Tri-tip was really good and the fries are exceptional!! Service with a smile. So the best barbecue…read moreI've had in a while. Atmosphere upbeat and restaurant clean. Would go back for some more when in town.

It was okay. My son got the brisket fries and I got tri-tip with Mac and cheese. The brisket was…read morepretty tasty! He didn't like the fries though. The Mac and cheese was creamy but everything was too salty for us. My youngest son got a burger and fries but also didn't care for the fries. If you get the brisket, I think it's the star!

In town for work. Only steakhouse near my hotel. The other reviews and pics did not do it justice…read more I thought I'd have to order from a counter and receive food in a basket, but not the case! Full service restaurant, great friendly staff/service. Food was great.

Tried to go to their sister restaurant (Hickory in the Pines) in Island Park today for lunch…read more Prices were quite high for the area and they didn't have any lighter fare options on the menu. Meats you had to purchase a combination platter for $40. When we asked about it, we overheard the manager state "if they don't like our menu, they can leave", which is exactly what we did. Food may be good, don't know, but their customer service isn't.

We saw all the barbecue spots in the region, asked a couple locals for their recommendations, and…read moreSparks came out on top. We arrived about 5:45pm and they were sold out of a few items we wanted to order. We would say the food was average to slightly above average. The restaurant is clean and lots of dark colors with wood decor. It is a cafeteria style service but staff mostly chatted amongst themselves except to say 'we're out of that' to us. We did see them cleaning tables, condiment area frequently.

The meat had a smoke ring, but I'll be damnd if I could find the smoke. Slaw was a mayo bomb and…read morethe beans had a pronounced chili pepper flavor. The sauces were much meh. I would find somewhere else to get cooked meat in Rexburg.

For $13 you get a meat and two sides. I went with the brisket, habanero corn, and mac and cheese…read more The corn was great. I didn't really taste much habanero, but it was still really good. The mac and cheese was also great. Same with the brisket. The sides were massive. I easily made two meals out of my $13 order. I do wish they had more types of BBQ sauce, especially a spicy one. I'm spoiled by BBQ restaurants with Carolina style, sweet, heat, and more. They could also use a soda fountain, but they do give free water bottles which is a nice gesture. Rexburg has a surprisingly growing food scene and I'll try and stop by again in the future.

I booked Pit BBQ for a picnic following my husband's memorial service in Idaho Falls. Delivery was…read moreover an hour late with no contact. I finally got hold of the office and they explained that they were short-staffed and were on their way. In all that time, I never got a phone call, email or text to keep me informed. It was more than frustrating. The food was good, but no bread/buns came with the meat. Kinda hard to make sandwiches without that. Contact and communication was definitely a problem throughout the ordering and delivery. Had I been contacted that delivery was running late, I could have arranged to pick up the food. Not a good way to run a business. Arla Godfrey

These ribs are juicy and fall off the bone tender! Two thumbs up. We'll be back! Try the Turkey…read more. it's great!

Loved it! Our server Savannah was friendly and helpful. She gave great recommendations. She took…read moregood care of us. Jaime also stopped by to fill up our drinks. The service was top notch. The decor is cute and cozy. My girls loved the bench seating with all the pillows. The food was the star of the show. I ordered the sweet and crunchy salad after the recommendation from Savannah. I Added the grilled chicken. It was a huge salad so yummy and shared it with my daughter. She got the Yellowstone pizza and said the crust was perfect. Other family members ordered sandwiches with soup. We had several flavors of lemonade. Everything was delicious!

What a great spot!!! We liked it so much we went two days in a row! We had the pizza and turkey…read moreclub. The pizza was amazing, and is full of. Flavor. The turkey club was great too! If in the area, I'll will 100% be back.

I'm not a big pizza fan. But I love this place! My brother-in-law was the owner's mission…read morecompassion back in the day and he told us about this place and how the owner always wanted to open a pizza joint. Well, he opened a really good one! We ordered the Bee Sting/Godfather pizza. The Bee Sting has Crushed red pepper, oregano, assorted spicy Italian cured meats, ricotta, & Howells Honey, fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, olive oil. I never thought of putting honey on my pizza. Honestly, you can barely taste it. The Godfather has Italian sausage, cup-and-char pepperoni, sliced meatballs, provolone, mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano. We ordered the New York crust. It was crispy and it held its shape. The sauce was not overpowering and blended well with all the spices The Dessert Katie Kay pizza was amazing. It had strawberries, blue berries, strawberry gel, fresh whipped cream and powdered sugar. What a great way to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Righteous Slice makes a wicked good pizza. This place is definitely worth checking out. I got the…read morehog heaven. Unfortunately I thought their house made sausage was really gross. Everything else was top-notch. The Popeye pizza was spectacular. We ordered our pizzas ahead of time and showed up to get them when they're ready and took them to go.

$11 for a cheesesteak sandwich from a food truck? Hell yes! Simple menu, great prices! I can't…read morethink of a single bad thing to say. Great food for a great price from great people. What more could you want? Also, I found this truck in Boise? Maybe they expanded.

We got the chipotle and the supreme, both were SO GOOD. Super fresh and tasty. Only thing causing…read morethe missing star was the portions were a bit small, right away we noticed there wasn't a lot of meat. Overall good, we'll be back!