Creno&#x27;s Pizza

You're in for a treat if Evan happens to be working the bar. Try one of his specials or let him…read moresurprise you. As far as food, the grilled cheese is my go to. It's not only comforting but absolutely delicious.

Absolutely delicious-"The Mix" salad and Hawaiian BBQ pizza. Best salad I've ever ha! best Hawaiian…read morepizza I've ever had!

Bar

The mob scene

See all

Menu

Adornetto's

3.7(125 reviews)

3.3 mi

first time visiting after a nearly year long remodel. Was surprised to see the price increases and…read moreportion size. Their salad with cheese and 2 cherry tomatoes was$7.25. As if that wasn't bad enough, the bowl wasn't even half full. You could actually see the bottom of the bowl. We ordered a "large" pepperoni pizza which i think they said was 14" and 2 salads, just water and it was over $45.00 + tip. needless to say what was once a family favorite just priced itself out of a faithful couple. My 2 sibling and their spouses were also dining with us and were shocked as well.

This place was recommended to us by friends, so we went today and enjoyed it. We loved the modern…read moreatmosphere and the seating was comfortable. The waitress was prompt and our order came out perfectly. I started with a cucumber lemonade (with alcohol) drink and it was yummy as all get out. I'd have loved to have one or three more but didn't want the hangover! I ordered the 8" veggie pizza and minused the peppers. I usually don't order veggie simply due to the amount of liquid that ends up sogging up the crust. I suspected today's would be good and it was! I had enough left over to bring home for a snack during movie night. Hubs had the meat lovers and he enjoyed it and a draft beer. We're not local but we'd come back if we were.

Inside

Tri - colored Cheese Tortellini

See all

Garlic Bread With Mozzarella Cheese

Creno's Pizza

3.4(16 reviews)

4.9 mi

Worst pizza I ever had Iwas 5 mins away and pizza was dry and stale..first time customer and…read morelast ,subs were just as bad..but,delivery was not bad..give that person a raise..

Not only is this pizzeria renowned for its exceptional taste, but it also consistently delivers…read morehigh-quality pizzas. Their unwavering commitment to excellence ensures that every order is a satisfying experience.

Pepperoni Stromboli

See all

Pizza Cottage - Zanesville

3.6(40 reviews)

5.4 mi

Best Food and service the Buck!! My order is always hot and delicious..We just moved here from…read moreColumbus Ohio, and no disappointment awesome as Ever.

Fabulous pizza and fast delivery. Would def order from them again. Their square-cut thin crust is…read morethe bomb

See all

Tat's Pizzeria

3.6(36 reviews)

1.4 mi

The food is amazing! Their Antipasto salads are the best around! Filling and loaded! They have a…read moredrive thru window to call ahead and pickup! Always friendly staff. The ambiance inside is family friendly and relaxed. Overall a great experience.

Friendly service and the food was good. The pizza was a…read morelittle bit greasy but salads had lots of cheese and was very good

House Salad

Current menu

See all

Current menu

Earl's Village Pizza

2.5(4 reviews)

6.6 mi

Edit: Owner reached out...they make the pizza as they did before this recent change if you ask. If…read morethis is true on my next order then they are 5 stars for sure. No longer like the original. This pizza was great before they recently decided to go to a thin crust. Owner (I believe) advised they went to thin crust recently due to complaints. I find this explanation suspect given all the great past reviews. Maybe they are trying to cut costs. This is unfortunate, because the original Earl's was not a thin crust pizza. My family of 6 were all disappointed when I brought the pizza home. Off to Wally's to get more pizza since half the amount of dough used to make the old pizza made the one I got.

Super friendly people. Delivery driver was great. Their crust was trash. It was hard and hard to…read morebite through, like it had sat out for a day or two and hardened. I ate one piece and threw it away and went into town to a different place.

16" all the way pizza

See all

The building.

Lang's Pizza And Subs

3.9(11 reviews)

6.1 mi

Now called Kecks pies and pints. Terrible!!! Waiting over and hour for wings and a pizza. Wings…read moregood, pizza not so much.

This business is now Keck's Pie's and Pints. A week ago we…read moreordered a pizza like we have for the last 5 years (Langs). The pizza had hardly any sauce. I called immediately and told the girl that answered the phone, she said "we tend to go light on sauce ". I told her I paid for sauce on my pizza. She then said, "I can give you 25% off your next order...what ever happened to "The Customers always right?" We will go elsewhere for now on.

