Crostatas Rustic Pizza

Friendly service. Dining is clean, narrow, and relatively quiet. Fresh salad. Delicious pizza,…read moremeatball sub, and pizza. Always fresh, good flavor, served hot. Always worth a visit.

Came for lunch with friends. Split the pepperoni calzone with my husband. He had a house salad…read more His house salad was large and had a lot of cheese. It was very fresh and he enjoyed it. The calzone was really good and perfect with the marinara sauce. Friends ordered the Reuben March special sub and they enjoyed it. The basil pasta looked good that was also ordered. Our server was attentive and friendly. There were 5 of us in the back. There was a small table put to a booth. It was ok, but wobbly. Other than the wobbly table, great place for lunch! Tasty and speedy! Definitely recommend.

Tiramisu

See all

Geraci's Pizza

3.2(24 reviews)

2.3 mi

Great place, pizza by the slice available, staff is great. The guy that's always there is…read moreprofessional,fast, and you can actually carry a conversation if it is not slammed busy. Always clean!!!! I hit this place for lunch at least once a week and I recommend it to everyone. Try it out for an affordable meal.

I tried this particular pizza place based on a recommendation from a friend. The pizza is just…read moreaverage, for the price you would expect better.

The counter

See all

Couple booths for sit down. Geraci's!!

Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

4.4(59 reviews)

3.7 mi

One of the best pizza institutions in Cleveland. Carmella's serves up the freshest and tastiest…read morepizza around. Pro tip it's cash only but very worth it.

What do you do when you're being touristy in a city you're not familiar with and need a late…read moredinner? Order from Domino's or another national chain just to be safe? NEVER! You try out a local joint... Preferably the diviest one you can find. Carmella's was the perfect fit! Not our beloved hometown pie but a solid win just the same. Definitely a tad to the divey side. Take-out and cash only. No paper plates or napkins. The staff had a bit of a Bill and Ted feel... meaning perhaps a little befuddled but so nice and helpful. The pizza was great! Crust was just right, nice balance of cheese, sauce and toppings and flavorful. Best I've had in Ohio. If you find yourself on the east side of Cleveland Carmella's is a good call!

Inside

Pepperoni and Hand pulled sausage

See all

Exterior

LaRich's Pizza

3.9(35 reviews)

0.9 mi

•$$$

Great pizza for pickup. Staff were friendly. Picked up a small pepperoni. Very good flavor.read more

Delicious. Small place with attentive staff that is efficient and kind. Highly recommend.read more

See all

Pizza Roma

4.2(59 reviews)

2.3 mi

They take orders and then are closed when you show up. They seem to close arbitrarily.read more

This pizza is sooo good. I first tried this pizza last month at my niece engagement party. I came…read moreback in town this month for the wedding. This was my first stop after leaving airport. I could not remember the vegetarian pizza but the owner is a sweetheart and took the time to describe multiple pizzas . The California pizza is chefs kiss. The owner also let me sample a slice of pizza with carmelized onion and it was also great. The entire staff was so gracious. I would be a regular weekly customer if I did not live out of state but this will be my go to when in town

California-very delicious well seasoned/flavor pizza with fresh delicious veggies

See all

Cannoli

Zeppe's Pizzeria

4.1(53 reviews)

0.9 mi

Pizza was good , delivery guy was nice.. we frequent the Miles rd location for happy hour usually…read morebut we were in the neighborhood and decided to grab pizza. It was good.

I ordered a cobb salad with extra chicken, no bleu cheese and no egg. What I got was no extra…read morechicken and tons of bleu cheese, which is all over the salad and impossible to remove. I absolutely detest bleu cheese, but I guess they just feel that everyone likes it, forget what I ordered. I'm so angry that I simply couldn't get what I asked for. Horrible.

Exterior

BBQ Chicken Pizza

See all

Zepperoni Rolls

Georgio's Oven Fresh Pizza

3.7(19 reviews)

2.8 mi

Ordered an Italian sub had to be the worst thing I've eaten in this area. They put cubed ham on it…read morewith pepperoni, a drizzle of cheese, chopped tomatoes, chopped onions, and a few pieces of lettuce for eight bucks... What a disgrace for this area...

1/2 sheet pizza is the way to go. Love their hipster pizza. I was recommended this by a friend and…read morenow this is my favorite pizza place I. Mayfield.

