Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Criminal Pie And Pantry

    5.0 (1 review)

    Criminal Pie And Pantry Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Criminal Pie And Pantry

    Recommended Reviews - Criminal Pie And Pantry

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Blondie's Bakery Boutique

    Blondie's Bakery Boutique

    4.7
    (59 reviews)
    0.7 mi

    Pros: The staff is extremely friendly and the interior of the shop is heavily decorated so much…read morepink! The decorations are adorable and make the place look livelier. I usually buy the raspberry cake slice, the macarons, and Whoopie Cookies. I've purchased the cruffles and the macarons as gifts for my friends, and they're always adorned in a cute box with a ribbon bow. There are also gluten-free cupcakes available. They've never disappointed me and I often walk out of the store with a smile and my sweet tooth satisfied. Cons: Street parking can be tricky during busier times. However, it's about a 5 minute walk away from the Santa Rosa Plaza Mall. The cake slices and cupcakes lay on the buttercream pretty thick, which can get overly sweet. Overall: I had been going to Sift Dessert Bar since 2015, and when it closed in 2024, I was surprised to find that the location for the original Santa Rosa store is now owned by a former manager of Sift Dessert Bar! If you missed Sift Dessert Bar, you'll definitely love Blondie's Bakery Boutique. The colorful interior and sweet treats make this shop a must-visit. While I have ordered a cake from Sift Dessert Bar, I have not done so for Blondie's Bakery Boutique.

    Blondie is a badass. She and her team made gorgeous custom…read moresucculent design cupcakes. She came in early to make sure we got them in time for our party. The cupcakes were gorgeous and the gluten-free almond cake was delicious for all.

    Photos
    Blondie's Bakery Boutique
    Blondie's Bakery Boutique
    6' Chocolate Cake

    See all

    6' Chocolate Cake
    Red Bird Bakery

    Red Bird Bakery

    4.4
    (73 reviews)
    0.3 mi

    Finding a neighborhood gem like Red Bird Bakery is exactly why we support local artisans. This spot…read morehas mastered the balance of traditional technique and a welcoming, community-focused atmosphere that makes it a standout in the North Bay. The craftsmanship here is evident in every loaf and pastry. Their sourdough is a masterclass in texture, boasting that perfect, resilient crust and a complex, airy crumb that captures the essence of classic fermentation. The sweet and savory options are equally impressive, delivered with a warmth that feels authentically local. * **Pastry Excellence:** The ham and cheese croissants are expertly laminated, providing a shatteringly crisp exterior that gives way to a rich, savory center. For those with a sweet tooth, the berry scones are consistently packed with fresh fruit and have a tender, buttery finish. * **Signature Granola:** Beyond the fresh bakes, their granola is a hidden star--perfectly toasted, balanced in sweetness, and ideal for a high-energy morning. * **The Vibe:** Whether you're visiting the Sebastopol Avenue location or catching them at the farmer's market, the service is genuinely personal. The brick-and-mortar space has a cool, industrial-meets-inviting aesthetic that makes it a great destination, even if you're used to grabbing your favorites at Oliver's. Have you had a chance to try any of their seasonal special loaves, or do you tend to stick to the classic sourdough?

    Cute bakery and cafe in a neat funky/artsy little neighborhood…read more Visited for the first time around 10am on a weekday, only a person or two in line ahead of me. No danish left, but tried a cinnamon roll and an Italian deli sandwich. The roll was good, but a little more dense than I like. The sandwich was fantastic and pretty large for the price. A small latte was very good, love their beans!

    Photos
    Italian cold sandwich
    Italian cold sandwich
    Mini cheesecake
    Mini cheesecake
    Chocolate raspberry tart

    See all

    Chocolate raspberry tart
    Criminal Baking & Catering Company

    Criminal Baking & Catering Company

    4.2
    (550 reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $$

    This place absolutely exceeded my expectations! If you care about food and love incredible flavors…read morewith good people, you should 100% come here. If you value fancy things and mediocre food, this place is not your place. So this place is kind of close to downtown, near the hockey rink, in an old industrial building. It is the very definition of what I would call a hole-in-the-wall restaurant. When I walked in, I was incredibly impressed by the amount of beautiful and delicious-looking food in their case! I quickly studied the menu and decided on the bacon bowl. It had eggs, green chili salsa, home-fried potatoes, seasonal veggies, all served on a bed of lettuce. The flavors were outstanding. Not only was it a good-sized breakfast, but the flavors were just delicious. The veggies were perfectly seasoned and not overcooked. The egg and potatoes were nice, and the overall flavor was just wonderful. I liked this place so much that I ended up coming back on day two of my trip just to eat here again with a friend! The people were absolutely incredible at this location! Each day I had a wonderful conversation and honestly just felt so included and acknowledged. If I lived closer, this would be a place that would be on my weekly routine.

    I stop in here fairly often, but just realized I had forgotten to show some love for this local…read morebakery. I stop in for the savory pastries as snacks often, but most recently I dropped in for a couple of sweet treats to take to a friend's house for dinner. We had Strawberry and Rhubarb tart and a couple of mini-bundt chocolate cakes. Both were a hit! Great bakery! Give them a shot!

    Photos
    Cafe Space
    Cafe Space
    Hard banana bread
    Hard banana bread
    Seating area

    See all

    Seating area
    Rosi Sweets

    Rosi Sweets

    4.2
    (5 reviews)
    2.3 mi

    Berry Chantilly cake is one of my and my family's favorites. I found Rosie through Instagram and…read moredecided to order one from her shop. I sent her a Pinterest photo of a style that I really liked and got the berry Chantilly. The frosting was so delicious, and that's coming from somebody who doesn't like frosting. The berries on the inside were super fresh and flavorful. Everybody in the family loved the cake. It also looked incredible she was able to make a beautiful cake without sacrificing the flavor. If I could leave six stars I would. This is the only place I'll be ordering cakes from from here on out.

    I am always amazed at how amazing her pastries and cakes taste and look. I've bought from her since…read moreshe starting selling and even before she did, we knew she would be a great success in baking because it's something she truly loves doing and it shows when you taste anything she makes. She is super professional, kind, and she really makes the whole process very easy. Whenever I order from her, she asks questions to make sure she will get everything we request and no details get left out. Since we started buying our family birthday cakes from her, we haven't stopped! With other cakes I would usually take the merengue or frosting off the cake because it was always too thick or I just never liked the flavor, but her merengue is so light and so delicious, I eat the whole thing every single time! Must try!!

    Photos
    Betty Chantilly cake with custom design
    Betty Chantilly cake with custom design
    Tres leches cake with walnuts, our family favorite!
    Tres leches cake with walnuts, our family favorite!
    Tres Leches Cake with Walnuts

    See all

    Tres Leches Cake with Walnuts

    Criminal Pie And Pantry - popuprestaurants - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...