Donatos Pizza

3.8(20 reviews)

4.6 mi

This Zanesville Donatos is less than 3 minutes away from my mom's house so I've ordered from here…read moremany times over the years. However, it wasn't until my family decided to do pizza on Christmas eve that I realized I've never left them a review. So, here I am. Find them directly off Maple Ave across the street from Kroger. They have a drive thru window which can make pick up very easy. There's plenty of parking and the dining room is a good size. As for the food, I've never really had a bad experience. My order has always been correct and tasty. With it typically just being a plain cheese pizza, I would hope that's the case. Now on Christmas eve they did forget to give us the salads that came with our order. I suppose we also forgot to get them along with the other stuff. That said, when I went back to pick them up, I did have to wait like 20 minutes, but they were swamped. My family obviously wasn't the only one that thought pizza was the move. But honestly, that's the only real hiccup I can think of and it deserves some grace given the circumstances. Fun fact - Donatos is a Columbus-based pizza chain with 400+ locations and this particular location was their very first franchise location, which is pretty cool. Gotta love seeing Ohio businesses thrive. I have no doubt my family and I will continue to order from here.

Ordered this in a hurry, pepperoni rolls were barely rolls. On the size of my fist the others size…read moreof my thumb... it was quick.. normal looking on inside and outside. Not busy...food tasted good

Chicken Spinach Mozzarella™

Chicken Harvest Salad

See all

Chicken Caprese Entrée Salad

The Barn

3.6(67 reviews)

3.2 mi

Food wonderful service wonderful all the waiters are excellent. The mood of the place was like the…read more1920s. It was excellent. Nothing else to say about it.

Just adequate food with terrible prices! My husband and I both ordered a grilled chicken sandwich…read morewhich we assumed came with fries. Nope, they were another $3.79 and $3.99 for my husband who ordered the seasoned fries, which by the way were frozen deep fried French fries. $9.99 was the price of the sandwich with out any toppings. Okay so I get paying for cheese but really, tomato and lettuce too? The server asked what condiment and when I asked if they had honey mustard, she never said there'd be an up charge. So my $9.99 sandwich was now $12.79 without any fries! Hand cut fries have to be the cheapest side and most restaurants add them to sandwich plates and only charge for substitutions. Our total bill for two sandwiches and fries plus one iced tea was $35.96. And if it was gourmet or a larger serving I wouldn't post this review, but it was small and ordinary food! We stopped here on our way home from another location and weren't familiar with the area. Chances are we'll never be by again but I thought I'd save someone else from being ripped off!

My view of the bar and all the awesome lights and things to look at !

Cheese pizza

See all

Menu for the Barn!

Little Caesars Pizza

1.6(21 reviews)

4.3 mi

No one will be surprised, but I'm writing to advise against ordering from Little Ceasar's Maple…read moreAve. App order placed at 4:10 for 5:45 pickup, left with the mediocre food at 6:45. House full of family waiting over an hour for dinner. Absolute chaos and zero concern or customer service. Random excuses after saying 4 times over 30 minutes "its coming out now." App said "in the oven" at 5:29, so I asked at 6:15 if they were burnt yet. Blank stares. There were 10 pizzas in the "pick up with a code" warmers, but no codes were configured. 8 people tried. There were over 20 more pizzas in piles in the back stacked up and getting cold. They have decent pizza for a reasonable price, IF you can get them. Haven't seen a Hot&Ready pizza for at least 5 years now. Unless you want to stand in their depressing lobby for an hour, don't order.

Absolutely disgusting. This place looked like it hadn't been cleaned in years. There was dirt and…read moregrime everywhere I looked, and there was what looked like mold on the walls and around parts of the building. The whole place smelled awful, and it made me want to leave as soon as I walked in. The employees acted completely unprofessional, and the atmosphere was chaotic. Not to mention they all look like are on crack and meth whores. It honestly felt like nobody cared about cleanliness or customer service. They are all rude asf not giving a care in the world. I would never come back here and definitely wouldn't recommend this place to anyone. Save yourself the time and go somewhere else. Also came across this video from a ex employee

See all

Who tf even knows what this is

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Hillary S.

