myself wishing the food had just a bit more punch to match the atmosphere. read more

See all

My sweet friend surprised me with reservations to Cosmica while I was visiting. I was blown away with the cute, intimate restaurant, I wish I got a better picture of where we were sitting, so dang beautiful! I tried the lasagna and hands down that has to be the best lasagna I've ever had! A perfect pocket of sausage and ricotta, and their red sauce is flavorful but not overpowering! My husband had the maccheroni alla genovese which was also spectacular. We shared the house puffy bread appetizer which was a great start to the meal experience. read more

See all

I know Cosmica was on the NYT Top 50 but curious as to what qualifies to get on this list -- we shared the Caesar salad, the bolognese & linguine and shrimp. While the bolognese was exceptional the other 2 dishes were alright. The service was not what was expected, we weren't checked on once while eating food and the waiter just dropped the dessert menu on our table, not the type of service that is expected. We walked in around 7pm and was told we could be seated at 815pm, when we walked in around 8pm there were multiple table empty and told that we had to wait til 815 to be seated. Clearly there were several empty tables, including the one we ended up being seated at. I'd say this place is busy due to the NYT hype. read more

Cosmica - Linguine & shirmo Bolognese - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

See all

The food was amazing! The plates that we ordered were delicious. The Italian flavors are unlike anywhere else in Utah, and you truly can't order wrong! I started with the Fluffy bread and Raw Tuna appetizer, which were both delicious. We also got the Chicken Parm and the pizzas which were absolutely excellent. The service was fast and consistent, but the servers attitude wasn't very charismatic. Cosmica does well at fostering a buzzing atmosphere and excellent ambiance but for my group the loud music made the experience less enjoyable. read more

See all

I had the pleasure of visiting Cosmica the other night with a friend. The service was fantastic and the food all but one dish were amazing. The beef carpaccio was wonderful. The eggplant appetizer was amazing and the short ribs and pizza were outstanding . Combine that with the desserts and it was a great meal. The only thing that didn't add up was the white Bolognese.. it seems their kitchen is going to be editing their menu so I look forward to trying new things and hopefully they keep the things that are fantastic on the menu read more

Delicious! The house bread was fantastic. The pasta was good, although I like it really really saucy.

Fun atmosphere, pasta was great but LOVED the puffy bread. Our waitress was the perfect amount of helpful and the other staff were really hands on as well. I never had to ask for a refill, they were always there to fill our cups or take away our empty plates. Great place, will be coming back for the pizza next time! read more

See all

Adorable decor and space!!! Parking isn't too bad as there's a decent amount of street parking in the area. Might be harder during peak times with nearby bars. Great staff, too!!! We got the eggplant parm, bolognese, and linguine. I personally didn't think anything was a standout and was rather bland, but I did think the ingredients were top notch. read more

Been twice. First time we had one of those stupid NYC kinda tables where you have to sit by strangers. Food was good, but hard to live up to the hype. Really good eggplant parm. Not soggy. Went back with friends who wanted to try it. Had a booth this time. Food again all good. Little peppery. 2 salads, 2 apps, 4 drinks, 2 pastas = $240. All said, went to get our cars and both were towed by the owners of the strip club "Trails" next door. Geeze!! Our bad, yeah. But can we get a little sympathy or help? Anything? The Cosmica manager was a total a-hole who told us we shoulda known better. Tells me they get it every day. Either way, complete jerk of a manager. Final verdict: Screw this place and its pretension. Find a better space and location- then pop off. read more

This place is a total vibe. Incredible decor, food, and wine selection. We got the arancini to start, which had the perfect texture. Next we split a pizza and pasta for our mains. Sauce was DELICIOUS. Flavors of both were outstanding. We finished with the rhubarb cheesecake which was perfect. Our waiter Zach was great, but we had a couple hiccups in our experience that I want to share as feedback, but to be fair they are a new restaurant. We went at 6:15 and I sat directly in the sun. When I asked to move to the empty booth behind, I was told it was reserved...even though no one sat there the whole time we were there. Towards the end of our reservation, the people next to us asked to move because of the sun and their waiter said "Well, we can just scoot your table closer, they're leaving soon." Which, definitely made us feel like we needed to exit ASAP. I'm definitely looking forward to coming back and will probably choose a later reservation to avoid the sun. read more

Cosmica - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

the decor is immaculate and it incredible vibes for such a small space. i love the somewhat maximalist decor, but it also feels not overbearing. this place has been booked solid since the nyt article, so i tried my luck with a walk-in. thankfully they got me a seat at the bar in about 5 mins! my boyfriend and i each ordered a mocktail of the bartenders choice and she made this mint tea with basil mocktail that was incredible!!! we ordered the puffy bread with anchovies and it was incredible, but also pretty salty with the combo of pecorino and anchovies. the tuna crudo was pretty good and had a nice spice, but not mind blowing imo. the shrimp scampi was solid! this place didn't get 5 stars to me because i think my expectations were through the roof because the recent buzz and it didn't blow my mind.. but it was pretty good overall! other notes: it was good, but honestly didn't blow my mind like i had hyped up due to the nyt ranking read more

Lunch with friends was delicious! So much so I forgot to take pictures until we were done eating we had the puffy bread with the cheese/pepper spread, Pomodoro spaghetti, lasagna, and the pizza with broccolini. Everything was very tasty and came out piping hot. The ambience is lovely and service was excellent. read more

See all

Really amazing experience. Great food. Ended up taking my wife on a experience here. Service was great.

