We visited CR Hero's for the Tenderloin Trail for Hamilton County. We had not been here before and are very satisfied with our visit. The tenderloin sandwich was great!!! The 'Hoosier Daddy' was excellent! All four in our party selected the same thing. Two of us selected tots, the other two selected fries; I highly recommend the tots though my wife said the fries are excellent as well. Get the tenderloin loaded and ask for the aioli/garlic mayonnaise. It's has a kick and the flavor is outstanding. Dress the sandwich with tomato, onion, lettuce and a pickle and you will have one of if not the best tenderloin sandwich you've ever had! The eating area is a rustic bar setting. It is comfortable but a 'tad' loud but we were able to talk ok. It was comfortable and we're enjoyed the evening quite a bit. Our server was friendly, courteous and prompt. He help us navigate the menu and getting the right sandwich and he helped us get our Tenderloin Trail Pass discount for the meal (get there before the end of July to take advantage of the pass) read more

It's a smaller place (in the winter, it looks like they have a nice outdoor area). We came here while out of town for a sports competition with a large group. It is great for groups and kids. We picked the spot for their good reviews of gluten free items. Everything was delicious, and the kids loved being able to adventure to the arcade and order fun drinks, while the adults got to also partake in drinks. Absolutely will be back again when visiting the area! read more

CR Hero's - Arcade and photo ops for kids - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Five stars for food and service. CR Hero's has great family /pub food. Tenderloin- 2 thumbs up! Warning: lots of kids and families, so go with the expectation that the place is hoppin'! Great carry out, too. Always good service. Highly recommend. read more

Came in with the family on a Tuesday and loved the experience! Tuesdays are meant for families: Free kids meals w/ adult purchase Free ballon animals Free face painting Arcade room (daily) They also have happy hour deals 3-5:30pm! We had really good appetizers: cheese curds and fried pickles. My favorite were the cheese curds, soft cheesy inside with a great batter on the outside! The fried pickles were also good! The portions were great. Got adventurous and tried the jalapeño popper burger, it's a really popular burger. There are so many options to try, I'm confident I can find more burgers I'll love. The salads also looked really good and I'd like to try one on my next visit. They also offer cute/fun themed drinks for the kids and my two opted for a milkshake and a just ducky (blue mixed drink with gummy worms and a rubber duck on top). Pictured: Kid's Mac & Cheese Meal Kid's Slider Meal Cheese Curds Fried Pickles Jalepeno Popper Burger read more

See all

Went in for lunch with my son and grandson. It's a place open to families. We ordered a pretzel with cheese for an appetizer! It was buttery and served with ranch and nacho cheese! Fantastic! One of the best pretzels I've had in a long time! I have seen on a review that this is one of the best breaded tenderloins in the state! I'm not much of a breaded tenderloin eater but this was out of this world! Fantastic! My sandwich was called Hoosiers daddy! It was served with lettuce, tomato and onion. It has a side of mayo served with it! This also comes with French fries that were crispy and hot. A delicious meal!!! Our server was very attentive and kind too! read more

See all

A friend and I decided to meet here because it is in between and we both agreed we were happy that we did! One side is more of a bar, they actually have it closed off which I liked b/c the other have is more family style tables and booths. Our server, Brock took great care of us and was very attentive - my friend went with the steak with sweet potato fries, I just got their boneless wings (half sweet chili and half medium hot) and we shared their spinach dip w/pita - we also had hot tea and they have honey available (not always common) - nonetheless, we enjoyed everything! They have happy hour until about 5:30 (weekdays) and Wednesdays you receive FREE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES - Brock gave us 2 each If you haven't stopped in before, I hope this review has made you start the car! read more

CR Hero's - Store front - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Great place for family. We were able to watch some of the college basketball games and enjoy our food. I had salmon and broccoli which was good but not a huge portion. My other half had steak and twice baked potatoes. The steak wasn't cook like he ordered and the waiter was able to get a new one cooked for him fairly quickly. My little one enjoyed the smiley fries, burger. We had dessert chocolate and Oreo milkshakes which were both delicious. CR Hero offers Americana food with a family friendly atmosphere. read more

CR Hero's - Salmon, broccoli - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

It's a mom and pop neighborhood bar in the negative sense. If you're not part of their community, you're ignored. It was disappointing. Food was okay. Service was disappointing...They were focused on their regulars and ignored everyone else. read more

Always good food. Wonderful service. Love the hero theme of the restaurant. This is a regular place for us.