266

6

2

10 years ago

Their chef salad is the best in town, possibly in the whole state... and I love the "rainbow" look they make of the veggies on it! The pepperoni pizza is covered with pepperonis and delicious. The taco pizza can sound a little weird but it's absolutely delicious too! read more

Bev H.

0

3

0

15 years ago

Great pizza, as well as the rest of the menu. Fast delivery or Pickup. Sometimes the phone help just puts you on hold without saying they are doing so. I find this a little rude. Overall good place for take out, eat in or delivery. read more

Alicia S.

0

2

0

14 years ago

Just ordered from here and it was pretty good. I had their turkey club and breadsticks. Only reason I'm giving it a 4 is because my breadsticks showed up cold. Decently priced. read more

Karissa R.

0

1

0

3 years ago

Great Food! the family and I love eating from here! communication has never been a problem for me, they get my order right every time and the subs are the best read more

Creno's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Creno's Pizza also viewed

Plaza Pizza - Newark

3.4

(72 reviews)

Provably the best all time pizza in town since the 1960s, with a thin, crackly crust and truly…read moredelicious sauce. Drawback are the price and the wait, and that it's going to take multiple pizzas to fill people up -- their pizzas are to die for but not filling. A Newark legend.

My husband and I have always made it a point to stop at Plaza Pizza whenever we're in Newark…read more Unfortunately, our most recent visit was a huge disappointment. The restaurant just doesn't seem to have recovered since COVID. They no longer offer dine-in service, and all of the tables have been pushed in front of the prep area, so customers can no longer watch the pizzas being made--a feature that used to add to the experience. The condition of the restaurant was concerning. The ceiling tiles were stained and discolored, several were out of place leaving openings to the floor above, and there appeared to be visible mold on ceiling tiles and around the vent above the pizza ovens and prep area. Given the location, it raised concerns for me about sanitation and food safety. The drink cooler was completely empty. When we asked, we were simply told they were out of beverages. We ended up buying drinks from the business next door, where they mentioned that Plaza Pizza customers regularly come there because the pizza shop doesn't have beverages available. The pizza itself wasn't what we remembered. The signature cracker crust that made Plaza Pizza special is gone. It lacked the crisp, fresh texture it once had and instead tasted stale. The bottoms of both pizzas were also dotted with black debris from the oven deck -- the oven decks have been cleaned between pizzas which should be a standard operating procedure. The restaurant was extremely hot inside, and I noticed ingredients such as sauce being kept in containers on the counter rather than in a refrigerated prep table. Having spent many years working in food service, those observations prompted me to review recent Licking County health inspection reports. I found multiple repeat violations that had reportedly remained uncorrected, which made the issues I observed even more concerning. This restaurant used to be one of our favorite stops, and it's disappointing to see how far it has declined. I genuinely hope the owners invest in cleaning, maintenance, and stronger food safety practices because Plaza Pizza was once a local gem. Until then, we'll be taking our business elsewhere.

Creno's Pizza

3.4

(8 reviews)

Called to place a order and was informed that a previous order had been delivered but did not get…read moretheir money. I explained that I have NEVER gotten a pizza delivered and wanted to speak to the owher abd was told by the wanna be manager kid that he wished me good luck with that. The pizza is not worth the mouth that answers the phone . Come to find out it was the neighbor upstairs who had gotten the pizza and the delivery guy did not want to get her change for a 50.00 ( 36.00 order) which would have only been 14.00 and was told done worry about it. She called the shop to make it right abd waited the next day for the delivery guy to never show up. In my 50 plus years I've NEVER heard of getting a pizza delivered and not receiving the payment. Come on crenos in buckeye lake , who's fault is this really?

Ordered from here tonight while traveling back to Alabama from Pennsylvania. The Stromboli was…read morefresh and hot the cheese bread was awesome! The brownie dessert was super moist and delicious!!!

Four Star Pizza

3.0

(3 reviews)

Total garbage, ordered four subs and got four bags of soggy bread with huge gobs of disgusting…read moremayo, rotten toppings and foul meat. Called the shop and talked to manager and not nothing but language as foul as their subs. Not only will he not make it right with me, he put us on the no service in the future list, like I would ever order from these scumbags again.

