The food was awesome, pizza was a little greasy, but very ver fresh and delicious. Lots of fresh garlic and fresh herbs being used. The place had very nice music playing. Service was a literally weird. The kid didn't seem to know that i wanted to order. It felt weird saying "hey id like to order" but that's his fault for not asking... being nice would go along way. Also the place was very very clean. They need all the support they can get, please walk in! They're very good at making pizza! read more

First, I'd like to give a huge Thank you to the gentleman who helped us with dinner tonight. This is my first try of NY pizza and the food is just as great as the service. We ordered 2 slices of cheese and 1 penne pasta pizza(added a little bbq). Garlic knots and the Oreo cheesecake and a lemoncello cheesecake slice(drizzled with raspberry sauce) The food is outstanding! The service was wonderful. The staff asked if we'd like to stay and eat. The restaurant had several booths and was clean and organized. They even have Italian ice, zepollia(spelling) They were welcoming and warm and provided explanations and suggestions. read more

See all

The pizza is below average but I haven't tried the other menu items yet to give a full review

Do you like ricotta cheese? Do you like mozzarella cheese? Do you really, really like cheese? Do you like a nice soft crust? Don't like tomato sauce? If yes to all then you will love the thick heavy white cheese slice at this spot. If you have lactose problems get one of their other creative slices. One slice of this delicious white pie is probably enough for 2 meals. We also had their pepperoni pinwheel which was made with fresh dough, lots of pepperoni and mozzarella rolled into a circle with tomato sauce on the side. The pepperoni gave it enough greasy deliciousness that it quickly disappeared. Lots of other pasts dishes to choose from. Everything made fresh. Wednesday special is a regular pie, garlic knots and zeppoles. Great family small business that we were happy to support. read more

Victorio's II - Garlic knot pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Consistently delicious classic pizza and great staff. Always helpful and quick. Love this place

Aside from the delicious food, the staff is wonderful. Always the best customer service! In a world where getting good help is difficult and so many disgruntled employees, it's great to see that this staff is always friendly, generous, and genuine. read more

Always great food & customer service. Fresh, delicious pizza. Great garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, zeppoles, everything you need from a pizza shop. The pizza sauce is amazing, lots of oregano We tried the garlic knot pizza tonight - fresh and delicious with fresh parsley and Parmesan cheese on a their (already delicious) regular pie, with perfectly "soft on the inside, crisp on the outside" garlic knot crust - AMAZING. Definitely recommend read more

Victorio's II - Garlic Knot Pie - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

this place is pretty much my family and extended family's pizza place. they've been coming here for years whether it's dinner or just going for lunch and the quality has never dipped over the years and they still continue to have great food and great prices. if you're in the area it's worth a stop. read more

See all

I've tried this place a few times. Food is good. It's the staff that's the issue. You're never met with a friendly hello. Prices are a little high. If they were nice and welcoming I wouldn't mind paying but they aren't. read more

Is a good place, I enjoy eating there I like service and the ambiance, the food is good

Victorio's I & II use to be my number one pizzeria until a recurring problem surfaced. Early this summer, a Victorio's I pizza special order came with an uninvited guest, a cockroach! Then I switched to Victorio's II and it seemed that the problem was resolved until recently. Low and behold, another cockroach was hanging out by the garlic knots container and bag of zeppole. I live in a private home and occasionally insects do make its way into the house: e.g., spiders, flies, moths, but never cockroaches. The coincidence of the appearance of a cockroach situated on my kitchen counter by a Victorio's takeout containers has me convinced that their supply warehouse has an infestation problem. Hopefully this problem will soon be resolved since their food is generally very good. read more

This is but one of quite a few pizza restaurants and take out joints in my local neighborhood. Though it's somewhat off the beaten path, I was passing by and figured I'd give their garlic knots a try. Tale of the tape: Garlic Knots Unlike other pizza places, these truly resemble knots! Also unlike other places, they are somewhat large as well. However, the first part of the name is, unfortunately, absent. There is at best a mild garlic flavor to these knots. In addition, the dough is rather dense and heavy. They would best be enjoyed after having been baked for awhile in a toaster oven, then dipped in a good marinara. As I haven't had any of their other fare, it would be unfair to rate them anything other than a three, though their knots certainly do not even approach that high an approbation. I will update this review accordingly when I sample other parts of their menu. read more

The worst dining experience I have ever had anywhere in the world. The waitress slammed the food on the table, was threatening to charge us double for modifying our order due to a dietary restriction. When we entered the door we ignored. Also the food was bland and overpriced. The whole experience was so unpleasant. read more

Listed as opens at 11 I get here at 11:10 and the door is still locked there is somebody behind the counter that totally ignored me, called 2 times and they don't answer ... I'll just take my service and money else where that actually respects customers and there open times .. read more