This family pub has a unique decor of superheroes and historical figures. Our server was very helpful and attentive. The food was pretty good. Our kids loved their specialty drinks! Nice place is bring the family on a random day. I'm sure we'll be back soon! read more

See all

Clean, very friendly staff, and the food was really good! We had a couple of "hosier daddy's,(tenderloin sandwiches), turkey club, and a patty melts, all very tasty! They have a full bar, with multiple beers on tap. Highly recommend! read more

Great local restaurant, Midwest food like tenderloins, good if you have kiddos that you want to entertain

Great food, Awsome service! Always in our rotation. We always try to sit at the bar love the atmostphere, read more

My family has been regular customers at CR Hero's since it opened in the early 2000s. This is one of my must-eat-at places when I visit family! When I found out about my food allergies, we discovered that CR Hero's had also undergone some menu changes to accommodate gluten-free diets. I always leave feeling satisfied and full! My favorites are the cheese fries (gluten-free, dedicated fryer) and the Hoosier Mama, but the burgers are always a solid choice. The food is always fresh, the waitstaff is friendly, and the decor is top-notch! When I describe CR Hero's decor to friends, they are confused until they walk inside and see the superheroes (comic book and real life) coating every wall. The vibes are not to be missed, nor is the food! read more

See all

I love this place! Been here a couple times. They have so many options for everyone dining. Great prices as well. I have celiac disease so I can't have gluten and they have gluten free chicken tenders and fries (all fried in a dedicated fryer), that's unheard of! My husband got boneless wings and fries. Our server was Brock and he was so helpful and attentive. Do yourself a favor and stop in read more

CR Hero's - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Walked into the bar today (on a Thursday). 6 other people at the bar. Sat there for 10+ minutes and watched the bartender serve the guy that came in behind us. He never once even acknowledged us that we walked in and we were literally sitting next to the people he was serving. Seems like if you aren't a regular there- you don't matter. Won't be going there again. read more

Had always wanted to try this little neighborhood place and glad I finally did. Was there for lunch during the weekday with a coworker, but noticed a full bar on the left side. We both ordered the firecracker burger - Cheddar Jack cheese, bacon slices, onion straws, pretzel bun, firecracker sauce on the side. It was a good sized burger & had a nice amount of heat. I would go back and try other items on the menu; told my hubs we need to go again. #yum #ReviewsByRL read more

See all

Well the foods is good I feel like they could have more options on the kids menu and also my family members agree that there French fries could be more crispy but they have great service and they have super cool bathrooms read more

I'm a huge superhero fan so if you are too you'll love everything about this place! You'll find everything from Spiderman, Super-Man, Hulk, etc. you & your little ones will definitely find your favorites! The menu has a wide range of options from burgers, steak, pizza, all the usual favorites and I can't say I've had a bad thing yet! Even on a busy day, I've had bad service or waited too long for food read more

Incredible family friendly restaurant in the Geist area! This is a must-visit for any families in or traveling to the area. The food is solidly American and sooo good. I got the chicken and waffles, and they were so delicious. My husband got the jammin' bacon burger and it was great too! The price of the food is also very reasonable. They have a great assortment of fun drinks and meals for the kids. There's a small arcade for kids to enjoy and plenty of TVs featuring an assortment of family and kids shows. I highly recommend CR Heroes for those with little ones! read more

We have absolutely loved coming here over the years, which is why I am so saddened and disappointed by the treatment from the manager, Lauren, towards our group. We have raved to our friends and family about this establishment until today. A member of our party requested to be moved from a booth to a table, only to be accused of "being aggressive" with staff (which was absolutely not true, there is a difference between having a backbone and being aggressive), and then being banned from the establishment only after leaving a bad review. We were asked to leave in such a poor, distasteful manner. It is just a shame that their manager has absolutely no customer service skills. Regardless, the food and the wait staff was great tonight. We have loved attending Trivia Nights (Tim is the absolute best!) here and it is just so unfortunate that this incident occurred and was handled so poorly. read more