Friendly drivers, really good food! When other pizza shops wasn't open, they where! I got a chicken…read moresub and hot wings and the food was delicious!!!!! The staff that answered the phone was friendly as well and they delivered the food quickly as well. Overall I will be ordering from here more often!!!! I suggest others do as well.

Adornetto's

3.7

(125 reviews)

first time visiting after a nearly year long remodel. Was surprised to see the price increases and…read moreportion size. Their salad with cheese and 2 cherry tomatoes was$7.25. As if that wasn't bad enough, the bowl wasn't even half full. You could actually see the bottom of the bowl. We ordered a "large" pepperoni pizza which i think they said was 14" and 2 salads, just water and it was over $45.00 + tip. needless to say what was once a family favorite just priced itself out of a faithful couple. My 2 sibling and their spouses were also dining with us and were shocked as well.

This place was recommended to us by friends, so we went today and enjoyed it. We loved the modern…read moreatmosphere and the seating was comfortable. The waitress was prompt and our order came out perfectly. I started with a cucumber lemonade (with alcohol) drink and it was yummy as all get out. I'd have loved to have one or three more but didn't want the hangover! I ordered the 8" veggie pizza and minused the peppers. I usually don't order veggie simply due to the amount of liquid that ends up sogging up the crust. I suspected today's would be good and it was! I had enough left over to bring home for a snack during movie night. Hubs had the meat lovers and he enjoyed it and a draft beer. We're not local but we'd come back if we were.

Harvest - Granville

4.0

(37 reviews)

Absolutely incredible experience at Harvest Pizza in Granville! The pizza is phenomenal--the…read morewood-fired crust has the perfect balance of chew and char, and the fresh ingredients really stand out. To top it off, their wine selection is fantastic and pairs perfectly with the menu. Great atmosphere, wonderful service, and delicious food. I will definitely be a regular here from now on. Highly recommend!

Food is awesome here! Came for a business lunch and the salad and turkey sandwich were phenomenal!…read moreHigh quality ingredients and fantastic flavors. Service is very friendly albeit it took a while for food to come. Regardless, loved everything!

Russo's Kitchen Bar

4.3

(100 reviews)

You're in for a treat if Evan happens to be working the bar. Try one of his specials or let him…read moresurprise you. As far as food, the grilled cheese is my go to. It's not only comforting but absolutely delicious.

Absolutely delicious-"The Mix" salad and Hawaiian BBQ pizza. Best salad I've ever ha! best Hawaiian…read morepizza I've ever had!

Don & Sue's Pizza

3.7

(64 reviews)

This may be one of my favorite pizza places. Love the sauce. Ordered a pizza with pepperoni and…read morebanana peppers. Was got and fresh.

Food is good and the atmosphere is fun, and the drinks are good and cold! There services was also…read morevery good!

Carmen's Pizza

4.8

(4 reviews)

Food was pretty good and really cheap. The service was great. The owner frank was great to talk to…read morewhile I waited on my food.

Great pizza and subs. They really make a great Italian sub and don't scrimp on the meat.read more

Clay's Cafe & Catering

4.2

(106 reviews)

Wowie! Hidden place. Definitely a sleeper…read more The restaurant is an old 50s soda bar. Still has the bar set up. There are tons of board games for people of all ages. The milkshake was so delicious they served it in a soda shop glass and left the metal mixing cup. Stromboli was next to none. I've tried Stromboli in many states and this by far is my absolute favorite. The lady serving us was super busy and moving from table to table and she was so kind. The other people looked like high school kids just trying to work hard and make some money. Great small town feel. Help out local restaurants by supporting them and keeping the town working!

My absolute favorite ice cream is at this restaurant. I ask for the ice cream first and the food…read morecan come as it is ready. This restaurant is always busy and you honestly have to wait a while for the hot food. Our server was friendly and attentive to our needs. We ordered way more food than two people could possibly eat but we knew we could take it home. I love the cappuccino crunch ice cream. It is my all time favorite flavor. The ice cream came out pretty melty because of the extreme heat. Our server apologized for it. The restaurant has games available for the wait. The restaurant is quiet enough for conversation with one of your favorite sons also! The tables were clean as was the restroom. The food is decent. This is not gourmet dining nor is it necessarily healthy. As an occasional treat, the food hits the spot. We will be back!

Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap

4.4

(202 reviews)