Sadly our server really ruined our experience. When we asked what some of the popular dishes were for each course we were met with a response that made us feel like we were burdening our server. We simply wanted some guidance so we can get our order in quicker. We were able to put some apps in, the food came out, and we were ready to order more and let our server know, but he didn't return for 15 minutes. Our dishes were done at this point. My boyfriend and I tried to flag him down 3 times but he just kept walking right past us. Finally, on the 4th try my boyfriend had to stand up as he was walking by to put the rest of our order in. While we don't want to believe our server just didn't like us, it certainly felt that way as we watched him cater to tables next to us several times while skipping ours. We had a great experience with the Sommelier, and the food overall was quite good, but sadly we felt our server missed the mark. Our food paced out at odd times because he didn't come back for the rest of the order. Hopefully an isolated incident. read more

My husband and I dined at Cosmica with another couple on Oct 27, 2025. Boy, were we all severely disappointed in every aspect of the restaurant! Service was terrible- 3 of our pasta meals came out promptly, but not very hot, but my husbands Pizza came 12 minutes later. And my husbands drink didn't show up until 20 min after our orders were taken, despite being asked about it twice. And if you're going to have a dinner restaurant, don't give me a plastic cup for water! I asked for a grown-up glass for my water, which they gave me. The food: Substandard in taste and definitely very small portions. I ordered the Maccheroni Alla Genovese. What came was a small bowl that looked like it came from a school lunchroom cafeteria. The dish was mildly warm and the braised meat portion took me a while to find it since it was minuscule (maybe 1 TBSP portion). The dish lacked any flavor (some sherry would have helped). Certainly not worth the $26. We ordered the House puffy bread with Spicy Pomodoro for $18. Great bread but the 6-inch diameter flatbread was an extremely small portion. We even ordered dessert since we were still hungry. Again, small portions. I came home and had half a sandwich. And prior to our arrival, we received text messages telling us that our visit time would be a max of 1:45 for 4 people. They did a good job on making us feel rushed throughout the entire meal so they could boot us out quickly. I certainly don't know what all the fuss was about. James Beard has certainly dropped their standards with this restaurant. read more

Cosmica is THAT girl -- Italian-style diner vibes with puffy bread, branzino, and the smoothest tequila cocktail (Mix #1, IYKYK). Didn't snap it all but trust... the budino lives rent-free. read more

Cosmica - Puffy bread - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

See all

I honestly can't wait to go back. The apps, drinks, service & food were amazing. My fav Caesar salad I've had!! read more

Cosmica - Caesar salad, shoestring fries, pasta - Italian Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

For being one of the "best" restaurants in SLC, I have to be honest that the food wasn't good. Service was great. Drinks were good. Cute space. But no parking available, and no flavor what so ever to the bolognese. read more

Cosmica is an absolute gem in SLC! We had a fantastic experience from start to finish. We parked about a block away as the street directly next to the restaurant was full. The natural wine selection is great--we went with a Cab Sauv that paired perfectly with everything. The staff was attentive without being overbearing, and the vibe of the place is spot-on: cool, comfortable, and with just the right ambient temperature. We were a party of three and ordered two apps (arancini and snap peas), two pastas (rigatoni and maccheroni), and a pizza topped with prosciutto. Every single dish was flavorful and beautifully prepared--perfect portions and well-balanced flavors. You can tell the ingredients are high quality and thoughtfully used. Highly recommend for a relaxed yet elevated dining experience. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

The decorations in this place are like upscale retro! I had a yummy mocktail. They had a great variety of beverages including coffee and teas. The pizza sauce was unique and delicious! We also got the Cesar salad which comes with a garlic dressing which was tangy and refreshing. The staff was so kind. We will definitely be back again. read more

See all

I want to write glowing reviews and uplift businesses; someone might interpret this as nice: from seating to check took 30 minutes. The staff was friendly and worked as a team. In those 30 minutes I didn't have anything I would choose to eat or drink again. Whether it was the "puffy bread" sitting in a puddle of garlic oil or a fennel salad so coated in olive oil that I literally could not taste the fennel (who knew that was possible), every dish gave the feeling of someone that has researched fine Italian online. The dishes were not coursed out so they all hit the table at the same time. In a way this was a good thing, as we did not particularly like any of the dishes and it gave us a chance to mix and match, seeing if there was some way to improve one with ingredients from another. One person in our group sincerely said she would have enjoyed Olive Garden (which is not somewhere she would ever choose to go) more. One of the challenges with Italian in the US is that even someone who cannot cook can make decent Italian at home. We could have gone to Caputo's and picked up some incredible burata, tapenade, pasta, some Leavity bread, etc. and it would have been a far more enjoyable meal for us. To produce truly world class (in my opinion) Italian requires perfect technique, excellent ingredients, and an immaculate balance of a few ingredients. It is sublime when it happens and after the NYT best restaurants nod that is what I was expecting and completely missed. read more