Georgio's

See all

Small calzone with mushroom green peppers onions tomatoes and marinara

Master Pizza

3.5(82 reviews)

3.0 mi

I recently went here with a friend to split a pizza on a weekend evening. We were able to place our…read moreorder quickly and got our pizza in a timely manner. Master Pizza is a no-frills, hole-in-the-wall restaurant-everything is self-serve other than the pizza. My friend and I split the Ultimate Cheese Pizza on a Cleveland-style crust. The crust was perfectly cooked with a nice crunch and the cheese blend was also delicious. My only critique is that there was somehow too much cheese (a first for me), which could have been balanced out with some tomato sauce.

Great place to grab a quick pizza and wings. Interior had been remodeled with a few small tables…read moreand booths. Pizza's are delicious and cooked well. Not the largest wings you will get but great flavor and tender. Grab your own drinks or adult beverages from the cooler. Very good salads. Reasonable price and quick/friendly service.

Pepperoni Passion Pizza

Ultimate Cheese Pizza

See all

My favorite pizza pepperoni and pineapple. My husband's favorite pizza sausage with extra cheese.

Romeo's Pizza

3.7(23 reviews)

1.1 mi

We order pizza from here every week. Our guests from out of town love it too. The staff is friendly…read moreand the pizza is delicious.

I've been a customer of this location for over six years. Up until today the quality has always…read morebeen good although the prices have gone up. Placed my standard order and was extremely disappointed when I got home. Literally there was about one third of the usual toppings. Not sure if it's new ownership, but I won't waste any more of my money here.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

13 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Amjad A.

2 years ago

"I'm obsessed with Crostatas Rustic Pizza! The moment I took a bite, I knew I was in for a treat. The crust was perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of crunch and chew. The sauce was rich and tangy, and the cheese was melted to perfection. But what really sets Crostatas apart is the quality of their ingredients. You can tell they're using only the freshest toppings, and the flavors all work together in harmony. I've tried several of their pizzas, but the Margherita is my go-to - the simplicity of the fresh tomatoes, basil, and mozzarella is absolute perfection. The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and rustic, with exposed brick and wooden accents. The service is always friendly and attentive, and the prices are very reasonable. Overall, I highly recommend Crostatas Rustic Pizza to anyone looking for a delicious, authentic Italian pizza experience. You won't be disappointed!" Let me know if you'd like me to make any changes! read more

Karin E.

5 years ago

We stopped by for lunch yesterday and was pleasantly surprised to find such a gem. You may want to try the risotto croquettes in marinara as an appetizer. It was unusual and flavorful. Amongst our items we chose for lunch, we had the wood-fired pizza. It was FABULOUS! The mushrooms were so tasty. I tore up the large fresh basil leaf to share on the pizza. The crust was just perfect. Treat yourself to the Tartufo al Cioccolato for dessert. There is a great wine list, as well as other drinks. Staff was friendly and provided prompt service. Hope you find your experience as great as we did. I am looking forward to trying some of the other items on the menu when I am in the area. Food made with fresh ingredients adds more flavor. You can taste the difference! Enjoy! read more

Matt R.

Elite 18

259

10 years ago

I love wood-fired pizza because I am a self-proclaimed pizza snob from NY, so I always have unfair comparisons. Wood fired italian pizzas are a different style that I always love. This place is really cute inside and out, and everything sounded awesome. I ordered a sausage pizza and then another one I added chicken to. Unfortunately they forgot to add the chicken to my pizza, which was disappointing. I waited 30 mins to get home and eat so the pizza had lost its crunch and was barely warm- totally not their fault because the flavor was there. I would imagine fresh, it would be 4 stars easily. Definitely willing to try them out again. read more

Helen D.

9 years ago

The worst pizza I have ever had, and I usually say there is "no bad pizza, just better pizza". The sauce had NO flavor at all it was just plain diced tomatoes and the toppings were scarce. To ad insult to injury, they wanted to call this "gourmet" and overcharge for a tasteless pizza. Don't waste your money- I would rather eat cardboard Little Caesar's. read more

Toni Q.

11 years ago

While Crostatas started as a tasty Neapolitan pizzeria, the offering has expanded to include quality homemade Italian dishes to bring me back to my childhood memories of food. I look forward to dining in this charming neighborhood setting when I am visiting Cleveland! It is a one of a kind!!! read more

Shelly D.

10 years ago

I love this place. There are some many great appetizers and menu choices. I think I could order anything and be happy. I think people will be pleasantly surprised at the quality, flavor, presentation, size and value. read more

Stephanie M.