Growing up, CR Hero's was my all-time favorite restaurant. I celebrated my birthdays here, got my face painted on kids eat free night, and begged to come here every time we went out for dinner. My family and I were regulars when I was younger, so much that I learned the weekly specials schedule: Free Cookie Wednesday, Trivia Thursday, and our favorite--kids eat free Tuesday, complete with balloon animals and face painting. CR Hero's held such a special place in my childhood because so much of the restaurant appealed to kids. From the specialty milkshakes, to the superhero theming, to the arcade, it was essentially a wonderland--with delicious food! As we got older and busier, CR Hero's fell off our radar, but our love for the restaurant was recently rekindled. When I was younger, I was a picky eater and really only tried the buttered pasta and the soft pretzels at CR's. Now that I have a more mature palate, I was ready to venture out onto more 'complex' dishes. For dinner, my sister and I both had the Buffalo chicken Mac and cheese. The meal comes with crispy chicken, but I was able to substitute grilled chicken for no additional charge. The mac and cheese was so creamy and cheesy, and the chicken was seasoned perfectly. The green onions added a nice pop of flavor to the dish, which my sister and I both enjoyed. As much as I loved it, I couldn't finish everything because the portion was huge! My sister and I could have split it and each had enough to fill us up. My mother had the filet grilled cheese with a side of the homemade potato chips. It looked and smelled delicious, and the steak was cooked to medium rare, exactly as she requested. My father was happy to see that the Buffalo chicken salad was still on the menu, as it has always been his favorite dish. And of course, no meal at CR Hero's is complete without an order of soft pretzels! Whether it's ordered a la carte or by the basket, the pretzels are hands-down my family's favorite appetizer. Salty, buttery, mouth-watering dough served piping hot, you really can't go wrong. We have even ordered a tray of CR's pretzels for our family gatherings on numerous occasions! CR Hero's will always hold a special place in my heart, not only for the nostalgia, but for the delicious food as well! ‍‍ read more

CR Hero's - Buffalo Mac N Cheese!! - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

I had high hopes for this place, but it did not meet my expectations. They have lots of parking available in the private parking lot that it shares with the other businesses in the strip mall that it is in. The restaurant is dedicated to fictional heroes and our everyday heroes (firefighters, police....). It has a large dining area and a bar net door that they can open access to from the inside. Both areas have televisions which are normally playing sports. They have super hero stuff all around the bar, the ones with and without capes. The staff here does their job. They are not rude and not overly friendly. They do what they need to do basically. The place was pretty busy while I was there. They have a menu full of pub style food such as wraps, burgers, salads, wings and tenderloins. I went with the Firecracker Burger with fries. It did not take long for me to get my food. The burger was ok. I have had better and I have had worse. I ordered an electric lemonade to wash down my food and it was pretty dull and tasted watered down. For me, this place was ok. Maybe I caught it on a bad day or ordered the wrong thing. I am not against going back, it just would not be my first choice. read more

See all

We came here after hearing about the kids night. My son loved the balloon animals and face painting plus kids eat free! They had SpongeBob on the tv and it was definitely a kids dream. He had so much fun. The only reason for three stars is just because the food is ok and nothing I'd wanna go back for. I'd come for the experience again though for sure! read more

Service was fantastic and patient Food was delicious My husband said his Monte Cristo sandwich was the best he's had. The fresh soft pretzels (3 per order) were also a really great appetizer! We will be back! read more

This place is a great find! We went on a Friday, unfortunately, not able to book reservation online, but got seated quickly which was great! The theme is good - definitely present, but not too over the top, women's bathroom was so cute! The service was excellent! Our waitress was thoughtful, checked on us regularly, and handled our chaos at the table with the kiddos. They had the cutest drinks for kids, and the adult drinks were delicious as well, with a large selection! The chicken fajita bowl was just okay - I found the chicken to be excellent, but the rest was really bland, especially the queso! The portion sizes are large so you may need a to go container! There is a little arcade to entertain the kids after eating for a bit, but the claw toys needed shaken up and it's disappointing you can't reach close to the edges much to try to grab for toys. Overall, excellent little place that I look forward to returning to! read more

CR Hero's - Kid's drinks (Gatorade with lids, candy eaten). Adult frozen strawberry concoction and the Quack (or similar for drink names). - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

We used to be regulars at CR Hero's--visiting multiple times a month for Indiana Trivia with Tim (who is fantastic). We've always enjoyed the food and usually decent service, especially given how busy trivia nights get. Tonight, however, was beyond disappointing--and ended with our entire party of five being banned for leaving an honest 1-star review. One of our guests politely asked to switch from a booth to a table once one became available. When it did, she approached the hostess stand and was suddenly accused by Manager Lauren of being "aggressive," which couldn't have been further from the truth. Still, we were allowed to move, and we figured that was the end of it. We had a great time at trivia, even won a $20 gift card. Then Lauren came over--smirking--and told us we're no longer welcome at CR Hero's. The reason? A single 1-star review written earlier about her behavior. So instead of handling concerns professionally, she chose to retaliate. We reached out to the owner (whose number Lauren gave us), hoping for a level-headed conversation. Instead, she stood by her manager without question and upheld the ban. She even asked us to return the gift certificates--after we'd already been made to feel completely unwelcome. We've never had an issue here before. But now? We won't be back--not because we don't want to, but because CR Hero's made it very clear that honest feedback isn't tolerated. Disgraceful treatment of loyal customers. A total shame. read more

Excellent - outstanding service, good food, convenient parking, fair pricing, friendly staff