I love their pizza. The cheese:sauce ratio is always on point and the dough is always cooked to perfection. Not doughy/chewy and not overly cooked to be rock hard. It's always perfect. It's also the flavor of the sauce! Amazing! read more

Called in at 2:10 for 2 pastas. Was told 20 minutes, but I came 40-45 minutes later and food is still not ready. They claimed they called me a few times but I never got a call and I always have service. Long story short it's been over an hour and I'm still waiting for food. The food is good but the service is extremely trash. Everyone looks like they are forced to work here ‍ read more

Absolutely disgusting, the chef here is terrible. All our pizza cheese was on the lid of our box, the chicken marsala was salty and the antipasto made me throw up after the fist bite. Called the store and was told "well I don't know you and I'm not the owner so there's nothing I can do" I was made to feel like a lier and brushed off. My husband was so angry he took the food back to the store. Not a signal employee wearing a mask even though they promote that all employees are required to wear masks for health safety. Never again will I order food here. read more

We were here for a weekend and stopped by around 8:30 p.m. for some food; the cheese pizza was OK, but the BBQ one was absolutely disgusting as if it was sitting there for a long period of time. The wings were also gross and had no meat on them or tasted as if they were reheated multiple times. They also seemed to have tipped themselves. Ask for a receipt if you are desperate enough to come here. They shouldn't serve paying customers food they wouldn't eat themselves. read more

Had a Sicilian pie over the weekend may be the best pie I have ever had.The sauce,the cheese the crust it was pizza nirvana.Thanks,I'll be back! read more

Great pizza !! Just moved to the neighborhood , so I figured I'd give them a try. They have a special that includes garlic knots and zeppoles. Pie arrived hot n fresh and staff was friendly and attentive. Thanks for a tasty pizza read more

I normally come here for their regular slice it's the best around. Today I decided to try a white spinach slice and it was incredible! Always fresh great pizza! read more

Good Food, Good Srevice. Friendly Fast We(8)of us had a great time apps were great. Veal perfect. Sauce perfect. Overall good for family and friends read more

I went there with a friend a few days ago. It's a cool place, with some nice people, and a good pizza. Don't expect anything crazy good, but it definitely gets the job done. read more

I was surprised at how good this pizza was. We only stopped here bc we saw a sign outside that said $11.99 for a large pie, 6 garlic knots & 6 zeppollis. So we thought why not! After we ate we were glad we gave it a try. We've ordered cheap pies from other places in the neighborhood and were disappointed with the taste of the pizza but not this time. We will def be back here. No place in the neighborhood has this kind of value for the quality of taste. read more

I liked the food a few weeks ago but ordered recently and probably won't order again eggplant parm was really watery and not breaded tastes like they boiled it just weird read more

The regular cheese pie is disgusting! The dough is often uncooked, there's no flavor or taste to this pizza. It's blah. Neither the zeppoles nor the garlic knots are anything special either. I won't be back! read more

I had the chicken salad slice it was very good the price is good.the baked ziti is yummy my favorite place.

I been coming here since moving in the area - food is always on loint and fresh, staff super friendly but Nick went above and beyond to make sure I had everything I needed and then some and I wanted to tell a manager in person. The kid knows how to deal with customers, sell and make you feel welcome and as a business owner myself he seems like an invaluable asset. Hopefully he's recognized and rewarded for his exceptional customer service and friendly demeanor. I would've returned regardless but I'll be visiting here more, solely because of Nick and his professionalism. read more

Been ordering pizza since moving to the area a few years ago. The pizza is not bad, they have some ok specials which is cool. My only issue every time I go to pick up my order they look at me like I have three heads...I always say thank you and good night but they just look at me like I just insulted them. Not sure what the deal is with that place...but like I said the pizza is not bad. read more

Penne with garlic, oil, broccoli, and spinach somehow worked out to $19. They should change their name from Victorio to R.I.C.O. Try somewhere else where you wont loose your shirt for a bowl of pasta. read more

This place has, hands down, some of the best pizza I've ever eaten. On top of that, the staff was fantastic and seemed to go above and beyond to take care of the customers. I highly recommend Victorio II! read more

Sorry to say the food at Victoria 's has gotten really bad and the help is rude as will. Dried up food was sent and then I was told they will not deliver any more to me. They can keep there food and your help will bring your Bizzness down. read more

I had terrible service, felt like the food was poor and the table was unclean. Also the waitress was rude to me. I feel this place is a poor excuse for a restaurant. They also charged the wrong price and figured the tax incorrectly and then didn't give me a receipt. Beware!!!! read more

Best pizza iv had on long island. Always great service! So many specialty slices to choose from. 100% recommend

Awesome food create staff and attitude. Love ordering food from here would defiantly recommend to people