16 years ago

Pretty good pizza! The only thing I don't like is that the pop comes in little bottles. I wish you could get a glass and some refills!

Al C.

192

4 years ago

Very very good food, but to pricey for the amount you get. I ordered take out, however the inside was very nice

Amelie C.

9 years ago

Everything about this restaurant was great! There is no doubt that you will find something you like.

Zarielle W.

6 years ago

I love this place we just discovered it and are in love. Thank you so much. We will be back

Deb L.

9 years ago

Authentic, unique, delicious, healthy, one of a kind selections on their menu.

Antonio R.

14 years ago

Pizza was pretty good but I've had better in Cleveland.

Bob S.

14 years ago

It was great!!

Crostatas Rustic Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Crostatas Rustic Pizza also viewed

Scotti's Italian Eatery

4.1

(114 reviews)

Great little Italian restaurant on East 185. Friendly staff, good food and price is right.read more

I came here about 2:00 pm. Door was locked. I called and man said it was a slow day so they decided…read moreto close and come I should come back at 4:00. (This is a family owned business.). I said I was already in the parking lot and in the meantime, the Orlando bread truck came there to deliver their bread and then driver drove away when no one answered the door. Man then opened the upstairs window and yelled at me to try to find the truck to come back. Seriously. You can't make this stuff up.

Guido's Pizza Haven & Restaurant

4.2

(168 reviews)

We have been going to Guido's Pizza for years. The family has been in business for over 60 years…read more Great pizza. Nice family.

We were in Chesterland so my wife and a friend could attend a luncheon of classmates from their…read morehigh school days. While the wives attended their event, we 2 guys were on our own for lunch. We opted for Guido's Pizza Haven and Restaurant which is now located in a much nicer facility than they had when the ladies when to school in Chesterland. I ordered the veal sandwich and added cheese, onions and peppers. My friend also ordered a sandwich, also with cheese, onions and peppers. The sandwiches were huge - we should have opted for the half sandwich option. And, with the cheese, onions and peppers, these sandwiches start out as "knife and fork" sandwiches. I was eventually able to eat part of it like a sandwich after eating a lot of the filling. Our sandwiches were delicious and the service was great. CAUTION - Guido's is CASH ONLY and they do not accept debit or credit cards. There is an onsite ATM.

Scorpacciata Pizza

3.9

(116 reviews)

Tiramisu was super rich and amazing. Charred broccoli was unique and had cold broccoli with some…read morenuts and feta under fig jam. Humboldt bruleed cheese came with peppered arugula and crackers and fig jam and wasn't bad. The mortadella pizza was dry. The crust was not good. Too chewy. It could have benefitted from some hot honey on top to make it pop. Not bad overall but nothing I'd bring anyone to try. The star was the pasta as the pasta here is definitely the best section of the menu. The other food is average or even mediocre compared to how fresh and uniquely flavorful their pasta is. The campanelle was stuffed with capers, salmon, and herbs. Great mixins. Rich sauce , soft super fresh noodles.

I cannot say enough good things about Scorpacciata…read more I first visited on Valentine's day, and had such a wonderful dinner I knew I had to bring my parents. My parents drove 2 hours this weekend to visit, and talked about how amazing the meal & our server, Jeremiah was the entire way home. The staff is very attentive, and knowledgable, and truly made us feel comfortable. Our server shared information about how ingredients were locally sourced, and answered all of our questions. When we dined, we ordered from the new spring menu. We got the charred broccoli, which was so unique and refreshing. It had a sweet note to it, which was wonderful. The house meatballs were full of herbs, and were paired with a flavorful red sauce. We also got the mussels, which were awesome! I also enjoyed their cherry bee cocktail, which is gin based, and it was tart, just the way I like them! My favorite dish there is the gnocchi, it is rich and the balsamic notes with the pears are just amazing. I got it on Valentine's day and thought about it ever since! The dessert, tiramisu was a nice way to finish the meal off. As someone who recently moved to the Cleveland area, I know there are a lot of good spots to try, but Scorpacciata truly is the place to be! The environment is so inviting, and the vibe makes me want to share this gem with everyone I know. Thank you, Scorpacciata, for an amazing meal every time.