I'm babysitting my two grandkids in Fishers & we wanted a night out. This place is perfect for kids. They have fancy kids mocktail drinks (we ordered two of the "shark bait" drinks. Kids menu includes typical items: we tried the chicken tenders, mini corn dogs, and soft pretzel. They have sports playing on several real TVs and cartoons on one. The Superhero decor gave them something to look at. I ordered a chicken wrap, which was huge but tasty. It's a good place for a family outing. read more

See all

Haven't had in years, but they have great food choices and it's always fresh and delicious. Never had a bad experience here, also such a cute place to have a nice quick dinner read more

The food was delicious, (we always share with each other)! Our server Maygen was very good! The thing that kept me from a 5 was the very pink light in the bathroom!! We will definitely go back! read more

CR Hero's - Waffles and chicken, Idaho nachos, gooey onion burger with Mac and cheese - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We decided to go have lunch here today because I was craving a fried pork tenderloin and a google search put this restaurant in the top 10. Not sure who did the reviewing because this was just an ok sandwich and nothing memorable. We were wanting some onion rings but they had none on the appetizer list so we just ordered a side of them and they were just basic frozen onion rings. Meh. We also got a 4 cheese bacon sandwich and the bacon was thin and mostly fat. It was ok for bar food but we likely won't go back. read more

CR Hero's - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Food is bar food but is good! Atmosphere is like neighborhood place for families on one side and a bar on the other side! Service can be a little iffy as there are lot of young servers but overall a good place to grab a bite! read more

If you have littles , they will love it here!! Its honestly is a hidden gem. When you walk in all the walls are filled with superheroes and so many other things. My 4 and 3 year olds loved it! It's such a good vibe place and the service is so good. Everyone is so nice and understanding if you have small kids. The food was great , we have been there multiple times and have enjoyed our food and cocktails very much! So pretty much parents and kids will have a good time out. . Lol They also have a small arcade in the back that kids can go to afterwards. It's such a cute place! read more

Great Salmon Salad, Soft Pretzels, Excellent Tenderloin sandwich, Fabulous service! Family ambience...energetic! Bar is separate from dining room! Kids welcome. Great for sports w/lots of screens! We have been going to CR Hero's for years!! Love it! read more

I'm constantly on the hunt for amazing wings (bone-in obviously)so after seeing pics on here I was determined to try them. I had firecracker and oriental sesame and was not disappointed! Wings are very nice sized and cooked very well. The firecracker sauce is not too spicy and has notes of sweet chili sauce. I thought it was unique and I'd order it again for sure. The oriental sesame sauce was tangy and had that umami flavor you look for in a teriyaki sauce. I'd rank these wings in the top 4 in Indy. read more

Just a short review and tons of praise! After a long day we called in a take-out order for 2 Crispy Chicken Salads. The person answering phones asked if we wanted full or half orders. Thanks - I didn't know there was a choice - one of each please! Plenty of food! The crispy chicken was crispy! The gratuitous onion rings didn't travel well the 10 min it took - I could have done without them but thanks for the effort! Pick up at the back door is always smooth and the orders are correct! I really needed that today! Thank you! read more

CR Hero's - Tribute to real heros. - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

This local neighborhood gem is not far from my house so I decided to grab some dinner here. They offer convenient "curbside" pick up in the back of the building. I phoned the order in, but there was technical difficulties and the phone disconnected. They called right back, apologized, and explained the issue. We almost completed the order, but was disconnected again. After about 5 minutes I called back to confirm my order, and they explained they had to reboot their system, but my order was in. No problem. We pulled up, gave the name, and paid for the order. We received our order and were on our way. Smooth transaction. I wasn't as impressed with my Texas BBQ chicken wrap. It was just okay. I don't think I'd order it again. The chicken and waffles were good. I'd order that again. Since this is so close to my home, I'm sure I'll give it another try soon. read more

See all

For starters this place is a gem! I had no idea this place even existed. We went for a late lunch so there weren't very many people there. Our server was jeremy, he was very attentive & helpful with explaining the menu!! We both enjoyed our meals and plan to come back ! What really has me wanting to come back is there variety of cookie skillets. I want to come back enough times to try each one. Also, no matter if you need to use it or not. YOU HAVE TO GO LOOK AT THE BATHROOMS! I was so fascinated by the womens restroom that I made my boyfriend go into the mens and snap some pics so I could see as well as post them! read more

See all

Our first visit here to enjoy the Hamilton Tuesday Tenderloin trail. The atmosphere was fun. Not a seat in the house was available. The staff was genuine and friendly. My wife and I sat at the bar. Our neighbors were both frequent this place and high remarks. The food was quick, accurate and tasty. Everything you would hope for. read more