Pizzazz on the Circle

3.5

(184 reviews)

I wanted something quick to eat. And came across this place. So I stopped in and ordered a…read morecalzone. I figured it would be just a regular ok calzone. But to me it was more than that. It had extreme flavor profile. The toppings and cheese were perfect and not cheap quality. The staff was friendly. And the atmosphere was pleasing. I showed up during lunch and not many people. But I assume dinner time they would be packed.

Once again, we had an outstanding meal at Pizazz! The gazpacho was spot on and the best I have ever…read more. My special, watermelon salad with shrimp was outstanding as was my husband's short rib bolognese. They are a w9nderful restaurant- staff is amazing and knows their menu inside out. I can't say enough about this place- if you've never been, go! Both the bar and dining room have booths as well as tables- we always opt for a booth and we're willing to wait to get one. The place is that good.

Zappitelli's Pizza

4.1

(149 reviews)

Great pizza. One order of chicken piccata is enough for two. Good family restaurant.read more

Went for lunch with with wife wife it took seconds into we sat die. Smile with a service the…read morewaitress was very helpful gave us time to look at what we want. So you can't go wrong with any you order we got large cheese pizza spaghetti and meatballs their rolls are great I could imagine the garlic knots. Everything came out on time. Everything is freshly made you can tell they take pride in their products...

Dino's Restaurant

3.9

(109 reviews)

It's been a while since I dined at Dino's so we stopped in for lunch. Place is very basic nothing…read morefancy but the food is always good. The chicken parmigiana was tender with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The Chicken Piccata was one of the best. It's a perfect blend of lemon and white wine. Every bite was so good. The server was friendly and took her time to explain their menu to us and recommended her favorites.

If you're craving some great authentic Italian food, then this is the place! Their artichoke dip is…read moreawesome, and they served it hot and cheesy with fresh bread. Tiramisu is top-notch. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The bar area is very cozy in a Cheers kind of way. I've been utilizing the carryout quite often, and I always enjoy the brief ambiance when I pop in to pick up my order. Very friendly staff. And did I mention that the portions are grandiose? A good bang for the buck in this economy. I highly recommend checking out this restaurant!

Stancato's Italian Restaurant

3.8

(294 reviews)

Best carbonara! Large portions. There were four of us for dinner and everyone left happy. my…read morehusband got the clam sauce and it was very good also. We're definitely coming back.

Went to Stancatos on Wednesday Night. Great experience from a family run business. Upscale yet…read moreaffordable food. We love the service. Loved the portion size. My favorite part of the meal was the Sunshine Salad - Romaine, Strawberries, Oranges, Red Onion, Almonds, Citrus Vinaigrette Dressing. So light and refreshing. The arrabiatta sauce is so good. Just spicy enough. The ciabatta bread stellar!! Just stellar. Will return.

Mario Fazios

4.5

(265 reviews)

Becca and the staff at Mario Fazios created two beautiful and delicious cassata cakes for my wife's…read morememorial Celebration last week. It was a bit of a rush order but Becca promised the cakes would be perfect and they absolutely were - the guests at the party couldn't stop talking about how wonderful they looked as well as tasted. It was exactly what my wife would have wanted, thank you so much.

We are always satisfied at Mario Fazio's. This time, they outdid themselves. We ordered the…read more"Heavenly Pasta", and it is the BEST PASTA EVER!!!!!!! APPLAUSE, APPLAUSE!!! CLAP, CLAP, CLAP!!! Thank you!

Geraci's Restaurant

3.4

(384 reviews)

When my son visits from out of town, there can be only one place for dinner: GERACI'S…read more In honor of the restaurant's 70th birthday, we were all smiles as we shared a delectable bowl of spaghetti with meat sauce and a small mushroom pizza. I would guess that Geraci's has been our family's favorite for more than 30 years. We are so glad that tonight's visit could continue our admiration for Geraci's.

Went with a group and all but one person got pizza. The other got fettuccine Alfredo with chicken…read more I was told that the fettuccine Alfredo was okay, but it lacked seasoning. As for the pizza, I got a margarita pizza, and even though the pizza crust was thin, the bottom of the pizza was still doughy and not quite cooked through We tried the pepperoni pizza and it just was kind of bland. In fact, that was the consensus across the table was that no matter what pizza we had, the dough was kind of weird and did not have a lot of flavor. Our server was very nice and seemed to be trying hard to keep up with all the tables. But for the price, honestly Little Caesars pizza is cheaper and tastes better. I don't think we will be back

Longo's Pizza

3.5

(72 reviews)